Note4Students
From UPSC perspective, the following things are important :
Prelims level: UNLF peace accord
Mains level: Successful peace deals in Northeastern states
Central idea
In a volatile state like Manipur, peace agreements can be challenging to implement because of the multiplicity of stakeholders and their divergent interests and grievances
Key Highlights:
- Welcoming a Milestone Accord: Recent peace accord between UNLF in Manipur and the government of India viewed positively for its potential impact on regional normalcy.
- Regional Peace Trends: Successful peace deals in Northeastern states like Mizoram, Tripura, and Shillong, along with significant progress in Assam through accords with separatist groups.
Key Challenges:
- Lurking Threat of Looted Arms: The presence of approximately 4,500 looted arms in various hands poses a substantial threat to the journey towards lasting peace.
- Complexities in UNLF Accord: Lack of clarity on the terms of the UNLF peace accord and potential complications arising from the involvement of militants in ethnic conflicts.
- Diverse Demands and Historical Grievances: Reconciling diverse demands and historical grievances from various ethnic and tribal communities in Manipur emerges as a complex challenge.
Key Terms/Phrases:
- Peace Dynamics: Peace accord, insurgency, Suspension of Operations (SoO) agreement.
- Challenges in Reconciliation: Multiplicity of stakeholders, ethnic conflicts, geopolitical factors.
- Key Players: Separatist groups, militant factions, political negotiations.
Key Quotes/Statements:
- “Any peace initiative is welcome — more so if it deals with a militant group abjuring arms to join the mainstream.”
- “The biggest hurdle in the road to peace remains the floating looted arms numbering around 4,500 in various hands.”
- “Diverse demands from various ethnic and/or tribal communities… making it hard to arrive at a resolution that satisfies all parties.”
Key Examples/References:
- Positive Precedents: Peace accords in Mizoram, Tripura, Shillong, and Assam leading to regional normalization.
- NSCN-IM Accord: The signing of an accord by the National Socialist Council of Nagaland — Isak-Muivah (NSCN-IM) in 2015.
- Militant Factions in UNLF: Presence of factions like the Pambei faction advocating for dialogue.
Key Facts/Data:
- Ban Extension: The ban extension on nine Meiti extremist groups, including UNLF and Manipur People’s Army (MPA).
- Surrender Statistics: Tripartite accords initiated by the Centre since 2014 leading to 6,112 insurgents surrendering.
- Arms Challenge: Presence of 4,500 looted arms posing a significant challenge to peace efforts.
Critical Analysis:
- Distrust and External Influences: Challenges in implementing peace agreements due to historical distrust, external influences, and divergent interests.
- Fragility of Agreements: The fragility of peace agreements highlighted by disruptions caused by extremist factions or splinter groups.
- State’s Volatility: Manipur’s volatile state demands comprehensive efforts for lasting peace.
Way Forward:
- Addressing Arm Threat: Focus on resolving the issue of looted arms to ensure a major cause of concern is adequately addressed.
- Transparent Communication: Clearly communicate the terms of the UNLF peace accord to manage expectations and foster understanding.
- Holistic Approach: Focus on political negotiations, rehabilitation of displaced individuals, and dismantling militant-controlled zones.
- Inclusive Engagement: Engage all political parties, appoint a political negotiator, and seek a comprehensive agreement that satisfies various stakeholders.
Get an IAS/IPS ranker as your 1: 1 personal mentor for UPSC 2024
Attend Now
Note4Students
From UPSC perspective, the following things are important :
Prelims level: Na
Mains level: India's approach to covert operations to align with international norms.
-1596348923.png?auto=format%2Ccompress&fmt=webp&fit=max&format=webp&q=70&w=400&dpr=2)
Central idea
The article explores the credibility crisis faced by India in the realm of covert operations, focusing on recent legal challenges and a lack of trust with the U.S. The key themes include the impact on international relations, the dynamics of intelligence sharing, and the need for a balanced diplomatic approach to maintain India’s global image.
Key Highlights:
- Espionage and Covert Operations: Recent U.S. indictment against Nikhil Gupta for targeting Khalistani separatists in North America.
- Credibility Challenges: Multiple legal challenges to Indian intelligence operations abroad, raising questions about New Delhi’s credibility.
- Global Reach of Indian Security: Operations against Khalistani and Pakistani operatives in various countries, showcasing India’s security establishment’s capabilities.
Key Challenges:
- Credibility Crisis: Impact on New Delhi’s credibility in covert capacities and public messaging.
- Trust Deficit: Lack of trust and information sharing between India and the U.S.
- Diplomatic Balancing Act: Juggling international engagements and addressing concerns from western allies.
Key Terms/Phrases:
- Covert Operations Dynamics: Espionage, intelligence, and covert operations.
- Targeted Groups: Khalistani separatists, extradition, extra-judicial actions.
- International Relations: Trust deficit, bilateral ties, Five Eyes intelligence partnership.
Key Quotes/Statements:
- “In the shadowy world of espionage, intelligence and covert operations, the only rule is to never get caught carrying out a mission.”
- “Trust is still an issue.”
- “India’s double standard in its international engagements.”
Key Examples/References:
- Legal Battles: Forcible return of UAE princess, Latifah, and the “attempted kidnap” of Mehul Choksi.
- Convictions and Challenges: Conviction of Indian naval officers in Qatar for espionage.
Key Facts/Data:
- Alleged Operations: Involvement of Indian agencies in operations against Khalistani and Pakistani operatives globally.
- Information Gaps: Lack of full information sharing between the U.S. and India regarding the alleged conspiracy.
Critical Analysis:
- Credibility Concerns: Questions raised about India’s credibility in covert operations and international engagements.
- Trust Dynamics: Ongoing trust deficit between India and the U.S. impacting information sharing.
- Image Management: Balancing India’s image globally, considering hard and soft power approaches.
Way Forward:
- Transparent Investigations: Address credibility concerns through thorough and transparent investigations.
- Enhanced Information Sharing: Strengthen trust and information-sharing mechanisms with international partners.
- Adaptive Diplomacy: Evaluate and adjust India’s approach to covert operations to align with international norms.
- Diplomatic Outreach: Enhance diplomatic efforts to manage relationships with western allies and neighbors.
Get an IAS/IPS ranker as your 1: 1 personal mentor for UPSC 2024
Attend Now
Note4Students
From UPSC perspective, the following things are important :
Prelims level: na
Mains level: How Henry Kissinger tricked the world
Central idea
Henry Kissinger’s enigmatic legacy, spanning 80 years, encapsulates both admiration and criticism, depicting him as a “miracle man” and a “confidence man.” His influence on post-World War II global affairs prompts reflection on the intricate dynamics of power and diplomacy, posing ethical questions about leadership.
Key Highlights:
- Henry Kissinger’s Impact: Henry Kissinger, a pivotal figure in post-World War II global affairs, has left an indelible mark, often hailed as a “miracle man” but critiqued as a “confidence man.”
- Confidence Man Persona: Described as immensely talented and charming, Kissinger projected an aura of indispensability, successfully ingraining himself in the power structures globally for nearly 80 years.
- Ambiguous Morality: The term “confidence man” encapsulates Kissinger’s ability to project charm while potentially having a morally hollow core, raising questions about the ethical dimensions of his actions.
- Longevity and Influence: Despite controversies and criticisms, Kissinger’s influence endured, evident in his 100th birthday gala hosting the world’s elite and maintaining access to leaders like President Xi even in his later years.
Key Challenges:
- Moral Ambiguity: Kissinger’s approach to power and diplomacy raises ethical concerns, as he seemed more inclined towards realpolitik and a will to power than moral considerations.
- Impact on Global Conflicts: The decisions and actions condoned by Kissinger, such as the delayed peace agreement in Vietnam and support for controversial military interventions, are linked to significant human suffering and casualties.
Key Phrases:
- Confidence Man: A term used to characterize Kissinger’s charismatic yet potentially morally questionable persona, emphasizing his knack for presenting himself as indispensable.
- Will to Power: Kissinger’s approach to diplomacy is seen as a will to power, prioritizing the acquisition and maintenance of power as a measure of success.
Key Quotes:
- Eqbal Ahmad’s Assessment: “Kissinger was not a miracle man. He was a confidence man.”
