💥Join UPSC 2027,2028 Mentorship (August Batch) + XFactor Notes & Microthemes PDF
Talk to Mentor

Civilsdaily

Login

Subject: History

  • #AccessibleIndia: Can Mughal History Inspire Modern Inclusion?

    Accessible Tours of Agra and Fatehpur Sikri for Differently Abled Travelers | Alphonso Stories

    Central Idea:

    The article highlights the importance of accessibility and inclusion for individuals with disabilities in public spaces, using personal experiences and examples from Fatehpur Sikri, a 16th-century monument, to underscore the need for adherence to international standards and the implementation of inclusive practices across India. It emphasizes the urgent need for prioritizing accessibility in the built environment, including ramps and other accommodations, to enable full participation and empowerment of all citizens, regardless of their physical limitations.

    Key Highlights:

    • Personal experiences at Fatehpur Sikri illustrate the significance of proper accessibility measures.
    • Lack of adherence to international standards poses challenges for individuals with disabilities in navigating public spaces.
    • The Rights of Persons with Disabilities Act (RPWD) is mentioned as a framework for promoting accessibility, but implementation lags.
    • Inclusive design is essential for ensuring equal access to public buildings, transport, and information technology.
    • The absence of accurate disability data in India raises questions about the extent of inclusivity and the need for targeted policies.

    Key Challenges:

    • Inconsistent adherence to international accessibility standards in public spaces.
    • Limited implementation of the Rights of Persons with Disabilities Act (RPWD) despite its enactment.
    • Lack of accurate disability data hampers effective policy formulation and planning.
    • Heterogeneity of disabilities poses challenges in designing inclusive solutions.
    • Socioeconomic disparities contribute to unequal access to accessible infrastructure and support services.

    Main Terms:

    • Accessibility
    • Inclusion
    • Rights of Persons with Disabilities Act (RPWD)
    • Universal design
    • Public accommodations
    • Built environment
    • International standards
    • Heterogeneity of disabilities
    • Socioeconomic disparities
    • Inclusive practice

    Accessible India Campaign| National Portal of India

    Important Phrases:

    • “International standard for a ramp slope”
    • “Rights of Persons with Disabilities Act (RPWD)”
    • “Universal design”
    • “Built environment”
    • “Socio-economic background”
    • “Accurate disability data”
    • “Inclusive environment”
    • “Heterogeneity of disability”
    • “Accessibility of public accommodations and roads”
    • “Participation in civic and socio-economic life”

    Quotes:

    • “If a city built in 1569 AD can be made nearly 95 per cent wheelchair accessible, so can all public accommodations and roads.”
    • “Only by accomplishing this can we realise the full potential of our citizenry, empowering them to actively contribute their professional expertise and diverse skills for the optimal development of the country.”
    • “It is evident that our country has miles to go before genuine inclusivity can be celebrated.”
    • “The absence of ramps is just one example of why the disabled citizenry often finds it challenging to fully participate in civic and socio-economic life, potentially resulting in diminished self-esteem.”
    • “Every Indian deserves the freedom to experience our country’s rich history and heritage along with the rights accorded to all citizens.”

    Anecdotes:

    • The personal experience of the author’s brother tipping over in a wheelchair due to a steep ramp highlights the dangers posed by inadequate accessibility measures.
    • The contrast between the accessible ramps at Fatehpur Sikri and the inaccessible environments encountered in daily life underscores the importance of universal design in public spaces.

    Useful Statements:

    • “Implementing proper accessibility measures is a cost-effective investment in enhancing accessibility for individuals with physical limitations.”
    • “Inclusive design is essential for ensuring equal access to public buildings, transport, and information technology.”
    • “In pursuing true accessibility, involving multiple end-users in the design process is crucial for determining its success.”

    Examples and References:

    • Fatehpur Sikri as an example of successful accessibility implementation.
    • Comparison between international standards and the actual accessibility of public spaces in India.
    • Mention of UN-Habitat’s definition of an inclusive environment.
    • Reference to the Rights of Persons with Disabilities Act (RPWD) as a framework for promoting accessibility.
    • World Health Organization’s data on global disability prevalence versus India’s reported disability rates.

    Facts and Data:

    • Fatehpur Sikri is mentioned as being nearly 95% wheelchair accessible.
    • The World Health Organization estimates that 16% of the global population experiences significant disabilities.
    • India’s last Census in 2011 reported only 2.2% of the population as having disabilities.

