💥Join UPSC 2027,2028 Mentorship (July Batch) + XFactor Notes & Microthemes PDF
Talk to Mentor

Civilsdaily

Login

Distribution: yearly

  • Sub-Categorization among SCs: Legal Aspects and Implications

    Central Idea

    • In a recent election rally in Telangana, PM made a commitment to explore the sub-categorization of Scheduled Castes (SCs) to identify and uplift the most marginalized among them.
    • This move is seen as an attempt to garner support from the Madiga community, the largest among the SC communities in the state.

    SC Sub-Categorization: Legality Check

    • State-Level Attempts: Over the past two decades, several states, including Punjab, Bihar, and Tamil Nadu, have attempted to introduce reservation laws to sub-categorize SCs within their territories. These efforts have been held up in courts, awaiting a Supreme Court Constitution Bench’s decision.
    • Andhra Pradesh’s Initiative: The issue surfaced when the Andhra Pradesh government formed a commission in 1996, led by Justice Ramachandra Raju, to recommend sub-categorization based on disparities among SC communities. However, the Supreme Court, in 2004, ruled that states did not possess the unilateral authority to sub-categorize communities within the SC and Scheduled Tribes (ST) lists, as these lists are the prerogative of Parliament and the President.
    • Contradictory Rulings: A 2020 judgment by a five-judge Bench, led by Justice Arun Mishra, contradicted the 2004 ruling by stating that determining benefits within the SC/ST lists would not amount to “tinkering” and could be done by states. This discrepancy prompted the referral of the 2020 judgment to a larger Bench.

    Government Initiatives and Legal Opinions

    • Union Government’s Efforts: The 2004 judgment prompted the Union government to explore the possibility of sub-categorization. In 2005, the Attorney-General of India (AGI) opined that sub-categorization was feasible if supported by “unimpeachable evidence” and suggested a constitutional amendment for this purpose.
    • National Commission Recommendations: The National Commission for Scheduled Castes (NCSC) and the National Commission for Scheduled Tribes (NCST) opined that a constitutional amendment was unnecessary. They cited Article 16(4) of the Constitution, which allows states to create special laws for under-represented backward classes.

    Arguments for Sub-Categorization

    • Graded Inequalities: Proponents argue that sub-categorization addresses the graded inequalities within SC communities. It ensures that the more backward communities receive their fair share of benefits, preventing the dominance of relatively advanced communities.
    • Representation at All Levels: The goal is to ensure representation at all levels, including higher positions. However, the most backward SCs lag so far behind that even reserved positions at advanced levels may not benefit them due to a lack of suitable candidates.

    Data Requirement for Sub-Categorization

    • Legal experts emphasize the importance of robust data, including population numbers, socio-economic indicators, and community-specific information.
    • This data would form the basis for reasonable categorization, quota allocation, and policy decisions.

    Conclusion

    • The sub-categorization of Scheduled Castes (SCs) is a complex legal and social issue that remains unresolved, with contradictory Supreme Court rulings and varying opinions among government bodies.
    • While sub-categorization aims to address disparities within SC communities, it raises practical challenges, such as data collection and ensuring meaningful representation.
    • The quest for a fair and legally sound sub-categorization mechanism continues, with the need for comprehensive data and clear legal guidelines at the forefront of the debate.

  • Amal Kumar Raychaudhuri and the Raychaudhuri Equation

    Raychaudhuri

    Central Idea

    • Amal Kumar Raychaudhuri, an Indian physicist, overcame obstacles and restrictions to make a profound contribution to the field of general relativity.

    A.K. Raychaudhuri: Early Life  

    • Born in Barisal, now in Bangladesh, in 1923.
    • Educated in Kolkata.
    • Developed a deep interest in general relativity during his time at the Indian Association of Cultivation of Science (IACS).

    Challenges Faced

    • While passionate about general relativity, Raychaudhuri was instructed by the director of IACS, Meghnad Saha, to work on topics of the director’s choosing or leave.
    • Raychaudhuri, with limited career options, complied with Saha’s directive but continued to explore the mysteries of gravity in his spare time.

