💥Join UPSC 2027,2028 Mentorship (July Batch) + XFactor Notes & Microthemes PDF
Talk to Mentor

Civilsdaily

Login

Distribution: yearly

  • Copyright Protection for Religious Texts

    copyright

    Central Idea

    • The recent ruling by the Delhi High Court has brought attention to copyright infringement concerning religious texts, particularly the Bhaktivedanta Book Trust’s works on Indian religious philosophy and spiritualism.
    • This landmark case addresses copyright protection for sacred texts and the implications for digital platforms.
    • Let’s explore the details of the case and its broader implications.

    Are Religious Texts Copyright-Protected?

    • Public Domain: Most religious scriptures, such as the Old Testament and New Testament, are in the public domain. Copyright law does not apply to works in the public domain.
    • Exceptions: Modern translations of religious texts, like the New International Version (NIV) of the Bible, may enjoy copyright protection as they represent new creative works by translators.
    • Protections: Additionally, transformative works, like television adaptations of epics like the Ramayana and Mahabharata, are protected.

    Understanding Copyright Law in India

    • Scope of Protection: The Indian Copyright Act of 1957 safeguards “original work,” creative expressions independently created and fixed in a tangible medium.
    • Exclusive Rights: It grants exclusive rights to creators/authors, including the right to use, reproduce, distribute, perform, and display their work.
    • Transformative Works: The Act also protects transformative works, which creatively modify, reinterpret, or build upon existing material to create something distinct.

    Duration of Copyright Protection

    Literary, Dramatic, Musical, Artistic Works Lifetime of the author plus 60 years from the year following the author’s death or last surviving author’s death.
    Cinematographic Films 60 years from the year of publication or creation.
    Sound Recordings 60 years from the year of first publication.
    Anonymous or Pseudonymous Works 60 years from the year of publication, or lifetime of the author plus 60 years if the author’s identity is disclosed during this period.

    Bhaktivedanta Book Trust’s Case

    • Founder’s Works: The trust claimed copyright ownership of its founder’s works, which had simplified religious books and scriptures, making them accessible to the common man.
    • Infringement Allegation: The trust alleged that various websites, mobile apps, and Instagram handles were reproducing a significant number of its copyrighted works almost verbatim on their online platforms without authorization, constituting infringement.

    Delhi High Court’s Ruling

    • Copyright Protection: The court ruled that adaptations of sacred scriptures, including explanations, meanings, interpretations, and audio-visual works, are entitled to copyright protection because they represent original works by authors themselves.
    • Reproduction Clarification: While the reproduction of the actual text of sacred texts, such as the Srimad Bhagavad Gita, is permissible, the court emphasized that copyright protection applies to the original parts of literary works that preach, teach, or explain the scripture.
    • Trust’s Rights: Given that Srila Prabhupada had entrusted the copyrights to be administered by the Bhaktivedanta Book Trust, the court emphasized that the works cannot be reproduced without the trust’s authorization, license, or permission.
    • Preventing Piracy: The court acknowledged that unauthorized reproduction, including shlokas (verses), translations, and interpretations, by defendant entities would result in immense revenue loss for the trust.

    Conclusion

    • The Delhi High Court’s ruling on copyright protection for religious texts has far-reaching implications for safeguarding the originality and rights associated with sacred scriptures.
    • While religious texts themselves may not be copyright-protected, creative adaptations, explanations, and interpretations enjoy legal protection.
    • This decision serves as a precedent for preserving the intellectual property rights of organizations involved in disseminating spiritual knowledge while discouraging unauthorized reproduction and piracy.

  • Quantum Algorithms: The Power and Promise

    Central Idea

    • Quantum computers are often heralded as the solution to complex problems that classical computers struggle with.
    • However, harnessing the full potential of quantum computing isn’t just about having the hardware; it requires the development of clever quantum algorithms.

    Understanding Algorithms

    • An algorithm is a logical sequence of mathematical steps designed to solve a specific problem.
    • For example, adding three numbers involves two steps: adding the first two numbers and then adding the result to the third number.

