💥Join UPSC 2027,2028 Mentorship (July Batch) + XFactor Notes & Microthemes PDF
Talk to Mentor

Civilsdaily

Login

GS Paper: GS2

  • The severe erosion of fiscal federalism

    Fiscal federalism in dire straits?

    Central Idea:

    The article discusses Kerala’s protest against the imposition of a Net Borrowing Ceiling (NBC) by the Central Government, which restricts the state’s ability to borrow funds. It argues that this imposition undermines fiscal federalism and challenges the constitutional authority of the state legislature over financial matters.

    Key Highlights:

    • Kerala Chief Minister Pinarayi Vijayan leads a protest against the Central Government’s imposition of a financial embargo on Kerala.
    • The NBC limits states’ borrowings, including those from state-owned enterprises like the Kerala Infrastructure Investment Fund Board (KIIFB), leading to a severe financial crisis in Kerala.
    • The article questions the constitutionality of including state-owned enterprises’ debt in the state’s total debt, arguing that it encroaches on the state legislature’s authority over financial matters.
    • Kerala’s Fiscal Responsibility Act, 2003, aims to reduce fiscal deficit, demonstrating the state’s commitment to fiscal discipline.
    • The article criticizes the move towards “annihilative federalism,” where the central government’s actions detrimentally affect states’ ability to meet welfare obligations.

    Key Challenges:

    • Balancing fiscal discipline with the need for states to fund development projects and welfare schemes.
    • Addressing the erosion of fiscal federalism and the encroachment of central authority over state finances.
    • Resolving the conflict between the powers of the central government and state legislatures regarding financial matters.
    • Mitigating the impact of borrowing restrictions on states’ ability to fulfill their financial obligations.

    Key Terms:

    • Net Borrowing Ceiling (NBC): Limit imposed on states’ borrowings from all sources.
    • Kerala Infrastructure Investment Fund Board (KIIFB): State-owned body responsible for funding infrastructure projects.
    • Fiscal Responsibility Act: Legislation aimed at reducing fiscal deficit and promoting financial discipline.
    • Fiscal Federalism: Distribution of financial powers and responsibilities between the central government and states.
    • Annihilative Federalism: Central government actions that undermine states’ financial autonomy and welfare obligations.

    Key Quotes:

    • “The wide array of constitutional issues…point at the severe erosion of fiscal federalism in the country.”
    • “The borrowing restrictions are an example of ‘annihilative federalism’ at play.”

    Key Examples and References:

    • Kerala’s protest led by Chief Minister Pinarayi Vijayan against the financial embargo imposed by the Central Government.
    • The inclusion of KIIFB’s debt in Kerala’s total debt, leading to funding constraints for welfare schemes.
    • Comparison of Kerala’s fiscal deficit reduction efforts with the central government’s fiscal deficit estimates.

    Key Facts and Data:

    • Kerala’s fiscal deficit reported to have reduced to 2.44% of the GSDP.
    • Central government’s fiscal deficit estimated to be 5.8% for 2023-2024.

    Critical Analysis:

    The article underscores the tension between central authority and state autonomy in financial matters, highlighting the constitutional ambiguity surrounding the imposition of borrowing restrictions. It argues for a balanced approach that acknowledges states’ fiscal responsibilities while ensuring fiscal discipline.

    Way Forward:

    • Reevaluate the imposition of borrowing restrictions to ensure they do not unduly impede states’ ability to meet financial obligations.
    • Enhance dialogue and cooperation between the central government and states to address fiscal challenges while respecting constitutional principles.
    • Clarify the division of financial powers between the central government and state legislatures to mitigate conflicts and promote fiscal federalism.

  • Fate of Indian Projects in Myanmar

    myanmar

    Introduction

    • The Arakan Army captured Paletwa in the Chin State, near Bangladesh and India. This has cast aspersions about the development of key Indian projects in Myanmar.

    Myanmar Coup: A quick recap

    • Myanmar’s military ousted Aung San Suu Kyi’s elected government in February 2021.
    • The military expected resistance to subside quickly. After three years, opposition to the military regime is growing.