- Kissinger’s Perspective: “There are two kinds of realists: Those who manipulate facts and those who create them.”
Key Examples and References:
- Crimes and Controversies: Kissinger’s involvement in delaying the Vietnam Peace Agreement, bombing of Cambodia, ignorance of the East Pakistan genocide, and support for interventions like in East Timor and Argentina.
- Greg Grandin’s Estimate: Historian Greg Grandin approximates around four million deaths attributable to Kissinger’s decisions.
Critical Analysis:
- Moral Objectivity: Kissinger’s approach challenges the conventional moral objectives associated with realism, portraying power as the ultimate measure of success.
- Survival Mentality: The analysis suggests that Kissinger’s worldview was shaped by a fear of powerlessness, instilled by the European experience, driving him to prioritize power at any cost.
Way Forward:
- Reflection on Morality: Evaluating the moral implications of diplomatic actions, emphasizing a balance between realism and ethical considerations in global affairs.
- Global Accountability: Reflecting on Kissinger’s legacy prompts a broader discussion on holding powerful figures accountable for decisions that impact millions of lives.
Get an IAS/IPS ranker as your 1: 1 personal mentor for UPSC 2024
Attend Now
Note4Students
From UPSC perspective, the following things are important :
Prelims level: na
Mains level: Legal Language Simplification
Central idea
The Indian government, led by Prime Minister Narendra Modi, is actively simplifying legal language to promote “Access to Justice,” making legal texts more understandable for every citizen. This strategic initiative, aligned with constitutional principles, addresses historical ambiguities and leverages technology to enhance accessibility, contributing to global legal recognition and fostering a transformative journey toward inclusive justice.
Key Highlights:
- Legal Language Simplification: The Indian government, led by Prime Minister Narendra Modi, is undertaking a mission to simplify legal language, aligning with the vision of “Access to Justice” and aiming to make legal texts more accessible to the common citizen.
- Constitutional Principle: The initiative reflects the constitutional principle that legal language should be understandable to every citizen, emphasizing the importance of ensuring citizens comprehend their rights and responsibilities.
- Correction of Ambiguities: The government is addressing historical ambiguities in legal language, such as those in Sections 213 and 214 of the IPC, to enhance legal precision and effective enforcement, eliminating potential loopholes.
- Global Recognition: The government’s commitment to simplifying legal language has gained international recognition, positioning India as a forward-thinking adopter of progressive measures for legal accessibility.
- Digital Transformation: The simplification efforts align with the Digital India campaign, leveraging technology to enhance accessibility, with online platforms and digital resources making legal information more readily available.
Key Challenges:
- Historical Complexities: Addressing historical intricacies in legal language poses a challenge, requiring thorough examination and correction of ambiguities that have persisted over time.
- Public Engagement: While seeking public input in the simplification process is a positive step, ensuring effective public engagement and capturing diverse perspectives can be challenging.
Key Phrases:
- Access to Justice: The overarching vision guiding the simplification initiative, aiming to remove barriers of legal complexity that hinder the common citizen’s understanding of legal texts.
- Legal Empowerment: The goal of simplification extends beyond language, aiming to empower citizens with legal knowledge, fostering a sense of legal empowerment among the diverse population.
Key Quotes:
- “We must see that the constitution is not only passed by the Constituent Assembly but that it is also worked by the common people of the country.” – B R Ambedkar
- “The government envisions a legal landscape where language is not a barrier but a bridge to justice.”
Critical Analysis:
- The reduction in legal disputes due to misunderstandings and misinterpretations underscores the positive impact of the simplification initiatives in fostering a clearer legal framework.
Way Forward:
- Continue the integration of plain language drafting principles into legal education to nurture a generation of legal professionals capable of navigating legal intricacies with clarity and precision.
- Sustain efforts to engage the public in the simplification process, ensuring diverse perspectives are considered for comprehensive legal accessibility.
- Monitor and evaluate the impact of simplification on reducing legal disputes and enhancing India’s global economic competitiveness.
- Explore additional measures, such as comprehensive glossaries in multiple languages, to further enhance the understanding of legal language among citizens.
Get an IAS/IPS ranker as your 1: 1 personal mentor for UPSC 2024
Attend Now
Central idea
The central idea underscores the need for a bottom-up approach, private sector engagement, and innovative models like the SPARK project to bring about attitudinal shifts, economic opportunities, and social recognition for persons with disabilities, ultimately fostering a more equitable and inclusive global development agenda.
Key Highlights:
- Disability Intersectionality: Disability intersects with social, economic, and gender vulnerabilities, necessitating comprehensive consideration for equitable action.
- Global Disability Statistics: Globally, 1.3 billion people live with disabilities, with 80% in developing countries and 70% residing in rural areas.
- Exclusionary Systems: Current systems designed for non-disabled persons lead to exclusion, resulting in higher instances of poverty, limited education access, and social discrimination for people with disabilities.
- Importance of Language: The distinction between “for” and “by” in disability inclusion is crucial. Inclusion should involve persons with disabilities in the process, not just for them.
- Economic Impact: Inclusion of persons with disabilities in the economy could boost global GDP by 3% to 7%, emphasizing the economic benefits of inclusion.
- Employment Scenario: Current employment scenarios limit job opportunities for persons with disabilities, contradicting the UN Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities.
- Rural Challenges: Persons with disabilities in rural areas face heightened challenges, including limited access to education, employment, and exclusion from developmental schemes.
- UDID Card and Government Schemes: In India, UDID cards and various government schemes exist for persons with disabilities, emphasizing the need for awareness and last-mile connectivity of benefits.
- SPARK Project: The ILO and IFAD’s SPARK project focuses on disability inclusion in rural areas, with Disability Inclusion Facilitators (DIFs) leading awareness and engagement efforts.
Key Challenges:
- Awareness and Accessibility: Limited awareness and accessibility to government benefits for persons with disabilities, particularly in rural areas.
- Societal Perception: Persons with disabilities often face societal perceptions that view them as objects of charity rather than active participants in decision-making processes.
- Climate Calamities: Rural areas with high agricultural dependence face increased risks from climate calamities, further impacting persons with disabilities.
- Private Sector Engagement: While a robust legal framework exists, greater engagement with the private sector is crucial for promoting the employment of persons with disabilities.
Key Quotes:
- “For is often used when a person is receiving something and By is to identify the agent performing an action.”
- “Disability inclusion is rooted in assuring the rights of persons with disabilities and recognizing the economic benefits of inclusion.”
- “It is about time that the voices and needs of persons with disabilities be prioritized at the center of the global development agenda.”
Key Terms:
- Intersectionality: The interconnected nature of social categorizations such as disability, gender, and economic status, which creates overlapping and interdependent systems of discrimination or disadvantage.
- UDID Card: Unique ID for persons with disabilities, a card established as part of the Rights of Persons with Disabilities Act (2016) in India.
- Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs): A collection of 17 global goals set by the United Nations in 2015 as a universal call to action to end poverty, protect the planet, and ensure prosperity for all.
- Disability Inclusion Facilitators (DIFs): Individuals trained to engage with communities, raise awareness, and identify barriers to inclusion for persons with disabilities.
Key Phrases:
- Economic Consequences of Exclusion: Refers to the impact on the global GDP when excluding persons with disabilities from the workforce, as highlighted in the ILO study.
- Last-Mile Connectivity: Ensuring the final leg of delivery or accessibility of government benefits to the remotest areas, especially in the context of persons with disabilities.
- Social Development Dimension: Viewing disability inclusion not only as a matter of rights but also as a crucial aspect of social development.
Key Statements:
- “Disability as an identity and entity exists at the intersection of multiple vulnerabilities — social, economic, and gender — with each facet requiring careful consideration when conceptualizing action for equity.”
- “The inclusion of persons with disabilities into the economy can help boost global GDP between 3% to 7%, as per the study by the International Labour Organization.”
- “It is about time that the voices and needs of persons with disabilities be prioritized at the center of the global development agenda.”
Key Examples and References:
- The SPARK Project: Implemented by the ILO and IFAD, the SPARK project in Maharashtra demonstrates successful inclusion efforts led by persons with disabilities.
