đŸ’„Join UPSC 2027,2028 Mentorship (July Batch) + XFactor Notes & Microthemes PDF
Talk to Mentor

Civilsdaily

Login

Archives: Mains

  • Discuss the nature of Jammu and Kashmir Legislative Assembly after the Jammu and Kashmir Reorganization Act, 2019. Briefly describe the powers and functions of the Assembly of the Union Territory of Jammu and Kashmir.

    The Jammu and Kashmir Reorganization Act, 2019, following the abrogation of Article 370 and 35A, reorganized the former State of J&K into two Union Territories – Jammu & Kashmir (with legislature) and Ladakh (without legislature).

    Nature of J&K Legislative Assembly after the J&K Reorganization Act, 2019

    The UT of J&K Assembly resembles that of Delhi and Puducherry, functioning under Article 239A with limited law-making powers.

    The Lieutenant Governor (LG) is the head of the UT, appointed by the President, and wields greater authority than Governors of states.

    The Assembly has a five-year term (not six as earlier).

    Abolition of J&K Legislative Council – Bicameralism ended, Assembly became unicameral.

    Out of 107 seats in J&K Assembly-

    83 elected,

    24 reserved for Pakistan-occupied Kashmir (PoK),

    5 to be nominated by the LG, including 2 women (as per the Act, 2019 amendment 2023).

    Powers and Functions of J&K Legislative Assembly

    Legislative Powers

    Can legislate on subjects of the State List, except public order, police and concurrent list subject.

    Section 36 – Financial Bills in J&K UT can be introduced or moved in the Legislative Assembly only on the recommendation of the Lieutenant Governor.

    Laws require assent of the LG, who may refer bills to the President.

    Executive Oversight

    The Council of Ministers, headed by the Chief Minister, is collectively responsible to the Assembly.

    The Assembly exercises oversight through questions, motions, debates, and budget control.

    However, Section 53 – LG acts in discretion on matters related to All India Services & Anti-Corruption Bureau.

    Financial Powers

    Can pass the annual budget and authorize expenditure from the Consolidated Fund of J&K.

    Money Bills require the prior recommendation of the LG.

    The J&K Legislative Assembly post-2019 is a restricted legislature, balancing democratic representation with the Union’s direct control over sensitive subjects.

  • “In contemporary development models, decision-making and problem-solving responsibilities are not located close to the source of information and execution, defeating the objectives of development.” Critically evaluate.

    Contemporary development models

    Neoliberal – privatization, and deregulation

    Technocratic Model – Data driven governance

    Donor-Driven Model

    PPP Model

    Participatory Development Model

    Decision-Making and Problem-Solving Not Close to Ground

    Centralized Policy Design, with limited input from grassroots institutions. Eg- Uniform guidelines under PMAY-Gramin

    Bureaucratic Hierarchies lead to delayed responses. Eg- delays in fund release under MGNREGA due to multi-tier approvals.

    Technocratic and Data-Centric Planning leads to exclusion of indigenous knowledge.

    Weak Decentralization – PRIs and ULBs lack fiscal and functional autonomy. Only 40% of states have functional District Planning Committees (NITI Aayog, 2022).

    Lack of Coordination – ministries and departments work in silos. Eg- Smart Cities Mission: 60% projects delayed due to poor coordination.

    Lack of Participatory democracy – Communities are treated as beneficiaries rather than partners in development.

    Political and Fiscal Centralization through centrally sponsored schemes

    Regulatory Capture – Eg- Nexus of Bureaucracy-Politicians-Corporate. (Vohra Committee)

    Counter-Argument

    73rd & 74th Constitutional Amendments empowered PRIs and ULBs for local governance and participatory planning.

    Gram Panchayat Development Plans (GPDPs) institutionalized bottom-up planning in over 2.6 lakh Panchayats.

    Aspirational Districts Programme (ADP) – Promotes data-driven local governance with district-level flexibility and real-time monitoring.

    PM Gati Shakti National Master Plan – Integrates 16 ministries on a GIS-based platform to align planning and execution at ground level.

    Mission Karmayogi – Builds capacity of field-level officials for local problem-solving and citizen-centric service delivery.

    Cooperative Federalism via NITI Aayog – Governing Council enable state-specific and local feedback-based planning.