    Quantum Computing

    • Quantum computing is a cutting-edge field of computing that leverages the principles of quantum mechanics to perform certain types of calculations much faster than classical computers.
    • Instead of using traditional bits (0s and 1s), quantum computers use quantum bits or qubits, which can exist in a superposition of states. Here are some key aspects:
    1. Superposition: Qubits can represent multiple states simultaneously, enabling quantum computers to explore many solutions in parallel.
    2. Entanglement: Qubits can be entangled, allowing information to be processed in ways that classical computers cannot replicate efficiently.
    3. Quantum Gates: Quantum algorithms manipulate qubits using quantum gates, which can perform complex operations on qubits.
    4. Quantum Advantage: Quantum computers have the potential to solve certain problems exponentially faster than classical computers, such as factoring large numbers and simulating quantum systems.

    Quantum vs. Classical Algorithms

    • Algorithm Complexity: The efficiency of an algorithm is determined by the number of steps it takes to solve a problem, particularly as the input size increases.
    • Quantum Advantage: Quantum algorithms, implemented using quantum gates, can potentially outperform classical algorithms by reducing the number of required steps.
    • Superposition in Quantum Bits (Qubits): Unlike classical bits, qubits can exist in states of both 0 and 1 simultaneously, allowing quantum algorithms to exploit superposition for speed-up.

    Shor’s Algorithm: Factorization Made Efficient

    • Shor’s Breakthrough: Peter Shor’s quantum factorization algorithm significantly outperforms classical methods in identifying factors of large integers.
    • Efficiency Comparison: Shor’s algorithm operates with a polynomial increase in steps, while classical algorithms exhibit superpolynomial growth.
    • Cryptographic Implications: The efficiency of Shor’s algorithm raises concerns for classical cryptography, as it could potentially challenge the security of large integer-based encryption systems.

    Grover’s Algorithm: Quantum Search Mastery

    • Quantum Search Algorithm: Lov Grover’s quantum search algorithm excels at identifying numerical patterns in extensive lists of data.
    • Classical vs. Quantum: Classical methods may require nearly half the number of steps as there are patterns, while Grover’s quantum algorithm drastically reduces the steps required.
    • Scalability: Grover’s algorithm showcases exponential speed-up, requiring only a fraction of additional steps for significantly larger datasets.

    Deutsch-Jozsa Algorithm: Superposition’s Advantage

    • Problem Scenario: Deutsch-Jozsa tackles the identification of a relationship between two sets – one with two-digit binary numbers and another with binary associations.
    • Two Types of Relations: The algorithm distinguishes between constant and balanced relations.
    • Quantum Efficiency: In classical computing, this task may need up to three steps. Quantum computing, using superposition, achieves the same with just one computation, regardless of input size.

    Expanding World of Quantum Algorithms

    • Diverse Applications: Quantum algorithms offer efficiency gains in optimization, drug design, pattern search, and more.
    • Promise of Quantum Computing: Once reliable, large-scale quantum devices become available, they will revolutionize problem-solving across various fields.
    • Interdisciplinary Nature: Quantum algorithm research spans computer science, mathematics, and physics, and it continues to evolve, providing ample opportunities for contributions.

    Conclusion

    • Quantum algorithms represent the intelligent design that unlocks the immense potential of quantum computers.
    • As quantum technology advances and reliable devices emerge, these algorithms will play a pivotal role in tackling complex problems that have long eluded classical computing.
    • Quantum algorithm development remains an interdisciplinary frontier with abundant room for innovation and groundbreaking discoveries.

    Back2Basics: Quantum Theory

    Quantum theory, also known as quantum mechanics or quantum physics, is a fundamental branch of physics that describes the behavior of matter and energy at the smallest scales, typically at the level of atoms and subatomic particles. It introduces the following key principles:

    • Wave-Particle Duality: Particles like electrons and photons exhibit both particle-like and wave-like properties, depending on how they are observed.
    • Superposition: Quantum particles can exist in multiple states simultaneously, known as superposition, until observed.
    • Entanglement: Particles can become entangled, where the state of one particle is dependent on the state of another, even when separated by large distances.
    • Quantization: Certain physical properties, such as energy levels in atoms, are quantized, meaning they can only take on specific discrete values.

