Note4Students
From UPSC perspective, the following things are important :
Prelims level: Directorate General of Civil Aviation (DGCA)
Mains level: Implement stringent safety reporting and accountability measures in the Indian aviation industry.
Central Idea:
The article discusses the recent aviation accident at Tokyo’s Haneda airport involving a Japan Airlines (JAL) Airbus A350 and a Japanese Coast Guard Bombardier Dash 8. It highlights the disciplined evacuation and professionalism displayed by JAL’s crew, contrasting it with incidents where passengers’ lack of discipline during emergencies led to safety concerns. The author also points out flaws in training and safety reporting within the Indian aviation industry, focusing on a recent hard landing incident involving an Air India Airbus.
Key Highlights:
- The Tokyo aviation accident as an example of Murphy’s law.
- Disciplined evacuation by JAL crew saved lives.
- Comparison with incidents of passenger indiscipline during emergencies.
- Flaws in reporting and handling safety incidents in Indian aviation.
- The importance of crew training and adherence to safety procedures.
Key Challenges:
- Lack of discipline among passengers during emergencies.
- Flaws in training and safety reporting within the Indian aviation industry.
- History of covering up serious incidents and accidents in Air India.
- Need for proactive action and accountability in the face of safety concerns.
Key Terms:
- Notice to airmen (NOTAM)
- Aviation Safety Adviser
- Directorate General of Civil Aviation (DGCA)
- Simulator proficiency check
- Emergency evacuation procedures
- Hard landing
- Aircraft type conversion
Key Phrases:
- “If there is a possibility of several things going wrong, the one that will cause the most damage will be the one to go wrong.”
- “High professional standards in JAL’s training of its crew.”
- “A disturbing fact is the failure of the Air India management to act proactively.”
- “The hard landing accident at Dubai should serve as a wake-up call for the airline.”
Key Quotes:
- “The world witnessed the highest quality of discipline and crew training.”
- “Many questions will be raised, and we will not have any reasonable answers.”
- “Merely stating that safety is paramount when so many incidents are being swept under the carpet will not improve the reputation of the airline.”
Key Statements:
- The disciplined evacuation from the JAL aircraft showcased the importance of crew training and adherence to safety procedures.
- Flaws in training and safety reporting in the Indian aviation industry, especially in incidents like the hard landing at Dubai, raise concerns about passenger safety.
Key Examples and References:
- Tokyo aviation accident involving JAL Airbus A350 and Coast Guard Dash 8.
- Air France flight AF 358 overshooting runway incident.
- Emirates flight EK 521 crash incident with passenger indiscipline.
- Air India’s history of covering up incidents, including the recent hard landing at Dubai.
- Indian Airlines Airbus crash in Bangalore in 1990 and TAM Airlines Airbus crash in Sao Paulo in 2007.
Key Facts:
- All 379 passengers on the JAL plane in the Tokyo incident escaped, with five fatalities on the smaller aircraft.
- Aircraft manufacturers must demonstrate complete evacuation within 90 seconds in maximum density configuration.
- The hard landing by an Air India Airbus in Dubai involved a 3.5g impact, posing serious risks.
Critical Analysis:
The article critically examines the disciplined response of JAL’s crew in contrast to incidents of passenger indiscipline during emergencies. It sheds light on the flaws in training and safety reporting within the Indian aviation industry, emphasizing the need for accountability and proactive measures. The historical context of accidents caused by confusion in flying different aircraft types is highlighted, urging the industry to focus on standards and crew proficiency.
Way Forward:
- Implement stringent safety reporting and accountability measures in the Indian aviation industry.
- Emphasize crew training and adherence to safety procedures, learning from incidents like the Tokyo aviation accident.
- Ensure transparency in reporting and addressing safety concerns to improve the reputation of airlines.
- Evaluate crew selection criteria for new aircraft types, prioritizing proficiency and experience over seniority.
- Collaborate with international aviation standards to enhance overall safety in the industry.
Get an IAS/IPS ranker as your 1: 1 personal mentor for UPSC 2024
Attend Now
Note4Students
From UPSC perspective, the following things are important :
Prelims level: Jan Vishwas Bill 2023
Mains level: The impact of voice votes, the Anti-Defection Law, and the dismissal of division calls on legislative transparency and accountability
Central Idea:
The article discusses the absence of voting records during the recent Parliament session, highlighting the significance of recorded votes in representing legislators’ stances and fostering transparency in the legislative process. It also explores the impact of the Anti-Defection Law on MPs’ dissent and the increasing use of voice votes, leading to a lack of accountability.
Key Highlights:
- 19 bills were passed in the recent Parliament session, but voting records were not made available.
- The use of voice votes, lacking individual records, is a preferred method for passing legislative motions.
- The Anti-Defection Law has limited MPs’ ability to dissent, reducing the significance of debates and votes.
- The scarcity of voting records hampers Opposition parties in communicating their positions to the electorate.
Key Challenges:
- Lack of transparency due to the absence of voting records.
- The impact of the Anti-Defection Law on MPs’ freedom to dissent.
- Dismissal of division calls during crucial legislative moments.
Key Terms:
- Voice vote
- Anti-Defection Law
- Division call
- Legislative transparency
- Accountability
- Dissent
Key Phrases:
- “A shadow of opacity has fallen over our legislative processes.”
- “The scarcity of voting records can be a symptom of a deeper problem.”
- “The impact of the Anti-Defection Law on MPs’ dissent is a matter of concern.”
Key Quotes:
- “Transparency defines the measure to which our parliamentarians’ political decisions are traceable, which begets accountability.”
- “The right to a division, meant to be readily available, has become shrouded in subjective judgement.”
Key Examples and References:
- The passage of the Jan Vishwas Bill 2023 and the farm bills through voice votes.
- Asaduddin Owaisi’s dissent on various bills, illustrating the importance of voting records.
- Dismissal of division calls during the passage of the Weapons of Mass Destruction Bill and the Electricity Amendment Bill.
Key Facts:
- In Modi I, 40 divisions were raised for 180 bills, while in Modi II, only 20 divisions were allowed for 209 bills.
- Only 15.4% of bills in the BJP’s 10-year tenure have voting records.
Critical Analysis:
The article critically examines the impact of voice votes, the Anti-Defection Law, and the dismissal of division calls on legislative transparency and accountability. It emphasizes the need for voting records to ensure a clear representation of MPs’ stances.
Way Forward:
- Reevaluate the impact of the Anti-Defection Law on MPs’ dissent.
- Ensure the availability of voting records to enhance legislative transparency.
- Address the dismissal of division calls to uphold the right to record votes.
- Promote a more accountable and transparent legislative process through recorded votes.
In essence, the article advocates for the restoration of transparency in the legislative process through the provision of voting records and a reconsideration of the Anti-Defection Law’s impact on MPs’ dissent.
Get an IAS/IPS ranker as your 1: 1 personal mentor for UPSC 2024
Attend Now
Note4Students
From UPSC perspective, the following things are important :
Prelims level: Corbett Tiger Reserve (CTR)
Mains level: Complexity of human-wildlife conflicts
Central Idea:
The article highlights the success of Corbett Tiger Reserve (CTR) in India in managing and conserving its tiger population, emphasizing the importance of a balanced approach involving wildlife protection, community engagement, and ecological sustainability.