    Community-Led Models – Swachh Bharat Mission and Jal Jeevan Mission emphasize village-level implementation and monitoring.

    State Level Measures – Kerala’s People’s Plan Campaign

    Way Forward

    Capability Approach – increase spending on Health (2.5%of GDP) and Education (6% of GDP)

    Adopt Best Practices – Participatory Budgeting in porto alegre brazil

    Decentralized Governance based on principle of subsidiarity.

    “Growth becomes meaningful only when it expands human freedom and capability.” – Amartya Sen

    For this, decision-making authority and problem-solving responsibilities should be at the grassroots level.

    Social Justice

    Government Policies and Interventions for Welfare Schemes for Vulnerable Sections

  • With the waning of globalization, post-Cold War world is becoming a site of sovereign nationalism. Elucidate.

    Thomas Friedman, (The Lexus and the Olive Tree), defines globalization as the inexorable integration of markets, nation-states, and technologies, making it farther, faster, deeper, and cheaper. However, at present, the world is witnessing ‘Deglobalisation’.

    Waning of Globalization

    Global trade as % of GDP peaked at 61% in 2008, declining to ~52% by 2024 (World Bank).

    Reversal of Liberalization- Trade wars, tariffs (US-China), and reshoring policies mark a retreat from free markets.

    The splinternet, 5G bans, and AI regulation indicate the politicisation of technology.

    Weakening of Global Institutions- paralysis of WTO, and unilateral sanctions. Eg- USA’s CAATSA

    Regionalism replacing globalization – RCEP, IPEF, BRICS+, EU strategic autonomy.

    Rise of Sovereign Nationalism

    Economic Nationalism – US “America First”, India’s Atmanirbhar Bharat, EU’s strategic autonomy.

    Resource Nationalism- Nations asserting control over rare earths, energy, and food exports. Eg- Indonesia’s nickel ban.

    Political Sovereignty – Brexit (2016) justified as “taking back control”.

    Identity Politics- Nationalist rhetoric linked to cultural, ethnic, or religious identity. Eg- rise of Neo Fascist powers in Europe.

    Strategic Assertion – Russia’s rejection of Western dominance through the Ukraine war.

    Digital Sovereignty – EU’s GDPR and DSA for data protection; China’s Great Firewall.

    Security Nationalism – Eg- Iran’s nuclear program

    Vaccine & Resource Nationalism during COVID-19

    Backlash Against Migration- Eg- Immigration controls in UK, EU, USA

    Public Opinion Shift- Global surveys (Pew, 2023) show declining trust in globalization and preference for domestic self-reliance.

    The retreat of globalization signals a transition from hyper-interdependence to guarded sovereignty and realist state-centric politics

  • Discuss the ‘corrupt practices’ for the purpose of the Representation of the People Act, 1951. Analyze whether the increase in the assets of the legislators and/or their associates, disproportionate to their known sources of income, would constitute ‘undue influence’ and consequently a corrupt practice.

    The Representation of the People Act, 1951 defines a set of “corrupt practices” (Section 123), violation of which can lead to disqualification of a candidate (Section 8).

    Corrupt Practices under RPA, 1951

    Bribery – Offering or accepting gratification (money, jobs, gifts, entertainment) to induce candidature, withdrawal, or voting/refraining from voting. Eg- Distribution of cash or liquor during elections.

    Undue Influence – Interference (direct or indirect) with the free exercise of electoral rights through threats, inducements, or pressure. Eg- Threats of social boycott or misuse of official authority.

    Appeal on Identity Grounds – Seeking votes based on religion, caste, community, race, or language, or using religious/national symbols.

    Promotion of Enmity – Spreading hatred between groups for electoral gains.

    False Statements – Publishing knowingly false information about a candidate’s personal character or conduct to prejudice election prospects.

    SC in 2023 held that providing false information about electoral Candidates Qualification is not a Corrupt Practice under RPA, 1951.

    Free Conveyance of Voters – Hiring vehicles/vessels for voters’ free transport to polling stations.

    Excessive Expenditure – Spending beyond limits prescribed under Section 77.

    Misuse of Official Machinery – Seeking help from government servants such as gazetted officers, judges, police, armed forces.