    Critical Analysis: The article effectively combines personal anecdotes with broader observations to highlight the challenges and importance of accessibility and inclusion in India. It critiques the lack of adherence to international standards and the limited implementation of legislative frameworks, emphasizing the need for concrete action to address these issues. However, it also acknowledges the complexities involved, such as the heterogeneity of disabilities and socioeconomic disparities, which require nuanced approaches to ensure meaningful inclusivity.

    Way Forward:

    • Prioritize accessibility and inclusion as national priorities, possibly under a dedicated “mission.”
    • Ensure consistent adherence to international standards in the design and construction of public spaces.
    • Improve implementation of the Rights of Persons with Disabilities Act (RPWD) and enhance data collection on disability prevalence.
    • Promote inclusive design practices and involve end-users in the planning and development of accessible infrastructure.
    • Raise awareness and advocate for the rights of individuals with disabilities to foster a more inclusive society.
  • In news: Mohammed Quli Qutb Shah’s Tomb

    In news: Mohammed Quli Qutb Shah’s Tomb

    Introduction

    • A digital twin of the Mohammed Quli Qutb Shah’s tomb was unveiled by a reality technology company, Hexagon in Hyderabad.

    Who was Mohammed Quli Qutb Shah?

    • Parentage: Muhammad Quli Qutb Shah was born on April 4, 1565, as the third son of Ibrahim Quli Qutb Shah Wali and his Hindu mother Bhagirathi.
    • Literary Talent: He was not only an able administrator but also a skilled poet who composed verses in Persian, Telugu, and Urdu.

    Contemporaries of Quli Qutb Shah

     

    • Akbar (1556–1605): Mughal Emperor known for his religious tolerance and administrative reforms.
    • Rani Durgavati (1550–1564): Queen of the Gondwana Kingdom in central India, renowned for her bravery in resisting Mughal expansion.
    • Maharana Pratap (1572–1597): Rajput ruler of Mewar, famous for his defiance against Mughal Emperor Akbar and his valor in battles.
    • Chand Bibi (1550–1599): Regent of the Ahmednagar Sultanate in Deccan, known for her role in defending Ahmadnagar against Mughal forces.
    • Guru Ram Das (1574–1581): Fourth Sikh Guru who established the city of Amritsar and contributed significantly to Sikhism’s growth.
    • Sher Shah Suri (1540–1545): Founder of the Sur Empire in North India, celebrated for his administrative reforms and construction of the Grand Trunk Road.

    Key Accomplishments

    [A] Reign and Accomplishments

    • Ascension to the Throne: Muhammad Quli succeeded his father in 1580 at the age of 15 and ruled for 31 years.
    • Military Campaigns: Despite facing rebellions, he effectively led troops and quelled disturbances, ensuring stability in his realm.

    [B] Foundation of Hyderabad

    • Urban Planning: Concerned about overcrowding in Golkonda, Muhammad Quli initiated the construction of Hyderabad in 1591.
    • Land Selection: While folklore suggests a romanticized version of land selection, Muhammad Quli’s vision for Hyderabad’s development aimed at relieving congestion and promoting growth.

    [C] Architectural Marvels and City Planning

    • Charminar: As the architectural centrepiece, Charminar was built under Muhammad Quli’s patronage, symbolizing the city’s grandeur.
    • City Layout: Hyderabad was meticulously planned with a gridiron layout, featuring significant landmarks like Darulshafa, Mecca Masjid, and Badshahi Ashurkhana.

    [D] Support for Arts and Literature

    • Calligraphic Art: Under Muhammad Quli’s rule, calligraphy flourished, with various scripts adorning buildings such as the Mecca Masjid.
    • Literary Contributions: Muhammad Quli’s poetic works in Urdu and Dakhni languages reflected his diverse interests and cultural appreciation.
    • Taraqqi: He was a poet himself and composed poetry in Persian and Telugu under the pen name “Taraqqi”.

    [E] Medical and Literary Contributions

    • Intellectual Hub: Hyderabad became a centre for medical and literary pursuits, with scholars producing notable works during Muhammad Quli’s reign.
    • Preservation of Culture: Muhammad Quli’s literary legacy, including his Diwan, is preserved in institutions like the Salar Jung Museum, showcasing his contribution to cultural heritage.

    Legacy and Influence

    • Cultural Integration: Muhammad Quli’s reign represents a period of cultural fusion, blending Hindu and Islamic traditions in the Deccan region.
    • Symbol of Unity: His efforts to promote harmony and coexistence endure as a testament to the inclusive ethos of his administration.