    Conflict Dynamics near Indian Borders

    • Complex Dynamics: The capture of Paletwa has triggered a complex dynamic between the Chin and Arakan ethnic groups.
    • Ethnic Majority: Majority of Paletwa’s residents belong to the Chin ethnic community.
    • Historical Claims: Some in the Rakhine State argue that Paletwa historically belonged to the Arakan Hill Tracts during colonial rule.
    • Inter–Ethnic Solidarity: Inter-ethnic solidarity among EAOs is essential for an effective fight against the military.
    • Challenge of Compromise: Finding an inter-ethnic compromise on settlements like Paletwa is challenging due to its strategic location.

    Impact on India’s Kaladan Project:

    • Significance for Kaladan: The developments in Paletwa have implications for India’s Kaladan Multimodal Transit Transport Project (KMTTP) in Myanmar.
    • Addressing Challenges: The Kaladan project aims to address northeast India’s geo-economic and geo-political challenges.
    • Project Delays: Delays in project implementation were caused by rugged terrain, inadequate coordination, political instability, and security challenges.
    • Local Attitudes: Attitudes of local ethnic organizations must be considered for swift Kaladan project execution.
    • Local Interest: People in Mizoram and Chin State are interested in the project’s completion as it boosts economic activity.

    China Factor in the Region

    • Three Brotherhood Alliance: The Arakan Army is part of the Three Brotherhood alliance, believed to have Chinese support. This alliance aims to safeguard Chinese investments in Myanmar.
    • Reports of Chinese Support: Reports suggest that the Arakan Army receives funding and military equipment from China.
    • Concerns for India: Concerns exist in India about Beijing using armed groups to hinder India’s connectivity projects in Myanmar.
    • China’s Economic Presence: China has increased its economic presence along Myanmar’s Bay of Bengal coast.
    • Infrastructure Initiatives: Operationalized pipelines and agreements for a deep-sea port and special economic zone are part of China’s initiatives in Myanmar.

    Conclusion

    • India, as a liberal democracy, faces scrutiny regarding the impact of its external engagement on sectarian/identity-based violence in the neighborhood.
    • Scaling up humanitarian and development assistance while collaborating with ethnic organizations is essential.

  • Floor Test in Jharkhand Assembly

    Introduction

    • The new government has won the trust vote on the floor of the Jharkhand Assembly. A floor test serves as a pivotal check to determine if the executive enjoys the confidence of the legislature.

    What is Floor Test?

    • Definition: A floor test is a constitutional measure employed to ascertain whether the Chief Minister, appointed by the Governor, commands the majority support of the Legislative Assembly.
    • Governor’s Role: The Governor appoints the CM, typically from the party securing the majority of seats in the Assembly.
    • Voting of Confidence: If the majority is challenged or questioned, the Chief Minister must seek a vote of confidence to prove the majority among the members present and voting.
    • Consequences of Failure: Failure to secure the majority in the floor test necessitates the resignation of the Chief Minister.
    • Application: Floor tests are conducted both in the Parliament and state legislative assemblies. They are also utilized in cases of disputes within coalition governments.

    Postponement of Floor Tests

    • Legal Precedent: Recent Supreme Court rulings have clarified that floor tests need not be postponed even if the decision on the disqualification of rebel members is pending.
    • Shivraj Singh Chouhan v/s Speaker Case: The 2020 case involving Shivraj Singh Chouhan established this principle.
    • Discretion in Special Cases: In exceptional situations with no clear majority, the Governor can use discretion to expedite the selection of the Chief Ministerial candidate for a floor test.

    Composite Floor Test

    • Multiple Claimants: When multiple individuals stake a claim to form the government, a Composite Floor Test is conducted.
    • Majority Determination: In cases where the majority is unclear, a special session is convened to ascertain the majority.
    • Counting the Majority: Majority is determined based on those present and voting. Voting can occur through voice votes or division voting, involving electronic gadgets, ballots, or slips.
    • Speaker’s Vote: In case of a tie, the Speaker may cast the deciding vote.