- International Labour Organization (ILO): Referenced for its study on the economic consequences of excluding persons with disabilities from the workforce.
- Rights of Persons with Disabilities Act (2016): Legislation in India that includes provisions for UDID cards and various schemes for persons with disabilities.
Key Facts:
- Global Disability Statistics: Approximately 1.3 billion people globally live with some form of disability, with 80% residing in developing countries.
- Rural Challenges: In India, 70% of persons with disabilities live in rural areas, facing greater challenges in accessing education and employment opportunities.
- Economic Impact: Inclusion of persons with disabilities in the workforce could boost global GDP by 3% to 7%, according to the ILO study.
Key Data:
- Percentage of Global Population with Disabilities: 1.3 billion people, equivalent to nearly the entire population of India.
- Percentage of Persons with Disabilities in Developing Countries: 80%, with 70% residing in rural areas.
- Impact on Global GDP: Inclusion of persons with disabilities can boost global GDP by 3% to 7%, according to the ILO.
Critical Analysis:
- Bi-Directional Link: Evidence shows a connection between disability, poverty, nutrition, and hunger, emphasizing the need for inclusive opportunities and employment in rural areas.
- Societal Perceptions: Persons with disabilities often face societal perceptions that view them as objects of charity rather than active participants in decision-making processes.
- Private Sector Engagement: The importance of engaging the private sector and building confidence in hiring workers with disabilities is highlighted.
Way Forward:
Prioritize the voices and needs of persons with disabilities at the core of the global development agenda for genuine inclusion and social justice. This involves awareness, engagement, and a bottom-up approach to disability inclusion, especially in rural areas.
Get an IAS/IPS ranker as your 1: 1 personal mentor for UPSC 2024
Attend Now
Central Idea:
The Indian state faces a paradox of being too burdensome in bureaucracy yet too small in terms of personnel. The focus should shift from the size of the state to addressing issues of perverse incentives, skill gaps, and institutional constraints for effective governance.
Key Highlights:
- Bureaucratic Challenges: Setting up businesses or homes in urban areas in India involves navigating a complex web of licenses, permits, and clearances, reflecting the bureaucratic thicket that hinders efficiency.
- State Size Discrepancy: While India has a relatively small number of civil servants per capita and a lower public sector share in employment, it struggles with challenges in providing essential services and infrastructure.
- Perverse Incentives: The root cause of governance inefficiency lies in perverse incentives within public institutions, hindering policymakers and officials from making and implementing effective policies.
- Need for Delegation: Lessons from countries like Australia and Malaysia suggest that separating policymaking and implementation responsibilities expedites execution and encourages innovations, improving program outcomes.
- Technocratic Gap: The lack of technocratic skills at the policymaking level results in substantial outsourcing to consultancy firms, revealing a gap that needs to be addressed for effective governance.
Key Challenges:
- Technocratic Skill Deficiency: The Indian bureaucratic system lacks technocratic skills, leading to significant outsourcing of crucial tasks to consultancy firms, highlighting a need for internal capability building.
- Policy Failures: Both proponents and critics of a larger state miss the fundamental issue of perverse incentives and skill gaps, contributing to policy failures across various sectors.
Key Phrases:
- People-Thin, Process-Thick State: Describes the Indian state as lacking in personnel but burdened with complex processes, emphasizing the need for a shift in focus from size to efficiency.
- Perverse Incentives: Highlights the negative motivations within public institutions that hinder sound policymaking and implementation.
Key Quotes for good marks:
- “The main problem, however, is the perverse incentives created by public institutions and the skill gap among officials.”
- “Both sides to the debate are missing something fundamental.”
Anecdotes:
- National Highways Authority of India: The example of the NHAI, where policymaking and execution are separated, showcases the effectiveness of delegation in reducing delays and cost overruns.
Critical Analysis:
- Audits and Oversight: The focus on compliance over policy objectives due to narrowly scoped audits by oversight agencies hampers effective decision-making, causing delays and disputes.
Way Forward:
Implementing institutional reforms, such as separating policymaking and implementation, enhancing technocratic skills, and sensitizing oversight agencies to contextual policy decisions, can improve state capability.
Get an IAS/IPS ranker as your 1: 1 personal mentor for UPSC 2024
Attend Now
Note4Students
From UPSC perspective, the following things are important :
Prelims level: na
Mains level: India's nimble and forthright diplomacy
Get an IAS/IPS ranker as your 1: 1 personal mentor for UPSC 2024
Attend Now
Note4Students
From UPSC perspective, the following things are important :
Prelims level: PLI Scheme
Mains level: sustained economic recovery
Central idea
The Indian growth story remains a beacon of hope. The economy is unlikely to slow down in line with other major economies of the world as the government continues to undertake reforms.
Key Highlights:
- Economic Growth: The Indian economy expands by 7.6% in Q2, challenging doubts on post-pandemic macroeconomic resilience.
- Manufacturing Surge: The manufacturing sector grows robustly at 13.9%, indicating positive outcomes from policy initiatives and credit stabilization.
- Corporate Health: Corporate books show impressive bottom-line growth, reflecting broad-based economic recovery.
- Capex Intentions: Historic capex intentions with new investment announcements reaching Rs 37 lakh crore in 2022-23, signifying increased private sector participation.
- Agricultural Transformation: Agriculture grows by 1.2%, with a shift towards allied activities reducing dependence on traditional farm income.
- Banking Support: Banks increasingly finance the entire agri value chain, with agri loans growing by 15.4% in 2022-23.
- Services Sector Moderation: Services sector growth moderates to 5.8%, influenced by low growth in trade, hotels, transport, and communication.
- Consumption Patterns: Private consumption decelerates to 3.1%, possibly impacted by higher inflation, expected to pick up in the third quarter.
- Government Investments: Government consumption and investments register healthy growth, with gross fixed capital formation increasing by 11%.
Key Challenges:
- Global Growth Risk: Risk of softer global growth, especially in the US and Euro region, may impact India’s exports and economic momentum.
- Consumer Sentiment Woes: Consumer sentiments in major economies worsen amid growing uncertainty, potentially affecting global trade.
Key Terms and Phrases:
- Macro-economic Resilience: India’s ability to withstand and recover from economic shocks.
- PLI Scheme: Production-Linked Incentive scheme aimed at boosting manufacturing in specific sectors.
- Corporate Balance Sheets: Financial health and performance of businesses.
- Capex Intentions: Plans and commitments for capital expenditures.
- Allied Activities in Agriculture: Diversification into areas like dairy and fisheries within the agriculture sector.
- Gross Fixed Capital Formation: Investment in fixed assets contributing to economic growth.
- Consumer Sentiments: Public attitudes and feelings regarding economic conditions and spending.
- Global Trade Headwinds: Challenges and obstacles affecting international trade.
Key Quotes:
- “The Indian growth story remains a beacon of hope.”
- “The economy is unlikely to slow down in line with other major economies of the world.”
Key Statements:
- Manufacturing sector growth indicates an uptick triggered by government expenditure, policy initiatives, and credit stabilization.
- Agriculture’s increased focus on allied activities reduces dependence on traditional farm income.
- Historic capex intentions and private sector participation signal a strong economic recovery.
Key Examples and References:
- New investment announcements hitting a high of Rs 37 lakh crore in 2022-23, showcasing increased private sector participation.
- Agriculture loans by banks increase by 15.4% in 2022-23, indicating growing support for the agri value chain.
Key Facts and Data:
- Indian economy grows by 7.6% in Q2, marking two consecutive quarters of 7% plus growth.
- Manufacturing sector grows at a robust 13.9%, reaching a nine-quarter high.
- New investment announcements hit Rs 37 lakh crore in 2022-23, compared to Rs 20 lakh crore in 2021-22.
- Agriculture grows by 1.2% in Q2, with allied activities contributing significantly.
Critical Analysis:
- The robust economic growth raises questions about the accuracy of forecasts doubting India’s resilience.
- The manufacturing sector’s strong performance indicates positive outcomes from government initiatives and policies.
- Private sector participation in capex reflects confidence in the economic recovery.
- Increased focus on allied activities in agriculture showcases a shift in the sector’s dynamics.
- The potential risk of softer global growth highlights external factors influencing India’s economic trajectory.