  • M.S. Swaminathan, P.V. Narasimha Rao, Charan Singh to get Bharat Ratna

    Bharat Ratna

    Introduction

    • The Bharat Ratna will be conferred on former Prime Ministers P. V. Narasimha Rao and Choudhary Charan Singh, as well as Green Revolution pioneer S. Swaminathan.
    • This will add to the two awardees already announced earlier this year — socialist leader Karpoori Thakur and former Deputy Prime Minister L. K. Advani.

    About the Bharat Ratna Laureates

    [1] Dr. M.S. Swaminathan

    Aspect Details
    Early Life
    • Born on August 7, 1925, in Kumbakonam, Madras Presidency.
    • Pursued higher education in zoology and agricultural science.
    • Passed away on 23rd September, 2023 at the age of 98.
    Career Highlights
    • Conducted research on combating potato crop parasites during a UNESCO fellowship (1949-1954).
    • Earned a PhD from the University of Cambridge in 1954.
    • Served as Director-General of the Indian Council of Agricultural Research (1979-1982).
    • Appointed as Director General of the International Rice Research Institute in 1982.
    Green Revolution Contributions
    • Pioneered high-yielding variety seeds and improved irrigation methods.
    • Collaborated with Dr. Norman Borlaug to develop high-yielding wheat varieties (1965-1970).
    Challenges and Advocacy Advocated for fair Minimum Support Prices for farmers and highlighted ecological concerns.
    Legacy and Recognition
    • Received numerous international accolades and civilian awards from India and other nations.
    • Honored with Padma Shri (1967), Padma Bhushan (1972), and Padma Vibhushan (1989) awards in India.
    • Awarded over 80 honorary doctorates from universities worldwide.

     

    [2] PV Narasimha Rao

    Details
    Early Life
    • Born on June 28, 1921, in Karimnagar district, Hyderabad State (now Telangana, India).
    • Passed away on December 23, 2004, in New Delhi.
    Education
    • Bachelor of Arts degree from Osmania University.
    • Higher studies at the University of Bombay and Nagpur University.
    Political Career
    • Started in the Indian National Congress.
    • Served as MLA in undivided Andhra Pradesh.
    • Held ministerial positions, including Minister of External Affairs and Minister of Defence.
    Economic Reforms (1991)
    • Initiated significant economic reforms in response to the 1991 crisis.
    • Reforms included dismantling the License Raj, opening up the economy, and initiating privatization.
    Foreign Policy
    • Strengthened ties with the United States and other major powers.
    • Initiated the “Look East Policy” to enhance engagement with Southeast and East Asia.
    South Asian Diplomacy
    • Handled the situation in Jammu and Kashmir and initiated dialogue with Pakistan.
    • Deployed peacekeeping forces to Sri Lanka as part of the Indian Peace Keeping Force (IPKF).
    Political Legacy
    • Credited with laying the foundation for India’s economic liberalization and globalization.
    • Recognized for pragmatic leadership during a critical period in India’s history.
    • Remembered as a statesman who shaped India’s economic and foreign policies.

     

    [3] Choudhary Charan Singh

    Aspect Details
    Early Life
    • Born on December 23, 1903, in Noorpur village near Hapur, India.
    • Entered politics during the national movement and was elected to the United Provinces Assembly from Chhaprauli in 1937.
    Political Career
    • Advocated for village economy issues and fought against the exploitation of peasants by big landlords.
    • Served as Revenue Minister in UP’s first Chief Minister Govind Ballabh Pant’s cabinet, instrumental in implementing zamindari abolition and land ceiling laws.
    • Emerged as a popular leader among North Indian farmer communities and Muslims.
    • Became UP’s first non-Congress Chief Minister in 1967, forming a coalition government.
    • Won the 1977 Lok Sabha elections on the Janata Party ticket, became Deputy PM under Morarji Desai’s government.
    • Formed the Janata Party (Secular) in 1979, briefly served as PM with support from Indira Gandhi.
    Legacy
    • Championed the cause of peasants and created a new political class representing farming communities in North India.
    • Influenced the shift of farmer communities from Congress and Jan Sangh to parties specifically representing them.
    • His son, Ajit Singh, formed the Rashtriya Lok Dal (RLD), continuing the family’s political legacy.
    • Charan Singh remains hailed as one of India’s tallest Jat leaders.

