Note4Students
From UPSC perspective, the following things are important :
Prelims level: Flue-Gas Desulphurisers (FGDs) , Integrated Gasification Combined Cycle (IGCC)
Mains level: India's energy mix
Central Idea
- Globally, 80% of energy comes from fossil fuels like oil, coal, and gas. In contrast, renewable sources like solar and wind contributed only 2.4% in 2022.
- India, with its energy supply per capita well below the global average, faces the dual challenge of meeting growing energy demands and pursuing sustainable development.
Need for Electricity Security
- Stable and Affordable Power: Ensuring a reliable electricity supply that meets increasing demands at an affordable cost is crucial.
- Renewables’ Minor Role: Despite India’s significant potential for renewable energy, it made up only a small portion of the energy mix in 2022.
- Coal’s Predominance: In FY 2022-2023, coal-fired thermal power plants (TPPs) generated 74.3% of India’s electricity, driven by escalating demand and the need to support major industries.
Balancing Emissions and Development
- India’s Global Emission Share: India’s cumulative emissions from coal-fired power plants and followed by industry account for just 3.3% of the global total (US-EPA), highlighting its role in global development.
- Sustainable Development Imperative: Catering to the energy needs of 17% of the world’s population, India must ensure that sustainable development is more than a slogan.
Challenges and Strategies
- Dependency on Critical Battery Materials: Most materials for grid-scale battery storage are controlled by a few countries, posing energy security risks. Cost-effective batteries are expected post-2030.
- Efficiency and Nuclear Expansion: India needs to improve TPP efficiency, expand nuclear energy, and enhance pumped storage to integrate more renewables.
Coal’s Role in Electricity
- Future Projections: India’s national grid could absorb more renewable electricity by 2031-2032, but cost differences with coal-fired TPPs pose challenges.
- Domestic Coal Dependence: With 96% of coal for TPPs sourced domestically, coal capacity in India is expected to grow significantly.
Concerns of Coal Transport
- High Ash Content: Indian coal’s high ash content causes erosion and performance issues in TPPs.
- Transportation Issues: Long-distance transport of unwashed coal strains transportation systems and raises environmental concerns.
- Coal Washing: Requiring miners to supply only washed coal to TPPs over 500 km away can reduce emissions and pollution.
Flue-Gas Desulphurisers (FGDs) Dilemma
- Sulphur Emissions: Despite Indian coal’s lower sulphur content, tall stacks and weather conditions lead to sulphur dioxide emissions.
- Climate and Cost Implications: Installing FGDs in TPPs increases coal consumption, reduces efficiency, and requires significant investment.
Way forward
- Advanced Technologies: Supercritical and Ultra-Supercritical technologies can lower carbon emissions.
- IGCC for Carbon Capture: Integrated Gasification Combined Cycle (IGCC) plants can capture CO2, aiding in low-carbon electricity generation.
- Government Incentives: Promoting IGCC or Advanced Ultra-Supercritical Technology (AUSC) before 2030 can foster low-carbon initiatives.
Conclusion
- The challenge of global warming arises from all fossil fuels, not just coal.
- The principle of “common but differentiated responsibilities” should guide global climate change efforts.
- India’s journey towards low-carbon development is essential.
Get an IAS/IPS ranker as your 1: 1 personal mentor for UPSC 2024
Attend Now
Note4Students
From UPSC perspective, the following things are important :
Prelims level: RBI governor
Mains level: leadership during a critical financial period
Central idea
S Venkitaramanan, as RBI Governor, navigated a challenging financial landscape, implementing innovative measures, including pledging gold reserves, to overcome a critical balance of payment crisis exacerbated by the Iraq-Kuwait War. His leadership traits, commitment to reform, and resilience in dynamic political shifts define his impactful legacy
Key Highlights:
- Historical Interaction with S Venkitaramanan: The author shares a personal connection with S Venkitaramanan dating back to the late 1980s when they worked together in the Reserve Bank of India (RBI). Venkitaramanan, at that time, was the Finance Secretary in the government of India.
- Challenges Faced by Venkitaramanan as RBI Governor: Venkitaramanan assumed the role of RBI Governor during a challenging period marked by a critical balance of payment problem, intensified by the Iraq-Kuwait War. The situation demanded unconventional measures, including shipping gold reserves to raise foreign exchange.
- Extraordinary Steps Taken: To address the balance of payment crisis, the RBI, under Venkitaramanan’s leadership, borrowed around USD 405 million by pledging gold reserves kept outside India. This unusual step showcased determination and innovation in navigating a complex financial scenario.
- Dynamic Political Environment: The backdrop of frequent changes in the central government added complexity to the financial responsibilities of the RBI and its governor. Venkitaramanan played a crucial role in tapping international financial institutions and raising the necessary foreign exchange.
- Role of IMF and Devaluation of Rupee: The RBI, led by Venkitaramanan, approached the International Monetary Fund (IMF) for assistance. The initial request was related to the Compensatory and Contingency Financing Facility (CCFF), providing limited conditionalities. Additionally, the government, in consultation with the RBI, decided to devalue the rupee sharply in two steps in June 1991.
- Reform Initiatives: Venkitaramanan was a reformer who initiated banking sector reforms and introduced changes in the exchange rate system, moving towards a dual exchange rate. He advocated for a strong role for public sector enterprises where efficiency could be maintained.
- Leadership Traits: Venkitaramanan’s leadership qualities included a sharp mind, the ability to cut through complex problems, a willingness to listen to diverse viewpoints, and courage in making crucial decisions.
Key Challenges:
- Balance of Payment Crisis: Venkitaramanan faced a critical balance of payment problem aggravated by external factors such as the Iraq-Kuwait War. The challenge was to bridge the financial gap and avoid default in payment obligations.
- Dynamic Political Changes: Frequent changes in the central government added an additional layer of complexity to financial decision-making. Venkitaramanan navigated these changes while fulfilling the responsibilities of the RBI.
Key Terms and Phrases:
- Compensatory and Contingency Financing Facility (CCFF): An IMF facility created to aid countries facing sudden rises in the price of imported commodities or a sudden fall in export prices. The RBI approached the IMF for assistance, initially focusing on the CCFF.
- Dual Exchange Rate System: Venkitaramanan initiated a shift towards a dual exchange rate system, marking a significant change in the country’s approach to managing its currency’s value.
- Gold Pledging to Raise Foreign Exchange: The RBI, under Venkitaramanan, borrowed around USD 405 million by pledging gold reserves kept outside India during the balance of payment crisis.
Critical Analysis:
- Innovative Leadership in Crisis: Venkitaramanan’s decision to ship gold reserves and explore unconventional measures showcased innovative leadership during a financial crisis, preventing a default in payment obligations.