    Challenges with the Floor Test

    • Luring of MLAs: In some instances, ruling party MLAs may be lured with rewards or incentives, undermining the constitutionality and fairness of the floor test.
    • Constitutional and Moral Implications: Such actions are seen as constitutionally immoral and unjust, as they circumvent the Tenth Schedule through engineered defections using the judicial process.

    Back2Basics: No Confidence Motion

    • Rule 198 of Lok Sabha: The process for a No Confidence Motion is explained under this rule in the Lok Sabha.
    • Constitutional provisions: While the Constitution does NOT mention the terms ‘No Confidence Motion’ or ‘floor test,’ Articles 75 and 164 establish the collective responsibility of the executive to their respective legislatures.
    • Procedure: Any Opposition member can move a no-confidence motion, which requires the backing of at least 50 members for acceptance.
    • Discussion Period: The Speaker announces a date for discussion, which must occur within 10 days from the date of acceptance.

  • Tackling Unfair Means in Public Examinations: The 2024 Bill

    cheating

    Introduction

    • The Public Examinations (Prevention of Unfair Means) Bill, 2024, introduced in Lok Sabha, seeks to combat “unfair means” in public examinations and enhance transparency and credibility in the examination system.
    • This comprehensive legislation addresses various aspects of unfair practices in public exams and outlines stringent penalties for violations.

    “Unfair Means” in Examinations

    • Enumerating Offenses: Section 3 of the Bill outlines at least 15 actions that constitute “unfair means” in public examinations, primarily for monetary or wrongful gain.
    • Examples: These actions include question paper leaks, unauthorized access to question papers or answer sheets, tampering with answer sheets, providing unauthorized solutions to questions, and conducting fake examinations.

    Scope of “Public Examinations”

    • Defining Public Examinations: Under Section 2(k), a “public examination” encompasses any examination conducted by designated “public examination authorities” listed in the Bill’s Schedule or notified by the Central Government.
    • Designated Authorities: The Schedule includes entities like UPSC, SSC, RRBs, IBPS, and NTA, responsible for various national-level examinations.
    • Central Government’s Authority: Ministries and Departments of the Central Government, along with their attached and subordinate offices for staff recruitment, fall under the Bill’s purview.

    Penalties for Violations

    • Stringent Measures: Section 9 stipulates that offenses are cognizable, non-bailable, and non-compoundable.
    • Cognizable Offenses: Authorities can arrest individuals without a warrant.
    • Non-Bailable: Bail is not a matter of right and is subject to a magistrate’s discretion.
    • Non-Compoundable: Complainants cannot withdraw the case, necessitating a trial.

    Punishments

    • Individual Offenders: Violators may face imprisonment ranging from three to five years and fines of up to Rs 10 lakh.
    • Additional Penalty: Failure to pay the fine can result in additional imprisonment, as per the provisions of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023.
    • Service Providers: Those providing support for examination conduct can be fined up to Rs 1 crore, along with other penalties.
    • Organized Paper Leaks: In cases of organized paper leaks constituting “organized crime,” offenders may face imprisonment for a minimum of five years, extendable up to ten years, and a fine not less than one crore rupees.

    Rationale Behind the Bill

    • Addressing Rampant Paper Leaks: Numerous cases of question paper leaks in recruitment exams nationwide have disrupted the hiring process and affected millions of applicants.
    • Need for Specific Legislation: The absence of a substantive law to address unfair practices in public examinations necessitated a comprehensive central legislation.
    • Objectives: The Bill aims to ensure transparency, fairness, and credibility in public examinations while deterring individuals and entities exploiting vulnerabilities in the system for wrongful gains.
    • Model Draft for States: The Bill is intended to serve as a model for states to adopt at their discretion, assisting them in preventing disruptions in their state-level public examinations.

    Conclusion

    • This legislation represents a significant step toward safeguarding the integrity of public examinations in India.
    • By establishing stringent penalties for unfair practices and addressing the issue of paper leaks, the legislation seeks to reassure candidates that their sincere efforts will be duly rewarded and their future secured.
    • Moreover, the Bill’s potential to serve as a model for state-level legislation enhances its impact in curbing exam-related malpractices.

