PYQ Relevance[UPSC 2024] Examine the need for electoral reforms as suggested by various committees with particular reference to the “One Nation-One Election” principle. Linkage: The Special Intensive Revision (SIR) ensures clean, verified, and inclusive voter rolls, a prerequisite for implementing “One Nation-One Election”. Both aim to reduce electoral fragmentation and enhance institutional credibility in India’s democracy. |
Mentor’s Comment
The Election Commission of India (ECI) has initiated the Special Intensive Revision (SIR) of electoral rolls across multiple States and Union Territories, the first such nationwide exercise after 21 years. This is a technical yet politically sensitive process, central to the integrity of India’s democratic machinery. The SIR’s rollout tests administrative preparedness, inclusivity, and transparency ahead of major elections, including those in Bihar. This article decodes the why, what, and how of the SIR, examining its implications for governance, political participation, and electoral legitimacy, all crucial themes for UPSC GS Paper II (Polity & Governance).
Why in the News
The Election Commission of India launched the Special Intensive Revision (SIR) on November 4, 2025, across nine States and three Union Territories, following its implementation in Bihar. This is the first SIR in 21 years and only the ninth in India’s 75-year electoral history.
It marks a significant institutional reform aimed at updating 51 crore voter records of nearly half of India’s electorate across 321 constituencies and 1,843 Assembly segments. Given that the Bihar SIR was a test case plagued by logistical, legal, and political complexities, the pan-India rollout serves as a stress test for India’s electoral infrastructure and citizen inclusion mechanisms.
Introduction
The Special Intensive Revision (SIR) represents the most comprehensive voter list update since the early 2000s. It aims to eliminate duplications, include new electors, and ensure clean, verified rolls before upcoming elections. However, the process faces challenges related to citizenship verification, migration, and state-level customisation, revealing both the strengths and vulnerabilities of India’s electoral architecture.
What is the Special Intensive Revision (SIR)?
- Definition: A systematic, state-wise verification and revision of electoral rolls conducted by the Election Commission of India (ECI).
- Objective: To ensure accuracy, transparency, and inclusivity in voter registration, enabling free and fair elections.
- Scale: Covers 51 crore electors across 321 constituencies involving 5.33 lakh polling stations and 7.64 lakh booth-level agents.
- Timeline: Draft roll on December 9, 2025; final roll on February 7, 2026.
- Precedent: First SIR in 21 years, after the last comprehensive revision in 2004.
Why Was a Nationwide SIR Needed?
- Electoral Gaps: Regular annual updates failed to address mass migration, duplication, and exclusion errors.
- Bihar Experience: The Bihar SIR revealed outdated rolls, multiple entries, and dead voters, pushing ECI to extend the process nationwide.
- Inclusivity Goals: To bring marginalised and mobile populations (e.g., migrants, first-time voters) into the democratic fold.
- Supreme Court Concerns: Emphasised the need for ‘clean and transparent’ electoral rolls as foundational to electoral legitimacy.
How is the SIR Different from Regular Roll Revision?
- Depth of Verification: Involves door-to-door enumeration and mandatory document verification.
- Decentralised Accountability: Booth Level Officers (BLOs) given fixed time frames for inclusion/exclusion decisions.
- Transparency Mandate: The term ‘document’ must be entered for each elector to ensure traceability.
- Technological Integration: ECI uses data analytics and cross-verification to detect duplication or absence.
- Flexibility: Though standardised nationally, procedures vary by State due to differing local challenges and citizenship laws (e.g., Assam).
How Does the SIR Strengthen Electoral Legitimacy?
- Authenticity of Rolls: Builds a citizen-owned voter base, verified through both local and digital checks.
- Political Party Engagement: Booth-level agents of political parties ensure collective scrutiny and confidence in the system.
- Institutional Collaboration: States are required to provide dedicated staff and avoid officer transfers during the process.
- Error Minimisation: Reduction in ‘zero appeals’ cases, i.e., disputes over wrongful exclusions/inclusions.
- Legal Sanction: Backed by Supreme Court validation, strengthening constitutional trust in the ECI.
What Are the Remaining Challenges?
- State-Specific Complexities: Tamil Nadu, Kerala, and West Bengal express concerns over exclusion of eligible voters.
- Administrative Burden: Requires massive coordination across 21,000+ officers and State governments.
- Social Sensitivities: Citizenship verification in Assam and border districts remains politically charged.
- Public Trust Deficit: Needs sustained communication to avoid alienation of first-time or marginalised voters.
- Past Precedent: The Bihar experience showed that data errors and delayed grievance redress erode legitimacy.
Conclusion
The Special Intensive Revision marks a transformative shift in India’s electoral administration. While it reflects institutional momentum and transparency, its success depends on ground-level execution, inter-state coordination, and public confidence. The SIR is both a logistical challenge and a democratic opportunity, a crucial test for the ECI’s credibility in ensuring a clean, inclusive, and verifiable electoral base.
Get an IAS/IPS ranker as your 1: 1 personal mentor for UPSC 2024