    Theoretical Breakthrough: The Raychaudhuri Equation

    • Raychaudhuri focused on the problem of singularities in general relativity, specifically points where gravity could become infinitely strong.
    • Developed a unique approach that bypassed complex mathematical challenges.
    • Introduced the Raychaudhuri equation, a simple and elegant formula that showed the inevitable convergence of matter in curved spacetime.
    • The equation hinted strongly at the existence of singularities, a critical aspect of general relativity.

    Influence on Renowned Physicists

    • Raychaudhuri’s equation played a pivotal role in the work of Stephen Hawking and Roger Penrose.
    • Hawking’s area theorem, demonstrating that the surface area of black holes never decreases, relied on the Raychaudhuri equation.

    Recognition and Legacy

    • Despite his groundbreaking work, Raychaudhuri received limited recognition in India.
    • He faced obstacles in career advancement, including rejection by Calcutta University.
    • Raychaudhuri eventually joined Presidency College, Kolkata, where he became a revered teacher, inspiring future generations of physicists.

  • NASA-ISRO NISAR Mission Prepares for Launch

    nisar

    Central Idea

    • The NASA-ISRO Synthetic Aperture Radar (NISAR) mission, a collaborative effort between NASA and ISRO, is on track for its scheduled launch in the first quarter of 2024.

    About the NISAR Mission

    • Collaboration: NISAR is a Low Earth Orbit observatory developed jointly by NASA and ISRO, highlighting international collaboration in space exploration.
    • Launch Vehicle: The mission is set to launch from the Satish Dhawan Space Centre in Sriharikota onboard ISRO’s GSLV Mark-II launch vehicle.
    • Data Utility: NISAR data will offer unprecedented detail and assist researchers in various ways, including monitoring volcanic activity, tracking groundwater use effects, measuring ice sheet melt rates, and observing changes in global vegetation distribution.
    • Mission Duration: The $1.5-billion NISAR mission has a planned mission life of three years and will survey Earth’s land and ice-covered surfaces every 12 days following a 90-day commissioning period.

    Advanced SAR Technology

    • Dual-Band SAR: NISAR carries L and S dual-band Synthetic Aperture Radar (SAR) using the Sweep SAR technique, providing both wide coverage and high-resolution data.
    • Observatory Structure: The SAR payloads are mounted on the Integrated Radar Instrument Structure (IRIS) along with the spacecraft bus, forming an observatory.
    • Contributions: NASA’s Jet Propulsion Laboratory (JPL) provides the L-band SAR and several key components, while ISRO’s U R Rao Satellite Centre contributes the spacecraft bus, S-band SAR electronics, launch vehicle, and mission operations.

    Key milestones achieved

    • Thermal Vacuum Testing: The thermal vacuum testing, a critical system-level test, was successfully completed in Bengaluru. This test ensures that the spacecraft can operate effectively under extreme temperature conditions.
    • EMI and EMC Testing: Electromagnetic interference (EMI) and electromagnetic compatibility (EMC) testing have also been successfully accomplished.
    • Upcoming Vibration Tests: The next phase involves conducting vibration tests to simulate the harsh launch environment. This test will subject the satellite to intense vibrations while mimicking the conditions of a rocket launch.

  • Debate over Appropriate Age of Admission to Class 1

    age

    Central Idea

    • The age at which children should begin formal education has been a topic of debate and discussion, with variations in policies and practices among different states and countries.
    • Understanding the rationale behind these age criteria is crucial for shaping educational policies that align with the needs and development of young learners.

    NEP 2020 and Minimum Age for Class 1

    • National Education Policy (NEP) 2020: NEP 2020 introduces a “5+3+3+4” structure for formal schooling, emphasizing early childhood education for ages 3 to 5 years.
    • Minimum Age for Class 1: According to NEP 2020, a child should be 6 years old to enroll in Class 1, following three years of early childhood education.

    Recent News and Policy Implementation

    • Union Education Ministry’s Efforts: The Union Education Ministry has urged states to align their Class 1 admission age with NEP 2020’s recommendation.
    • Kendriya Vidyalayas Case: Last year, Kendriya Vidyalayas increased the admission age to align with NEP 2020, leading to a legal challenge that was ultimately dismissed.
    • Delhi Government’s Decision: This year, the Delhi government decided to maintain its existing guidelines, permitting Class 1 admission below the age of 6.