Key Highlights:
- CTR, spanning 1288.31 sq.km, has shown significant progress in tiger conservation, recording the highest density of wild tigers globally, from 231 to 260 in four years.
- The richly-forested, highly-biodiverse landscape attracts various enthusiasts and researchers.
- The article acknowledges the unsung heroes among the forest staff and local communities who contribute to the reserve’s ecosystem.
- Grassland and water management practices, strategic wildlife corridors, and addressing human-wildlife conflicts are vital aspects of CTR’s holistic approach.
Key Challenges:
- Human-wildlife conflicts, particularly with tigers and elephants, pose a formidable challenge.
- Ensuring the safety and security of the forest staff, who face risks while patrolling the reserve.
- Balancing the economic dependence of local communities on tiger-related tourism with the risks posed by wild animals.
Key Terms:
- Tiger Conservation Plan
- Core and buffer zones
- Biodiversity
- Grassland management
- Wildlife corridors
- Human-wildlife conflict
- Eco Development Committees (EDCs)
Key Phrases:
- “An unforgettable sight: the dread and danger lurking in the treacherous gaze of a stalking tiger.”
- “A delicate balance of forest flora and fauna is crucial for a healthy forest ecology.”
- “The rising incidence of human-elephant and tiger-human conflict poses a formidable challenge.”
- “Living with Tigers initiative aims at creating awareness and behavioral changes among local communities.”
Key Quotes:
- “A glimpse of the peerless king of the jungle in all his majesty is truly captivating.”
- “The only way ahead is by enjoining forest conservation upon all local stakeholders.”
- “The revival of the tiger since 1973 has meant a cultural renaissance and revival of our conservation ethics and values.”
Key Examples and References:
- The success of the beehive-fencing project to guard crops against wild elephants.
- The “Living with Tigers” initiative promoting awareness and behavioral changes among school children and villagers.
- The economic dependence of Ramnagar district on tiger-related tourism.
Key Facts:
- CTR covers 1288.31 sq.km and recorded 260 tigers in 2022.
- 27 different kinds of grasslands are present at CTR.
- The beehive-fencing project resulted in the creation of “Corbee Honey,” managed by local Eco Development Committees.
Critical Analysis:
The article acknowledges the complexity of human-wildlife conflicts as “wicked problems,” requiring unique solutions. It emphasizes the need for a collaborative, engaging, and socio-culturally-sensitive approach in addressing conservation challenges.
Way Forward:
- Continue efforts to balance economic benefits of tiger-related tourism with wildlife conservation.
- Scale up successful initiatives like the beehive-fencing project and “Living with Tigers” awareness program.
- Strengthen community engagement for long-term conservation efforts.
- Promote sustainable practices for wildlife protection, grassland management, and water conservation.
In essence, the article underscores the success of CTR in tiger conservation and the imperative of a comprehensive approach involving ecological sustainability, community engagement, and innovative solutions to address ongoing challenges.
Get an IAS/IPS ranker as your 1: 1 personal mentor for UPSC 2024
Attend Now
Note4Students
From UPSC perspective, the following things are important :
Prelims level: Na
Mains level: critical examination of the challenges in the current education system
Central Idea:
The article discusses the challenges and inadequacies in the current examination systems of educational institutions in India. It emphasizes the need for transparency, oversight, and credibility in assessments to ensure that degrees and certificates truly reflect students’ learning achievements.
Key Highlights:
- Credibility of the examination system is crucial for maintaining educational standards.
- Decentralized systems in India with numerous universities and boards face challenges in maintaining transparency and standardization.
- The article criticizes the focus on memory-based testing, inflation of marks, and a lack of emphasis on higher-order thinking skills.
- Employers often rely on their own assessments rather than institutional certifications.
- The article suggests the use of technology, external audits, and adherence to minimum standards to improve assessment processes.
Key Challenges:
- Lack of transparency and oversight in examination processes.
- Inconsistency and inadequacies in syllabi and teaching methods.
- Confidentiality leading to malpractices and scandals in examinations.
- The need for balancing autonomy with proper oversight in educational institutions.
- Negligence, fraud, and quality issues in assessment processes.
Key Terms:
- Decentralized system
- Transparency
- Oversight
- Standardization
- Higher-order thinking
- Autonomy
- External audit
- Credibility
- Minimum standards
- Technology in assessment
Key Phrases:
- “Credibility of assessment and standard of education can be ensured only through transparency in teaching and assessment.”
- “Inconsistency of the examination system is cause for concern.”
- “Confidentiality is also a cause for scandals in examinations.”
- “Transparency and proper oversight take lead roles in the examination systems.”
Key Quotes:
- “A credible examination system is one of the key ways to improve the standard of education.”
- “The employability of a graduate depends on higher order learning, while examination boards do not certify students on those skills.”
- “The higher education regulator truly believes in decentralization through autonomous institutions without oversight.”
Key Examples and References:
- Instances of question papers with language errors, conceptualization issues, and irrelevant questions.
- Employers disregarding institutional certifications in favor of their own assessments.
- The coaching market for competitive examinations and skilling due to a lack of faith in institutional certifications.
Key Facts:
- India has over 1,100 universities, 50,000 affiliated colleges, and 60 school boards.
- Total enrollment in higher education is 40.15 million students.
- Employers conduct rigorous assessments of candidates’ academic achievements and suitability for employment.
Critical Analysis:
The article provides a critical examination of the challenges in the current education system, emphasizing the need for transparency, oversight, and credibility. It highlights the disconnect between institutional certifications and actual learning outcomes, calling for a shift towards higher-order thinking skills.
Way Forward:
- Emphasize transparency in teaching and assessment processes.
- Implement external audits of assessment systems to ensure reliability and consistency.
- Balance autonomy with proper oversight in educational institutions.
- Use technology to standardize question paper setting and evaluation processes.
- Codify and address issues of negligence, fraud, and academic inadequacies in assessments.
- Release audit reports regularly to assess examination boards in terms of transparency, reliability, and consistency.
Get an IAS/IPS ranker as your 1: 1 personal mentor for UPSC 2024
Attend Now
Note4Students
From UPSC perspective, the following things are important :
Prelims level: Lethal autonomous weapons systems
Mains level: Rise of "digital sovereignty"
Central Idea:
- The global landscape witnesses a complex interplay of power dynamics in AI and frontier technologies. Efforts by international bodies like the United Nations set ethical frameworks for responsible AI development.
Key Highlights:
- UN initiatives on AI governance and ethical principles.
- Rise of “digital sovereignty” challenging traditional notions of territorial sovereignty.
- Emergence of contrasting “digital empires,” with the US favoring a free market approach and China leaning towards state-driven regulation.
- Concerns about China’s regulatory model spreading globally due to its technological success and political control.
- The EU advocating for a human rights-based approach to AI development.
Key Challenges:
- Threats to privacy and democracy due to the manipulation of personal information by AI tools.
- Tension between the free market approach and authoritarian regulatory models.