Way Forward:
- Continued government reforms and support for economic growth.
- Monitoring and addressing potential risks from softer global growth.
- Sustaining the positive momentum in manufacturing and capex through policy measures.
- Emphasizing the role of allied activities in agriculture for a diversified income base.
- Nurturing consumer sentiments and encouraging private consumption for sustained economic recovery.
Get an IAS/IPS ranker as your 1: 1 personal mentor for UPSC 2024
Attend Now
Note4Students
From UPSC perspective, the following things are important :
Prelims level: G20
Mains level: momentum of inclusivity and global collaboration
Note for students: The writer is Prime Minister of India hence there is high possibility UPSC may use this for prelims, mains, interview and essay be aware and alert for these kind of highly valuable articles.
Central idea
India’s G20 presidency prioritized inclusivity, sustainable development, and climate action, offering an alternative to GDP-centric progress. The emphasis on the Global South’s concerns and achievements in digital infrastructure collaboration marked a departure from the status quo.
Key Highlights:
- India’s G20 presidency focused on inclusive, ambitious, action-oriented, and decisive strategies.
- Inclusivity was a central theme, integrating the African Union and emphasizing the Global South’s concerns.
- India introduced the Digital Public Infrastructure (DPI) and a Green Development Pact for sustainable progress.
- The G20 2023 Action Plan targeted SDGs, with a special emphasis on health, education, gender equality, and environmental sustainability.
- Commitment to climate justice, equity, and significant financial support for developing countries were key features.
Key Challenges:
- Addressing conflicts, competition, and declining multilateralism.
- Balancing development cooperation amid geopolitical tensions.
- Navigating the transition from GDP-centric to human-centric progress.
- Mobilizing substantial resources for climate and development financing.
Key Terms:
- Vasudhaiva Kutumbakam
- New Delhi Leaders’ Declaration (NDLD)
- Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs)
- Digital Public Infrastructure (DPI)
- Green Development Pact
- Lifestyles for Sustainable Development (LiFE)
- Nationally Determined Contributions (NDCs)
- Multilateral Development Banks
Key Phrases:
- “One Earth, One Family, One Future”
- “Voice of the Global South Summit”
- “People’s Presidency”
- “Jan Bhagidari” (People’s participation)
- “Digital Public Infrastructure Repository”
- “Tripling of global renewable energy capacity by 2030”
- “Climate justice and equity”
- “Women’s Reservation Bill 2023”
| Key Quotes
For value addition of mains answer they may come as essay topics as they are written by pm of our country. UPSC is very keen on selecting such type of content be focused and revise this article multiple times.
“The interests of the few had to give way to the aspirations of the many.”
“For the first time, there was a recognition of the quantum jump needed in the magnitude of development financing.”
“It revitalised multilateralism, amplified the voice of the Global South, championed development, and fought for the empowerment of women everywhere.”
|
Key Statements:
- “Inclusivity has been at the heart of our presidency.”
- “India sought to offer the world an alternative to the status quo, a shift from a GDP-centric to human-centric progress.”
- “India’s Women’s Reservation Bill 2023 epitomizes our commitment to women-led development.”
- “India’s G20 achieved 87 outcomes and 118 adopted documents, a marked rise from the past.”
Key Examples and References:
- The inclusion of the African Union in the G20.
- ‘Voice of the Global South Summit.’
- Digital innovations like Aadhaar, UPI, and Digilocker.
- G20’s emphasis on climate-conscious consumption and planet-friendly production.
- India’s leading role in UN reforms.
Key Facts:
- G20 achieved 87 outcomes and 118 adopted documents during India’s presidency.
- The G20 Declaration calls for tripling global renewable energy capacity by 2030.
- India’s Women’s Reservation Bill 2023 reserves one-third of parliamentary and state legislative assembly seats for women.
- Developing countries require $5.9 trillion to fulfill their NDCs by 2030.
Key Data:
- The G20 reached 1.4 billion citizens through “Jan Bhagidari” events.
Critical Analysis:
India’s G20 presidency successfully navigated challenges, emphasizing inclusivity, sustainable development, and climate action. The presidency revitalized multilateralism and amplified the voice of the Global South, marking a significant shift in the global narrative.
Way Forward:
- Sustaining the momentum of inclusivity and global collaboration.
- Implementing the G20 2023 Action Plan for accelerated progress on SDGs.
- Continued advocacy for climate justice, equity, and financial support for developing nations.
- Strengthening the role of Multilateral Development Banks for effective development financing.
- Advancing UN reforms for a more equitable global order.
Get an IAS/IPS ranker as your 1: 1 personal mentor for UPSC 2024
Attend Now
Note4Students
From UPSC perspective, the following things are important :
Prelims level: Broadcast Advisory Council
Mains level: press freedom and diversity
Central idea
India’s Broadcasting Services Bill aims at regulating broadcasting comprehensively, introducing positive steps like audience data transparency and competition in terrestrial broadcasting. However, concerns arise over privacy, jurisdictional conflicts with OTT regulation, and lack of measures on ownership and an independent regulator.
Key Highlights:
- The Broadcasting Services (Regulation) Bill aims to regulate broadcasting comprehensively, marking the third attempt since 1997.
- Positive propositions include obligations for record-keeping, audience measurement transparency, and allowing private actors in terrestrial broadcasting.
Key Concerns:
- Lack of privacy safeguards for subscriber and audience data in data collection practices.
- Inclusion of Over-the-Top (OTT) content suppliers in the definition of broadcasting creates jurisdictional conflicts and poses threats to smaller news outlets.
Positive Provisions Requiring Refinement:
- Obligation for maintaining records of subscriber data.
- Stipulation of a methodology for audience measurement.
- Provision to permit private actors in terrestrial broadcasting.
Apprehensions:
- Expanded definition of broadcasting may limit conditions for journalists and news outlets not part of large television networks.
- The mandate for a ‘Content Evaluation Committee’ to self-certify news programming raises feasibility and desirability concerns.
Crucial Silences in the Bill:
- Lack of measures to assess cross-media and vertical ownership impacts diversity in the news marketplace.
- Absence of provisions for creating an independent broadcast regulator.
Government Empowerment and Intrusive Mechanisms:
- The Bill grants the government leeway to inspect broadcasters without prior intimation, impound equipment, and curtail broadcasting in “public interest.”
- Violations of the Programme Code and Advertisement Code could result in deleting or modifying content.
Concerns Regarding Broadcast Advisory Council:
- Doubts about the Council’s capacity to address grievances raised by over 800 million TV viewers.
- Lack of autonomy for the Council, as the Central government has the ultimate decision-making authority.
Key Terms and Phrases:
- Over-the-Top (OTT) content suppliers
- National Broadcasting Policy
- Content Evaluation Committee
- Vertical integration
- Broadcast Advisory Council.
Key Statements:
- Privacy concerns arise due to the Bill’s lack of guardrails for subscriber and audience data collection practices.
- The absence of measures to assess cross-media and vertical ownership impacts the diversity of news suppliers.
- The Bill’s silence on creating an independent broadcast regulator is a significant omission.
Key Examples and References:
- The Bill is part of a series of attempts to regulate broadcasting, following initiatives in 1997 and 2007.
- TRAI’s ‘National Broadcasting Policy’ proposes including OTT content suppliers in the definition of broadcasting services.
Key Facts and Data:
- Lack of specifics on cross-media and vertical ownership in the Bill impedes diversity in the news marketplace.
- No provisions for an independent broadcast regulator, with the proposal for a ‘Broadcast Advisory Council.’
Critical Analysis:
- The potential positive provisions of the Bill require refinement, particularly concerning privacy protection and oversight bodies for news outlets.
- Intrusive mechanisms grant significant power to the government, posing concerns about press freedom and external pressure on news suppliers.
Way Forward:
- The Bill must address jurisdictional conflicts, incorporate privacy safeguards, and reconsider intrusive provisions for effective and balanced regulation.
- Protection of press freedom and diversity should be prioritized through fine-tuning potentially positive provisions and addressing omissions.