    Booth Capturing – Seizing polling stations or ballot boxes by force.

    Glorification of Sati or Regressive Practices – Using such appeals for electoral advantage.

    Assets of Legislators and the Question of Undue Influence

    Since 2004, under the Representation of the People Act, 1951, MPs must declare their assets and liabilities to the Speaker (Lok Sabha) or Chairman (Rajya Sabha) within 90 days of taking their seat.

    The Supreme Court, in Lok Prahari case, mandated that candidates disclose not only their assets but also the sources of income of themselves, their spouses, and dependents.

    It directed the Centre to amend election rules and nomination forms, and sought a permanent mechanism to probe disproportionate asset growth of legislators.

    The Court held that non-disclosure of assets or income sources amounts to a corrupt practice under Section 123, RPA 1951.

    A legislator’s or associate’s increase in assets disproportionate to known income is also a matter of corruption under Prevention of Corruption Act (1988) or criminal misconduct under IPC/Prevention of Money Laundering Act. Section 8 (3) of the Act states that if an MP or MLA is convicted for any other crime and is sent to jail for 2 years or more, he/ she will be disqualified for 6 years from the time of release.

    Thus, the disqualification provisions ensure the trinity of Ethics, Accountability and Fairness of electoral process.

  • Do you think that globalization results in only an aggressive consumer culture?

    Thomas Friedman, (The Lexus and the Olive Tree), defines globalization as the inexorable integration of markets, nation-states, and technologies, making it farther, faster, deeper, and cheaper.

    Globalisation resulting in an aggressive consumer culture

    Expansion of Global Brands – Multinational corporations standardise consumption patterns. Eg- McDonaldization of food habits

    Market-Driven Aspirations – Identity increasingly shaped by consumption choices. Eg- Status linked to ownership of branded gadgets like Apple iphones

    Advertising and Media Influence – Eg- Targeted digital ads promoting instant gratification and lifestyle consumption.

    The spread of “Buy Now, Pay Later” schemes has led to a spike in “impulse buying” among Gen Z, replacing the traditional Indian value of Mitavyaya (frugality).

    Cultural Commodification – Traditions converted into market products. Eg- Big Billion Days during Diwali

    Rise of “Fast Culture” – Globalization of supply chains allows for the rapid production of cheap goods, encouraging a “use and throw” mentality. Eg- Fast Fashion industry

    Urban Lifestyle Homogenisation – Eg- rise of mall culture

    Youth-Oriented Consumerism – Eg- Social media influencer culture shaping consumption norms.

    Inequality-Driven Consumption Pressure – Aspirational consumption among lower middle class despite income gaps.

    The traditional Indian value of Mitha-vyaya (balanced spending) is being replaced by the “You Only Live Once” (YOLO) philosophy due to global individualistic culture.

    Counter-Argument- Beyond Aggressive Consumerism

    Rise of Sustainable and Ethical Consumption – increasing demand for organic food and eco-friendly products.

    Minimalism – globalization has spread the philosophy of “Less is More.” Eg- the Scandinavian “Lagom” philosophy

    Glocalization (Think Global, Act Local) – Eg- McDonald’s menu in India is beef-free, while Domino’s serves Paneer Tikka Pizza.

    Global Export of Culture – Eg- International Yoga Day and the global Ayurveda market have moved Indian traditional knowledge to the center of global wellness.

    Reassertion of Values (“Returning to Roots”) – urban youth increasingly participates in traditional festivals like Ganesh Chaturthi or Chhath Puja as a mark of identity.

    Circular Economy Adoption- focus on “Recycle and Upcycle” business models, countering the throwaway culture.

    Global Environmental Activism to hold government and corporate accountable for unsustainable policies and practices. Eg- Fridays for Future movement

    Revival of Local Crafts through E-commerce – Platforms like Etsy or India’s Jaypore promote traditional “Slow Fashion” (like Handloom) and ethical consumerism

    Globalization has also facilitated Universal Human Rights Advocacy – Eg- global #BlackLivesMatter or #MeToo movements

    Flow of Knowledge and Ideas – Globalisation enables access to education, research, and innovation. Eg- wikipedia

    Globalization is a Janus-faced phenomenon (Anthony Giddens). Improving regulation, social consciousness, and value choices is needed.