  • [pib] Setu Bandhan Scheme

    Central Idea

    • Recently, the Union Minister for Road Transport and Highways announced the approval of Setu Bandhan Scheme for seven bridge projects in Arunachal Pradesh, utilizing funds from the Central Road and Infrastructure Fund (CRIF).

    What is Setu Bandhan Scheme?

    • Setu Bandhan is an initiative under the Ministry of Road Transport and Highways.
    • Its primary aim is to enhance inter-state connectivity, particularly in rural border areas that have been historically underserved by state roads.
    • The scheme aims to replace railway line Level Crossings (LCs) with Road Over Bridges (ROBs) or Rail Under Bridges (RUBs) in various states.

    About Central Road and Infrastructure Fund (CRIF)

    • Established in 2000 through the Central Road Fund Act, 2000.
    • Previously known as the Central Road Fund.
    • It falls under the jurisdiction of the Ministry of Finance.
    • The fund is financed through a cess levied in conjunction with excise duty on petrol and diesel.

  • CJI lists measures against LGBTQI Discrimination

    Central Idea

    • In a significant ruling, CJI D Y Chandrachud made a series of directions to address discrimination against the LGBTQ+ community and underscored the need for legislative action to recognize same-sex marriages.
    • This decision reflects a pivotal moment in India’s LGBTQ+ rights movement, emphasizing the intersection of legal and societal norms.

    Preventing LGBTQI Discrimination: Key Directions by CJI

    • Creation of Safe Houses: The ruling called for the establishment of “Garima Grehs” or safe houses in all districts to provide shelter to LGBTQ+ individuals facing violence or discrimination. These safe houses aim to offer refuge and support to those in need.
    • Anti-Discrimination Measures: The Centre, States, and Union Territories were urged to ensure that LGBTQ+ community members are not subjected to discrimination based on gender identity or sexual orientation. This includes equal access to goods and services available to the public.
    • Public Awareness: The ruling emphasized the need to sensitize the public about queer identity, affirming that it is natural and not a mental disorder. It encourages educational efforts to promote understanding and acceptance.
    • Hotline Numbers: The authorities were directed to establish hotline numbers that LGBTQ+ individuals can contact when facing harassment or violence. This initiative aims to provide immediate assistance and support.
    • End of Harmful “Treatments”: The ruling called for an immediate cessation of any “treatments” offered by doctors or others that attempt to change gender identity or sexual orientation. It prioritizes the well-being and autonomy of LGBTQ+ individuals.
    • Protection from Family Pressure: Police were advised not to force LGBTQ+ persons to return to their natal families if they choose not to do so. Furthermore, the ruling emphasized the importance of verifying the claims of LGBTQ+ individuals when they file complaints against their families, ensuring their freedom is not curtailed.
    • Fair Preliminary Investigation: Before registering an FIR against a queer couple or one of the parties involved, a preliminary investigation should be conducted. This step ensures that the complaint discloses a cognizable offence, preventing unnecessary legal action against LGBTQ+ individuals.

    Historical Context

    • The ruling underscored that India has a rich history of LGBTQ+ lives, encompassing various identities and communities.
    • It emphasized that queerness is not limited to urban settings or privileged classes but exists across different regions, castes, and economic backgrounds.

    Future Steps

    • The ruling has set a precedent for addressing discrimination and ensuring the protection of LGBTQ+ rights.
    • Justice S K Kaul expressed the need for a comprehensive anti-discrimination law prohibiting discrimination based on sexual orientation.
    • State governments have also been prompted to create guidelines and committees to address LGBTQ+ issues, demonstrating the broader impact of this ruling beyond the courtroom.