- Potential dominance of China’s oppressive regulatory model in the global AI landscape.
Key Terms:
- Digital sovereignty
- Techno-optimism
- Authoritarian regulatory model
- Surveillance capitalism
- Lethal autonomous weapons systems (LAWs)
Key Phrases:
- “Digital sovereignty” transforming territorial sovereignty.
- “Digital empires” in complicity and collision.
- “Techno-optimism run wild” leading to an appeal for authoritarian regulatory reach.
- “Surveillance capitalism” and “digital authoritarianism” shaping the uncertain future of the technopolitical.
Key Quotes:
- “Privacy, anonymity, and autonomy remain the main casualties of AI’s ability to manipulate choices.”
- “China’s regulatory model will prevail, normatively and descriptively.”
- “Whether surveillance capitalism, digital authoritarianism, or liberal democratic values will prevail remains uncertain.”
Key Examples and References:
- UNICEF hosting a joint session on AI governance.
- The US and China as contrasting digital empires.
- EU Declaration on Development advocating a human rights-based approach.
Key Facts:
- Social media industry growth from $193.52 billion in 2001 to $231.1 billion in 2023.
- Concerns about the impact of China’s technological success combined with political control on global AI governance.
Way Forward:
- Continued efforts to humanize AI applications in civil and military contexts.
- Global collaboration to establish norms and frameworks for responsible AI development.
- Vigilance against the potential spread of oppressive regulatory models, emphasizing human rights and inclusivity.
Get an IAS/IPS ranker as your 1: 1 personal mentor for UPSC 2024
Attend Now
Note4Students
From UPSC perspective, the following things are important :
Prelims level: 74th Constitutional Amendment
Mains level: The Kerala Urban Commission
Central Idea:
- The article discusses the formation of the Kerala Urban Commission in the context of global urbanization trends and the need for a comprehensive approach to urban development.
- It highlights the challenges faced by urban areas in India and emphasizes the significance of revisiting and re-evaluating urban policies.
Key Highlights:
- The article reflects on the historical development phases of urbanization in post-independent India, noting the failures of both Nehruvian centralized planning and the subsequent privatization trends in the 1990s.
- It underscores the necessity of understanding objective patterns of urbanization, focusing on migration, settlement patterns, and the role of information technology.
- Governance issues in cities, such as delayed transfer of subjects to municipalities and the debate on having managers instead of elected officials, are highlighted.
- The article suggests that existing urban missions, like Swachh Bharat and Smart Cities, have failed to produce desired results and may continue to do so.
Key Challenges:
- Piecemeal approaches to urban development are criticized for their failure to address the complex realities of urbanization.
- Governance issues, including the delay in transferring subjects to municipalities and the debate on city affairs management, pose challenges to effective urban governance.
- The article suggests that existing urban missions, like Swachh Bharat and Smart Cities, have failed to produce desired results and may continue to do so.
Key Terms:
- Urban Commission: Refers to the proposed or existing bodies tasked with addressing the challenges and complexities of urban development.
- Urbanization: The process of population migration from rural to urban areas, leading to the growth and development of cities.
- Nehruvian Period: Refers to the development era influenced by Jawaharlal Nehru’s centralized planning approach.
- Privatization: The transfer of control or ownership of public services or assets to private entities.
- Fifteenth Finance Commission: A reference to the commission responsible for recommending the distribution of financial resources between the central and state governments.
Key Phrases:
- “Holistic city approach”: Refers to a comprehensive and integrated strategy for urban development.
- “Engines of growth”: Describes the shift in cities’ perception from spaces of enlightenment to centers focused on economic development.
- “Mission mode of development”: Refers to project-oriented approaches like the Jawaharlal Nehru National Urban Renewal Mission and Smart Cities Mission.
- “Complex processes unfolding”: Highlights the intricate nature of governance and financial structures in urban areas.
Key Quotes:
- “Cities were made competitive and termed as ‘engines of growth’ — not spaces of enlightenment, future of dreams, and habitat.”
- “The urbanisation process cannot be reduced to some mission approaches…”
- “Kerala Urban Commission can be the lighthouse for other States…”
Key Statements:
- “An urban commission is required at the national and State levels to understand some of the interesting objective patterns of urbanisation.”
- “The period of the 1990s is the one where the abject privatization of cities began…”
Key Examples and References:
- Mention of the National Commission on Urbanisation formed by Rajiv Gandhi and its recommendations.
- Reference to global urbanization trends, including the impact on climate change and unequal city spaces.
- Examples of failed urban missions like Swachh Bharat and Smart Cities.
Key Facts:
- More than half of the world’s population (56%) currently lives in cities.
- Kerala’s urbanized population is estimated to be around 90%.
- The Nehruvian period witnessed the construction of around 150 new towns with a centralized planning approach.
Key Data:
- The 74th Constitutional Amendment marked a shift towards more private initiative and investment in urban development.
- The Kerala Urban Commission has a 12-month mandate to address urbanization challenges and lay a roadmap for 25 years of urban development.
Critical Analysis:
- The article critically examines the historical phases of urban development in India and highlights the shortcomings of past approaches.
- It questions the effectiveness of existing urban missions and emphasizes the need for a holistic understanding of urbanization processes.
- Governance issues and financial centralization are critically discussed as impediments to successful urban development.
Way Forward:
- The article suggests that the formation of the Kerala Urban Commission could serve as a model for other highly urbanized states.
- It advocates for a comprehensive and objective approach to urban development, emphasizing the importance of addressing challenges such as migration, settlement patterns, and information technology.
- The need for revisiting and relooking at urban policies is underscored for a more successful and sustainable urban future.
Get an IAS/IPS ranker as your 1: 1 personal mentor for UPSC 2024
Attend Now
Note4Students
From UPSC perspective, the following things are important :
Prelims level: Foreign Contribution Regulation Act
Mains level: state's tactics to limit civic space, affecting organizations fighting against communalism
Central Idea:
- The article discusses the threats faced by India’s civic space, particularly organizations fighting against communalism. Emphasizes the importance of protecting constitutional freedoms.
Key Highlights:
- Constitutional freedoms are under siege in India’s diverse and vibrant civil society.
- Organizations actively fighting communalism are facing severe attacks, affecting their funding and leadership.
- The state employs various instruments, including legal charges, amendments to laws, and tax-related measures, to curb civic space.
- Impact is significant on organizations supporting minority, Dalit, Adivasi rights, and equity promotion.
Key Challenges:
- High-intensity attacks leading to financial constraints and imprisonment for leaders of certain NGOs.
- Shrinking civic space even for neutral or non-communal organizations.
- Utilization of legal instruments like money laundering charges and investigations to intimidate NGOs.
- Amendments to laws, such as the FCRA, restricting access to foreign funds for NGOs.
- Intimidation of domestic donors through tax-related provisions.
Key Terms/Phrases:
- Civic space
- Constitutional freedoms
- Anti-communal
- NGOs (Non-Governmental Organizations)
- FCRA (Foreign Contribution Regulation Act)
- Money laundering charges
- Civic mobilization
- Secularism
- Adivasi rights
- Human rights causes
Key Quotes/Statements:
- “The last bastion and ray of hope for India’s democracy is its civic space.”