    Right to Education (RTE) Act, 2009

    • RTE Act’s Age Provision: RTE Act guarantees education from ages 6 to 14, implying that elementary education (Class 1) should begin at age 6.
    • Historical Perspective: The age of 6 was chosen based on global practices and historical references, including Mahatma Gandhi’s basic education principles.

    Research on Entry Age for Formal Education

    • David Whitebread’s Research: Studies comparing early literacy lessons starting at ages 5 and 7 in New Zealand showed no significant advantage for early introduction to formal learning.
    • Reading Achievement Study: A study across 55 countries found no significant association between reading achievement and school entry age.

    Global Practices in Starting Formal Education

    • Standard Age of 6: Many East Asian and European countries start formal education at age 6, with younger children often attending preschool.
    • Scandinavian Approach: Scandinavian countries typically begin formal education at age 7, supported by universal child care for younger children.
    • US and UK Variation: The USA and UK stand out as countries where children generally start school at age 5, with varying childcare provisions.

    Conclusion

    • The debate over the appropriate age for starting formal education encompasses a range of factors, including developmental readiness, educational goals, and cultural norms.
    • Understanding the diverse approaches and research findings can inform policymakers as they strive to create educational systems that best serve the needs of young learners.

  • PM-PVTGS Development Mission launched

    pvtgs

    Central Idea

    • Prime Minister launched Pradhan Mantri PVTG Development Mission worth Rs 24,000 crore for the development of Particularly Vulnerable Tribal Groups (PVTGs) during.

    PM PVTGS Development Mission

    • Objective: This Rs 24,000-crore initiative is dedicated to the holistic development of PVTGs.
    • Focus Areas: It aims to provide essential amenities like road and telecom connectivity, electricity, housing, clean water, sanitation, improved education, healthcare, nutrition, and sustainable livelihoods.
    • Multi-Ministerial Approach: Multiple ministries will collaborate to implement development projects, including Pradhan Mantri Gram Sadak Yojana, Pradhan Mantri Gramin Awas Yojana, and Jal Jeevan Mission.

    Who are Particularly Vulnerable Tribal Groups (PVTGs)?

    • Unique Characteristics: PVTGs are a subset of tribal groups in India characterized by primitive traits, geographical isolation, low literacy, zero to negative population growth rate, and economic backwardness.
    • Dependency on Hunting: These tribes often rely on hunting for sustenance and employ pre-agricultural technology.
    • Historical Background: The distinction for Primitive Tribal Groups (PTGs) was introduced in 1973 by the Dhebar Commission.
    • Expansion: In 1975, the Centre identified 52 tribal groups as PTGs, and this list expanded by 23 groups in 1993.
    • Renaming as PVTGs: In 2006, these groups were renamed as Particularly Vulnerable Tribal Groups (PVTGs).

    Current status of PVTGs

    • Population and Distribution: India is home to 2.8 million PVTG members, belonging to 75 tribes, residing in 22,544 villages across 220 districts in 18 states and Union Territories.
    • Statewise Population: States with significant PVTG populations include Odisha (866,000), Madhya Pradesh (609,000), and Andhra Pradesh (including Telangana) (539,000).
    • Largest PVTG: The largest PVTG is the Saura community in Odisha, numbering 535,000.

    Try this PYQ:

    Q.Consider the following statements about Particularly Vulnerable Tribal Groups (PVTGs) in India:

    1. PVTGs reside in 18 States and one Union Territory.
    2. A stagnant or declining population is one of the criteria for determining PVTG status.
    3. There are 95 PVTGs officially notified in the country so far.
    4. Irular and Konda Reddi tribes are included in the list of PVTGs.

    Which of the statements given above are correct? (CSP 2019)

    (a) 1, 2 and 3

    (b) 2, 3 and 4

    (c) 1, 2 and 4

    (d) 1, 3 and 4

     

    [wpdiscuz-feedback id=”m9e0nli45f” question=”Please leave a feedback on this” opened=”1″]Post your answers here.[/wpdiscuz-feedback]

  • FATF Mutual Evaluation of India

    Central Idea

    • A team from the Financial Action Task Force (FATF) is currently conducting a mutual evaluation in India.
    • India’s mutual evaluation report is expected to be discussed during the FATF plenary meeting in June 2024.