     

    Back2Basics: Bharat Ratna

    Details
    Nature
    • Bharat Ratna is the highest civilian award of the Republic of India.
    History and Evolution
    • Instituted in 1954.
    • Originally limited to achievements in arts, literature, science, and public services.
    • Criteria expanded in December 2011.
    First Recipients C. Rajagopalachari, Sarvepalli Radhakrishnan, and C. V. Raman were the first recipients in 1954.
    Key Aspects
    • Not mandatory to be awarded every year.
    • Can be awarded to non-Indian citizens.
    • Recommendations made by the Prime Minister to the President.
    • Restricted to a maximum of three awards per year.
    • Recipient receives a Sanad (certificate) and a medallion.
    • No monetary grant accompanies the award.
    Article Reference
    • Cannot be used as a prefix or suffix to the recipient’s name, but can be indicated in biodata/letterhead/visiting card as “Awarded Bharat Ratna by the President” or “Recipient of Bharat Ratna Award”.
    • Article 18(1) of the Constitution states that the award cannot be used as a prefix or suffix to the recipient’s name.

  • 390 YO Lamp Post in Nalgonda dedicated to Kasi Viswanatha

    Lamp Post

    Introduction

    • The recent discovery of a Deepastambham (lamp post) and other archaeological findings along the River Krishna in Nalgonda district, Telangana, sheds new light on early medieval trade ties in the region.

    Lamp Post and its Structure

    • Unique Findings: Archaeologists unearthed a 20-foot tall lamp post with inscription and a small flat-roofed structure near the Krishna river bank in Telangana.
    • Rare Artefacts: Lamp posts are uncommon in the Deccan region but are prevalent in temple architecture along the west coast, highlighting the uniqueness of this discovery.
    • Historical Context: The lamp post, dated back to June 1635, bears a multilingual inscription in Telugu mixed with Tamil, indicating its dedication to Kasi Viswanatha.
    • Functional Significance: Due to its height, the lamp post likely served as a lighthouse along the riverine trade route, facilitating navigation and trade activities.

    Significance of Inscriptions

    • Historical Documentation: Inscriptions provide valuable insights into the socio-cultural and economic landscape of the region during the early medieval period.
    • Cultural Connections: The presence of inscriptions suggests a connection between the local community and wider trade networks, enriching our understanding of historical trade routes.
    • Hyderabad Connection: The village’s proximity to Hyderabad, ruled by the Qutb Shahi dynasty, suggests its significance in the regional trade network.
    • European Accounts: References by European travellers, such as Jean Baptiste Tavernier, hint at the existence of riverine trade routes alongside land routes during the same period.

    Continuity of Trade Routes

    • Longstanding Trade Connections: The discovery of an eighth-century inscription from the Badami Chalukya era underscores the village’s role as a vital trade hub over millennia.
    • Cultural Exchange: Trade routes facilitated not only economic transactions but also cultural exchanges, shaping the region’s diverse heritage.

    Try this PYQ:

    Which one of the following foreign travellers elaborately discussed about diamonds and diamond mines on India? (CSP 2018)

    (a) Francois Bernier

    (b) Jean Baptiste Tavernier

    (c) Jean de Thevenot

    (d) Abbe Barthelemy Carre

     

    [wpdiscuz-feedback id=”1vwy3mwliy” question=”Please leave a feedback on this” opened=”1″]Post your answers here.[/wpdiscuz-feedback]

  • Book Review: How India ignored its Aqua-Geography of Histories

    coast

    Introduction

    • India’s coastal geography, often overshadowed in educational curricula, holds profound historical and cultural significance.
    • While India’s connection with its southern seas is acknowledged, the broader implications of its maritime heritage remain underexplored.

    Irony of India’s Maritime Geography

    • Distance from the Sea: While some might remember that India is bound by sea all along the south, the connections with the sea do not consciously register — for a great many people even today, the sea is a very distant object.
    • Impact of Natural Events: It may perhaps impinge on the consciousness a little more when there are reports of cyclones or storms (or the tsunami that hit some years ago in 2004), but the expanse of the sea, the links with the oceans, and the historical and geographical connections are typically rather hazy.

    Historical Perspectives on Indian Geography

    • School Definition: Moreover, children are mostly taught about only two parts of India — the plains to the north, and the peninsula to the south.
    • Sanskrit Texts: But historically, India was defined slightly differently. In early Indian Sanskrit texts, the subcontinent is seen as divided into five major regions
    1. Madhyadesa (middle country),
    2. Udicya or Uttarapatha (northern India),
    3. Pracya (eastern India),
    4. Dakshinapatha (Deccan) and
    5. Aparanta (western India)
    • Different Interpretations: The term Dakshinapatha came to be used in two ways: the entire peninsula, or more commonly, a more limited area from the Narmada to the Tungabhadra and Krishna rivers. To the south of this lay the Dravidadesa or Tamilakam.
    • Imperial Gazetteer’s Definition: On the other hand, as defined in the Imperial Gazetteer, the ‘Deccan’ has also been understood as referring to the entire landmass south of the Vindhya mountains and the great Gangetic plain, and so it can be taken to mean the entire peninsular region of India.