- “The scale of attack on organizations actively fighting against communalism is alarming.”
- “The state employs a range of instruments to limit the civic space of various organizations.”
Key Examples and References:
- Amnesty International, Centre for Equity Studies, Citizens for Justice and Peace, among others, facing severe attacks.
- Greenpeace transitioning from high-intensity attacks to a lower level.
Key Facts/Data:
- Amendments to the FCRA in 2010 and 2020 impacted around 18,000 NGOs between 2015 and 2022.
- The 2020 amendments to the Income-Tax Act make renewals of NGO certificates mandatory every five years.
- The Central Bureau of Investigation (CBI) is empowered to investigate NGOs under the FCRA.
Critical Analysis:
- The article presents a critical analysis of the state’s tactics to limit civic space, affecting organizations fighting against communalism.
- It highlights the severity of attacks and the broader impact on democratic values.
Way Forward:
- Strengthening opposition and regional leaders who take a clear secular position.
- Mobilizing anti-communal and progressive civic space to safeguard democracy.
- Advocating for the protection of constitutional freedoms and reviewing stringent laws impacting NGOs.
- Raising awareness about the importance of civic space in preserving India’s democracy.
Get an IAS/IPS ranker as your 1: 1 personal mentor for UPSC 2024
Attend Now
Note4Students
From UPSC perspective, the following things are important :
Prelims level: The World Health Organization's report on global disparities in blood collection.
Mains level: public-private partnerships to improve blood collection and distribution
Get an IAS/IPS ranker as your 1: 1 personal mentor for UPSC 2024
Attend Now
Note4Students
From UPSC perspective, the following things are important :
Prelims level: Section 132 of the Income Tax Act
Mains level: I-T searches, a form of extra-constitutional power
Central Idea:
The article critiques the persistent judicial deference in interpreting statutes related to privacy rights in India, despite a significant Supreme Court decision in 2017. It focuses on the unchecked power granted to tax authorities under Section 132 of the Income Tax Act, highlighting the need for proportionality and stricter judicial review in executive actions.
Key Highlights:
- The 2017 Supreme Court decision affirmed the fundamental right to privacy but hasn’t significantly impacted the interpretation of related statutes.
- Section 132 of the Income Tax Act grants broad powers to tax authorities, allowing searches without judicial warrants.
- Recent incidents, like a lawyer’s raid, raise concerns about the abuse of these powers and the lack of safeguards.
Key Challenges:
- The persistence of a culture of judicial deference to executive authority in interpreting statutes.
- The broad and unchecked powers granted to tax authorities under Section 132 of the Income Tax Act.
- Lack of proportionality and strict judicial review in executive actions, risking potential abuse of power.
Key Terms:
- Judicial Deference
- Section 132 of the Income Tax Act
- Proportionality
- Fundamental Right to Privacy
- Executive Authority
Key Phrases:
- “Culture of justification”
- “Judicial Deference”
- “Doctrine of proportionality”
- “Wednesbury rule”
Key Quotes:
- “The promised culture of justification is rarely on show, replaced by a culture of judicial deference.”
- “Search and seizure powers must adhere to the doctrine of proportionality, ensuring a balance between means and violated rights.”
Key Examples and References:
- The Gujarat High Court questioning income-tax authorities on a lawyer’s raid.
- The evolution of income-tax laws, especially the 1961 legislation and the subsequent Supreme Court cases.
Key Statements:
- “Post-Puttaswamy, there ought to be no place for the Wednesbury rule, especially when fundamental rights are at stake.”
- “The state’s power to search and seize must be subject to the doctrine of proportionality.”
Critical Analysis:
The article critically examines the inconsistency in judicial interpretation post the Puttaswamy case, emphasizing the need for a more stringent review of executive actions, particularly in cases involving privacy rights. It questions the application of the Wednesbury rule and advocates for a proportional and justifiable approach.
Way Forward:
- Advocate for a reevaluation of Section 132 of the Income Tax Act in light of the Puttaswamy judgment.
- Emphasize the importance of proportionality and judicial scrutiny in executive actions, especially those involving fundamental rights.
- Call for a more comprehensive and balanced approach to interpreting statutes, ensuring protection against arbitrary executive excesses.
Get an IAS/IPS ranker as your 1: 1 personal mentor for UPSC 2024
Attend Now
Note4Students
From UPSC perspective, the following things are important :
Prelims level: FRBMA
Mains level: adhering to fiscal correction paths
Get an IAS/IPS ranker as your 1: 1 personal mentor for UPSC 2024
Attend Now
Note4Students
From UPSC perspective, the following things are important :
Prelims level: Collegium system
Mains level: backlog of cases, appointment of judges based on perceived proximity to political power
![Burning Issue] Judiciary in Times of COVID-19 Outbreak - Civilsdaily](https://d18x2uyjeekruj.cloudfront.net/wp-content/uploads/2020/05/jud-300x188.jpg)
Central Idea:
The author highlights the challenges faced by the Indian judiciary, emphasizing the need for unbiased judges and a political system that separates religion from politics. The use of religious sentiments for divisive purposes is criticized, calling for a transparent and merit-based judicial appointment system.
Key Highlights:
- Judicial challenges in handling a growing population and increasing litigations.
- Delayed justice in the Supreme Court, impacting the relevance of decisions.
- Concerns about the quality of judges and perceived ideological alignments in appointments.
- Critique of the current collegium system and its lack of transparency.
Key Challenges:
- Overburdened judiciary with a rising number of cases.
- Delayed justice affecting the effectiveness of legal decisions.
- Perceived ideological biases in judicial appointments.
- Lack of a transparent and merit-oriented system for judge selection.
Key Terms:
- Collegium System: The system of appointing judges through a committee of senior judges.
- Ideological Alignment: Alleged connections between judges and specific political or religious ideologies.
- Judicial Hierarchy: The levels of the judicial system, with the Supreme Court being the highest.
Key Phrases:
- “Bedevilled with challenges”: Describing the complex issues faced by the judiciary.
- “Divide and rule”: Criticizing the use of religious emotions for political manipulation.
- “Seminal issues”: Highlighting the critical issues decided by the Supreme Court.
Key Quotes:
- “India needs judges who deliver justice unconcerned with majoritarian sentiments.”
- “The collegium system has failed us.”
- “For the judiciary to regain its glory, it needs to do more than just decide on cases.”
Key Examples and References:
- Reference to the Chief Justice addressing dormant cases but acknowledging the urgency needed.
- Critique of the appointment of judges based on perceived proximity to political power.
Key Facts and Data:
- Increase in litigants seeking justice due to a burgeoning population.
- Delayed hearings and decisions in the Supreme Court.
- Issues with the current system of appointing judges.
Critical Analysis:
The author criticizes the judiciary’s current state, highlighting issues of delayed justice, ideological biases, and the failure of the collegium system. Emphasis is placed on the need for transparency and merit in the appointment process.
Way Forward:
- Reforming the judicial appointment process to ensure transparency and meritocracy.
- Addressing the backlog of cases to expedite justice delivery.