    Conclusion

    • The Supreme Court’s ruling on LGBTQ+ rights signifies a significant milestone in the ongoing struggle for equal rights and acceptance.
    • While legislative recognition of same-sex marriages remains pending, the directions provided by the CJI emphasize the importance of dismantling discriminatory practices and promoting inclusivity in Indian society.
    • The ruling paves the way for a more equitable future for LGBTQ+ individuals in the country.

  • Judicial Perspectives on LGBTQI Marriage and Adoption Issues

    Central Idea

    • In a recent landmark decision, the Supreme Court, led by Chief Justice of India D Y Chandrachud, deliberated on granting legal status to same-sex marriages.
    • This case has sparked significant interest as it explores the intersection of individual rights and societal norms.

    Judicial Perspectives on Various Issues:

    [A] Fundamental Right to Marry

    Issue Minority View (CJI) Majority View
    Petitioner Argument
    • Marriage is not fundamentally important;
    • It gained significance through state regulation as Civil Union.
    • Marriage’s importance is personal preference and social status.
    • It is necessarily NOT a fundamental right.

     

    [B] Interpretation of Special Marriage Act

    Issue Minority View (CJI) Majority View
    Framing the Issue
    • Cautioned against expansive interpretations;
    • Suggested encroachment on the legislature’s domain.
    • Concurred with the minority view.
    • Emphasized the SMA’s purpose for facilitating civil marriages between heterosexual couples.

     

    [C] Queer Couples’ Right to Adopt a Child

    Issue Minority View (CJI) Majority View
    Discriminatory Regulations
    • Struck down certain CARA regulations, asserting that they do not serve the child’s best interests.
    • Highlighted the discriminatory impact on the queer community based on their sexuality.
    • Acknowledged the discriminatory aspect.
    • But believed legislative action, rather than judicial imposition, should bring about this change.

     

    [D] Civil Unions for Queer Couples

    Argument Minority View (CJI Chandrachud) Majority View
    Recognition of Civil Unions
    • Connected the right to form intimate associations with freedom of speech and expression.
    • Proposed that the state should acknowledge various entitlements for such relationships.
    • Disagreed with prescribing a “choice” of civil unions.
    • Suggested that the state should facilitate this choice for those who opt for it.

     Conclusion

    • The Supreme Court’s decision on same-sex marriage reflects a complex interplay of legal, social, and legislative factors.
    • While the minority view leans towards immediate recognition of civil unions and highlights the importance of individual rights, the majority opinion emphasizes the legislative role in bringing about changes in societal norms.
    • The verdict underscores the evolving landscape of LGBTQ+ rights in India and the ongoing dialogue surrounding equal rights and inclusivity.

  • Explained: India’s Bid for the 2036 Olympics

    Olympics

    Central Idea

    • Prime Minister Modi recently confirmed India’s formal bid to host the 2036 Olympic Games, raising questions about the financial implications and benefits of hosting this prestigious event.

    About Olympics

    Origins Began in ancient Greece in 776 BCE in Olympia.
    Revival Revived by Pierre de Coubertin in 1896 in Athens, Greece.
    Five Rings Olympic flag features five interlocking rings representing unity among 5 continents.
    Olympic Motto “Citius, Altius, Fortius” (Faster, Higher, Stronger) reflects the pursuit of excellence.
    Sports Included Features a diverse range of sports, from athletics and swimming to archery and gymnastics.
    Discontinued Sports Some sports, like tug of war and live pigeon shooting, have been removed.

    Selecting the Olympics Host City

    • International Olympic Committee (IOC) Decision: The host city is chosen by the International Olympic Committee members through a secret ballot, with the majority vote determining the winner.
    • Competition and Diplomacy: Securing the opportunity to host the Olympics involves significant financial resources and diplomatic efforts. Typically, winners are announced 7-8 years before the event.