  • How to restore WTO’s authority

    WTO | 2023 News items - Members share views in informal talks on trade and industrial policy

    Central Idea:

    The ongoing crisis in the World Trade Organisation’s (WTO) dispute settlement mechanism (DSM), particularly the paralysis of the appellate body (AB) due to the US blocking the appointment of new members, poses a significant challenge to the multilateral trading regime. Developing countries like India are pushing for the restoration of the AB to its original form, but alternative options are being considered due to the US’s reluctance.

    Key Highlights:

    • The DSM, particularly the AB, is crucial for ensuring compliance with WTO rulings and maintaining a rules-based global trading system.
    • The US has blocked the appointment of new AB members since 2019, rendering it ineffective and undermining the enforcement of WTO rulings.
    • Developing countries, led by India, are advocating for the restoration of the AB to its original form to ensure fairness and predictability in dispute resolution.
    • Alternative options include joining interim arrangements led by the European Union or proposing a diluted AB with limited powers, but these may compromise the effectiveness of the DSM.
    • Scholars propose a compromise solution where countries can opt out of the AB’s jurisdiction, allowing its restoration while accommodating the US’s concerns.

    Key Challenges:

    • The deadlock caused by the US’s opposition to the AB’s functioning has led to a crisis in the DSM, undermining the WTO’s authority.
    • Developing countries face the challenge of balancing their desire for a fully functioning AB with the need to accommodate the US’s concerns to maintain consensus within the WTO.
    • Alternative solutions, such as interim arrangements or diluted AB proposals, may lack the necessary enforceability or compromise the integrity of the DSM.

    Key Terms:

    • World Trade Organisation (WTO)
    • Dispute Settlement Mechanism (DSM)
    • Appellate Body (AB)
    • Interim Appeal Arbitration Arrangement (MPIA)
    • International Court of Justice (ICJ)

    Key Phrases:

    • “Crisis in the dispute settlement mechanism”
    • “Paralysis of the appellate body”
    • “Developing countries’ advocacy”
    • “Alternative options”
    • “Compromise solution”

    Key Quotes:

    • “The WTO’s DSM — its crown jewel — comprises a binding two-tiered process with a panel and an appellate body (AB).”
    • “Consequently, countries have found an easy way to avoid complying with the WTO panel rulings. They appeal into the void, thereby rendering the WTO toothless.”
    • “A fully functional dispute settlement, with the checks and balances that the appellate body provides, is the best bet for the developing world.”
    • “India and other developing countries should continue striving for the ideal solution: The restoration of the AB in the form it existed till 2019.”

    Key Statements:

    • “The ongoing crisis in the dispute settlement mechanism (DSM) poses a significant challenge to the multilateral trading regime.”
    • “Developing countries are pushing for the restoration of the AB to its original form to ensure fairness and predictability in dispute resolution.”
    • “Alternative options may compromise the effectiveness of the DSM and undermine the enforcement of WTO rulings.”

    Way Forward:

    • Advocate for Restoration: Developing countries should continue advocating for the restoration of the AB to its original form, emphasizing its importance for ensuring fairness and predictability in the global trading system.
    • Explore Compromise Solutions: Consider compromise solutions, such as allowing countries to opt out of the AB’s jurisdiction, to accommodate the concerns of key stakeholders like the US while maintaining the integrity of the DSM.
    • Strengthen Interim Arrangements: If necessary, explore joining interim arrangements led by entities like the European Union to provide temporary solutions while working towards a more permanent resolution within the WTO framework.

  • A critical view of the ‘sanitation miracle’ in rural India

    India Achieves Another Major Sanitation Milestone - 50% Villages Are Now ODF Plus Under Swachh Bharat Mission Grameen Phase II Nearly 3 Lakh Villages Declare Themselves ODF Plus, A Significant Step Towards Achieving SBM-G Phase II Goals By ...