    Geographical Features of the Indian Subcontinent

    • Demarcated Regions: Within the peninsula itself are five clearly demarcated regions — the Western Ghats skirting the Arabian Sea, the northern Deccan plateau, the eastern plateau, the Eastern Ghats towards the Bay of Bengal and the coastal strip between the ghats on either side and the sea itself.
    • Plateau Considerations: While studies have traditionally tended to focus on only the western part of the plateau as the ‘Deccan’, it is to be remembered that the plateau region covers much of the northern peninsula.
    • Extent of Ghats: Furthermore, the ghats bordering it extend almost down to Kanyakumari. The western coastal strip is generally narrow, being indented and segmented by spurs from the Western Ghats or by small rivers flowing to the sea from the hills.
    • Eastern Ghats Description: The Eastern Ghats are less continuous, with a wider and more fertile coastal strip, containing, as it does, the deltaic plains of the two major river systems of the Deccan plateau, the Krishna and Godavari.

    Coastal Divisions and Sub-regions

    • Distinct Names for Ghats: On both coasts, the ghats are given different names in various regions. So, for example, the Western Ghats up to Karnataka are also often referred to as the Sahyadri ranges.
    • Plateau Description: What is normally understood as the Deccan plateau proper is a broad quadrangle covering most of the present-day Maharashtra state, with a topography typical of plateau land.
    • Transition to Plains: As it begins to give way to the plains in Andhra Pradesh and Karnataka (the south-eastern and southern plateaus), the geography becomes rougher and rockier, and is interspersed with forest land and riverine stretches.
    • Coastal Strip Description: The western coastal strip is a narrow strip of land, very rarely extending more than eighty kilometres inwards from the sea. This strip is particularly narrow from the Tapi river to Goa, after which it widens a little on the Karnataka coast and finally includes all of present-day Kerala, for the ghats here form the demarcation between Kerala and modern Tamil Nadu.

    Coastal Features and Subdivisions

    [A] Western Coast

    • Technical Divisions: This coast is technically divided into three parts, excluding Gujarat. The northernmost section is called the Konkan, which is further subdivided into two segments — the northern one running approximately from the Tapi to Chaul (modern Revdanda) and the southern from Chaul to Goa.
    • Coastal Divisions: South of Goa is the Canara coast, stretching till Mount Eli (Ezhimala) in modern-day Kerala, known to early travellers as Mount Dilli or Dely. The Malabar coast begins here and extends to Kanyakumari, the tip of the peninsula.
    • Maritime Economic Considerations: However, in maritime economic terms, it is rather difficult to limit oneself only to this western stretch of the coastline, for connections extend northwards into the Gujarat coast and eastwards across the ghats into the plateau region.

    [B] Eastern Coast

    • Ease of Access: The Eastern Ghats, as mentioned earlier, are not continuous, which means that access to the interior from the coast (or vice versa) is much easier.
    • Water Bodies: The eastern coastal strip features deltas and various other water bodies, including, in the northernmost part of the region, Chilika Lake in modern-day Odisha; Kolleru Lake between the Krishna and the Godavari deltas, approximately in the centre of the coast; and Pulicat Lake, which lies towards the southern edge of the Deccan region.
    • Historical Significance: All these lakes used to be hubs for trade and fishing, with Pulicat also being the heart of a thriving weaving industry through most of India’s medieval era.

    Port Dynamics

    • Abundance of Ports: Both coasts are, of course, marked by innumerable ports. A brief survey of these ports is enough to indicate the ever-present climatic and natural hazards they faced.
    • Western Coast Considerations: The physical geography of the west coast, given its numerous indentations, offers ample natural shelters all along its length, with the two largest natural harbours being Mumbai (Bombay) and Goa.
    • Importance of Smaller Ports: However, throughout the medieval and early modern period (approximately the eighth to eighteenth century), the harbours of ports like Mangalore, Honawar, Bhatkal or Chaul were no less important in terms of the traffic they handled.