Get an IAS/IPS ranker as your 1: 1 personal mentor for UPSC 2024
Attend Now
Note4Students
From UPSC perspective, the following things are important :
Prelims level: World AIDS Day
Mains level: resilience of sex workers, bar dancers, and trans individuals
Central idea
The article on World AIDS Day sheds light on the neglected lives of Mumbai’s marginalized communities, emphasizing lessons from the HIV epidemic. It calls for grassroots engagement, holistic healthcare solutions, and dignity-centered public health strategies.
Key Highlights:
- Forgotten Narratives: Reflecting on the lives of marginalized communities in Mumbai on World AIDS Day.
- Overlooked Wisdom: Emphasizing the resilience of sex workers, bar dancers, and trans individuals.
- Lessons from the Epidemic: Drawing insights from the HIV epidemic and its impact on these communities.
Key Challenges:
- Information Gap: Sub-standard public awareness efforts leading to misinformation.
- Access Barriers: Discrimination preventing vulnerable communities from accessing healthcare.
- Top-Down Struggles: Ineffectiveness of top-down approaches in understanding diverse high-risk communities.
Key Terms:
- Grassroots Engagement: Involving local communities in decision-making and solutions.
- Holistic Solutions: Addressing issues comprehensively, considering social, economic, and cultural contexts.
- Stigma and Discrimination: Negative attitudes and actions directed towards marginalized groups.
Key Phrases:
- “Forgotten Narratives“: Bringing attention to the overlooked stories of marginalized communities.
- “Grassroots Wisdom”: Advocating for effective health interventions through community involvement.
- “Holistic Approach”: Moving beyond traditional health services for comprehensive solutions.
Key Examples and References:
- Walks in Mumbai’s Shadows: Personal anecdotes from journeys with marginalized groups.
- Voices of Resilience: Quotes sharing insights on life, disease, and discrimination.
- Epidemic Lessons: Reference to valuable knowledge gained during the HIV epidemic.
Key Facts:
- Call for Collective Action: Emphasizing the need for public trust and stakeholder involvement.
- Investment in Health: Recognizing the commitment of poor and vulnerable populations to their well-being.
- Activism’s Role: Highlighting activism as essential for equitable and accessible healthcare.
| Key Quotes, Anecdotes, Key Statements for good marks |
| |
| “Even the best strategies falter without grassroots engagement.” |
| “The key to ending an epidemic lay in uniting diverse high-risk groups, combating stigma and discrimination.” |
| “Conversations with these communities illuminated the multidimensional aspects of human sexuality, desire, and behavior change.” |
| “Every issue had human, economic, and social dimensions.” |
| “Activism is the kernel around which change can grow. In India, even today, marginalized groups face mistreatment, and it is activism that can make care equitable and accessible.” |
| “Health must come with dignity and empowerment.” |
| “They certainly gave me life lessons in self-respect, desire, and love.” |
Critical Analysis:
- Emotional Impact: Personal anecdotes and quotes enhance the emotional connection to the narrative.
- Advocacy for Change: Effectively advocates for a shift towards inclusive, grassroots-centered health strategies.
- Learnings from Marginalized: Stresses the importance of learning from marginalized communities for effective healthcare solutions.
Way Forward:
- Dignity-Centered Strategies: Calls for strategies prioritizing dignity, equity, and grassroots engagement.
- Community Learning: Emphasizes the value of understanding and incorporating lessons from marginalized communities in public health interventions.
Get an IAS/IPS ranker as your 1: 1 personal mentor for UPSC 2024
Attend Now
Note4Students
From UPSC perspective, the following things are important :
Prelims level: NA
Mains level: Industry-academia collaborations in Indian higher education are underutilized
Central idea
The article underscores the underutilization of collaborations between Indian higher education institutions (HEIs) and industries, hindering gains from intellectual property (IP) commercialization. It identifies key challenges such as divergent goals, cultural differences, communication gaps, and the need for trust-building.
Key Highlights:
- Industry-academia collaborations in Indian higher education are underutilized, hindering potential gains from IP commercialization and technology transfers.
- Collaborative success requires shared goals, addressing cultural differences, establishing effective communication, and building trust.
Key Challenges:
- Divergent Goals: Misalignment between HEIs’ focus on theoretical knowledge and industries’ profit-driven practical applications.
- Cultural Differences: Varied approaches to data scrutiny and application development create challenges in collaboration.
- Communication Gaps: Lack of understanding of industry regulatory processes and language differences hinder effective partnerships.
- Building Trust: Fear of research results being published without considering commercial implications, requiring clear agreements.
Key Terms:
- Intellectual Property (IP)
- Technology Transfer
- Collaborative Goals
- Cultural Gap
- Communication Channels
- Trust Building
- Short-term Collaborations
- Long-term Research Collaborations
- Symbiotic Relationship
Key Phrases:
- “Shared goals crucial for collaboration success.”
- “Cultural gap between academia and industry must be bridged.”
- “Effective communication channels and trust-building are essential.”
- “Clear agreements on IP and publication to ensure transparency.“
Key Examples:
- Collaboration between HEI and renewable energy company highlights cultural differences.
- Pharmaceutical company collaboration emphasizes the need for understanding regulatory processes.
- University-tech company collaboration for software application development showcases IP arrangement challenges.
Key Facts:
- Many Indian HEIs miss out on capitalizing on research through IP commercialization.
- Lack of collaboration hampers gains from patents, licensing, and start-up ventures.
Critical Analysis:
- The article highlights crucial challenges in industry-academia collaborations and emphasizes the importance of addressing them for mutual benefit.
- The need for effective communication, trust-building, and clear agreements is appropriately underscored.
Way Forward:
- Foster a culture of open dialogue and flexibility.
- Implement training programs for understanding industry processes.
- Encourage short-term collaborations for quick problem resolution.
- Promote long-term research collaborations for cutting-edge technology development.
- Government funding agencies should announce research grants and encourage joint project proposals.
By addressing these challenges and fostering collaboration, Indian higher education institutions and industries can create a mutually beneficial ecosystem.
Get an IAS/IPS ranker as your 1: 1 personal mentor for UPSC 2024
Attend Now
Note4Students
From UPSC perspective, the following things are important :
Prelims level: 2023 women reservation Act
Mains level: Two routes for women's political empowerment
Central Idea
Political empowerment of women in India faces challenges despite the 2023 women reservation Act, with recent Assembly elections showing inadequate efforts by political parties to field more women candidates.
Key Highlights:
- Two routes for women’s political empowerment: legislative reservation and quotas within political parties.
- Examples from Nepal, Bangladesh, and Pakistan using legislative reservation.
- Countries like Australia, Canada, South Africa, and Sweden achieve women’s representation without legislatively-backed quotas.
- In India, the 2023 Act reserves 33% seats for women in State Assemblies and Parliament.
- Despite the Act, recent Assembly elections show insufficient commitment from political parties.
Key Challenges:
- In Madhya Pradesh, BJP and Congress fielded 28 and 30 women candidates, respectively, out of 230 seats after the Act.
- Telangana sees minimal increase, with BJP and Congress fielding 12 women candidates each out of 119 seats.
- No party in any state reaches the mandated 33% mark for women candidates.
- Despite innovative moves like Congress reserving 40% seats in UP in 2022, overall progress is lacking.
- TMC’s success in Odisha and West Bengal suggests regional parties are more proactive in women’s political representation.
Key Facts and Data:
- Act passed in Lok Sabha with significant majority, only two opposing members.
- In Uttar Pradesh 2022 elections, Congress reserved 40% seats for women, a bold move.
- BJD and TMC’s success in Odisha and West Bengal elections with more women candidates.
Critical Analysis:
- The Act, though commendable, looks good on paper due to its linkage with delimitation after 2026.
- Regional parties like TMC have shown commitment and won with more women candidates, questioning the reluctance of national parties.
Way Forward:
- National and regional parties need to demonstrate genuine commitment to women’s political empowerment by increasing the number of women candidates.
- Learning from the success of regional parties like TMC, other political entities should actively promote and support women in politics.
- Continuous monitoring and public discourse can encourage political parties to fulfill their commitment to women’s representation.
While the enactment of the 2023 women reservation Act is a positive step, recent Assembly elections reveal a gap between legislation and action, with political parties showing reluctance to genuinely empower women in politics. Continuous efforts and monitoring are crucial for bridging this gap and ensuring meaningful representation.