    Central Idea:

    The article discusses the progress and challenges of India’s sanitation programs, particularly focusing on the Swachh Bharat Mission-Grameen (SBM-G) and its Phase II. It highlights the importance of behavioral change alongside infrastructure development for sustainable sanitation practices.

    Key Highlights:

    • Improvement in sanitation coverage in India from 39% in 2014 to 100% in 2019 under SBM-G.
    • Launch of Phase II of SBM-G focusing on sustainability and ODF Plus status by 2024-25.
    • Challenges including non-usage of toilets due to various reasons such as lack of infrastructure, hygiene issues, and social norms.
    • Disparities in toilet access and usage across different states and socio-economic groups.
    • Importance of social networks and behavioral change campaigns in promoting sanitation practices.
    • Lack of synergy and coordination among various government programs addressing basic needs.

    Key Challenges:

    • Ensuring sustained usage of toilets post-construction.
    • Addressing disparities in access and usage across different regions and socio-economic groups.
    • Overcoming social norms and behaviors hindering sanitation practices.
    • Lack of coordination among different government programs related to basic needs.

    Key Terms/Phrases:

    • Swachh Bharat Mission-Grameen (SBM-G)
    • Open Defecation Free (ODF)
    • Total Sanitation Campaign
    • ODF Plus
    • Jal Jeevan Mission (JJM)
    • Social norms
    • Behavioral change campaigns

    Key Quotes:

    • “The construction of toilets does not automatically lead to their use.”
    • “Sanitation behavior also varies across socio-economic classes.”
    • “Behavioral change in sanitation cannot happen independently.”

    Key Examples/Anecdotes:

    • Survey findings showing reasons for non-usage of toilets in different regions.
    • Observations on the influence of social networks on sanitation behavior.

    Key Statements:

    • “Improvement in sanitation coverage needs to be viewed from the perspective of behavioral change for true sustainability.”
    • “Social norms and economic conditions significantly influence toilet usage.”

    Key Facts/Data:

    • Sanitation coverage improved from 39% in 2014 to 100% in 2019 under SBM-G.
    • NARSS-3 reported 95% toilet access but only 85% usage in rural India.
    • Around 10 crore toilets were constructed between 2014 and 2019.

    Critical Analysis:

    The article effectively highlights the progress and challenges in India’s sanitation programs, emphasizing the importance of behavioral change alongside infrastructure development. It underscores the need for targeted efforts to address disparities and overcome social norms hindering sanitation practices. Additionally, the critique of the lack of synergy among government programs provides valuable insight into the inefficiencies in addressing basic needs.

    Way Forward:

    • Strengthening behavioral change campaigns tailored to different socio-economic contexts.
    • Enhancing coordination among government programs addressing basic needs.
    • Targeted interventions to address disparities in access and usage across regions and socio-economic groups.
    • Continuous monitoring and evaluation to ensure sustained usage of sanitation facilities.

  • An Uttar Pradesh model to tackle malnutrition

    An Uttar Pradesh model to tackle malnutrition - The Hindu

    Central Idea:

    The article highlights the success of a decentralized approach to tackling malnutrition in Uttar Pradesh by empowering women through community-based micro-enterprises. This initiative, led by self-help groups, focuses on producing fortified and nutritious foods for pregnant/breastfeeding mothers and children, distributed via the Integrated Child Development Services (ICDS) programme.

    Key Highlights:

    • Collaborative effort between the Department of Women and Child Development and the Uttar Pradesh State Rural Livelihood Mission.
    • Decentralized production of take-home rations by women’s enterprises.
    • Positive impact on livelihoods with over 4,000 women engaged in 204 self-help group micro-enterprises.
    • Re-formulation of take-home rations to enhance nutritional value and address monotony.
    • Focus on strengthening demand through diverse and nutritious products.
    • Innovation through app-based solutions and QR code tracking for supply chain management.

    Key Challenges:

    • Ensuring consistent quality and safety standards.
    • Overcoming logistical challenges in decentralized production and distribution.
    • Addressing potential resistance to change from centralized to decentralized models.
    • Sustaining long-term engagement and empowerment of women.