    About Financial Action Task Force (FATF)

    • Foundation: FATF was founded in 1989 through the initiative of the G7 nations.
    • Secretariat: The FATF Secretariat is headquartered at the OECD headquarters in Paris, France.
    • Plenary Meetings: FATF conducts three Plenary meetings during each of its 12-month rotating presidencies.
    • Membership: As of 2019, FATF consists of 37 member jurisdictions.

    India’s Engagement with FATF

    • Observer Status: India became an Observer at FATF in 2006, marking the beginning of its association with the organization.
    • Full Membership: On June 25, 2010, India officially became the 34th country to attain full membership in FATF, signifying its active participation and commitment to the organization’s objectives.

    Understanding the Mutual Evaluation Process

    • Review Framework: The mutual evaluation process is an essential mechanism through which FATF assesses a country’s legal and institutional framework to combat money laundering and terrorist financing. It also evaluates the country’s implementation of measures to prevent these financial crimes.
    • Compliance Assessment: During this process, FATF scrutinizes a country’s adherence to its 40 recommendations regarding anti-money laundering and counter-terrorism financing. It also evaluates the practical effectiveness of these measures.
    • Outcome and Rating: The outcome of the mutual evaluation is documented in a report. This report highlights the country’s strengths, identifies weaknesses, and suggests areas for improvement. A rating is assigned based on the level of compliance and effectiveness.

    FATF’s Evaluation of India

    • Comprehensive Assessment: FATF’s evaluation of India encompasses various aspects, including the nation’s legal framework, regulatory system, law enforcement efforts, and international collaboration.
    • Alignment with Global Standards: Central agencies in India have been actively working to ensure that the country’s anti-money laundering and counter-terrorism financing laws align with international standards and that their practical implementation is effective.

    Significance of FATF Evaluation

    • Report Impact: The evaluation results in a comprehensive report detailing India’s strengths, weaknesses, and areas requiring improvement. This report includes a rating based on compliance and effectiveness.
    • Global Anti-Financial Crime Efforts: The mutual evaluation process is a crucial tool in the worldwide fight against money laundering and terrorist financing.
    • Financial Implications: The outcome can significantly affect a country’s access to international financial markets and its standing in the global community.

  • Reviving Adultery as a Criminal Offense

    Adultery

    Central Idea

    • The Parliamentary Committee on Home Affairs has proposed the reintroduction of adultery as a criminal offense in the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita (BNS), 2023, a law designed to replace the Indian Penal Code (IPC), 1860.
    • The committee’s recommendations have sparked a debate on the legal position of adultery and its implications on constitutional rights and gender equality.

    Adultery De-Criminalization in India

    • Adultery in IPC (1860): Until 2018, Section 497 of the IPC defined adultery as a criminal offense, penalizing only men for engaging in adulterous relationships.
    • Supreme Court’s Verdict (Joseph Shine vs. Union of India, 2018): The Supreme Court unanimously struck down Section 497, citing discrimination and violations of fundamental rights.

    Parliamentary Committee’s Recommendations

    • Gender-Neutral Adultery: The Committee suggests reinstating adultery as a criminal offense but making it gender-neutral, applicable to both men and women.
    • Safeguarding Marriage Sanctity: The Committee argues that safeguarding the sanctity of marriage is crucial and justifies criminalizing adultery.

    Legal and Constitutional Implications

    • Discrimination and Violation of Fundamental Rights: The Supreme Court’s verdict in Joseph Shine case highlighted the discriminatory nature of Section 497 and its violation of Articles 14, 15, and 21 of the Constitution.
    • Autonomy of Women: The judgment emphasized women’s autonomy and dignity, asserting that husbands do not possess legal sovereignty over their wives.
    • Privacy and Matrimonial Sphere: Adultery as a criminal offense intrudes into the privacy of the matrimonial sphere, which is better left as a ground for divorce.
    • Relic of Victorian Morality: The Court deemed Section 497 as a relic of Victorian morality that treats women as chattels and property of their husbands.