    Olympics

    Cost of Hosting the Olympics

    • Expensive Endeavor: Bidding for the Olympics is a costly proposition, with countries spending $50-100 million, even for unsuccessful bids. In case of a successful bid, the expenses can soar into billions of dollars.
    • Examples of Expenditure: Tokyo spent $150 million for its failed 2016 bid and even more for the successful 2020 bid. Toronto refrained from bidding due to the $60 million cost for the 2024 bid.
    • Infrastructure Investment: Hosting the Olympics entails building stadiums and enhancing infrastructure to accommodate athletes and tourists.

    Funding the Olympics Expenses

    • Local Government Responsibility: The majority of expenses, especially on infrastructure, are shouldered by the local government and are spread across the country’s budget.
    • Borrowing for Cost Overruns: Countries often resort to borrowing to cover cost overruns. The IOC contributes some revenue to the host country, but it constitutes a relatively small amount, e.g., $1.5 billion for Rio De Janeiro in 2016.

    Assessing the Worth of Hosting the Olympics

    • Benefits of Hosting: Hosting the Olympics elevates a country’s global status, promotes it as an investment and tourist destination.
    • Cautions on Overspending: Excessive spending can have dire consequences, as seen with Canada’s 30-year debt from the 1976 Montreal Games, the impact on Greece’s financial crisis after the 2004 Athens Olympics, and Rio’s $900 million bailout request from the Brazilian government.
    • Positive Outcomes: In some cases, such as Beijing, hosting the Olympics led to significant GDP growth acceleration, by at least 0.8%.

    India’s Prospects

    • Favorable Timing: India’s bid aligns well with its status as the world’s most populous and fastest-growing major economy.
    • Past Experience: Having previously hosted the 1982 Asian Games and the 2010 Commonwealth Games, India possesses a favorable track record, which the IOC takes into consideration.
    • Gujarat’s Bid: Gujarat is contemplating bidding for the 2026 Commonwealth Games, which could further demonstrate India’s hosting capabilities.
    • Economic Power: India’s ascent as an economic powerhouse enhances its candidacy’s appeal to other nations.

    Conclusion

    • While India’s bid to host the 2036 Olympics presents an opportunity to boost its global profile and economic prospects, it is essential to strike a balance between ambition and fiscal prudence.
    • The economic implications, positive and negative, of hosting such a monumental event should be carefully evaluated to ensure that the effort and investment yield substantial long-term benefits for the nation.

  • Places in news: Dhanauri Wetland

    Dhanauri Wetland

    Central Idea

    • The National Green Tribunal has given the UP government four weeks to inform it about the status of the Ramsar tag for Dhanauri wetlands.

    Dhanauri Wetland

    • The Dhanauri Wetlands is a bird-watching area located in Dhanauri village near Dankaur in Uttar Pradesh.
    • It is home to over 120 Sarus cranes (Sarus Cranes is the state bird of Uttar Pradesh).
    • It is a sanctuary for 23 species of endangered, critically endangered, and threatened birds, with special significance as a habitat for the majestic Sarus crane.

    Ecological Significance

    • Dhanauri is a natural wetland that hosts more than 217 bird species, including over 150 Sarus cranes, and serves as a vital birding and nesting site.
    • It has received recognition as an Important Bird Area by Bird Life International and has been documented by the BNHS (Bombay Natural History Society).
    • During peak migratory seasons (November to March), the wetland hosts over 50,000 waterfowls.

    Why in news?

    • Dhanauri plays a crucial role in supporting the vulnerable Sarus crane population.
    • The wetland fulfills two key Ramsar site criteria out of nine:
      1. It hosts over 1% of the biogeographic Sarus crane population.
      2. The area serves as a congregation site for 20,000+ waterfowls and various other species.

    Ramsar Wetlands

    • The Ramsar Convention, also known as the ‘Convention on Wetlands,’ is an intergovernmental environmental treaty founded by UNESCO in 1971.
    • It derives its name from the city of Ramsar in Iran, where it was initially signed.
    • Ramsar sites are wetlands of global significance recognized under this treaty.
    • The Montreux Record is a register of wetland sites on the brink of ecological changes and in need of close monitoring under the Ramsar Convention.