    Key Terms:

    • Self-help groups
    • Micro-enterprises
    • Integrated Child Development Services (ICDS)
    • Fortified foods
    • Decentralized production
    • Nutritional supplementation
    • Livelihood opportunities

    Key Phrases:

    • Women’s empowerment for nutrition
    • Decentralized model for take-home ration production
    • Strengthening demand through diverse products
    • Innovation and sustainability in food production
    • Multi-stakeholder approach for effective solutions

    Key Quotes:

    • “Engaging women from the community to run the take-home ration production units is a game-changer.”
    • “The State-wide expansion of micro-enterprises led by women confirms successful targeting and demonstrates how empowering women can bring about effective and sustainable processes.”

    Key Examples and References:

    • Collaboration between the Department of Women and Child Development and the Uttar Pradesh State Rural Livelihood Mission.
    • Use of two pilot plants by the United Nations World Food Programme in Unnao and Fatehpur.
    • Expansion to 202 production units across 43 districts, benefiting 12 million ICDS beneficiaries.

    Key Statements:

    • “This initiative presents an excellent opportunity for women to earn a livelihood and contribute to the local economy.”
    • “The re-formulated take-home rations are nutritious and designed to support the health and well-being of children.”

    Key Facts/Data:

    • Over 4,000 women engaged in 204 self-help group micro-enterprises.
    • Aim to generate an additional income of ₹8,000 a month for each woman.
    • Products include sweet and savory options like aata besan halwa and daliya moong dal khichdi.
    • Expansion to 202 production units across 43 districts, benefiting 12 million ICDS beneficiaries.

    Critical Analysis:

    • The initiative effectively addresses the intersection of women’s empowerment and nutrition, leveraging community resources for sustainable impact.
    • Decentralized production and diverse product offerings enhance accessibility and acceptability.
    • Challenges such as quality control and scalability need continuous monitoring and adaptation.

    Way Forward:

    • Continued support for women’s empowerment and capacity building.
    • Strengthening of quality assurance mechanisms.
    • Further research and innovation in product development and supply chain management.
    • Collaboration with stakeholders for scaling up and sustainability.

  • The road to a healthy democracy

    Role of Patients in Strengthening Indian HealthCare System

    Central Idea:

    Prathap C. Reddy, founder and chairman of Apollo Hospitals Group, advocates for India’s transformation into a developed nation by 2047, emphasizing the crucial role of healthcare in this vision. He highlights India’s demographic advantage, technological innovations in preventive healthcare, and the potential for India to lead the world in healthcare delivery and medical value travel.

    Key Highlights:

    • India’s demographic dividend, with a young population, presents a significant opportunity for development.
    • The importance of prioritizing preventive healthcare to address the growing burden of chronic diseases like diabetes, cardiovascular diseases, and cancer.
    • Technological advancements, including AI and machine learning, are revolutionizing preventive healthcare by enabling early detection and personalized prevention plans.
    • India’s healthcare sector is undergoing transformation, focusing on patient-centered care, expanded access, and quality improvement.
    • India’s healthcare infrastructure and clinical talent have gained global recognition, making it a preferred destination for medical value travel, particularly in specialized treatments like oncology, cardiology, and robotic surgeries.

    Key Challenges:

    • Addressing the increasing burden of chronic diseases and lifestyle-related health issues.
    • Ensuring equitable access to preventive healthcare tools and services across all segments of the population.
    • Scaling up healthcare infrastructure and workforce to meet the growing demand, especially in rural areas.
    • Overcoming barriers to the adoption of AI-driven healthcare solutions, including data privacy concerns and regulatory challenges.
    • Balancing the need for affordable healthcare with maintaining high-quality standards in a cost-effective manner.