Get an IAS/IPS ranker as your 1: 1 personal mentor for UPSC 2024
Attend Now
Note4Students
From UPSC perspective, the following things are important :
Prelims level: Adolescent Reproductive and Sexual Health Strategy (ARSH) and the National Adolescent Health Programme (RKSK)
Mains level: social justice education
Get an IAS/IPS ranker as your 1: 1 personal mentor for UPSC 2024
Attend Now
Note4Students
From UPSC perspective, the following things are important :
Prelims level: cyber attacks
Mains level: evolving landscape of terrorism emphasizes the shift to cyberspace
Central idea
The article underscores the transformation of terrorism into cyberspace, emphasizing the significance of robust cybersecurity measures in the face of escalating state-sponsored cyberattacks.
Key Highlights:
- Mumbai holds the unfortunate title of the most terror-attacked city globally.
- The November 26, 2008 (26/11) attacks were the most audacious, lasting three days.
- Intelligence was available before 26/11 attacks, but preventive measures failed.
- Post-attack, significant changes were made in the police department and security apparatus.
Key Challenges:
- Despite reforms, the landscape of terror warfare has shifted to cyberspace.
- The Russia–Ukraine and Israel–Hamas conflicts demonstrate the growing threat of cyber warfare.
- State-sponsored cyberattacks against India increased by 278% between March 2021-September 2023.
Key Terms and Phrases:
- 26/11 terror attacks, cyberspace, cyber warfare, state-sponsored cyberattacks.
Key Examples and References:
- November 26, 2008, terror attacks in Mumbai.
- Israel-Hamas conflict and the failure of the Iron Dome against cyber threats.
- 2023 India Threat Landscape Report by Cyfirma.
Key Facts and Data:
- State-sponsored cyberattacks on India increased by 278% from March 2021-September 2023.
- India faced 13.7% of all global cyberattacks.
- 13.91 lakh cybersecurity incidents in India in 2022.
Critical Analysis:
- Cybersecurity is of paramount importance in a highly digitized world.
- Recent incidents, including Apple’s warning, highlight the urgency for robust cybersecurity measures.
- The need for nationwide education and training on cyber threats is crucial.
Way Forward:
- Urgent investment in robust cybersecurity measures across government, private sector, and individual citizens.
- Comprehensive education programs, starting in schools, to raise awareness about cyber threats.
- Adequate training and financial support for government agencies to strengthen cybersecurity.
In conclusion, the evolving landscape of terrorism emphasizes the shift to cyberspace, demanding urgent and comprehensive cybersecurity measures, education, and training to safeguard against potential online threats like a “cyber 26/11.”
Get an IAS/IPS ranker as your 1: 1 personal mentor for UPSC 2024
Attend Now
Note4Students
From UPSC perspective, the following things are important :
Prelims level: na
Mains level: Maratha mobilization for reservation
![The Marathas' Demand for Reservation: A Litigation History [2014-21] - Supreme Court Observer](https://www.scobserver.in/wp-content/uploads/2021/10/Maratha-Litigation-History-2640-x-1100-px.png)
Central Idea:
- The Maratha community’s demand for reservation in education and employment stems from a crisis of dominance, influenced by urban and rural challenges.
Urban Crisis:
- Well-paid jobs in urban areas, historically held by Marathas, have rapidly disappeared since the late 1990s.
- Large-scale manufacturing industries and establishments providing such jobs have closed or downsized, leading to increased competition for fewer opportunities.
- Marathas, historically socially superior, used their dominant caste position to secure a significant share of jobs, particularly in the public sector.
- Economic liberalization and the shrinkage of public sector jobs have intensified competition among Marathas for limited opportunities.
Rural Crisis:
- Closure of factories has led to the return of workers to villages, disrupting the pattern of workers retiring in villages and their offspring working in cities.
- Rural youth face challenges migrating to urban areas for better-paying jobs, impacting the financial support they traditionally provided to family members in villages.
- Informal sector jobs become the primary option for rural Maratha youth, diminishing their social standing and pride in rural settings.
- The focus on secure public sector jobs, which have also decreased, becomes crucial for rural Maratha youth.
Education Challenges:
- Increased aspirations for higher education among Marathas face a decline in government institutions and a rise in private unaided colleges with exorbitant fees.
- Marathas, with limited financial resources, compete for a limited number of open-category seats in public institutions.
- Decrease in government-run educational institutions exacerbates the challenges faced by Maratha aspirants.
Crisis of Dominance:
- The combination of urban and rural crises contributes to a crisis of dominance for the Marathas.
- Disturbance of caste hierarchy norms due to Dalit mobility and OBC economic and political assertion adds to Marathas’ anxiety.
- The demand for reservation reflects the need for increased formal sector jobs and the expansion of public educational institutions to address the crisis.
Key Highlights:
- Maratha community demands reservation in education and public employment, intensifying since 2016.
- Historically, Marathas dominated well-paid jobs, but recent urban and rural crises have led to increased competition and challenges.
- Closure of manufacturing industries, decreasing public sector jobs, and rural youth’s struggles contribute to the crisis.
- Educational aspirations face challenges with a decline in government institutions and increased private college fees.
Key Challenges:
- Disappearance of well-paid urban jobs, increased competition, and shrinking public sector employment.
- Rural crisis disrupts the traditional pattern of workers retiring in villages and offspring working in cities.
- Decline in government-run educational institutions, limited open-category seats, and rising private college fees.
Key Terms and Phrases:
- Urban crisis, rural crisis, crisis of dominance, economic liberalization, formal sector jobs.
- Reservation, Maratha mobilization, well-paid jobs, private unaided colleges, public sector employment.
Key Examples and References:
- Maratha protests since 2016, closure of manufacturing industries, decreased public sector jobs.
- Disturbance in traditional caste hierarchies due to Dalit mobility and OBC economic and political assertion.
Key Facts and Data:
- Marathas historically occupied over 29% of open-category jobs in government.
- Jobs in the private formal sector increased from 2% to 3.5%.
- Contractual government jobs increased from 0.7 million to 15.9 million in 2017-18.
- Only 22.2% of colleges are managed by the government as of 2019.
Critical Analysis:
- Maratha crisis stems from economic shifts, urban-rural dynamics, and disturbance in caste hierarchies.
- Limited opportunities, competition, and declining public sector jobs contribute to the community’s mobilization.
- Educational challenges add to the complexity, demanding a comprehensive solution.
Way Forward:
- Address urban and rural crises by creating more formal sector jobs.
- Expand public educational institutions and implement large-scale scholarship programs.
- Focus on inclusive policies to reduce competition and restore traditional patterns of employment.
Conclusion:
- The Maratha mobilization for reservation is rooted in the challenges posed by the disappearance of well-paid jobs, urban-rural dynamics, and the disruption of traditional caste hierarchies. Addressing these challenges requires a focus on creating more opportunities in the formal sector and expanding accessible public education.
Get an IAS/IPS ranker as your 1: 1 personal mentor for UPSC 2024
Attend Now
Note4Students
From UPSC perspective, the following things are important :
Prelims level: India's Maritime Vision 2030
Mains level: Blue Economy: Sustainable use of ocean resources for economic development
Central idea
The article underscores the evolving challenges in the maritime domain, emphasizing the shift from traditional military approaches to a developmental model for maritime security. It highlights the need for collaboration among developing nations to address unconventional threats, such as illegal fishing and climate change, while acknowledging the reluctance to prioritize collective action over political and strategic autonomy.
Key Highlights:
- Evolution of Maritime Challenges: New dimensions in hard security challenges, including asymmetrical tactics and grey-zone warfare. Use of land attack missiles and combat drones reshaping the security landscape.
- Shift in Demand for Maritime Security: Growing demand from states facing unconventional threats such as illegal fishing, natural disasters, and climate change. Need for a broader approach beyond military means to address diverse maritime challenges.
- India’s Developmental Approach: Maritime Vision 2030 focuses on economic growth and livelihood generation through port, shipping, and inland waterway development. Indo-Pacific Oceans Initiative with seven pillars, including maritime ecology, marine resources, and disaster risk reduction.
New Threats in Maritime Domain:
- Recent developments include Ukraine’s asymmetrical tactics and China’s maritime militias, indicating a shift to improvised strategies.