- Navigating Political Changes: Managing financial responsibilities amid frequent changes in the central government demonstrated Venkitaramanan’s ability to navigate a dynamic political environment, ensuring financial stability.
- Reform Initiatives for Financial Resilience: Venkitaramanan’s focus on banking sector reforms and a dual exchange rate system aimed at enhancing financial resilience during turbulent times, showcasing a forward-looking approach.
Way Forward:
- Building on Reform Initiatives: Advocate for building on the reform initiatives introduced by Venkitaramanan, emphasizing the importance of a resilient financial system in navigating future economic challenges.
- Continued Collaboration with International Institutions: Encourage continued collaboration with international financial institutions to strengthen India’s economic resilience, leveraging lessons learned from Venkitaramanan’s innovative approaches.
- Maintaining a Prudent Financial Policy: Emphasize the importance of prudent financial policies, considering both domestic and international factors, to ensure stability and resilience in the face of economic uncertainties.
Balanced Diplomatic Conclusion for good marks:
S Venkitaramanan’s leadership during a critical financial period exemplifies courage, innovation, and resilience. Acknowledging his contributions, the nation can build on reform initiatives, collaborate globally, and maintain prudent financial policies for a stable and resilient economic future.
Get an IAS/IPS ranker as your 1: 1 personal mentor for UPSC 2024
Attend Now
Note4Students
From UPSC perspective, the following things are important :
Prelims level: urban heat island, United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change (COP28)
Mains level: susceptibility to climate change impacts on health
Get an IAS/IPS ranker as your 1: 1 personal mentor for UPSC 2024
Attend Now
Note4Students
From UPSC perspective, the following things are important :
Prelims level: NALSA Judgment
Mains level: Transgender Persons (Protection of Rights) Act (2019)
Central idea
The central idea revolves around advocating for the gradual and thoughtful inclusion of transgender individuals in the armed forces. By drawing parallels with successful women integration, proposing protected roles initially, and emphasizing social awareness, the approach aims for a balanced, transparent, and inclusive transformation within the military, recognizing and addressing historical discrimination.
Key Highlights:
- Growing Acceptance: People are becoming more accepting of transgender folks, which is a positive change. Society is starting to understand the importance of including everyone, regardless of their gender identity.
- Recognizing Challenges: We’re acknowledging that transgender individuals have faced a tough time with discrimination, stigma, and fewer opportunities. This recognition is crucial in addressing historical disadvantages.
- Legal Steps in India: India has taken legal steps, like the Transgender Persons (Protection of Rights) Act in 2019, to protect transgender rights. This shows a commitment to making things better since a significant judgment in 2014.
- Armed Forces Proposal: There’s a suggestion to include transgender individuals in the armed forces. This proposal comes from the realization that they’ve been at a disadvantage and need proactive help to be part of every aspect of life.
- Stepwise Integration Approach: The idea is to include transgender individuals gradually, just like how women’s roles in the armed forces expanded step by step. This way, we can be sure that we’re ready and set up for their inclusion.
- Learning from Women’s Inclusion: We’re learning from how women were included in the armed forces. By doing this, we hope to avoid problems and make the integration process smooth and successful.
- Roles for Transgender Personnel: Transgender individuals might start with roles in medical services and staff positions. Initially, these roles will be more protected to ensure they feel comfortable and respected.
- Social Awareness Emphasis: There’s a suggestion to make the armed forces more aware of societal justice and the discrimination faced by transgender individuals. This change in mindset is vital for a successful integration.
Key Challenges:
- Societal Prejudices: A challenge is dealing with society’s biases within the armed forces. Overcoming these biases is crucial for creating an inclusive environment.
- Balancing Inclusion with Discipline: We need to be careful about how inclusion might affect the strong discipline and camaraderie in the armed forces. Balancing inclusion with maintaining teamwork is a tricky but necessary challenge.
- Infrastructure Support: Developing the needed support for transgender individuals is important. This includes making sure the armed forces are ready and equipped for their inclusion.
- Dignity Concerns: We’re aware of concerns about respecting the dignity and self-respect of transgender individuals. To address this, there’s a proposal for more protected roles initially.
Key Terms and Phrases:
- Camaraderie and Discipline: The armed forces have strong bonds based on trust and teamwork. Keeping these bonds intact while embracing diversity is a challenge.
- Sensitization Road Map: We’re planning a roadmap to sensitize the armed forces at all levels. This means we want everyone to understand and accept the realities of discrimination.
- Competence and Capabilities: Transgender individuals should be accepted based on their skills and abilities. Competency and capability are what matter most.
- Sheltered Appointments: Initially, there’s a proposal for more protected roles to make sure transgender individuals feel secure and respected.
- Aide-de-Camp: Imagining a capable transgender officer in a prestigious role shows the positive impact they can have on perceptions and acceptance.
- Gradual Integration: Just like how women were gradually included, we’re looking at a step-by-step approach for transgender integration.
Key Facts and Data:
- NALSA Judgment as a Legal Milestone: In 2014, there was a significant decision recognizing and protecting transgender rights. This decision set the stage for later legal measures.
- Transgender Persons (Protection of Rights) Act (2019): In 2019, India took legislative steps to protect transgender rights. These measures show a commitment to making things better.
- Success of Women in Armed Forces: We’re looking at the achievements of women in the armed forces as a guide for including transgender individuals. Learning from past successes helps us avoid problems.
Critical Analysis:
- Acknowledging Historical Discrimination: We’re recognizing that a big change is needed in the armed forces’ way of thinking. This acknowledgment sets the stage for real change.
- Calibrated Approach to Integration: We’re emphasizing the importance of careful planning and a step-by-step approach. This ensures that inclusion happens smoothly.
- Learning from Women’s Inclusion: We’re learning from how women were included in the armed forces. This shows a readiness to apply lessons from one integration process to another.
- Impact on Discipline and Camaraderie: We’re considering how inclusion might affect the unique bonds within the armed forces. This balance is crucial for a successful integration.
- Recognizing Importance of Social Awareness: We’re identifying the need for the armed forces to understand societal justice. This change in mindset is vital for true and lasting change.
Way Forward:
- Advocating Wider Discussions: We’re suggesting more discussions and debates within the armed forces. This ensures that everyone’s perspective is considered.
- Gradual Expansion of Roles: We’re advocating for more roles based on abilities and merit. This ensures that everyone gets opportunities based on their skills.
- Involvement of Transgender Community: We’re suggesting that the transgender community should be part of decision-making. This makes sure their views are central to the integration process.
- Establishing Social Awareness Strategy: We’re emphasizing the need for a strategy to make the armed forces more aware. This ensures that everyone understands and accepts the need for change.
- Transparent and Just Process: We’re highlighting the importance of openness and fairness in the integration process. This ensures that the process is respectful and just for everyone involved.