  • Give a geographical explanation of the distribution of off-shore oil reserves of the world. How are they different from the on-shore occurrences of oil reserves?

    Petroleum reserves are found in sedimentary basins, where organic matter is trapped under pressure. Offshore reserves account for ~30% of global crude oil production. Their distribution is linked to continental shelf geology, passive margins, and deep-water basins.

    Geographical distribution

    The Persian Gulf (Middle East)- result of the collision between the Arabian and Eurasian plates, which created perfect “anticline” traps for oil. Eg- Safaniya field (Saudi Arabia), largest offshore oil field in the world.

    The Gulf of Mexico (North America)- It is characterized by salt domes that trap oil in the surrounding porous rock.

    The North Sea (Europe)- Situated between the UK, Norway, and Denmark. This region is a rift basin, with deep depressions where organic matter could settle.

    The South Atlantic Margins (Brazil & West Africa)- formed when South America and Africa drifted apart.

    Southeast Asia & India- in the South China Sea and India’s Mumbai High and Krishna-Godavari (KG) Basin

    Difference between off-shore and on-shore oil reserves

    Implications of uneven distribution of mineral oils in the world

    Energy security challenges – Oil-deficient countries face high import bills and current account deficits. Eg- India imports ~85% of its crude oil requirement.

    Resource Curse in Oil-rich Nations (Paradox of Plenty) – Overdependence on oil leads to limited economic diversification. Eg- Venezuela’s economic crisis.

    Energy trade is one of the key drivers of global geopolitics. Eg- US sanctions on Russian and Iran oil trade

    Competition for oil resources leads to wars and regional instability. Eg- Gulf Wars, Saudi-Iran rivalry.

    Oil-rich regions face oil spills, land degradation, and marine pollution. Eg- Niger Delta pollution.

    Global Carbon Emissions – oil and gas industry is responsible for over 5 billion tonnes of CO2 equivalent in direct emissions annually (15% of total energy-related emissions)

    In the long run, reducing oil dependence through clean energy, strategic reserves, and diversified supply chains is essential for ensuring equitable and sustainable global development.

  • Examine the main aspects of Akbar’s religious syncretism.

    Akbar’s religious policy marked a departure from orthodox Islamic statecraft, aiming to build an inclusive, stable, and composite polity in a religiously diverse empire.

    Main Aspects of Akbar’s Religious Syncretism

    Sulh-i-Kul (Universal Toleration) –

    State policy for equal treatment of all irrespective of faith. Eg- Appointment of Rajputs, Persians, Afghans, and Indian Muslims to high offices.

    Abolition of Discriminatory Taxes – Removal of Jizya (1564) and pilgrimage tax to reduce religious alienation.

    Ibadat Khana Debates (1575) – Platform for inter-religious dialogue among Muslims, Hindus, Jains, Christians, Zoroastrians.

    Mahzar (1579) – Akbar became the final arbiter in cases of theological dispute (Imam-i-Adil)

    Din-i-Ilahi (1582) – Emphasis on ethical conduct, loyalty, tolerance, not mass religion. It combined elements from various faiths

    Islam- Monotheism and the concept of a spiritual guide (Pir).

    Hinduism/Jainism- Vegetarianism and the prohibition of animal slaughter on certain days

    Zoroastrianism- Veneration of light and the Sun (Surya Namaskar).

    Respect for Non-Islamic Practices

    Ban on cow slaughter on certain days

    Patronage to Jain monks like Hiravijaya Suri.

    Akbar believed that religious conflict arose from ignorance. To bridge this, he established a Maktab Khana for translation of the Mahabharata, Ramayana, and Atharvaveda into Persian.

    Adoption of Socio-Religious Traditions

    He began appearing at the Jharokha Darshan and applied the Tika on his forehead.

    Celebrated festivals like Diwali, Rakshabandhan, and Nauroz at the court.

    As Irfan Habib notes, Akbar sought “a moral basis for kingship beyond sectarian boundaries,” laying foundations for India’s composite culture.

    Post Independence India

  • ‘Achieving sustainable growth with emphasis on environmental protection could come into conflict with poor people’s needs in a country like India – Comment.