- Advocating for a political system that separates religion from politics to avoid divisive agendas.
Get an IAS/IPS ranker as your 1: 1 personal mentor for UPSC 2024
Attend Now
Note4Students
From UPSC perspective, the following things are important :
Prelims level: Article 155
Mains level: conduct of Governors in Opposition-ruled States
Central Idea:
The conduct of Governors in Opposition-ruled States, exemplified by the recent actions of Kerala’s Governor, raises concerns about adherence to constitutional morality, necessitating a reevaluation of their roles and legal consequences.
Key Highlights:
- Kerala’s Governor, Arif Mohammed Khan, faced criticism for instructing the removal of posters and accusing the Chief Minister of supporting activists against him.
- Breaches of protocol, such as an unannounced tour of Kozhikode, added to the growing trend of Governors’ controversial actions.
- While the Constitution outlines functions, powers, and duties of Governors, the concept of constitutional morality should guide their public behavior.
- Reference to NCT of Delhi v. Union of India highlights the responsibility of individuals occupying constitutional offices.
- Article 361 provides limited immunity for Governors, exempting them from court scrutiny for official acts.
- Rameshwar Prasad v. Union of India establishes judicial review for cases of Governor’s motivated and whimsical conduct, suggesting accountability.
- Kaushal Kishor v. State of Uttar Pradesh clarifies that public functionaries’ freedom of expression is subject to reasonable restrictions.
- Ministers can be held personally liable for statements inconsistent with government views, emphasizing personal responsibility.
- Sarkaria Commission Report (1988) criticized Governors for lacking impartiality and becoming agents of the Union, emphasizing the need for detachment.
- Justice M.M. Punchhi Commission (2010) recommended restricting Governors from roles not envisaged by the Constitution, citing potential controversies.
Key Challenges:
- Governors’ failure to display impartiality and sagacity, engaging in local politics and controversies.
- Lack of adherence to recommendations for detached roles and limitations on Governors’ powers.
Key Terms and Phrases:
- Constitutional morality
- Limited immunity (Article 361)
- Judicial review
- Chancellorship of universities
- Sarkaria Commission
- Punchhi Commission
- Democratic legitimacy
- Raj Bhavans
Key Quotes:
- “Constitutional morality places responsibilities and duties on individuals who occupy constitutional institutions and offices.” – NCT of Delhi v. Union of India (2018)
- “Some Governors have failed to display the qualities of impartiality and sagacity expected of them.” – Sarkaria Commission Report (1988)
- “The Governor should be a detached figure and not too intimately connected with the local politics of the State.” – Justice M.M. Punchhi Commission report (2010)
Key Statements:
- Judicial review possible for Governor’s misbehavior unconnected with official duty.
- Sarkaria and Punchhi Commission reports emphasize the need for Governors’ impartiality and limited involvement in local politics.
- Kerala Assembly’s attempt to abolish Governor’s chancellorship raises concerns about democratic legitimacy.
Critical Analysis:
- The Governor’s actions in Kerala highlight a deviation from democratic norms and raise questions about the democratic legitimacy of gubernatorial decisions.
- Commission reports expose longstanding issues with Governor appointments and their roles, calling for systemic changes.
Way Forward:
- Future regimes should consider amending Article 155 to ensure Chief Minister consultation in Governor appointments, addressing recommendations from the Sarkaria report.
- Establishment of an independent body for Governor selection, with input from the Chief Justice of India, may enhance the quality of the selection process.
- Legal prohibitions against Governors’ further rehabilitation in official capacities could contribute to improving the functioning of Raj Bhavans.
Get an IAS/IPS ranker as your 1: 1 personal mentor for UPSC 2024
Attend Now
Note4Students
From UPSC perspective, the following things are important :
Prelims level: POLIX’s beryllium disc
Mains level: detection of lower-energy X-rays
Central idea
Key Highlights:
- ISRO successfully launched XPoSat, an X-ray Polarimeter Satellite, on New Year’s Day in 2024.
- The indigenous instrument, POLIX, built at Raman Research Institute, is a crucial step for Indian astronomers.
- POLIX aims to study X-ray polarization, providing insights into celestial magnetic fields.
Key Challenges:
- Collecting X-rays from space is challenging due to their high energy, making traditional focusing methods impossible.
- Earth’s atmosphere absorbs most X-rays, complicating the study of cosmic X-rays.
Key Terms and Phrases:
- XPoSat: X-ray Polarimeter Satellite.
- POLIX: Indian X-ray Polarimeter.
- Pulsars: Exotic stars emitting X-rays with strong magnetic fields.
- IXPE: NASA’s X-ray Polarimeter Explorer.
- XSPECT: Instrument on XPoSat for studying timing and spectral properties.
Key Quotes:
- “The instrument, totally indigenous in design and fabrication, will herald yet another milestone for Indian astronomers.”
- “Measuring the polarisation of X-rays would enable astronomers to gauge the directions of magnetic fields in celestial objects.”
Key Statements:
- POLIX, a cubical cylinder with a beryllium disc, detects X-rays and works on the principle of polarization after scattering.
- XPoSat, complementing NASA’s IXPE, will provide valuable information about pulsars and black holes.
Key Examples and References:
- Pulsars, city-sized stars with immense mass, often shine in X-rays and have powerful magnetic fields.
- POLIX’s beryllium disc allows the probing of lower energy X-rays compared to NASA’s instrument.
Key Facts and Data:
- POLIX measures roughly half a meter and weighs nearly 200 kilograms.
- XPoSat focuses on studying the timing and spectral properties of X-ray-emitting objects.
Critical Analysis:
- POLIX’s unique design using beryllium enhances the detection of lower-energy X-rays, providing a significant advantage.
- The launch of XPoSat signifies a major advancement in Indian X-ray astronomy, offering a valuable complement to NASA’s efforts.
Way Forward:
- Anticipation surrounds XPoSat’s data collection, expected to deepen our understanding of pulsars and black holes.
- Ongoing collaboration and advancements in X-ray astronomy will likely lead to further discoveries.
Get an IAS/IPS ranker as your 1: 1 personal mentor for UPSC 2024
Attend Now
Note4Students
From UPSC perspective, the following things are important :
Prelims level: Employees’ Provident Fund Organisation
Mains level: revisiting the pension computation methodology
Central idea
The EPFO’s recent clarification on the 2022 Supreme Court verdict regarding higher PF pension has sparked concerns among pensioners due to ambiguity in pension computation methods. Challenges include discrepancies for pre-2014 and post-2014 retirees, with a demand for increased minimum monthly pension.
Key Highlights:
- The EPFO’s clarification on the 2022 Supreme Court verdict on higher PF pension has raised concerns among pensioners and PF members.
- The Court approved higher pension payments with certain conditions, including amendments to the pensionable salary cap and contribution rules.
- The clarification introduces ambiguity by tying pension computation to the “date of commencement of pension.”
Key Challenges:
- Pre-2014 retirees choosing pension post-amendments receive lower pensions due to the calculation based on the average pay of 60 months.
- Post-2014 retirees face ambiguity and discrepancies in the revised pension amounts, seeking clarity through a worksheet.