    Ramsar Site Designation Criteria:

    Ramsar site designation hinges on several factors:

    1. Representing rare or unique natural wetland types.
    2. Supporting endangered species or threatened ecological communities.
    3. Maintaining biodiversity in specific biogeographic regions.
    4. Offering refuge during adverse conditions.
    5. Regularly accommodating 20,000 or more waterbirds.
    6. Sustaining 1% of a population of a single water-bird species.
    7. Serving as a critical source of food, spawning grounds, nurseries, and migration paths for fish.
    8. Regularly supporting 1% of a population of non-avian wetland-dependent animal species.

  • How do some Cancer Cells survive Chemotherapy?

    cancer

    Central Idea

    • Researchers at the Netherlands Cancer Institute have conducted a recent study to investigate drug resistance in cancer cells, focusing on resistance to a drug known as Taxol.
    • It studied Chemotherapy and cancer relapse, particularly when a small number of cancer cells resist treatment and remain dormant, potentially leading to a resurgence of the disease.

    Chemotherapy and its limitations

    • Cancer cells are characterized by uncontrolled and rapid division.
    • Chemotherapeutic drugs aim to halt this proliferation, often triggering programmed cell death, known as apoptosis, in response to halted cell division.
    • However, this approach also damages healthy dividing cells, leading to adverse side effects.

    Fine-Tuning Cancer Treatment

    • Oncologists face the challenge of finding an effective drug dose that eliminates cancer cells while minimizing unbearable side effects for patients.
    • One approach has been the development of antibody-drug conjugates (ADCs) that target specific proteins found mainly on cancer cells, sparing non-cancerous cells.

    Unraveling Drug Resistance

    • P-gp Protein: Some cancer cells escape drug treatments by overexpressing a protein called P-gp (permeability glycoprotein), which acts as a pump, expelling toxic compounds, including chemotherapeutic agents.
    • ABCB1 Gene: The production of P-gp is controlled by the ABCB1 gene, and cells that produce excessive P-gp can flush out chemotherapy drugs, preventing them from accumulating at levels needed to trigger apoptosis.

    Role of Cellular Location

    • Recent Findings: The study examined the sensitivity of cells to Taxol and identified that the location of the ABCB1 gene within the cell’s nucleus plays a crucial role.
    • Nuclear Envelope: In sensitive cells, the ABCB1 gene is located close to the nuclear envelope. In resistant cells, the gene has detached from the envelope and moved further inside the nucleus, resulting in a 100-fold increase in ABCB1 gene-related RNA.

    Key Protein: Lamin B Receptor (LBR)

    • LBR’s Influence: Researchers discovered that the presence or absence of a protein called Lamin B Receptor (LBR) affects the location of the ABCB1 gene.
    • Depletion of LBR: When LBR is depleted, cells can activate the ABCB1 gene when exposed to Taxol. However, the absence of the LBR gene itself does not immediately increase ABCB1 expression, indicating the involvement of additional factors.
    • Diverse Responses: Different cancer types exhibit varying responses to LBR depletion, highlighting the complex mechanisms governing gene expression and silencing.
    • Analogy: A simple analogy illustrates the diversity: Different bathrooms offer various options for drying clothes, and cancer cell types rely on different mechanisms to tether genes to the nuclear envelope.

    Significance

    • These findings emphasize the need for further research into the diverse ways cancer cells express or suppress genes.
    • Understanding drug resistance mechanisms opens avenues for developing strategies to maintain the potency of anti-cancer drugs while minimizing side effects, ultimately benefiting patients on their path to recovery.

  • Money Laundering Probe against a Political Party

    Central Idea

    • The Enforcement Directorate (ED) is contemplating adding a political party as an accused in a money laundering probe linked to the now-defunct Excise Policy of the Delhi government.