    Can the Supreme Court’s Decision Be Overturned?

    • Parliament’s Authority: While Parliament cannot directly overturn a Supreme Court ruling, it can pass legislation that addresses the basis of the court’s judgment.
    • Validating Legislation: Parliament can enact validating legislation that changes the circumstances under which the court’s judgment was rendered, effectively altering the legal landscape.

    Conclusion

    • The debate surrounding the reintroduction of adultery as a criminal offence is fraught with legal, constitutional, and societal implications.
    • It calls for a nuanced examination of individual rights, gender equality, and the sanctity of marriage within the framework of Indian law and society.

  • Centre-State Disputes: Implications on India’s Economy

    Central Idea

    • In India, disputes between the Central and State governments regarding economic policies have a long history, but in recent years, they have escalated in both frequency and intensity, taking on the character of ‘persistent frictions’ within the federal system.
    • These disputes have significant implications for India’s economy and its federal structure.

    Current Context

    • Impact of Economic Reforms: Economic reforms since 1991 have relaxed many controls on investments, granting some autonomy to States. However, States still rely on the Centre for revenue receipts.
    • Shift from ‘Give and Take’ to Hardened Stance: Recent State resistance has transformed the cooperative Centre-State relationship into a more rigid and confrontational dynamic.

    Emerging Conflict Areas

    • Homogenization of Social Sector Policies: Conflicts arise over the homogenization of social sector policies, where States seek greater discretion, but central agencies push for uniformity.
    • Functioning of Regulatory Institutions: Differences emerge regarding the functioning of regulatory institutions, leading to conflicts over jurisdiction.
    • Powers of Central Agencies: Central agencies attempt to increase their influence, often imposing their preferences on States.

    Economic Consequences of Interference

    • Crowding Out State Investments: Centralization of planning and implementation limits States’ flexibility in infrastructure development. This has resulted in reduced State investments, particularly in projects like roads and bridges.
    • Fiscal Competition: Frictions with the Centre have spurred fiscal competition between States and the Centre. States compete with each other and with the Centre, leading to complexities in welfare provisioning.
    • Inefficiencies Due to Parallel Policies: Frictions have resulted in parallel policies, where either the Centre or States duplicate each other’s efforts. For example, some States have rolled back from the National Pension System (NPS) due to fiscal concerns.

    Inevitable Interdependence

    • Article 258A: The Centre relies on States for the implementation of many laws and policies, particularly in concurrent spheres.
    • Preserving Interdependence: In a large, diverse, developing society like India, interdependence between the Centre and States is inevitable and needs to be maintained.

    Conclusion

    • The growing Centre-State disputes in India’s federal system have far-reaching economic implications.
    • Balancing autonomy and cooperation between the Centre and States is essential for the nation’s economic growth and effective governance.

    Back2Basics:

    Centre-State Financial Relations

     

    Article 268 to 281 Distribution of taxes between the Central Government and States, specifying various taxes and their sharing.
    Article 282 Allows the Central Government to provide grants-in-aid to States for specific purposes, including welfare programs.
    Article 293 Regulates borrowing powers of States, requiring Presidential consent for external borrowing to ensure fiscal discipline.
    Article 280 Establishes the Finance Commission, which recommends tax revenue and grants distribution between the Centre and States.
    Goods and Services Tax (GST) Governed by the Constitution (One Hundred and First Amendment) Act, 2016, and associated laws, transforming taxation in India.
    Fiscal Responsibility and Budget Management (FRBM) Act Guides fiscal discipline and management by setting fiscal targets for both Central and State Governments.
    Inter-State Council Established under Article 263

    Acts as a forum for dialogue between the Central Government and States on various issues.

     

  • India to host second Voice of Global South Summit

    global south

    Central Idea

    • Prime Minister will inaugurate the second Voice of Global South Summit. This will be the second Voice of Global South Summit in less than a year hosted by India.

    What is the Voice of Global South Summit?