    Sustainable development refers to a development path that meets the needs of the present without compromising the ability of future generations to meet their own needs (Brundtland Commission).

    Emphasis on environmental protection coming into conflict with poor people needs

    The poor depend directly on forests, rivers, and commons. They lose their livelihood due to strict conservation rules. Eg- protest by Jenu Kuruba tribe against expansion of “Core Areas” in Nagarhole tiger reserve

    Environmental bans affect subsistence livelihoods. Eg- ban on single-use plastics has disproportionately impacted street vendors

    Higher Cost of Green Alternatives – Eg- high initial cost of Solar pumps makes it unaffordable for small farmers

    Energy Transition Costs- closure of mines in the “coal belt” (Jharkhand/Odisha) threatens the informal livelihoods of nearly 15-20 million people linked to the coal economy.

    Urban Environmental Regulations – Closure of polluting units affects migrant workers.

    Fishing communities impacted by coastal regulation norms. Eg- Limitations under Coastal Regulation Zone (CRZ) rules.

    Unequal Burden of Environmental Compliance – Eg- Sand mining restrictions affecting daily-wage workers.

    Agricultural Restrictions- Policies discouraging water-intensive crops impact marginal farmers more as they lack capital to shift to high-value horticulture.

    Eco-restoration projects, such as clearing the Yamuna floodplains in Delhi, result in the demolition of informal settlements without adequate “Just Transition” housing.

    Shift from biomass to LPG under the ujjwala scheme reduced indoor pollution, but high refill costs force rural households back to firewood.

    Counter argument – benefits sustainable growth with emphasis on environmental protection for poor

    Disaster Risk Reduction – Environmental safeguards prevent loss of lives and assets. Eg- Protecting mangroves and wetlands saved thousands of lives during Odisha Cyclones.

    Public Health Gains – Cleaner air and water reduce disease burden and Out-of-Pocket Expenditure (OOPE) for the poor.

    Sustainable management secures long-term livelihoods. Eg- Watershed development improving water security.

    Green Livelihood Creation – Jobs in renewable energy, afforestation, waste management. Eg- “Suryamitra” schemes

    Sustainable agriculture improves resilience. Eg- solar pumps under PM-KUSUM scheme

    Water Security- Jal Jeevan Mission and watershed management under MGNREGA have improved groundwater levels, directly benefiting rain-fed marginal farmers.

    Energy Access with Sustainability – Eg- Solar lighting in off-grid rural areas.

    Intergenerational Equity – Unsustainable growth harms future poor the most.

    Legal Empowerment of Communities – Rights-based conservation models. Eg- Community forest management under forest rights Act

    Eco-Tourism- In places like Kaziranga, community-led tourism has provided a “conservation dividend” to local tribes.

    Global Finance- Eg- Green Bonds to fund low-cost housing and clean transport for the urban poor

    Way Forward

    Strengthening grassroot governance – Eg- ensuring fair, prior and informed consent of Gram Sabha in tribal areas

    Implementing RECLAIM framework to ensure sustainable, community-centric mine closures and “just transition” for communities

    Community-Led Conservation (The Nagaland Model) – Replicate Nagaland’s 407+ Community Biodiversity Conservation Areas (CCAs)

    Scaling “Green Subsidies” through DBT. Eg- “Refill Subsidy” for Ujjwala users

    Universalizing Climate-Resilient Agriculture – Expand PM-PRANAM (Natural Farming)

    Institutionalizing “Social Impact Credits” in Carbon Markets

    Ensure that the Blue Economy Policy protects the “First Right of Access” for traditional fisherfolk.

    As Indira Gandhi stated at the 1972 Stockholm Conference, “Poverty is the greatest polluter.” Thus, there is need to shifted toward a “Just Transition,” where environmental protection is pro-poor and poverty alleviation is ecologically sustainable.

  • How do you account for the growing fast food industries given that there are increased health concerns in modern society? Illustrate your answer with the Indian experience.

    Despite growing health consciousness, non-communicable diseases, and awareness about junk food risks, the fast food industry continues to expand rapidly @ CAGR of 7.3% in India.

    Increased health concerns in modern society

    Rising obesity levels – NFHS-5 reports overweight/obesity at 24% in women and 23% in men.