- Emerging threats involve grey-zone warfare, land attack missiles, and combat drones.
Demand for Maritime Security:
- Majority of recent demand stems from unconventional threats like illegal fishing, natural disasters, and climate change.
- Addressing these challenges requires commitment of capital, resources, and specialized personnel.
Global South’s Perspective:
- Developing nations perceive Indo-Pacific competition among powerful nations as detrimental to their interests.
- Challenges involve interconnected objectives in national, environmental, economic, and human security.
Challenges in Global South:
- Rising sea levels, marine pollution, climate change disproportionately impact less developed states, leading to vulnerability.
- Unequal law-enforcement capabilities and lack of security coordination hinder joint efforts against maritime threats.
Creative Models for Maritime Security:
- Maritime security transcends military actions, focusing on generating prosperity and meeting societal aspirations.
- India’s Maritime Vision 2030 emphasizes port, shipping, and inland waterway development for economic growth.
- Dhaka’s Indo-Pacific document and Africa’s Blue Economy concept align with a developmental approach.
Fight Against Illegal Fishing:
- Significant challenge in Asia and Africa marked by a surge in illegal, unreported, and unregulated fishing.
- Faulty policies encouraging destructive methods like bottom trawling and seine fishing contribute to the problem.
India’s Indo-Pacific Oceans Initiative:
- Encompasses seven pillars, including maritime ecology, marine resources, capacity building, and disaster risk reduction.
- Advocates collective solutions for shared problems, garnering support from major Indo-Pacific states.
Challenges in Achieving Consensus:
- Implementation of collaborative strategy faces hurdles in improving interoperability, intelligence sharing, and establishing a regional rules-based order.
- Balancing sovereignty and strategic independence remains a priority for many nations, hindering consensus.
Key Challenges:
- Complexity of Unconventional Threats: Conventional military approaches insufficient; requires capital, resources, and specialist personnel. Challenges include illegal fishing, marine pollution, human trafficking, and climate change.
- Global South’s Coordination Challenges: Unequal law-enforcement capabilities and lack of security coordination among littoral states. Reluctance to prioritize collective action due to varying security priorities and autonomy concerns.
- Vulnerability of Less Developed States: Disproportionate impact of rising sea levels, marine pollution, and climate change on less developed states. Vulnerability stemming from inadequate resources to combat environmental and security challenges.
- Lack of Consensus and Reluctance: Reluctance among littoral states to pursue concrete solutions and collaborate. Paradox of non-traditional maritime security, where collective issues clash with political and strategic autonomy.
Key Terms and Phrases:
- Grey-Zone Warfare: Tactics that fall between peace and war, creating ambiguity in conflict situations.
- Asymmetrical Tactics: Strategies that exploit an opponent’s weaknesses rather than confronting strengths directly.
- Maritime Vision 2030: India’s 10-year blueprint for economic growth in the maritime sector.
- Blue Economy: Sustainable use of ocean resources for economic development.
- Indo-Pacific Oceans Initiative: India’s initiative with pillars like maritime ecology, marine resources, and disaster risk reduction.
- IUU Fishing: Illegal, unreported, and unregulated fishing.
- Bottom Trawling and Seine Fishing: Destructive fishing methods contributing to illegal fishing.
Key Examples and References:
- Ukraine’s Asymmetrical Tactics: Utilization of unconventional strategies in the Black Sea.
- China’s Maritime Militias: Deployment in the South China Sea as an example of evolving threats.
- India’s Maritime Vision 2030: Illustrates a developmental approach to maritime security.
- Illegal Fishing in Asia and Africa: Rising challenge with negative environmental and economic impacts.
Key Facts and Data:
- Maritime Vision 2030: India’s 10-year plan for the maritime sector.
- Indo-Pacific Oceans Initiative: Seven-pillar initiative for collective solutions in the maritime domain.
Critical Analysis:
- Shift to Developmental Model: Emphasis on generating prosperity and meeting human aspirations in addition to traditional security measures.
- Comprehensive Maritime Challenges: Recognition of diverse challenges beyond military threats, including environmental and economic goals.
- Littoral State Reluctance: Paradox in the Global South, where collective issues clash with autonomy, hindering collaborative solutions.
Way Forward:
- Collaborative Strategies:Improved interoperability, intelligence sharing, and agreement on regional rules-based order.
- Prioritizing Collective Action: Developing nations must prioritize collective action over sovereignty for effective maritime solutions.
- Sustainable Development Goals: Prioritize sustainable development goals in littoral states, addressing challenges such as illegal fishing and climate change.
Get an IAS/IPS ranker as your 1: 1 personal mentor for UPSC 2024
Attend Now
Note4Students
From UPSC perspective, the following things are important :
Prelims level: na
Mains level: constitutional principles in the execution of international obligations
Central idea
Tax treaties or protocols signed by the executive to alter or vary the provisions of the IT Act must withstand the rigours of the constitutional and statutory requirements
Key Highlights:
- Landmark Decision: The Supreme Court’s decision in Assessing Officer (International Tax) vs Nestle SA is a landmark ruling reaffirming the constitutional principle that international obligations assumed by the executive require specific legislative conditions for legal effect.
- Constitutional Framework: The judgment delves into the interplay between domestic law and international law within India’s constitutional framework, emphasizing the need for parliamentary approval when international obligations conflict with domestically enacted laws.
- Article 73 and Article 253: The powers of the Union executive, as per Article 73, are co-terminus with those of Parliament, allowing the executive to assume international obligations without legislation. However, Article 253 emphasizes the dualism between international law and municipal law, requiring a domestic legislative process for conflicting obligations.
- Delegated Powers: Parliament can delegate treaty-making powers to the executive, exemplified by tax treaties under section 90 of the Income Tax (IT) Act. The court clarifies that assuming international obligations and enforcing them domestically are distinct processes.
- Section 90 of IT Act: The judgment interprets section 90, titled “Agreement with foreign countries or specified territories,” emphasizing the necessity of a notification for the implementation of agreements related to the avoidance of double taxation.
- MFN Clauses: Most-Favoured-Nation (MFN) clauses, aimed at altering taxation provisions, must be notified for incorporation into domestic tax law. Failure to do so would create uncertainty in the tax system, with no constitutional or statutory backing for unnotified application.
- Chaos and Uncertainty: Unnotified application of MFN clauses could lead to chaos and uncertainty, with taxpayers and assessing officers interpreting and applying the clauses based on individual understanding, lacking legal foundation.
- Scope of Judgment: The judgment’s scope is limited to the need for a notification for the implementation of MFN clauses, and questions related to diplomatic accountability or the executive’s capacity to prolong the performance of international obligations were not addressed.
- Importance of Constitutional Principles: The Supreme Court’s decision is applauded for upholding democratic principles, ensuring that international obligations assumed by the executive align with constitutional and statutory requirements.
Challenges:
- Future Events Contingency: The activation of MFN clauses contingent upon future events poses challenges in their timely application and raises questions about the executive’s diplomatic accountability.
Key Phrases:
- Dualism of Legal Systems: The constitutional framework recognizes international law and municipal law as separate and distinct legal systems.
- Domestic Legislative Processes: International obligations conflicting with domestic laws must undergo legislative processes for enforceability in courts.
- Separation of Powers: The judgment underscores the importance of the doctrine of separation of powers in judicially incorporating international obligations into domestic law.
Critical Analysis:
The court’s decision provides a robust interpretation of constitutional principles, ensuring that assumed international obligations align with domestic legal processes. The focus on the necessity of notifications for the implementation of MFN clauses reflects the court’s commitment to maintaining clarity and avoiding chaos in the tax system.
Key Examples and References:
- Article 73 and 253 of the Constitution: The judgment extensively refers to constitutional provisions such as Article 73 and Article 253 to establish the legal framework.
Way Forward:
- Legislative Precision: Policymakers should ensure precision in legislative processes, especially concerning the implementation of international obligations, to avoid legal ambiguities.
- Clarity in Notification: The executive should prioritize clarity in notifications, particularly when activating clauses contingent upon future events, to prevent interpretational challenges.