    Key Terms:

    • Demographic dividend
    • Preventive healthcare
    • Chronic diseases
    • Artificial Intelligence (AI)
    • Medical value travel
    • Patient-centered care
    • Healthcare infrastructure
    • Non-communicable diseases (NCDs)

    Key Phrases:

    • “Viksit Bharat” (Developed India)
    • “Health equity for all”
    • “Clinical excellence and prowess”
    • “Patient at the absolute centre”
    • “Medical value travel hub”
    • “AI-driven healthcare solutions”

    Key Quotes:

    • “India’s healthcare sector is at the cusp of transformation, potentially giving rise to a new healthcare model for the world to follow.”
    • “Preventive healthcare has touched new possibilities, empowering individuals to take control of their own health.”
    • “India stands at a pivotal moment in its healthcare journey.”
    • “Every individual and institution in the country should resolve to make India’s progress their priority.”

    Key Statements:

    • India’s demographic dividend offers a unique opportunity for development, but the health of the population is crucial for maximizing this potential.
    • Technological innovations in healthcare, including AI, have the potential to revolutionize preventive care and improve health outcomes.
    • India’s healthcare sector has gained global recognition for its clinical excellence, infrastructure, and affordability, positioning it as a leader in medical value travel.

    Key Examples and References:

    • Success of Apollo Hospitals Group in providing high-quality healthcare services and driving medical tourism in India.
    • Impact of technological interventions in preventive healthcare, such as AI-driven risk prediction and personalized prevention plans.
    • Growth of medical value travel industry in India, attracting patients from around the world for specialized treatments at lower costs.

    Key Facts and Data:

    • India’s population exceeds 1.4 billion, with a median age of 29 years, presenting a significant demographic dividend.
    • India has over 101 million diabetics and 136 million prediabetics, making it the diabetes capital of the world.
    • Cardiovascular diseases are the leading cause of mortality in India, and cancer incidence is projected to rise by 57.5% by 2040.
    • India’s healthcare costs are approximately one-tenth of the global average, making it an attractive destination for medical value travel.

    Critical Analysis:

    • While the article emphasizes the potential of technological innovations and medical value travel in transforming India’s healthcare sector, it’s essential to ensure that these developments benefit all segments of the population, particularly those in rural and underserved areas.
    • The challenge of addressing the growing burden of chronic diseases requires a comprehensive approach, including not only preventive measures but also effective management and treatment strategies.
    • Balancing affordability with quality in healthcare delivery is crucial to maintain India’s competitiveness in medical value travel while ensuring that patients receive optimal care.

    Way Forward:

    • Prioritize investments in preventive healthcare, leveraging technology to empower individuals to manage their health effectively.
    • Expand access to healthcare services, especially in rural and underserved areas, through innovative delivery models and infrastructure development.
    • Foster collaboration between public and private sectors to drive healthcare innovation and address key challenges in the sector.
    • Focus on capacity building and skill development to ensure a competent healthcare workforce capable of delivering high-quality care across all settings.
    • Advocate for policies that promote affordability, accessibility, and quality in healthcare delivery, ensuring that India’s healthcare system remains inclusive and sustainable.

  • GST Appellate Tribunals to be set around July or August

    Introduction

    • The Goods and Services Tax (GST) Appellate Tribunals, eagerly anticipated to address taxpayer disputes within the six-and-a-half-year-old indirect tax regime, are set to commence operations around July or August.

    What is GST Appellate Tribunal?

    • The GST Appellate Tribunal is a quasi-judicial body proposed to be established to resolve disputes related to the Goods and Services Tax (GST) in India.
    • It will function as an independent body to hear appeals against orders passed by the GST authorities or the Appellate Authority.
    • The tribunal will be composed of a national bench and various regional benches, headed by a chairperson appointed by the central government.
    • The proposed tribunal is expected to help expedite the resolution of disputes related to GST and reduce the burden on the judiciary.