Get an IAS/IPS ranker as your 1: 1 personal mentor for UPSC 2024
Attend Now
Note4Students
From UPSC perspective, the following things are important :
Prelims level: National Pharmacy Commission Bill, 2023
Mains level: NA
Central Idea
- The Union Ministry of Health and Family Welfare has unveiled the draft National Pharmacy Commission Bill, 2023, signalling a transformative shift in India’s healthcare landscape.
- This bill aims to replace the Pharmacy Act, of 1948, and the existing Pharmacy Council of India (PCI) with the forward-looking National Pharmacy Commission.
Key Highlights of the Bill
- Elevating Pharmacy Education: The primary objective of the bill is to elevate pharmacy education by enhancing access to affordable, high-quality learning opportunities. It envisions a robust educational framework that prepares future pharmacy professionals to excel.
- Universal Access to Pharmacy Services: The bill aspires to make pharmacy services accessible to all, fostering equitable healthcare delivery across the nation.
- Integration of Research and Ethical Standards: It encourages pharmacy professionals to seamlessly integrate the latest research into their practice, contribute to ongoing research efforts, and uphold the highest ethical standards.
- Transparency and Adaptability: The bill advocates for regular, transparent assessments of pharmacy institutions, the establishment of a national pharmacy register, and the flexibility to adapt to evolving healthcare needs. It also introduces an effective grievance redressal mechanism.
National Pharmacy Commission’s Architecture
- A New Beginning: The bill proposes the establishment of the National Pharmacy Commission, headquartered in New Delhi, heralding the dissolution of the existing Pharmacy Council of India.
- Composition: The commission will consist of a Chairperson, 13 ex-officio members, and 14 part-time members.
- Three Key Boards: The Central Government will constitute three vital boards under the commission:
- Pharmacy Education Board
- Pharmacy Assessment and Rating Board
- Pharmacy Ethics and Registration Board
Empowering State Chapters
- The bill mandates every State Government to establish a state pharmacy chapter within one year from the Act’s commencement.
- These chapters will operate under State Law and play a pivotal role in executing the Act’s provisions.
- The Pharmacy Ethics and Registration Board will maintain the National Pharmacy Register (NPR), a comprehensive repository containing detailed information about pharmacy professionals, ensuring transparency and accountability.
Get an IAS/IPS ranker as your 1: 1 personal mentor for UPSC 2024
Attend Now
Note4Students
From UPSC perspective, the following things are important :
Prelims level: Gamma-ray bursts (GRBs)
Mains level: NA
Central Idea
- A Star’s Explosive End: About two billion years ago, far beyond our Milky Way galaxy, a huge star exploded into a supernova. This explosion sent out a massive burst of gamma rays, the most powerful type of energy wave in the electromagnetic spectrum.
- Gamma-Ray Bursts: These bursts are short-lived but incredibly intense, often associated with the most dramatic events in the universe, like the death of massive stars.
Why discuss this?
- These gamma rays travelled across space for billions of years, finally reaching Earth in 2022.
- When they arrived, they caused a significant disturbance in Earth’s ionosphere, a layer of electrically charged gases high in our atmosphere.
What are Gamma-Ray Bursts?
- What Are They? Gamma-ray bursts (GRBs) are incredibly intense flashes of gamma rays, which are the most energetic form of light in the electromagnetic spectrum. These bursts are the most powerful explosions observed in the universe.
- How They Occur: They usually happen when massive stars collapse into neutron stars or black holes, or during the merger of neutron stars. These cosmic catastrophes release a tremendous amount of energy.
- Duration and Energy: GRBs can last from a few milliseconds to several hours, but they typically last a few seconds. The amount of energy released in this short time can be more than the Sun will emit in its entire 10-billion-year lifetime.
- Afterglow: Following the initial burst, GRBs are often followed by an ‘afterglow’ emitted at longer wavelengths (X-ray, ultraviolet, optical, infrared, and radio).
Earthly Consequences and Research
- Lasting Effects: The gamma rays disturbed the ionosphere for several hours and even set off lightning detectors in India.
- Scientific Importance: Although this burst didn’t harm life on Earth, it showed how sensitive our ionosphere is to space events.
- A Rare Event: Such a powerful gamma-ray burst is expected to hit Earth only once every 10,000 years.
Looking Ahead: Protecting Earth from Cosmic Threats
- Preparing for Future Events: Scientists are studying the potential risks of a similar event happening closer to Earth, within our own Milky Way.
- Low Risk: However, the chance of such a dangerous event happening is very low.
Get an IAS/IPS ranker as your 1: 1 personal mentor for UPSC 2024
Attend Now
Note4Students
From UPSC perspective, the following things are important :
Prelims level: China-Myanmar Economic Corridor
Mains level: Belt and Road Initiative
Central Idea
- In a significant move towards expanding the Belt and Road Initiative (BRI) in South Asia, China has expressed its commitment to prioritize the extension of the China-Myanmar Economic Corridor (CMEC) to Sri Lanka.
What is CMEC?
|
Details |
| Geographical Scope |
Connects China’s Yunnan Province with Mandalay, Kyaukphyu SEZ on the Bay of Bengal, and Yangon in Myanmar. |
| Strategic Importance |
Provides China an alternative to the Strait of Malacca for trade and energy transport. Offers a shorter, more secure route to the Middle East and Africa. |
| Infrastructure |
Involves building roads, railways, ports, and industrial zones. Key projects include the development of the Kyaukphyu deep-sea port. |
| Economic Impact on Myanmar |
Promises infrastructure development, foreign investment, and job creation in Myanmar. Raises concerns about debt sustainability, environmental impact, and displacement of local communities. |
| Political and Security Challenges |
The corridor passes through politically sensitive and conflict-prone areas in Myanmar, posing challenges to its implementation and stability. |
Expanding the Economic Corridor
- China’s Strategic Priority: State Councillor Shen Yiqin emphasized that China is making the extension of the CMEC to Sri Lanka a strategic priority.
- Free Trade Agreement Acceleration: Both nations affirmed their commitment to expediting the implementation of the China-Sri Lanka Free Trade Agreement, reinforcing their economic partnership.
Significance of CMEC in BRI
- CMEC’s Emergence: CMEC is the latest addition to the six land corridors within the Belt and Road Initiative, gaining prominence over the stalled Bangladesh-China India Myanmar (BCIM) corridor.
- South Asian Perspective: India and Bhutan remain outside the BRI framework, while countries like Sri Lanka are enthusiastic participants, poised for a more substantial economic contribution in the second phase of the initiative.
Get an IAS/IPS ranker as your 1: 1 personal mentor for UPSC 2024
Attend Now
Note4Students
From UPSC perspective, the following things are important :
Prelims level: Langlands Program
Mains level: Not Much
Central Idea
- Robert Langlands, a mathematician famous for his “Langlands Program,” has shifted his focus to Turkish literature in his later years.