    • The VoGS Summit is a Indian initiative that has been designed to provide a common platform for the countries of the Global South to share their perspectives and priorities on several major issues.
    • It aims to find out solutions for common challenges faced by developing countries through talks.
    • Inspired by PM’s vision, ‘Sabka Saath Sabka Vikas Sabka Vishwas aur Sabka Prayas’, the summit follows India’s philosophy of Vasudhaiva Kutumbakam.

    How did the summit start?

    • The foundation of this unique initiative was laid considering the recent global developments that have severely impacted the developing world.
    • These include events such as Covid pandemic, mounting debt, ongoing Ukraine conflict, and challenges of food, energy security and others.
    • Often, the worries of developing countries do not gain adequate attention and space on the global stage.
    • The relevant existing platforms have proven to be deficient in handling the challenges and concerns of the developing nations.

    About Global South

    • Global South refers to countries in Asia, Africa, and South America, while Global North includes countries like the US, Canada, Europe, Russia, Australia, and New Zealand.
    • It’s a term used to categorize countries based on economic development and historical factors.

    Features of Global South

    • Mostly lower-income countries, often with colonial histories.
    • Not strictly limited to the Southern Hemisphere; many are in the Northern Hemisphere.
    • Used as a value-free alternative to “Third World.”
    • Major countries like Brazil, China, India, Indonesia, and Mexico are part of the Global South.

    Need for Classification

    • Helps describe economic and geopolitical differences.
    • Overcomes the limitations of East/West or First/Second/Third World classifications.
    • Recognizes the shared history of colonization.
    • Acknowledges the emergence of economically powerful South countries.

    Indian Context

    • India aims to represent the underrepresented Global South in international forums.
    • Calls for reform in multilateral institutions like the UNSC, UN, and IMF.
    • Emergent economies like India and China seek cooperation with other Global South countries.
    • Challenges the dominance of the Global North in international affairs.

    Criticism of Classification

    • Some find the term too broad and vague.
    • Questions about whether elites of the Global South aim to challenge global capitalist structures.
    • Concerns about the neglect of Africa in the rise of Asia.

    Significance of Global South

    • India aims to unite Global South nations to address common concerns.
    • Potential for technical and idea exchanges and cooperation in various areas.
    • Highlighting shared concerns like energy security and sustainable development.

    Challenges for Consolidation

    • Debate over climate reparations and exclusion of India and China.
    • Impact of the Russia-Ukraine War on Least Developed Countries.
    • China’s increasing influence in the Global South through initiatives like the Belt and Road.

    Way Forward

    • India needs active engagement in regional politics within the Global South.
    • Recognize differentiation within the Global South in terms of wealth, needs, and capabilities.

  • Kazi Nazrul Islam and his Iconic Song

    Kazi Nazrul Islam

    Central Idea

    • A movie-maker has issued an apology for the unintended distress caused by its rendition of the iconic song “Karar Oi Louho Kopat” penned by Bengali poet Kazi Nazrul Islam in 1922.

    Who was Kazi Nazrul Islam (1899-1976)?

    • Kazi Nazrul Islam was born on May 24, 1899, in Churulia, a village in the Burdwan district of West Bengal, India.
    • He was a famous poet, writer, and musician from Bengal.
    • He is well-known for his songs, which are called “Nazrulgeeti.”
    • These songs are very popular and loved by in West Bengal, Bangladesh, almost as much as Rabindrasangeet of Rabindranath Tagore.
    • Nazrul is often called the “Vidrohi Kavi (Rebel Poet)” because he wrote more than 4,000 songs, and many of them were about protesting and fighting against unfair rules and powerful rulers.
    • These songs inspired the freedom fighters of Bengal who were fighting against the British colonial rule.
    • He is celebrated as the national poet of Bangladesh and is also revered in West Bengal, India.

    Understanding “Karar Oi Louho Kopat”

    • Nazrul was an ardent supporter of India’s struggle for independence from British colonial rule. He used his poetry and writings to inspire and mobilize people against British oppression.
    • Published in 1922 in “Banglar Katha” and later included in Nazrul’s “Bhangar Gaan,” the song was penned as a call to break down the iron gates of prison, symbolizing resistance against British oppression.
    • He wrote the song of revolution after the British threw Deshbandhu Chittaranjan Das (1870-1925) in prison in 1922.