    Diabetes epidemic – India hosts over 101 million diabetics (ICMR-2023).

    Cardiovascular diseases due to High salt and trans-fat consumption from fast foods.

    Rising lifestyle disorders among youth – Early onset hypertension and fatty liver disease.

    “Hidden Hunger” concern – foods high in energy but deficient in micronutrients like Zinc, Iron, and Vitamin B12.

    Public health campaigns – Eg- Fit India Movement and Eat Right India by FSSAI.

    Despite this, the fast food industry is growing. Reasons behind it are as follows

    Time poverty in urban life – Long work hours reduce cooking time. Eg- Dual-income households in metros.

    Changing work patterns – Night shifts favor ready food. Eg- BPO employees ordering late-night meals.

    Youth bulge – Large young population (median age is 28) with experimental tastes.

    Aspirational consumption – Fast food symbolizes modern, global lifestyle in tier 2 and tier 3 cities

    Affordability due to economies of scale – Cheaper than healthy alternatives.

    Localization of menus – Cultural adaptation increases acceptability. Eg- McAloo Tikki, paneer pizzas.

    Digital food delivery platforms like Zomato and Swiggy reduce transaction cost and effort.

    Aggressive marketing and discounts – Price nudges override health logic. Eg- Buy-one-get-one offers.

    Street food as indigenous fast food. Eg- Vada pav, momos, chowmein stalls.

    Awareness-action gap – Knowledge does not ensure behavior change.

    Food as leisure and socialization – Eg- Family outings to QSRs on weekends.

    Weak regulatory deterrence – Eg- Calorie labeling not strictly enforced.

    Way Forward

    Clear front-of-pack labeling – Traffic-light nutrition labels. Eg- UK’s color-coded food labels.

    Fiscal nudges – Eg- Mexico’s sugar tax reducing soda consumption.

    Restrict junk food near schools. Eg- Chile’s ban on junk food advertising to children.

    Strengthening regulation – Eg- FSSAI’s Eat Right certification.

    Promoting low-AGE Diet (Advanced Glycation End product) consisting of fruits, vegetables, whole grains, and low-fat dairy products.

    Systemic regulation, affordable healthy alternatives, and environments where the healthy choice becomes the easy choice are essential for “Healthy India”

    Role of Women and Women’s Organization

  • ⁠The ethos of civil service in India stand for the combination of professionalism with nationalistic consciousness – Elucidate.

    The Indian civil service, rooted in the Weberian model of bureaucracy, has evolved to combine professional competence with a deep commitment to national development and constitutional values.

    Professionalism in Civil Service

    Merit-based recruitment through the Union Public Service Commission ensures competence and impartiality. Eg- Competitive examination system for IAS, IPS, IFS.

    Training institutions like Lal Bahadur Shastri National Academy of Administration (Mussoorie) instill administrative skills, ethics, and leadership. Eg- ‘Bharat Darshan’ exposure tours.

    Adherence to rules, procedures, and the principle of political neutrality.

    Expertise in policy formulation, implementation, and evaluation across diverse sectors.

    Commitment to Rule of Law – civil servants uphold constitutional provisions and legal frameworks.

    Nationalistic Consciousness

    The civil service was ‘Indianised’ after independence, transforming from a colonial instrument of control to a vehicle of national development. Eg- Sardar Vallabhbhai Patel’s vision of IAS as the ‘steel frame’ of India.

    District administration model – DMs serve as the face of governance in remotest areas, ensuring national integration.

    Role in nation-building – Eg- land reforms, Green Revolution, poverty alleviation, literacy missions, Aadhaar, Digital India.

    Crisis management during national emergencies – natural disasters, pandemics (COVID-19 management by district administration).

    Constitutional values of justice, liberty, equality, and fraternity guide civil service conduct. Eg- Upholding secularism and protecting minority rights.

    Commitment to social justice – implementation of reservation policies, tribal welfare, women’s empowerment schemes.

    Challenges

    Political interference and transfers undermine neutrality.

    Red tape and resistance to reform.

    Ethical dilemmas in balancing political directives with public interest.

    The Indian civil service, at its best, embodies what Jawaharlal Nehru envisioned: “a service that is devoted to the nation, that understands the problems of the country, and that has the courage and integrity to serve the people.”