- Lack of incorporation of interest rate component in pension calculations.
- Long-standing demand to increase the minimum monthly pension beyond ₹1,000, with calls for linking it to the cost of living index.
Key Terms:
- EPFO: Employees’ Provident Fund Organisation
- EPS: Employees’ Pension Scheme
- Pensionable salary cap: ₹15,000/month
- Amendments (2014): Raised pensionable salary cap, altered contribution rules, and changed computation basis.
- Date of commencement of pension: Controversial factor in pension calculation.
Key Quotes:
- “There is also a demand for incorporating the component of interest rate… the pension amount would at least see a rise of ₹2,300 per month.” – MP M. Shanmugam
- “The government’s contributions should increase… to achieve a durable social security system for contributors to the economy.”
Key Statements:
- The clarification’s reliance on the “date of commencement of pension” has created confusion and dissatisfaction among pensioners.
- Ambiguity in post-2014 retirees’ pension calculations prompts the need for a clearer worksheet.
Way Forward:
- Address concerns by revisiting the pension computation methodology.
- Consider increasing the minimum monthly pension, as demanded by various stakeholders.
- Enhance government contributions to ensure a robust social security system.
- Provide clear guidelines and a comprehensive worksheet for post-2014 retirees to understand and verify their pension calculations.
Get an IAS/IPS ranker as your 1: 1 personal mentor for UPSC 2024
Attend Now
Note4Students
From UPSC perspective, the following things are important :
Prelims level: COVID-19 subvariants
Mains level: Continuous tracking of virus variants is challenging due to the unpredictable nature of genetic changes.
Central idea
Dr. Chandrakant Lahariya discusses the emergence of the JN.1 sub-variant of SARS-CoV-2, highlighting its classification as a Variant of Interest (VoI). He emphasizes the need for ongoing genomic sequencing and data tracking while reassuring that, as of now, there’s no evidence of increased severity or immune escape. The central idea is to approach COVID-19 like any respiratory illness, maintaining standard preventive measures and avoiding unnecessary concerns.
Key Highlights:
- Dr. Chandrakant Lahariya, a medical doctor with extensive WHO experience, addresses the emergence of the JN.1 sub-variant of the Omicron variant of SARS-CoV-2.
- Over 1,000 subvariants have been reported since the novel coronavirus outbreak in 2019.
- The designation of JN.1 as a Variant of Interest (VoI) prompts increased genomic sequencing for monitoring.
Key Challenges:
- Continuous tracking of virus variants is challenging due to the unpredictable nature of genetic changes.
- Distinguishing between inconsequential and significant genetic alterations requires careful assessment by international agencies and experts.
Key Terms:
- SARS-CoV-2: Severe Acute Respiratory Syndrome Coronavirus-2.
- VoI: Variant of Interest.
- VoC: Variant of Concern.
- Hybrid Immunity: Combined immunity from natural infection and vaccination.
Key Phrases:
- “Silent wave”: JN.1 circulated without causing a significant increase in reported or clinical cases.
- “Genetic material changes”: Variants and subvariants result from alterations in the virus’s genetic structure.
Key Quotes:
- “Designating a variant as VoI does not automatically mean there is a reason to worry.”
- “JN.1 is not a new virus but a sub-variant of BA.2.86, itself a subvariant of Omicron.”
- “There is no scientific evidence to support having a fourth shot of COVID-19 vaccines.”
Key Statements:
- WHO declared the end of the COVID-19 pandemic in May 2023 but emphasized the need for ongoing virus and variant tracking.
- JN.1, as a VoI, requires heightened genomic sequencing and data tracking but doesn’t indicate an immediate cause for concern.
Key Examples and References:
- JN.1 is a subvariant of BA.2.86, part of the Omicron variant of SARS-CoV-2.
- Waste-water surveillance in some Indian cities suggested JN.1 circulated widely without a significant increase in reported cases.
Key Facts:
- Since 2019, more than 1,000 subvariants and recombinant sub-lineages of SARS-CoV-2 have been reported.
- Immunologically, current evidence supports continued protection from COVID-19 vaccines against subvariants.
Key Data:
- Average daily deaths due to respiratory diseases and tuberculosis in India are 50 to 60 times higher than COVID-19 deaths.
Critical Analysis:
- Dr. Lahariya emphasizes the need for nuanced government responses, responsible citizen behavior, and clear science communication.
- The spike in COVID-19 cases may be due to increased testing, and deaths attributed to COVID-19 might be incidental in already sick individuals.
Way Forward:
- Handle SARS-CoV-2 like any other respiratory illness, focusing on standard public health measures.
- Individual and community levels should maintain routine activities, and school closure should not be considered in response to a COVID-19 case surge.
- Continuous surveillance, waste-water monitoring, and improved health facility services are essential for effective response.
Get an IAS/IPS ranker as your 1: 1 personal mentor for UPSC 2024
Attend Now
Note4Students
From UPSC perspective, the following things are important :
Prelims level: na
Mains level: PM Modi’s guarantees vs Rahul Gandhi’s promises
Central idea
Modi’s consolidation of leadership within the BJP presents a challenge to the party’s collective strength. The INDIA alliance struggles to form a united front, lacking a clear leader and shared ideology. Effective communication of Modi’s guarantees, coupled with voter perception of achievements, strengthens his political standing despite opposition attempts.
Key Highlights:
- Narendra Modi’s political dominance within the BJP, sidelining other leaders and making himself the primary focus for voters.
- Modi’s personal guarantees, particularly the promise of a Ram Temple in Ayodhya, shaping the party’s campaign narrative.
- Rahul Gandhi’s emphasis on ideology and the Congress Party’s goal of empowering the common man.
- Voter perception of Modi’s leadership, influenced by achievements such as the G20 meeting and the abrogation of Article 370.
- Challenges faced by the INDIA alliance in forming a cohesive narrative, lacking a clear leader and shared ideology.
Key Challenges:
- Modi’s overwhelming influence within the BJP, potentially sidelining the party’s collective strength.
- The INDIA alliance struggling to present a united front with a shared ideology and leadership.
- The challenge of convincing voters that getting rid of Modi is a crucial political goal.
- Weak response from the alliance to Modi’s guarantees, particularly Rahul Gandhi’s promise of a caste census.
Key Terms:
- Modi’s guarantees
- Ram Temple in Ayodhya
- INDIA alliance
- G20 meeting
- Abrogation of Article 370
- Ideology
- Caste census
Key Phrases:
- “Modi ki guarantee hai” (Modi’s guarantee)
- “Fight for ideology” – Rahul Gandhi’s perspective on the Congress Party’s goal.
- “Destroying democracy” – Alleged reason for getting rid of Modi.
- “Solid than the INDIA alliance” – Describing the stability of BJP and RSS compared to the alliance.
Key Quotes:
- “The foundation of the battle for political power is ideology, and the Congress’s objective is to hand over power to the common man.” – Rahul Gandhi.
Anecdotes:
- Modi’s choice of relatively unknown individuals as chief ministers after sidelining powerful leaders during elections.
- Details of Modi’s inspection tour of the Ram Temple, including the use of a gold coin in a ritual.