    Challenges and Hazards on the Coasts

    • Monsoon Challenges: Western ports face closures during the southwest monsoon, with shifting sandbanks and shoals posing dangers to ships.
    • Lack of Natural Harbours: The east coast lacks natural harbors, with ports vulnerable to silting near river deltas.
    • Unstable Delta Mouths: Delta mouths are prone to instability, potentially rendering established channels unusable after monsoon cycles.
    • Cyclone Vulnerability: The Bay of Bengal presents cyclone risks due to its enclosed nature, leading to higher possibilities of circular winds compared to the west coast.
    • Open Roads for Ports: East coast ports operate as open roads, requiring ships to navigate high surf, rolling waters, and random winds while loading and unloading goods.

    Trade Routes and Cultural Exchange

    • Port Competitiveness: Ports rely on their immediate interior areas, often shared by multiple ports, for sustenance and trade.
    • Political and Economic Factors: Port prosperity hinges on political stability and economic conditions in their vicinity.
    • Trade Patterns: West coast ports primarily trade with the Arabian Sea littoral, while east coast ports engage in trade across the Bay of Bengal.
    • Cross-Coastal Trading: Merchants from both coasts trade extensively across the Indian Ocean world, transcending geographical boundaries.
    • Established Routes: Trade routes across the Indian Ocean have existed for centuries, with changes in rulership but continuity in trade activities.

    Conclusion

    • The multitude of functional ports, diverse trade patterns, and established trade routes highlight the resilience and adaptability of India’s maritime regions.
    • As India continues to navigate its maritime heritage into the future, understanding and appreciating its maritime geography remain crucial for fostering sustainable development and cultural preservation.

  • Kalaripayattu gains popularity in Haryana

    Kalaripayattu gains popularity in Haryana

    Introduction

    • The introduction of Kalaripayattu, a southern Indian martial arts form, into the Khelo India games in 2021 has led to its growing popularity among boys and girls in Haryana.

    About Kalaripayattu

    • Originates from ancient knowledge of the human body.
    • Originated in Kerala during the 3rd century BC, lasting until the 2nd century AD; currently practiced in parts of Kerala and Tamil Nadu.
    • Practiced in a ‘Kalari’, a term in Malayalam indicating a gymnasium or a symbolic battlefield.
    • The term ‘Kalari’ appears in Tamil Sangam literature, denoting both a battlefield and a combat arena.
    • Considered one of the oldest martial arts in the world.
    • Known as the precursor to modern Kung Fu, often referred to as the “Father of Modern Kung Fu.”
    • Integrates Hindu rituals and philosophies, alongside medicinal practices derived from Ayurveda.
    • Incorporates elements from yoga and finger movements from Nata dances.

    Weapons used:

    Weapons are categorized into four groups:

    • Cutting, Slicing, and Piercing: Swords and daggers.
    • Pole Weapons: Spears and axes.
    • Bludgeoning Instruments: Sticks and maces.
    • Projectiles: Arrows, discuses, catapults, boomerangs, and other hand-thrown weapons.

  • Places of Worship Act and Ongoing Disputes: Explained

    Introduction

    • The Places of Worship (Special Provisions) Act, 1991, has once again come into focus due to ongoing civil suits challenging the religious character of mosques in Varanasi and Mathura.

    Enactment of the Places of Worship Act

    • Background: The Act was enacted in September 1991, during the Babri-Masjid Ram Janmabhoomi dispute, to address issues related to the status of places of worship.
    • Objectives: It aimed to freeze the religious character of places of worship as it existed on August 15, 1947, and prevent the conversion of places of worship from one denomination to another.

    Key Provisions of the Act

    • Continuity of Religious Character: The Act ensures that the religious character of a place of worship remains unchanged from its status on August 15, 1947.
    • Prohibition on Conversion: It prohibits the conversion of a place of worship of any religious denomination into one of a different denomination.
    • Abatement of Pending Cases: All pending legal proceedings regarding the conversion of a place of worship, initiated before August 15, 1947, would abate upon the Act coming into force, and no new proceedings can be initiated.

    Exceptions to the Rule

    • Ancient Monuments and Archaeological Sites: The Act does not apply to ancient and historical monuments and archaeological sites protected under the Ancient Monuments and Archaeological Sites and Remains Act, 1958.
    • Settled Disputes: It does not apply to suits that were already settled or disposed of or to conversions by acquiescence.

    Status of Ongoing Cases on the Gyanvapi Mosque

    • Current Litigation: Ongoing civil suits in Varanasi involve claims by Hindu worshippers asserting their right to worship deities within the Gyanvapi mosque premises.
    • Basis for Suits: The Hindu side claims that an old temple of Lord Vishweshwar existed at the center of the mosque compound, demolished by Emperor Aurangzeb in 1669.
    • Court Orders: Court orders have favored the position that these suits are not barred by the Places of Worship Act. The Archaeological Survey of India (ASI) conducted a survey that reported the existence of a temple before the mosque.