- This program is about finding deep links between two areas of math: number theory (the study of numbers) and harmonic analysis (a type of math that breaks down functions or signals into simpler parts).
Langlands Program: A Journey to Connect Different Math Areas
- Beginning: In 1967, Robert Langlands, a young mathematician at Princeton, started this journey with a letter to another mathematician, Andre Weil, sharing some groundbreaking ideas.
- Complex Ideas: The program is full of complicated ideas that are hard for even experts to fully understand.
- Goal: It aims to connect number theory and harmonic analysis, two areas of math that don’t seem related at first.
The Purpose of the Program
- Abel’s Discovery: In 1824, Niels Henrik Abel showed that it’s impossible to find a one-size-fits-all solution for certain math equations (polynomial equations) beyond a certain complexity.
- Galois’s Approach: Evariste Galois, who didn’t know about Abel’s work, suggested looking at patterns (symmetries) in the solutions of these equations instead of trying to solve them directly.
- Galois Groups: These are groups that show the patterns in the solutions of these equations and are key to the Langlands Program.
- Linking Ideas: The program tries to connect these Galois groups with something called automorphic functions, which would allow using calculus (a branch of math) to explore these equations, connecting harmonic analysis and number theory.
Automorphic Functions: Connecting Different Areas of Math
- Example of Automorphic Function: Think of functions that have a repeating pattern, like the way sine functions in trigonometry work.
- Special Symmetry: Automorphic functions have a unique property where they remain the same even after certain transformations, showing a special kind of symmetry.
- Role in Langlands Program: The program’s goal is to link these special functions with Galois groups, leading to new ways of understanding and solving math problems.
Impact of the Program
- Solving an Old Puzzle: In 1994, Andrew Wiles and Richard Taylor used ideas from the Langlands Program to solve Fermat’s Last Theorem, a famous and old math problem.
- Creating New Functions: This program helps in making new types of automorphic functions, which could help solve other complex math problems, like the Ramanujan conjectures.
- Geometric Langlands: This is a branch of the Langlands Program that looks at connections between different fields like algebraic geometry, representation theory, and even physics.
- Math and Physics Connection: Recent studies suggest that this program might help in understanding things in physics, like the study of electromagnetic waves.
Get an IAS/IPS ranker as your 1: 1 personal mentor for UPSC 2024
Attend Now
Note4Students
From UPSC perspective, the following things are important :
Prelims level: Article 200
Mains level: Read the attached story
Central Idea
- The Supreme Court has taken notice of the Tamil Nadu government’s assertion that Governor R.N. Ravi lacks the “discretion” to withhold approval for the ten Bills “re-passed” by the State Legislative Assembly.
- This legal matter revolves around the interpretation of Article 200 of the Constitution, which governs the Governor’s role in granting assent to Bills passed by the State Legislature.
Article 200 of the Indian Constitution
- It pertains to the “Assent to Bills.”
- It outlines the procedure for the Governor of a state in India to give their assent to bills passed by the state legislature.
- Article 200 states that when a bill is passed by the legislative assembly of a state (or in the case of a bicameral legislature, by the legislative assembly and legislative council), it shall be presented to the Governor for their assent.
Governor’s Discretion: The Governor has the discretion to either:
- Give their assent to the bill, after which it becomes a law.
- Withhold their assent to the bill, in which case the bill does not become law.
- Return the bill (if it is not a money bill) to the legislature with a request for reconsideration, along with a specific message explaining the reasons for withholding assent.
Reconsideration by the Legislature: If the Governor returns a bill for reconsideration, the legislature can then reconsider the bill, taking into account the Governor’s message. They may choose to make amendments to the bill or pass it again without any changes.
Assent after Reconsideration: If the bill is passed again by the legislature, with or without amendments, and is presented to the Governor, the Governor is bound to give their assent to it. In other words, the Governor cannot withhold assent a second time. |
Governor’s Discretion
- Article 200 Interpretation: The Tamil Nadu government argued that once Bills have been re-passed by the Assembly, they are treated similarly to Money Bills and cannot be rejected by the Governor.
- Questioning the Process: The CJI questioned whether the Governor must send the Bills back to the Assembly for reconsideration after withholding assent.
- Limiting Presidential Referral: The State also emphasized that the Governor cannot refer the reiterated Bills to the President after withholding assent.
Background and Delay
- Delayed Bills: The Bills in question were sent to the Governor’s office between January 2020 and April 2023, and the State accused the Governor of holding them indefinitely.
- Special Session: The TN Assembly convened a special session to re-pass the Bills after the Governor withheld assent.
- Governor’s Statement: The Governor returned the Bills with a simple statement: “I withhold consent,” prompting the Assembly to take action.
Legal Perspectives
- Governor’s Ceremonial Role: The State contends that the Governor’s role is primarily ceremonial and that he must act within the State Legislature’s framework.
- Will of the People: The Bills passed by the Assembly represent the will of the people and should not be delayed or rejected without valid reasons.
Supreme Court’s Response
- Addressing Delay: The Supreme Court acknowledged the need to address whether there has been a delay in the Governor’s constitutional function.
- Bill Status: The Attorney General mentioned that 182 Bills were presented to the Governor, with 152 approved, five withdrawn, and nine reserved for referral to the President.
- Key Issue: The real issue in this case involves amendments to State universities’ legislations that affect the Governor’s powers to select Vice-Chancellors.
Conclusion
- The Supreme Court’s hearing on this matter raises critical questions about the Governor’s role in granting assent to Bills and the need to ensure timely decision-making in the best interest of the people and governance of the State.
- The interpretation of Article 200 of the Constitution will play a pivotal role in this legal dispute.
Get an IAS/IPS ranker as your 1: 1 personal mentor for UPSC 2024
Attend Now
Note4Students
From UPSC perspective, the following things are important :
Prelims level: governor topic
Mains level: accountability and balance to the role of governors
Central idea
The article delves into the persistent constitutional challenges posed by the role of governors in India, emphasizing historical debates, predicting issues realized over time, and proposing judicial and constitutional solutions for effective governance and accountability.
Key Highlights:
- Governor’s Constitutional Role: The article highlights the constitutional concerns regarding the role of governors in Indian states, emphasizing their appointed nature and potential overreach in state matters.
- Recent Instances in Tamil Nadu: Specific instances in Tamil Nadu, where Governor R N Ravi returned bills for assent and delayed decisions, serve as examples of the ongoing issues related to gubernatorial powers.
- Constitutional Design Critique: The piece delves into the historical debates in the Constituent Assembly, expressing concerns raised by members like Dakshayani Velayudhan about the replication of colonial structures and the centralized nature of power.