Key Statements:
- “Nowadays, when I ask the average voter who he will vote for in next year’s general election, the answer is: Modi.”
- “Rahul Gandhi was speaking at a public rally to commemorate the 139th founding day of the Congress Party and explained his ideology.”
- “The only thing that all the twenty-eight parties in the alliance appear to agree on is that they have a mission to get rid of Modi.”
Key Examples and References:
- Modi’s achievements, such as the G20 meeting and the abrogation of Article 370, influencing voter perception.
- Weak response from the alliance, including promises like Rahul Gandhi’s caste census, compared to Modi’s guarantees.
Key Facts and Data:
- Modi’s success in making himself the central figure for voters in recent months.
- Voter approval of Modi’s leadership based on achievements and promises.
Critical Analysis:
- Examines the shift in BJP dynamics towards Modi’s singular leadership.
- Highlights the contrast between Modi’s effective communication of guarantees and the alliance’s struggle to present a cohesive narrative.
- Addresses the challenge of convincing voters that getting rid of Modi is crucial and the weak response from the alliance.
Way Forward:
- The BJP may need to balance Modi’s leadership with the strength of the party as a whole.
- The INDIA alliance needs a more cohesive narrative, a clear leader, and a shared ideology to present a formidable challenge.
- Emphasizes the importance of effectively countering Modi’s guarantees and presenting a compelling alternative to voters.
Get an IAS/IPS ranker as your 1: 1 personal mentor for UPSC 2024
Attend Now
Note4Students
From UPSC perspective, the following things are important :
Prelims level: K-shaped recovery
Mains level: importance of looking beyond personal interests and extending kindness to others.
Central idea
The central idea is to prioritize wishing a “Good New Year” over a simple greeting, emphasizing the connection between goodness, happiness, and knowledge. The message underscores the importance of understanding and kindness towards oneself and others, advocating for a collective effort to bridge societal divides and extend compassion in the face of challenges. The call is to make being good a priority, fostering a sense of duty, compassion, and reason in various aspects of life for a positive and inclusive new year.
Key Highlights:
- Emphasizes the importance of wishing a “Good New Year” over a simple “Happy New Year.”
- Connects goodness with happiness and knowledge.
- Urges understanding and kindness towards ourselves and others.
- Quotes Mahatma Gandhi on the importance of collective independence for fostering togetherness.
- Highlights instances of goodness during the Covid-19 pandemic, such as frontline workers and vaccine distribution.
- Stresses the need for harmony across societal divides like caste, class, and religion.
- Raises questions about the inclusion of the poor, disenfranchised, and marginalized in the new year.
Key Challenges:
- The challenge of deepening compassion in a divisive election year.
- The impact of political affiliations on personal identity.
- The difficulty of being good in a profit-driven and outcome-focused society.
- The masking of true selves through sophisticated tools and filters.
Key Terms:
- Good New Year
- Collective independence
- Harmony between reason, spirit, and appetite
- K-shaped recovery
- Compassion
Key Phrases:
- “Goodness, not newness, is happiness.”
- “Being good forces us to look beyond our inner orbit.”
- “Being good, like being a parent or a citizen, can never be the exclusive preserve of one party.”
- “In an age of me, myself and I.”
- “The most authentic version of ourselves is the one we see in the mirror when no one’s looking.”
Key Quotes:
- “A year which can enhance goodness is one in which we work a little harder to understand ourselves and those who are not like us.”
- “Kindness is being human.”
- “Our voting preference is not what makes us human — it’s our being good, our being kind that matters.”
Anecdotes:
- Mention of unsung frontline workers during the Covid-19 pandemic.
- Reference to the distribution of vaccines to countries without access.
- Reflection on moments when the nation acted as a good collective during the pandemic.
Key Statements:
- “A good new year asks us to protect the happiness of all.”
- “Being good, like being a parent or a citizen, can never be the exclusive preserve of one party.”
- “Our loved ones will be safe, they can take us for granted as a good new year means we look at those beyond them.”
Key Examples and References:
- Plato’s concept of a good life requiring harmony between reason, spirit, and appetite.
- Mahatma Gandhi’s call for a common declaration of independence by whole communities.
- Examples of individuals and nations displaying goodness during the Covid-19 pandemic.
Key Facts and Data:
- Mention of senior citizens and vulnerable populations prioritized for vaccination.
- Reference to the first to be vaccinated being chosen based on vulnerability rather than financial capability.
- Noting the challenges faced by various groups, such as students, executives, and families during the pandemic.
Critical Analysis:
- Highlights the importance of looking beyond personal interests and extending kindness to others.
- Raises awareness about societal divides and the need for collective efforts for a good new year.
- Acknowledges the challenges of maintaining goodness in a society driven by profit and outcomes.
- Encourages self-reflection on true values and identity beyond external influences.
Way Forward:
- Advocate for a continued focus on goodness and compassion beyond the initial days of the new year.
- Emphasize the importance of unity and togetherness in addressing societal challenges.
- Encourage individuals to prioritize being good in various roles, such as parents, citizens, and leaders.
- Suggest fostering a sense of duty, compassion, and reason in various professions and societal roles.
Get an IAS/IPS ranker as your 1: 1 personal mentor for UPSC 2024
Attend Now
Note4Students
From UPSC perspective, the following things are important :
Prelims level: Cyclone Michuang
Mains level: decision-making during a crisis
Central idea
Dr. Mani Sivasubramanian emphasizes the long-lasting impact of decisions made after Cyclone Michuang in Chennai, particularly regarding electricity cutoffs. The central idea revolves around the need for accountability in decision-making during crises, highlighting the delicate balance between safety measures and potential hazards for vulnerable populations, such as the elderly. The way forward involves a hierarchical approach, periodic reviews, and fixing responsibility for sub-optimal decisions.
Key Highlights:
- Dr. Mani Sivasubramanian, a heart surgeon, author, and social entrepreneur, discusses the long-lasting impact of decisions made after Cyclone Michuang in Chennai.
- Emphasizes the importance of accountability for decisions with visible and hidden consequences.
- Raises concerns about the practice of prolonged electricity cutoffs after a natural disaster, especially for vulnerable populations like the elderly.
Key Challenges:
- Balancing the need for safety measures, such as electricity cutoffs during cyclones, with potential hazards like accidents and security concerns.
- The complexity of decision-making during a crisis, requiring a dynamic and evolving approach.
- Striking a balance between conservative choices and potential complications due to inaction.
Key Terms:
- Decision accountability
- Electricity cutoff
- Vulnerable populations
- Dynamic balance
- Cataclysmic disaster
- Intellectual and analytical judgment
Key Phrases for good marks in mains:
- “Consequences of choices should be accounted for.”
- “Power disruption poses significant hazards, especially for the elderly.”
- “Decision-making in a crisis is an extreme test of judgment and personal strength.”
- “Potential cost of mistakes looms large in a decision-maker’s mind.”
Key Quotes:
- “There is no objectively ‘safe’ choice; it is a constantly evolving, dynamic balance.”
- “A bureaucrat should justify and document decisions in real-time for review.”
- “Complex decision-making should not become a contest of cheap populism.”