- Review of Existing Treaties: Periodic reviews of existing tax treaties to ensure they align with constitutional and statutory requirements and to address any potential issues related to conflicting obligations.
- Enhanced Diplomatic Engagement: Diplomatic efforts should focus on ensuring that assumed international obligations are seamlessly integrated into domestic legal frameworks to uphold constitutional principles.
The Supreme Court’s judgment serves as a guide for maintaining the sanctity of constitutional principles in the execution of international obligations, particularly in the context of tax treaties.
Get an IAS/IPS ranker as your 1: 1 personal mentor for UPSC 2024
Attend Now
Note4Students
From UPSC perspective, the following things are important :
Prelims level: Direct Benefit Transfer (DBT) JAM Trinity
Mains level: DBT's success
Key Highlights:
- India’s Direct Benefit Transfer (DBT) system lauded globally as a “logistical marvel.”
- DBT utilizes digital infrastructure to directly transfer government scheme benefits, covering 310 schemes across 53 ministries.
- The JAM Trinity (Jan Dhan, Aadhaar, and Mobile) post-2017-18 maximized DBT’s impact.
Dignity of the Poor:
- DBT’s overlooked benefit is its preservation of the dignity of the poor.
- Without corruption or leakages, DBT eliminates the need for the poor to parade for government benefits.
- Shift in approach—government benefits reaching the poor directly without intermediaries.
Poverty Perspectives and Historical Context:
- Discussion on poverty perspectives, referencing Michael Young’s “The Rise of The Meritocracy.”
- Challenge to the prevailing view that poverty is an individual’s fault, offering an alternative, rights-based approach.
- Advocacy for understanding poverty from an individual rights perspective and addressing historical contexts.
Rights-Based Approach to Poverty:
- Recognition of basic security rights for citizens regarding food, shelter, and health.
- Emphasis on shared societal responsibility for poverty, especially by the rich and elite.
- Contrast with technical solutions, highlighting the need to work with the poor.
Preserving Dignity in Design:
- Importance of not just providing benefits but also considering how they are delivered.
- DBT as a mechanism that ensures rightful benefits reach the poor while preserving their dignity.
- Elimination of the poverty parade with the government reaching the poor.
Replicating DBT Success:
- Suggestion to replicate the DBT design in other areas, with a focus on the judiciary.
- Reference to the judiciary’s challenges and an appeal to ensure justice reaches the poor efficiently.
- Call for collective efforts to address complex problems.
Challenges:
- Unquantifiable nature of preserving dignity makes it challenging to measure its impact.
- The need for broader societal shifts in perspectives on poverty and shared responsibilities.
Key Phrases:
- JAM Trinity (Jan Dhan, Aadhaar, and Mobile)
- Poverty parade
- Rights-based approach
- Shared societal responsibility
- Technical solutions vs. working with the poor
- Veil of ignorance (Rawlsian perspective)
- Dignity preservation in program design
Critical Analysis:
- Emphasis on the overlooked aspect of preserving dignity brings a unique perspective.
- The article challenges prevailing views on poverty, advocating for a rights-based approach.
- DBT is presented as a successful model, but challenges of replicating its success are acknowledged.
- The article connects poverty perspectives with societal responsibilities and justice delivery.
Key Examples and References for quality enrichment of mains answers:
- Michael Young’s “The Rise of The Meritocracy”
- The Tyranny of Experts by William Easterly
- Reference to the judiciary’s challenges and the appeal of the first woman tribal President.
Key Data and Facts:
- 310 government schemes across 53 ministries utilize DBT.
- Estimated savings of 1.14% of GDP attributed to DBT.
- 79,813 cases pending before 34 judges in the judiciary.
Key Terms:
- Direct Benefit Transfer (DBT)
- JAM Trinity
- Rights-based approach
- Poverty parade
- Veil of ignorance
- Shared societal responsibility
Way Forward:
- Advocacy for applying DBT’s success in other sectors, particularly the judiciary.
- Acknowledgment of complexity but a call for collective efforts to address challenges.
Get an IAS/IPS ranker as your 1: 1 personal mentor for UPSC 2024
Attend Now
Note4Students
From UPSC perspective, the following things are important :
Prelims level: Composition of Constitution Benches
Mains level: Suggestion to split the Supreme Court into a Final Court of Appeal and a permanent Constitution Bench
Central idea
The article discusses the challenges faced by the Supreme Court of India, the historical proposals for structural changes, and the recent proposal to create Constitution Benches as a permanent feature. It explores the need for regional benches to alleviate the overwhelming caseload and enhance the court’s efficiency, considering historical recommendations and current demands for reform.
Jurisdictions of the Supreme Court:
- Original, appellate, and advisory jurisdictions under the Constitution.
- Functions as a Constitutional Court and Court of Appeal.
Composition of Constitution Benches:
- Typically comprise five, seven, or nine judges.
- Deliberate on issues related to constitutional law.
- Article 145(3) mandates a minimum of five judges for substantial constitutional questions.
Broad Jurisdiction of the Supreme Court:
- Hears cases in Division Benches (two judges) or full Benches (three judges).
- Addresses diverse topics, from film prohibitions to allegations against public officials.
- Notable instances of entertaining frivolous public interest litigations.
Current Caseload and Need for Structural Change:
- 79,813 pending cases before 34 judges, prompting calls for structural reforms.
- CJI D.Y. Chandrachud’s recent announcement on establishing varied-strength Constitution Benches permanently.
Historical Proposals for Structural Change:
- Tenth Law Commission (1984) proposed splitting the Supreme Court into Constitutional and Legal Divisions.
- Eleventh Law Commission (1988) reiterated the need for division, aiming at wider justice availability.
- Bihar Legal Support Society v. Chief Justice of India (1986) expressed the “desirability” of a National Court of Appeal.
- 229th Law Commission Report (2009) recommended regional benches for non-constitutional issues.
Colonial Legacy and Evolution of the Supreme Court:
- Three Supreme Courts during colonial times (Bombay, Calcutta, Madras).
- Indian High Courts Act of 1861 replaced Supreme Courts with High Courts.
- Government of India Act, 1935, created the Federal Court of India.
- The Supreme Court, established on January 28, 1950, under Article 124 of the Constitution.
Increasing Judges and Overburdened Court:
- Evolution of the Supreme Court from eight judges in 1950 to 34 in 2019.
- Overburdened court issuing around 8-10 decisions yearly through Constitution Benches.
- Only four out of 1,263 decisions in 2022 from Constitution Benches.
Critical Analysis:
- Overburdened Judiciary: High number of pending cases (79,813) indicates the burden on the Supreme Court. The overwhelming workload affects the efficiency of the court in delivering timely justice.
- Historical Proposals: Historical proposals, like the Tenth Law Commission’s suggestion in 1984, proposed splitting the Supreme Court into Constitutional and Legal Divisions.The aim was to make justice more accessible and reduce litigants’ fees.
- Regional Benches Proposal: The 229th Law Commission Report (2009) recommended establishing regional benches to hear non-constitutional issues. The proposal aimed to decentralize workload and allow the Supreme Court to focus on constitutional matters.
- Historical Background: Evolution of the Supreme Court from colonial times with the creation of regional Supreme Courts. Transformation from three Supreme Courts (Bombay, Calcutta, Madras) to the current centralized structure.
Key Examples and References:
- Bihar Legal Support Society v. Chief Justice of India (1986) suggested establishing a National Court of Appeal.
- The 229th Law Commission Report (2009) recommended regional benches.
Key Facts:
- The Court sits in benches of varying sizes, as determined by the Registry on the directions of the Chief Justice of India (CJI), who is the Master of the Roster
- The Supreme Court was founded on January 28, 1950, under Article 124 of the Constitution.
- Workforce increased from 8 judges in 1950 to 34 judges in 2019 due to rising caseload.
Way Forward:
- Suggestion to split the Supreme Court into a Final Court of Appeal and a permanent Constitution Bench.
- A Constitution Bench (V. Vasanthkumar v. H.C. Bhatia) analyzing and proposing measures to protect citizens’ access to the Supreme Court.
- Opportunity to address structural gaps by designating appeal benches as regional benches under CJI’s guidance.
Get an IAS/IPS ranker as your 1: 1 personal mentor for UPSC 2024
Attend Now