    Booking a Political Party for Money Laundering

    • Applicable Law: Section 70 of the Prevention of Money Laundering Act (PMLA) addresses offences by companies, and it can be invoked in this case.
    • Definition of “Company”: While a political party isn’t a ‘company’ under the Companies Act, the PMLA includes an explanation that broadens the scope to include ‘associations of individuals,’ potentially encompassing political parties.

    Precedent for such Cases

    • If pursued, this action could set a significant precedent in India’s legal landscape.
    • Previously, political parties have been investigated under the Income Tax Act.
    • Trusts and NGOs are already within the purview of the PMLA, as per a notification by the Finance Ministry.

    Connection between Charges and Political Party

    • The central allegation by the ED is that the political party received the proceeds of crime in the excise scam.
    • An additional explanation in Section 70 of the PMLA specifies that a “company may be prosecuted, notwithstanding whether the prosecution or conviction of any legal juridical person shall be contingent on the prosecution or conviction of any individual.”
    • This implies that even if cases involving party members fail, the party can still be prosecuted for money laundering separately.

  • Supreme Court declines to Legalize Same-Sex Marriage

    Central Idea

    • The Supreme Court of India has declined to approve same-sex marriages in a blow to LGBTQ rights.
    • CJI said that it was outside the court’s remit to decide the issue and that parliament should write the laws governing marriage.

    Same-Sex Marriage Demand

    • Petitioners are urging for the reinterpretation of the Special Marriage Act (SMA), 1954, by replacing “man and woman” with “spouses” to accommodate LGBTQIA+ couples.
    • Such right to marry not only symbolizes equality but also grants access to numerous legal benefits, including insurance, adoption, and inheritance.

    Petitioners’ Demands

    Arguments Summary
    Constitutional Basis Asserted that the right to marry for non-heterosexual couples is implicit in various constitutional articles, including Articles 14, 15, 16, 19, and 21.
    Previous Landmark Judgments Referenced key Supreme Court judgments such as ‘Navtej Singh Johar vs. Union of India’ (2018) and ‘KS Puttaswamy vs. Union of India’ (2017) to support their case.
    Benefits and Rights Emphasized the importance of equal access to marriage-related benefits and rights, such as pensions and provident funds.
    Minimum Marriageable Age Suggested different minimum marriageable ages for lesbian, gay, and transgender couples based on gender identity.
    Recognition of Fundamental Rights Cited the Transgender Persons Protection Act, 2019, as a precedent recognizing the right to marry for all queer identities.

    Respondent’s Arguments

    Arguments Summary
    Maintainability and Jurisdiction Questioned the court’s jurisdiction to hear the case and raised concerns about the maintainability of the petitions.
    Impact on Existing Laws Argued that introducing marriage equality would impact 160 existing laws, making it the prerogative of Parliament to enact such changes.
    SMA Character and Intent Emphasized that the Special Marriage Act (SMA) was intentionally designed for heterosexual marriages, and changing its character and intent would require legislative action.
    Legitimate State Interest Contended that the State has a legitimate interest in regulating marriages, addressing aspects such as age of consent, bigamy, and prohibited degrees of marriage.
    Welfare of Children Advocated for prioritizing the welfare of children born to heterosexual parents, leading to differential treatment of heterosexual and homosexual couples.
    Public Perception Expressed concerns about societal acceptance and potential collateral damage to various legal provisions if same-sex marriage were declared a fundamental right.

    States Responses

    • Rajasthan, Assam, and Andhra Pradesh opposed the plea for legal recognition of same-sex marriages.
    • Sikkim, Maharashtra, Uttar Pradesh, and Manipur sought more time to respond.
    • Also, many fundamentalist religious organizations are opposed to such marriages.

    Conclusion

    • It must be noted that only Taiwan and Nepal allow same-sex unions in Asia, where largely conservative values still dominate politics and society.
    • The Supreme Court’s verdict on marriage equality in India is poised to shape the country’s LGBTQIA+ rights landscape profoundly.

    Also read:

    [Sansad TV] Perspective: Legalizing Same-Sex Marriage