    Under GST, if a person is not satisfied with the decision passed by any lower court, an appeal can be raised to a higher court, the hierarchy for the same is as follows (from low to high):

    1. Adjudicating Authority
    2. Appellate Authority
    3. Appellate Tribunal
    4. High Court
    5. Supreme Court

    Need for such Tribunal

    • Unburden judiciary: GST Appellate Tribunal will help resolve the rising number of disputes under the 68-month-old indirect tax regime that are now clogging High Courts and other judicial fora.
    • Improve efficiency of GST System: Overall, the establishment of the GST Appellate Tribunal is expected to improve the efficiency and effectiveness of the GST system in India.
    • Independent mechanism: The proposed Tribunal will provide an independent and efficient mechanism for resolving disputes related to GST.
    • Avoid tax evasion: It will help to expedite the resolution of disputes, reduce the burden on the judiciary, and promote greater certainty and predictability in the GST system.

    Issues with present litigation

    • Compliance issues: The GST system is relatively new in India, having been implemented in 2017, and there have been several issues with compliance and interpretation of rules and regulations.
    • Complex adjudication hierarchy: The current dispute resolution mechanism involves multiple layers of adjudication, starting with the GST officer and as mentioned above.
    • Time-consuming process: This process can be time-consuming, costly, and burdensome for taxpayers, especially small and medium-sized enterprises.

    Significance

    • The creation of these tribunals had been in the pipeline since the implementation of the GST regime on July 1, 2017.
    • The number of pending appeals by taxpayers related to central GST levies had surged to over 14,000 (June 2023).

  • Four issues that CJI highlighted within Legal Profession

    cji

    Introduction

    • During the Supreme Court’s 75th-year Foundation Day address, the Chief Justice of India (CJI) highlighted four crucial issues within the judiciary that require “difficult conversations.”
    • This article delves into these issues and their historical context.

    Major Issues with Legal Profession

    [1] Problem of “Adjournment Culture”

    • Definition: Adjournment culture refers to the practice of lawyers repeatedly seeking adjournments, delaying scheduled hearings.
    • Effect on Justice: Prolonged adjournments lead to case delays and contribute to the growing backlog of pending cases.
    • Legal Framework: Order XVII of the Civil Procedure Code, 1908 sets rules for granting adjournments, limiting them to three times, with sufficient cause shown.
    • Vicious Cycle: Advocates exploit heavy workloads to seek adjournments, perpetuating delays.

    [2] Managing Lengthy Oral Arguments

    • Constitutional Bench Matters: The court directs parties to schedule oral arguments to avoid repetition in important cases.
    • Mixed Success: Past cases, like the Ayodhya title dispute, had lengthy hearings despite scheduling.
    • Recent Improvements: Under CJI UU Lalit, a Constitution Bench case involving EWS reservations achieved efficiency through time scheduling.
    • US Model: The US Supreme Court restricts oral arguments to 30 minutes per side, considered but not adopted in India.

    [3] Alternatives to Extended Court Vacations

    • Flexi-Time: Introducing flexi-time for lawyers and judges is suggested, allowing them to choose working hours within a specified total.
    • Philippines Example: The Philippines implemented flexi-time for court employees based on valid reasons.
    • Historical Suggestions: Past reports and government recommendations aimed to reduce court vacations to tackle case backlog.
    • Supreme Court Rules: In 2014, the court limited summer vacations to seven weeks instead of ten.

    [4] Ensuring Equal Opportunities for First-Generation Lawyers

    • Leveling the Field: The CJI emphasizes providing a level playing field for first-generation lawyers and marginalized segments with the potential to succeed.
    • Progress: Over 50% of junior civil judge exam candidates are women, and 41% of Supreme Court law clerk candidates are women.
    • Inclusivity Efforts: Initiatives by the Supreme Court Advocates-on-Record Association (SCAORA) aim to support diversity, including giving weightage to first-generation lawyers for Senior Advocate designations.
    • Judicial Recognition: The judiciary acknowledges the growth and contributions of first-generation lawyers, dismissing claims that recognition is solely based on wealth and proximity.

    Conclusion

    • The judiciary faces multifaceted challenges, including adjournment culture, oral argument lengths, court vacations, and ensuring a fair platform for first-generation lawyers.
    • Addressing these issues requires frank discussions, reforms, and continued efforts to uphold the principles of justice and inclusivity within the legal profession.