- Unaddressed Predictions: The article points out that predictions made during the Constituent Assembly debates about potential misuse of gubernatorial powers have materialized, with governors often serving as agents of the Union government.
Challenges:
- Appointment and Removal Disparities: It highlights the disparities between the appointment and removal processes of the President and the Governor, suggesting a lack of checks and balances for governors’ actions.
- Perverse Incentives: The piece discusses the perverse incentives for governors, as they are secure in their positions as long as they align with the Union government, potentially leading to undue interference in state affairs.
Key Phrases:
- Colonial Legacy of Governors: The article stresses the continuation of the colonial institution of governors, raising questions about its relevance in an independent India.
- Powers and Accountability: It explores the imbalance in powers and accountability between the President and the Governor, pointing out the governor’s vulnerability to the Union government’s preferences.
Analysis:
- Judicial Intervention: The piece acknowledges the increasing judicial intervention to address governors’ conduct but questions the need for repeated court interventions and calls for a more sustainable solution.
- Constitutional Reform Proposal: While presenting a constitutional reform proposal from “Heads Held High,” the article suggests making governors accountable to state legislatures through election and impeachment, mirroring the President’s accountability to the Union Parliament.
Way Forward:
- Viable Alternatives: Instead of outright abolition, the article advocates for viable alternatives such as judicial scrutiny and comprehensive constitutional reforms to bring accountability and balance to the role of governors.
- State Legislature Accountability: Proposing a way forward, the article suggests a model where governors are made accountable to state legislatures through election and impeachment, akin to the President’s accountability at the national level.
Get an IAS/IPS ranker as your 1: 1 personal mentor for UPSC 2024
Attend Now
Note4Students
From UPSC perspective, the following things are important :
Prelims level: GSAT-7 and GSAT-7A
Mains level: emerging technologies in the military landscape
Central idea
The Indian military’s strategic embrace of emerging technologies, encompassing AI, cyber, and unmanned systems, reflects a forward-looking vision. While showcasing diverse initiatives, the article underscores the need for organizational shifts, jointness, and collaboration with civilians to effectively integrate these technologies
Key Highlights:
- Diverse Initiatives: Indian military strategically adopts AI, cyber, and unmanned systems, with each service branch leading initiatives.
- Strategic Vision: Reflects a forward-looking approach, leveraging technology for operational and strategic advantages.
- AIDef Showcases: Defence Ministry’s ‘AIDef’ presents Defence AI Council and Project Agency, showcasing a commitment to integrate AI across allied organizations.
- Indigenous Emphasis: Highlights a push for indigenization, aligning with national goals of self-reliance in defence.
Challenges:
- Organizational Shift Needed: Warns against viewing technology as a ‘plug and play,’ stressing the need for organizational and doctrinal changes.
- Data-sharing Imperative: Advocates for a cultural shift, urging military to share data with civilians for technology to reach its full potential.
- Crucial Interconnectedness: Identifies jointness and interoperability challenges, crucial for effective integration of emerging technologies.
- Need for Unified Commands: Stresses the urgency of joint theatre commands to streamline operations and enhance coordination.
Key Phrases:
- Civil-Military Partnerships: Emphasizes collaborative defence, necessitating partnerships with scientists, academics, and technologists.
- Shared Responsibility: Highlights the shared responsibility of the military and civilians in navigating the complexities of emerging technologies.
- Historical Challenge: Explores the perpetual military challenge of adapting to change, underlining the complexity of integrating emerging technologies.
- Strategic Evolution: Recognizes the need for a strategic evolution to effectively incorporate emerging technologies into military operations.
Analysis:
- Operational Synergy: Advocates for joint theatre commands to achieve operational synergy and seamless integration of emerging technologies.
- Unified Strategy: Stresses the importance of a unified strategy for joint operations, minimizing challenges related to technology integration.
- Specialization Advocacy: Urges a shift towards specialization in human resources practices, aligning officer expertise with the demands of emerging technologies.
- Intellectual Inclination: Recommends extended tenures for officers inclined towards technological domains, fostering intellectual capabilities.
| Value addition box from Civilsdaily
The U.S. Department of Defense (DoD) actively engages with private tech companies through initiatives like the Defense Innovation Unit (DIU) and In-Q-Tel to leverage cutting-edge technologies.
The U.S. prioritizes collaboration between defense agencies and civilian entities, exemplified by the establishment of the Defense Innovation Board, composed of experts from various industries.
The U.S. military emphasizes jointness through unified combatant commands, promoting interoperability in the application of emerging technologies across different branches. |
Key Data:
- ‘UDAAN’ Initiative: The Indian Air Force is utilizing AI, cyber, and virtual reality under ‘UDAAN’ to address operational, logistical, and training needs.
- Integrated Unmanned Roadmap: The Navy is progressing with emerging technologies, including an Integrated Unmanned Roadmap, as part of project ‘Swavlamban.’
- Defence Cyber Agency: Established in 2018, the Defence Cyber Agency addresses threats in the cyber domain.
- Defence Space Agency: Launched in 2018, it focuses on threats and capabilities related to space.
- Comprehensive Approach: Reveals the military’s comprehensive approach, identifying 45 niche technologies for diverse military applications.
- Strategic Preparedness: Illustrates a strategic preparedness to harness a spectrum of technologies for operational superiority.
- Communication Enhancements: Mentions GSAT-7 and GSAT-7A launches, highlighting advancements in military communication capabilities through satellite technology.
- Space for Defence: Showcases India’s utilization of space capabilities for defence purposes, marking a significant leap in technological applications.
Way Forward:
- Integrated Planning: Calls for integrated planning to address challenges in jointness and interoperability, laying the groundwork for successful technology integration.
- Cross-Service Collaboration: Advocates for cross-service collaboration, emphasizing the need for unified efforts to maximize the potential of emerging technologies.
- Private Sector Integration: Recommends openness to technocrats from the private sector, fostering innovation and expertise infusion for defence.
- Innovation Ecosystem: Calls for the creation of an innovation ecosystem, encouraging collaboration between defence and civilian talent for holistic technological advancements.
This transformative journey requires a multi-faceted approach, encompassing strategic vision, organizational adaptability, collaborative partnerships, and talent infusion to fully realize the potential of emerging technologies in the military landscape.
Get an IAS/IPS ranker as your 1: 1 personal mentor for UPSC 2024
Attend Now
Note4Students
From UPSC perspective, the following things are important :
Mains level: freedom of speech
)
Central idea
The article critically examines the Government of Tamil Nadu’s establishment of a Fact Check Unit, highlighting constitutional concerns, the potential impact on freedom of speech, and the challenges posed by ambiguity and absence of due process.
What is fact check unit?