    Implications of the Act in the Mathura Dispute

    • Shahi Idgah Mosque: Civil suits in Mathura pertain to the Shahi Idgah mosque near the Krishna Janmabhoomi Temple, with claims that it was built over Lord Krishna’s birthplace.
    • Challenging Compromise: The suits challenge a compromise reached in 1968 between Sri Krishna Janmasthan Seva Sansthan and the Shahi Idgah Trust. The Allahabad High Court has transferred all Mathura dispute suits to itself.
    • Act’s Applicability: Court decisions have held that the Act does not bar these suits. In the Mathura dispute, the Act is not applicable as the compromise decree predates its enactment.

    Conclusion

    • The Places of Worship Act, enacted to freeze the status of places of worship, is facing challenges in ongoing disputes, particularly in Varanasi and Mathura.
    • Courts have ruled that the Act does not prohibit these suits, emphasizing the need for a case-by-case examination to determine religious character.
    • These developments underscore the complexities and legal interpretations surrounding the Act’s application in the context of evolving disputes.

  • Moh-Juj: Traditional Animal Fights in Assam

    Introduction

    • The Assam government’s bid to revive traditional ‘Moh-Juj’ buffalo and bulbul (songbird) fighting during Magh Bihu has encountered a legal challenge from People for Ethical Treatment of Animals (PETA) in the Gauhati High Court.
    • PETA India seeks to ban these activities.

    Buffalo and bulbul fights: Age-Old Tradition

    • Folk Culture: Buffalo and bulbul fights are part of the folk culture during the Assamese winter harvest festival of Magh Bihu.
    • Location: Buffalo fights are prominent in places like Ahatguri in Nagaon district, while bulbul fights are held at the Hayagriv Madhab Mandir in Hajo.
    • Religious Significance: Bulbul fights are tied to religion, involving rituals, lamps, and offerings to Lord Vishnu.
    • Historical Legacy: The practice has roots in the traditions of the Ahom rulers.

    Discontinuation after SC Ruling

    • Supreme Court’s Intervention: The fights were discontinued after the Supreme Court’s 2014 judgment banned the use of bulls as performing animals in events like jallikattu.
    • Animal Welfare Board of India (AWBI): Following the SC ruling, the AWBI urged the Assam government to stop animal and bird fights during Bihu celebrations.
    • Resistance: Despite the prohibition, some continued to hold buffalo fights in defiance, leading to legal challenges.

    Revival Efforts after SC Clears Path

    • SC Ruling in 2021: The Supreme Court overturned its 2014 judgment, allowing states like Tamil Nadu, Maharashtra, and Karnataka to conduct traditional events involving bulls and animals.
    • Assam Government’s SOPs: The Assam Cabinet approved Standard Operating Procedures (SOPs) for buffalo and bulbul fights without deliberate cruelty.
    • Guidelines: SOPs permit fights in traditional locations, set specific dates, forbid harm to animals, and ban the use of intoxicating substances.
    • Revival: Buffalo and bulbul fights were resumed in Magh Bihu, with Chief Minister Himanta Biswa Sarma supporting the revival as part of Assam’s Bihu traditions.

    PETA’s Legal Challenge

    • PETA’s Petitions: PETA India filed petitions in the Gauhati High Court seeking a ban on both activities and an interim stay during the proceedings.
    • Allegations: PETA claimed that buffalo owners instigated fights through slapping, shoving, and using wooden sticks, resulting in injuries. Bulbuls were allegedly captured and forced to fight.
    • Court’s Response: The court heard PETA’s application and noted that organizing buffalo fights beyond January 25 violates government guidelines. It instructed the petitioners to inform the relevant authorities to prevent the event in violation of SOPs.

    Conclusion

    • The legal battle over the revival of traditional animal fights in Assam reflects the clash between cultural traditions, religious significance, and animal welfare concerns.
    • The Gauhati High Court’s decision will shape the future of these practices in the region.

  • Will Europe ever return ‘Looted’ Asian Artifacts?

    Artifacts

    Introduction

    • European museums have faced increasing pressure to return cultural artifacts to their countries of origin.
    • The restitution of these artifacts carries significant implications for diplomacy and international relations.

    France’s Pledge and Precedent

    • France’s Commitment: President Emmanuel Macron pledged support during the visit of Cambodian Prime Minister Hun Manet to return Khmer artifacts and expand the National Museum of Cambodia.
    • First European Leader: Macron became the first European leader to address demands for the return of looted antiquities in 2017, emphasizing France’s commitment to restoring cultural heritage.