Key Statements:
- Decision-makers should justify and document choices in real-time.
- Accountability is crucial, especially when decisions impact millions.
- Calls for a hierarchy-based approach in decision-making during crises.
Key Examples and References:
- Mentions the 2015 floods in Chennai as a reference to the consequences of decision-making during natural disasters.
Key Facts:
- In 2021, Tamil Nadu had 13.8 crore people over the age of 60 years.
- Chennai metropolitan area’s population is estimated to be over 12 million.
Key Data:
- 500,000 people in Chennai are above 60 years old, and over 50,000 are aged 80 or above.
Critical Analysis:
- Acknowledges the complexity of decision-making during a natural disaster.
- Emphasizes the need for a balance between safety measures and potential hazards.
- Advocates for accountability and periodic reviews of decisions.
Way Forward:
- Suggests a hierarchy-based approach with scaled levels of responsibility.
- Proposes involvement of more than one person in major decision-making.
- Calls for periodic reviews by an oversight team to challenge and reverse questionable choices.
- Highlights the importance of fixing responsibility for sub-optimal decisions.
Get an IAS/IPS ranker as your 1: 1 personal mentor for UPSC 2024
Attend Now
Note4Students
From UPSC perspective, the following things are important :
Prelims level: Bab al Mandab Strait
Central idea
The central idea focuses on the Houthi threat to Red Sea shipping, emphasizing the importance of navies and diplomatic efforts to maintain stability in the Indian Ocean. Historical trade warfare context and the need to address challenges like drone warfare underscore the urgency in safeguarding international trade routes. India’s proactive role and diplomatic leverage play a crucial role in ensuring regional stability.
Key Highlights:
- Houthi rebels, post the October 7 Hamas attack on Israel, pose a threat to Red Sea merchant-shipping traffic.
- Alfred Mahan’s emphasis on navies as a means to protect foreign trade and commerce for national prosperity.
- Indian Ocean’s vital role in global economy with 1,00,000 annual merchantmen, carrying 80% of the world’s oil.
- Indian Navy’s proactive role as a “preferred security partner” in maintaining good order at sea.
Key Challenges:
- Rising threat to Red Sea shipping by Houthi rebels affecting global trade.
- Historical instances of trade warfare impacting security and prosperity.
- Critical choke points in the Indian Ocean vulnerable to interdiction by states, pirates, and terrorists.
Key Terms and Phrases:
- Choke points: Narrow passages in the Indian Ocean constricting shipping traffic.
- Tanker war: Strategy targeting merchant ships to impact trade, as seen in the Iran-Iraq conflict.
- Flag state: State in which a ship is registered, exercising exclusive jurisdiction over vessels.
Key Quotes:
- “The necessity of a navy… springs from the existence of peaceful shipping…”
- “The Indian Navy’s self-assigned role of ‘preferred security partner’ in the region.”
Anecdotes:
- Eight-year-long Iran-Iraq conflict saw a “tanker war” impacting merchant ships in the Persian Gulf.
- Houthi rebels launching attacks on US Navy units and merchant shipping in the Bab al Mandab Strait.
Key Statements:
- Indian Navy’s commendable alacrity in responding to emergent situations in the Red Sea.
- US launching operation “Prosperity Guardian” to safeguard Red Sea shipping.
Key Examples and References:
- Germany targeting Allied merchant shipping in 20th-century global conflicts.
- Houthi attacks in the Bab al Mandab Strait affecting merchant ships seeking safe passage.
Critical Analysis:
- Importance of maintaining good order at sea for India’s own interest and international commitment.
- Challenges posed by ongoing Yemeni civil war affecting shipping in the Red Sea.
- Complexity of the conflict involving Saudi Arabia-Iran proxy clash and multilateral dimensions.
Way Forward:
- India leveraging its good standing with Iran and Israel to urge moderation and restraint.
- Addressing the challenges posed by drone warfare and evolving effective counter-measures.
- Ensuring diplomatic efforts to prevent the west Asian conflagration from spreading to the Indian Ocean.
Get an IAS/IPS ranker as your 1: 1 personal mentor for UPSC 2024
Attend Now
Note4Students
From UPSC perspective, the following things are important :
Prelims level: na
Mains level: desperate and perilous journeys of Indian migrants seeking illegal routes to the U.S. and Canada
Central idea
The grounding of a chartered plane in France reveals the desperate and perilous journeys of Indian migrants seeking illegal routes to the U.S. and Canada. It emphasizes the role of agents, tragic incidents, and the necessity for international collaboration to address the root causes and dismantle illegal immigration networks, highlighting the human cost of such endeavors.
Key Highlights:
- A chartered plane from the UAE to Nicaragua, carrying 303 Indians, was grounded in France for a human trafficking probe.
- The flight was hired by a non-European client, and passengers were possibly trafficked, leading to a French investigation.
- The passengers claimed they boarded willingly, and the flight was eventually forced to return to Mumbai.
- Gujarat and Punjab have high numbers of illegal Indian migrants to the U.S. and Canada, often taking risky “donkey routes.”
Key Challenges:
- Lack of opportunities in Gujarat pushes people to seek better prospects abroad, leading to illegal migration.
- Human trafficking networks operate, exploiting the desperation of individuals seeking a better life.
- The dangers of “donkey routes” involve traversing various countries with lenient visa policies, risking lives in harsh conditions.
Key Terms and Phrases:
- Donkey routes: Illegal migration paths involving multiple countries with lenient visa policies.
- Human trafficking: Exploitative practices involving illegal transportation of individuals.
- Chartered flight: Private aircraft hired for specific travel purposes.
- Asylum seekers: Individuals seeking protection and refuge in a foreign country.
Key Quotes:
- “The French authorities had received a tip-off and took it very seriously.”
- “The episode has once again called attention to the staggering number of Indians who migrate illegally to the U.S. or Canada.”
- “People don’t find any opportunities here. There are no well-paying jobs and sometimes no jobs at all.”
Anecdotes:
- Two passengers seeking asylum in France carried multiple passports and a substantial amount of money.
- Families taking extreme risks, like freezing to death near the U.S. border or drowning in attempts to cross rivers.
Key Statements:
- French authorities stopped exploring human trafficking angle after passengers claimed they boarded willingly.
- Gujarat Police cracking down on agents facilitating illegal immigration through donkey routes.
Key Examples and References:
- Shashi Kiran Reddy, a Hyderabad-based agent, behind the chartered flight facilitating illegal immigration.
- Instances of families freezing to death near the U.S. border or drowning while attempting to cross rivers.
Critical Analysis:
- Lack of opportunities and frustration in Gujarat and Punjab contribute to the high number of illegal migrants.
- The existence of human trafficking networks highlights the exploitation of individuals seeking better prospects.
Way Forward:
- Address root causes like lack of opportunities and corruption to discourage illegal migration.
- Strengthen efforts to dismantle human trafficking networks, collaborating with international agencies.
- Enhance awareness about legal migration pathways and associated risks to deter individuals from choosing illegal routes.
Get an IAS/IPS ranker as your 1: 1 personal mentor for UPSC 2024
Attend Now