A Fact Check Unit is an entity or organization tasked with verifying the authenticity and accuracy of information, particularly in the context of news, announcements, policies, schemes, guidelines, and initiatives of a government or other institutions.
Key Highlights:
- Establishment of Tamil Nadu Fact Check Unit: The Government of Tamil Nadu issues an order to create a Fact Check Unit for verifying information related to the state government across diverse media platforms.
- Constitutional Concerns Raised: Assertions about the order violating fundamental rights and being constitutionally vague and arbitrary, particularly emphasizing the potential infringement on freedom of speech.
- Impact on Freedom of Speech: Examining the implications of the Fact Check Unit on freedom of speech and expression, highlighting the need for reasonable restrictions and challenging the authority of a Government Order in imposing such restrictions.
- Chilling Effect Analysis: A deeper analysis of the perceived chilling effect on freedom of speech, exploring the implications of the Government acting as the arbiter of information authenticity.
Challenges:
- Scope Ambiguity and Potential Misuse: Critiques the lack of specificity in defining “information related to the Government of Tamil Nadu,” raising concerns about ambiguity and the possibility of misuse.
- Due Process Absence: Points out the absence of due process, where the Fact Check Unit lacks a mechanism for the author’s hearing, positioning the government as the sole determinant of information authenticity.
- Legal Limitations on Government Orders: Discusses the legal limitations of Government Orders in imposing restrictions on freedom of speech, underscoring the need for a more nuanced and legislative approach.
- Global Challenges of Misinformation: Draws parallels with global challenges of misinformation, citing events like the U.S. presidential election, and underscores the necessity for effective measures in addressing this widespread issue.
Key Phrases for enhancing answer quality:
- “Chilling effect on freedom of speech”
- “Unconstitutionally vague and arbitrary”
- “Opportunity of hearing”
- “Mis/disinformation and fake news challenge”
- “Government as judge, jury, and executioner”
Analysis:
- Constitutional Implications Explored: In-depth analysis of the constitutional concerns, with a focus on how the Fact Check Unit might impact freedom of speech and questioning the legal standing of a Government Order.
- Interrogation of Scope Ambiguity: Scrutiny of the ambiguity surrounding the definition of “information related to the Government of Tamil Nadu,” delving into potential implications for various forms of expression.
Key Facts:
- US Election and Misinformation Parallel: Drawing parallels with global challenges of misinformation during events like the U.S. presidential election, emphasizing the need for effective measures.
Way Forward:
- Stakeholder Consultation Advocacy: Advocacy for comprehensive consultations with stakeholders, including the public and intermediaries, to develop effective measures against misinformation.
- Global Best Practices Exploration: Encouraging exploration of global best practices, such as the European Commission’s Code of Practice on Disinformation, for a more inclusive and well-informed approach.
- Media Literacy Promotion Recommendation: Recommending the promotion of media literacy and support for an independent network of fact-checkers as constructive measures to combat misinformation.
Get an IAS/IPS ranker as your 1: 1 personal mentor for UPSC 2024
Attend Now
Note4Students
From UPSC perspective, the following things are important :
Prelims level: Freemartinism
Mains level: NA
Central Idea
- In the realm of animal husbandry, a phenomenon known as Freemartinism sheds light on the extraordinary diversity found in cattle.
Freemartinism: A Unique Phenomenon
- Freemartins are sterile female cattle born exhibiting characteristics of both sexes.
- This phenomenon arises when a male and a female twin develop within the same uterus, occurring in approximately 90% of twin pregnancies in cattle.
- The exchange of blood between the male and female foetuses during gestation plays a pivotal role in Freemartinism.
- Freemartinism is primarily attributed to the sharing of cells carrying the Y chromosome from the male twin with the female twin.
- Y chromosome triggers the development of male reproductive organs in the male foetus, while the female foetus, influenced by male hormones, undergoes incomplete development of its reproductive system.
- Freemartins possess underdeveloped or non-functional reproductive tracts, rendering them incapable of reproduction.
Agricultural Significance
- In agricultural settings, identifying freemartins is crucial to enhance reproductive efficiency in cattle breeding.
- Farmers often utilize physical and behavioural traits to identify freemartins, subsequently removing them from the breeding herd.
- This culling strategy helps improve the overall breeding program by ensuring that non-reproductive cattle do not contribute to the herd.
Get an IAS/IPS ranker as your 1: 1 personal mentor for UPSC 2024
Attend Now
Note4Students
From UPSC perspective, the following things are important :
Prelims level: Lachit Borphukan
Mains level: NA
Central Idea
- An animation film on an iconic Ahom general Lachit Borphukan has been selected for the International Film Festival of India (IFFI) 2023 to be held in Goa.
Lachit Borphukan
- Lachit Borphukan was a legendary military commander from the northeastern region of India, specifically from the state of Assam. Here are some facts related to him:
|
Description |
| Timeline |
1622-1672 |
| Dynasty |
Ahom Dynasty |
| Mughal Threat |
Faced the Mughal Empire’s expansion into Assam |
| Battle of Saraighat |
Led Ahom forces to victory against the Mughals in 1671
Defended Assam against the Aurangzeb’s forces led by Ram Singh |
| Leadership |
Known for strategic brilliance and guerrilla tactics |
| Legacy |
Revered as a symbol of Assamese pride and resistance |
| INS Lachit |
Indian Navy’s guided-missile destroyer named in honor |
| Lachit Divas |
Celebrated annually on November 24th in Assam |
https://www.thehindu.com/news/national/other-states/assam-ips-officer-directed-animation-film-chosen-for-iffi-2023/article67550668.ece
Get an IAS/IPS ranker as your 1: 1 personal mentor for UPSC 2024
Attend Now
Note4Students
From UPSC perspective, the following things are important :
Prelims level: Kadalundi Mudflats
Mains level: NA
Central Idea
- Kadalundi’s mudflats are shrinking drastically with sands cover.
- These mudflats have been a vital source of sustenance for thousands of migrant shorebirds, offering abundant prey like polychaetes and crustaceans.
About Kadalundi Mudflats
- Kadalundi Mudflats are situated in the Kadalundi Bird Sanctuary, which is located in the Kozhikode district of Kerala, along the southwestern coast of India. The sanctuary encompasses estuarine wetlands, mudflats, and mangrove forests.
- The mudflats are part of the estuarine ecosystem formed at the confluence of the Kadalundi River and the Arabian Sea.
- This unique environment is influenced by both freshwater from the river and saline water from the sea, creating a diverse habitat.
Ecological significance
- Kadalundi Mudflats are renowned for their rich biodiversity, especially in terms of avian species.
- The Kadalundi Bird Sanctuary and the mudflats are protected under the Wildlife Protection Act of 1972.
- The mudflats serve as a critical habitat for various resident and migratory birds.