    Cases of Repatriation

    • Musee Guimet’s Return: France’s National Museum of Asian art, Musee Guimet, agreed to return a seventh-century Khmer statue to Cambodia, taken during the colonial era.
    • Global Initiatives: Germany and France allocated funds for reviewing African heritage objects, possibly signaling similar efforts for Asian artifacts.
    • The Met’s Decision: The Metropolitan Museum of Art in New York pledged to return sculptures to Cambodia and Thailand, setting a precedent for other institutions.

    Legal Basis and Challenges

    • UNESCO Convention: 1970 UNESCO Convention on the Means of Prohibiting and Preventing the Illicit Import, Export and Transfer of Ownership of Cultural Property
    • Non-binding: It is a key legal framework for repatriation, but it doesn’t apply retrospectively to colonial-era looting.
    • National Legislation: Some countries, like Austria, are proposing national laws for returning objects acquired during colonialism.

    Reasons for repatriation

    • Soft Power Benefits: Repatriation can enhance a nation’s soft power, showcasing a commitment to international law, reconciliation, and better relations with affected countries.
    • Rebranding Opportunity: Returning artifacts is seen as an opportunity for Western governments to rebrand and mend historical wrongs, especially in regions like Southeast Asia.
    • EU’s Role: The European Parliament discusses the need for recognizing and addressing colonial legacies and restitution, potentially creating a permanent EU body on restorative justice.
    • Cooperation is Key: To gain recognition similar to the United States, European museums need to cooperate openly with the governments of the regions from which the artifacts originated.

    Conclusion

    • The return of cultural artifacts taken during colonialism is not only a legal and ethical issue but also a diplomatic endeavor.
    • European museums that engage in proactive repatriation efforts can build goodwill, foster cooperation, and enhance their soft power on the global stage.

  • Varanasi HC allows Hindu Prayers in Gyanvapi Premise

    Gyanvapi

    Introduction

    • The Varanasi District Court has issued an order permitting Hindu prayers to be conducted in the southern cellar of the Gyanvapi mosque complex, a decision met with both support and opposition.
    • This development comes amid ongoing legal disputes concerning the worship rights at the site.

    Allowing Prayers: Court’s Ruling

    • Prayers Allowed: The Varanasi District Court has directed the district administration to facilitate the resumption of puja (worship) within the disputed southern cellar of the Gyanvapi mosque complex within seven days.
    • Background: The order followed an application filed by Shailendra Kumar Pathak, the priest of the Acharya Ved Vyas Peeth temple, seeking worship rights for visible and invisible deities in the basement of the mosque.

    Reaction and Legal Challenges

    • Legal Challenge: The Anjuman Intezamia Committee of Gyanvapi Masjid, advised by the All India Muslim Personal Law Board (AIMPLB), intends to challenge the court’s decision in the Allahabad High Court.
    • AIMPLB’s Stance: AIMPLB criticized the court’s ruling as “totally unacceptable” and drew parallels to past disputes like the opening of locks at the Babri Masjid in 1986. They expressed concerns about the targeting of old mosques after the establishment of the Ram Mandir in Ayodhya.

    Historical Perspective

    • Prior Worship: The petitioner claimed that Hindu priests associated with the Vyas family used to perform daily rituals in the cellar before 1993 when it was discontinued by government orders.
    • Contested Claims: A member of the Anjuman Intezamia committee contested the assertion, stating that there had never been any puja conducted in the cellar.

    Ongoing Legal Proceedings

    • Next Hearing: The next hearing on this matter is scheduled for February 8, allowing the defendants, including the Anjuman Intejamia Masajid Committee that manages the Gyanvapi mosque, to file objections.
    • Parallel Legal Challenge: Another order by the Allahabad High Court concerns a revision application challenging the Varanasi district judge’s refusal to direct the Archaeological Survey of India (ASI) to conduct a scientific survey of the mosque’s wazukhana area.

    Concerns and Historical Parallels

    • Ethical Concerns: The decision to permit puja in the Gyanvapi mosque’s basement raises ethical questions and concerns about religious rights.
    • Parallels to History: AIMPLB sees parallels between recent developments and past disputes, raising concerns about historical patterns of targeting old mosques.

    Conclusion

    • The Varanasi District Court’s ruling allowing Hindu prayers in the Gyanvapi mosque’s southern cellar has ignited both legal challenges and discussions about religious rights and historical parallels.
    • The case continues to be a subject of significant debate and legal scrutiny.