- It is estimated that over 100 species of resident and migratory birds visit the area, making it a paradise for birdwatchers and ornithologists.
- They are a crucial stopover point for migratory birds travelling along the East Asia-Australasia Flyway.
Get an IAS/IPS ranker as your 1: 1 personal mentor for UPSC 2024
Attend Now
Note4Students
From UPSC perspective, the following things are important :
Prelims level: Onattukara Ellu (Sesame)
Mains level: NA
Context
- Kerala is taking efforts to expand the cultivation of Geographical Indication (GI)-tagged Onattukara sesame, a unique and valuable agricultural product.
- Onattukara sesame was granted the GI tag in January this year.
Onattukara Sesame (Ellu )
|
Description |
|
Region of Cultivation
|
Primarily cultivated in the Onattukara region, covering Alappuzha, Kollam, and Pathanamthitta districts in Kerala, India. |
| Medicinal Properties |
Onattukara sesame is known for its medicinal properties and high quality. |
| Traditional Use |
Traditional ayurvedic doctors in the region have used Onattukara sesame oil for treating rheumatism and skin protection since the 18th century. |
| Nutritional Value |
Rich in vitamin E and antioxidants. Contains essential fatty acids like oleic acid, linoleic acid, and palmitoleic acid. |
| Varieties |
Grown in various varieties, including ‘ayali,’ Kayamkulam-1, thilak, thilathara, and thilarani, developed by ORARS, Kayamkulam. |
| Market Potential |
Obtaining the GI tag is expected to increase its popularity and market value, leading to higher prices for sesame seeds and oil. |
| Pricing |
Current prices: Sesame seeds – ₹200 to ₹250 per kilogram, Sesame oil – ₹500 to ₹600 per kilogram. |
Get an IAS/IPS ranker as your 1: 1 personal mentor for UPSC 2024
Attend Now
Note4Students
From UPSC perspective, the following things are important :
Prelims level: Sea Buckthorn
Mains level: NA
Central Idea
- The Geographical Indication Registry has officially granted the GI tag to ‘Ladakh Sea Buckthorn’.
- It is the fourth GI tag after Apricot (Raktsey Karpo), Pashmina, and Ladakhi Wood Carving in Ladakh.
About Sea Buckthorn
- Sea buckthorn is a plant that grows in Europe and Asia.
- In India, it’s found in the Himalayan region, especially in dry places like the cold deserts of Ladakh and Spiti.
- This plant produces small orange or yellow berries that are sour but full of vitamins, especially vitamin C.
- It can survive really hot and really cold temperatures, which makes it perfect for the cold deserts.
- Every part of the plant—berries, leaves, twigs, roots, and thorns—are useful for medicine, food, fuel, and fencing.
- It’s also a vital food source for many birds and provides nutritious food for animals like sheep, goats, donkeys, cattle, and camels in the cold desert regions.
- It is often called the ‘Wonder Plant,’ ‘Ladakh Gold,’ ‘Golden Bush,’ or ‘Gold Mine’ of the cold deserts.
Back2Basics: GI Tag
- A GI is a sign used on products that have a specific geographical origin and possess qualities or a reputation that are due to that origin.
- Nodal Agency: Department for Promotion of Industry and Internal Trade (DPIIT), Ministry of Commerce and Industry
- India, as a member of the World Trade Organization (WTO), enacted the Geographical Indications of Goods (Registration and Protection) Act, 1999 w.e.f. September 2003.
- GIs have been defined under Article 22 (1) of the WTO Agreement on Trade-Related Aspects of Intellectual Property Rights (TRIPS) Agreement.
- The tag stands valid for 10 years.
Get an IAS/IPS ranker as your 1: 1 personal mentor for UPSC 2024
Attend Now
Note4Students
From UPSC perspective, the following things are important :
Prelims level: Global Talent Competitiveness Index (GTCI)
Mains level: NA
Central Idea
- India’s ranking in the Global Talent Competitiveness Index (GTCI) has significantly declined from 83 a decade ago to 103 in the latest report released this month.
- India now finds itself positioned between Algeria (ranked 102) and Guatemala (ranked 104), all classified as lower-middle-income countries.
About Global Talent Competitiveness Index (GTCI)
- The GTCI ranks 134 countries based on their ability to grow, attract, and retain talent.
- It is released by INSEAD, a partner and sponsor of the United Nation’s Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs)Davos, Switzerland recently.
- INSEAD is one of the world’s leading and largest graduate business schools with locations all over the world and alliances with top institutions.
- The report ranks countries based on 6 pillars:
- enable
- attract
- grow
- retain talent
- vocation and technical skills
- global knowledge skills
India’s Ranking and Comparisons
- Rank 103: India’s current rank is well below the median score of the countries assessed in the GTCI.
- BRICS Nations: India’s performance in the GTCI is the weakest among the BRICS countries. China leads the group at rank 40, followed by Russia at 52, South Africa at 68, and Brazil at 69.
- Top Three Countries: These are Singapore, Switzerland, and the United States.
- Skills Mismatch: India faces an increased skills mismatch and difficulties in finding skilled employees, resulting in its low rankings in the ‘Employability’ and ‘Vocational and Technical Skills’ categories.
- Best-Performing Area: India’s best-performing area in the GTCI is “Global Knowledge Skills,” driven by innovation and software development, contributing to its 69th position in the “Talent Impact” sub-pillar.
Get an IAS/IPS ranker as your 1: 1 personal mentor for UPSC 2024
Attend Now
Note4Students
From UPSC perspective, the following things are important :
Prelims level: BPTA
Mains level: India-China Border disputes
Central Idea
- India and China, historical adversaries who fought a war in 1962, reached their first-ever border agreement, known as the Border Peace and Tranquility Agreement (BPTA), in 1993, following years of border disputes.
- The BPTA aimed to maintain peace along the Line of Actual Control (LAC) and reduce the risk of unplanned confrontations.
Why discuss this?
- Thirty years later, the legacy of this historic agreement is continued by contested interpretations and unfulfilled commitments, while the ongoing border crisis further highlights the challenges both nations face in reaching a resolution.
BPTA: A Historic Yet Contested Agreement
- Context: The BPTA was negotiated in the aftermath of the Sumdorong Chu standoff, marking a significant diplomatic achievement in the early 1990s.
- Signing: The agreement was signed in 1993 during the tenure of PV Narasimha Rao as PM.
- Peaceful Coexistence: The agreement committed both nations to avoid using or threatening force against each other. It emphasized strict adherence to the LAC and mutual reduction of military forces to maintain friendly relations.
- Legacy: While it played a crucial role in maintaining peace for nearly two decades, the BPTA also spurred infrastructure development and frequent incidents, ultimately leading to the Galwan clash in 2020.
Ambiguity Surrounding the LAC
- Inherent Ambiguity: The primary issue undermining border agreements is the inherent ambiguity surrounding the LAC, which was embedded in the BPTA.
- LAC Problem: India’s discomfort with the term “LAC” proposed by China in 1959 remained a contentious issue.
- Ambiguous Formulation: The BPTA allowed both sides to clarify the LAC wherever necessary, implying a lack of shared perception about the 1959 LAC.
- Compromised Clarity: This formulation didn’t definitively reject China’s version of the LAC but aimed to prevent constant confrontation.
Impact on Subsequent Agreements
- Positive Developments: The BPTA paved the way for additional agreements, such as confidence-building measures in the Military Field along the LAC (1996) and the appointment of Special Representatives (2003).
- Unfinished Business: Negotiations for a final boundary settlement stalled, and the mechanisms to clarify LAC claims remained incomplete.
Infrastructure Development and Tensions
- Race for Facts on the Ground: Ambiguity over the LAC drove both countries to strengthen their claims through infrastructure development and increased patrols.
- Frequent Encounters: Frequent encounters between patrols exacerbated tensions along the border.
- Unforeseen Consequences: The BPTA inadvertently contributed to a slowdown in boundary negotiations, as both sides aimed to bolster their positions along the LAC.
The Current Crisis
- Blatant Disregard: The ongoing crisis, beginning in 2020, saw both nations cast aside the commitments made in the first article of the BPTA.
- Stalled Boundary Negotiations: Amidst the crisis, efforts to settle the boundary dispute have almost completely stalled.
- A Challenging Relationship: The 30-year-old border remains unsettled, mirroring the broader complexities of the India-China relationship.
Conclusion
- The BPTA reached 30 years ago, marked a significant milestone in India-China relations.
- However, its legacy remains deeply contested and fraught with ambiguities.
- As the ongoing border crisis unfolds, the challenges in achieving a lasting resolution and fostering peaceful coexistence between the two nations persist.
Get an IAS/IPS ranker as your 1: 1 personal mentor for UPSC 2024
Attend Now
Note4Students
From UPSC perspective, the following things are important :
Prelims level: POCSO Act
Mains level: Read the attached story
Central Idea
- In a recent decision, the Himachal Pradesh High Court ruled that the failure to report sexual crimes against minors is a bailable offence.
- This ruling has raised significant legal questions regarding the interpretation of the Protection of Children from Sexual Offences (POCSO) Act, particularly with respect to the nature of the offence and its implications for pre-arrest bail.
What is the POCSO Act?
- The POCSO Act came into effect on November 14, 2012, following India’s ratification of the UN Convention on the Rights of the Child in 1992.
- Its primary objective is to address offences related to the sexual exploitation and abuse of children, which were previously either not specifically defined or inadequately penalized.
- According to the Act, a child is defined as any person below the age of 18 years.
- In 2019, the Act underwent a review and amendment, introducing more stringent punishments (after Nirbhaya Case), including the death penalty, for those committing sexual crimes against children.
|
Interpretation of the POCSO Act
- Section 21 of POCSO Act: This section of the POCSO Act mandates the reporting of sexual offences against children. However, it does not explicitly specify whether the offence is bailable or not.
- Reference to CrPC: The court, in its ruling, argued that since the POCSO Act does not provide clarity on the bailability of the offence, it should be determined by referring to the Code of Criminal Procedure (CrPC).
- CrPC Classification: The CrPC classifies offences as either bailable or non-bailable based on the maximum punishment they entail. Offences punishable with imprisonment of less than three years are generally considered bailable and non-cognizable.
- POCSO Act’s Penalty: Section 21 of the POCSO Act prescribes a penalty of imprisonment ranging from 6 months to 1 year. Consequently, this makes it fall within the category of bailable offences under the CrPC.
Case Context
- Allegations: The case in question involved a hotel manager accused of failing to report an offence committed against a minor, as mandated by Section 21 of the POCSO Act.
- Main Accused: The main accused had committed a sexual assault on a minor schoolgirl and recorded a video of the incident in a hotel.
- Legal Charges: The accused faced charges under Sections 376 (Rape) and 506 (Criminal Intimidation) of the Indian Penal Code, as well as Sections 6 and 21 of the POCSO Act, which address aggravated penetrative sexual assault and the failure to report sexual crimes against children.
- Hotel Manager’s Involvement: The hotel manager was also named in the FIR due to the mandatory reporting provision under the POCSO Act.
Mandatory Reporting Under POCSO
- Section 19: Section 19 of the POCSO Act obliges “any person” who apprehends or has knowledge of a sexual offence against a child to report it to the Special Juvenile Police Unit (SJPU) or the police.
- Penalty for Non-Reporting: Section 21 of the POCSO Act prescribes a penalty, including imprisonment, for failing to report such offences.
- Exemptions: Children are not held liable for failing to report sexual offences, and those making false complaints are also exempt from punishment under Section 22 of the Act.
Supreme Court’s Perspective
- The seriousness of Non-Reporting: The Supreme Court has consistently held that the failure to report such cases is a serious crime, emphasizing the importance of reporting child sexual abuse.
- Specific Obligations: In certain cases, the Supreme Court has placed additional obligations on professionals, such as medical practitioners and educators, to report child sexual abuse cases to appropriate authorities.
Balancing Reporting Requirements with Privacy
- SC’s Balance Attempt: In a recent case (X vs The Principal Secretary, Health and Family Welfare Department, Govt of NCT of Delhi), the Supreme Court sought to balance the mandatory reporting provision under POCSO with the confidentiality provision under the Medical Termination of Pregnancy Act, 1971.
- Minors Seeking Medical Termination: The court recognized that minors may seek medical termination of pregnancies resulting from consensual sexual activity, and the mandatory reporting requirement might deter them from approaching qualified doctors.
- Harmonious Interpretation: To ensure that minors’ rights to privacy and reproductive autonomy are protected, the court advocated for a harmonious interpretation of both the POCSO Act and the Medical Termination of Pregnancy Act.
- Exemption for RMPs: The court suggested that registered medical practitioners, upon the request of minors and their guardians, can be exempted from disclosing a minor’s identity and personal details when reporting an offence under Section 19(1) of the POCSO Act or in any ensuing criminal proceedings.
Conclusion
- The Himachal Pradesh High Court’s ruling on the availability of the failure to report sexual crimes against minors has sparked discussions on the interpretation of the POCSO Act and its alignment with the CrPC.
- Furthermore, the Supreme Court’s efforts to strike a balance between mandatory reporting requirements and minors’ privacy rights underscore the complexity of addressing child sexual abuse within the legal framework.
Get an IAS/IPS ranker as your 1: 1 personal mentor for UPSC 2024
Attend Now
