💥UPSC 2027,2028 Mentorship (April Batch) + Access XFactor Notes & Microthemes PDF
Talk to mentor

Civilsdaily

Login

Type: op-ed snap

  • Parliament – Sessions, Procedures, Motions, Committees etc

    Decoding the Nyaya Sanhita Bill

    op-ed snap | Polity | Mains Paper 2: Governance, Transparency & Accountability, Citizens Charters

    Note4Students

    From UPSC perspective, the following things are important:

    Prelims level: Three key bills, provisions

    Mains level: Indian justice system reforms ,Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita Bill

    What’s the news?

    • The government recently introduced three key penal bills in a bid to reform the justice system.

    Central Idea

    • The recent introduction of three penal bills in the Lok Sabha by the government, aimed at decolonizing the Indian justice system, is a significant step in the realm of legal reform. While this initiative is commendable, it is crucial to recognize that the process of law-making and reform requires careful consideration and empirical validation.

    Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita Bill

    • This bill aims to replace the existing Indian Penal Code (IPC) of 1860.
    • The IPC defines crimes, sets out their elements, and prescribes corresponding penalties.
    • The Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita Bill seeks to update and modernize the criminal laws to better reflect evolving societal values and democratic aspirations.

    Why Public Participation Matters in Legal Reform?

    • The Colonial Legacy: Learning from Past Mistakes
      • The colonial penal law was replaced not due to inherent flaws but because it lacked participation from the Indian populace, imposing foreign ideas and values.
      • Recognizing the crucial need for broad public participation to avoid repeating this historical oversight
    • Macaulay’s Principle Revisited: Seeking Legal Certainty Through Debate
      • Reflecting on Thomas Babington Macaulay’s principle of “uniformity when you can have it, diversity where you must have it, but in all cases certainty.”
      • Emphasizing the goal of achieving equal and uniform application of the law through meaningful debate.
      • Stressing the significance of precise legal terminology for clarity and legal certainty.

    What constitutes undesirable behavior?

    • Changing Norms: The Evolution of Legal Definitions
      • Highlighting the evolving societal perceptions concerning behaviors deemed undesirable.
      • Citing examples like the transition of attempted suicide from a criminal offense to a recognized mental health issue under Section 115(1) of the Mental Health Care Act, 2017.
      • Examining the Supreme Court’s role in redefining adultery and its legal implications
    • From Offense to Health Issue: The Case of Attempted Suicide
      • Illustrating the transformation of attempted suicide from a crime to a mental health concern, reflecting a more compassionate and holistic approach.
    • Challenging Tradition: Adultery and the Supreme Court Decision
      • Analyzing the Supreme Court’s decision to redefine adultery and emphasizing the judiciary’s role in adapting to evolving social norms
    • The Call for Social Audit: Rethinking “Undesirable” Behavior
      • Advocating for a comprehensive social audit to redefine the concept of “undesirable” behavior, taking into account changing societal perspectives.
      • Stressing the importance of empirical analysis in this process.
    • Independent Oversight: The Need for Impartiality
      • underscoring the necessity of an independent and impartial body to conduct the social audit to ensure fairness and objectivity in evaluating behavioral norms.

    How to Balance Simplicity and Complexity in Penal Laws?

    • Simplification’s Promise: Streamlining the Legal Framework
      • Acknowledging efforts to simplify the legal framework through the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita and highlighting potential benefits like enhanced clarity and efficiency in legal procedures.
    • The Challenge of Overload: Retaining and Adding Offenses
      • Addressing concerns about the risk of retaining and introducing new offenses, which could offset the advantages of simplification and potentially overwhelm the legal system.
    • Revisiting Special Laws: The Malimath Committee’s Proposal
      • Noting the proliferation of special penal laws post-Indian Penal Code to address emerging crimes.
      • Suggesting an evaluation of whether these should be incorporated into the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita or managed through existing special laws or a new composite law, as proposed by the Malimath Committee.

    Addressing Gender and Children’s Rights: What the Bill Says?

    • Constitutional Alignment: Article 15(3) and Article 51A(e)
      • Recognizing the alignment of the proposed Offenses Against Women and Children’ with the constitutional vision, specifically referencing Article 15(3) and Article 51A(e),
    • Outdated Notions: Analyzing Clause 63 on Marital Rape
      • Highlighting concerns with Clause 63, which excludes sexual intercourse between spouses above 18 from the definition of rape, and drawing parallels with colonial-era legal thinking
    • Contradictory Provisions: Clauses 20 and 21 vs. Juvenile Justice Act of 2015
      • Pointing out inconsistencies between retaining Clauses 20 and 21 in Chapter III (General Exceptions) and the philosophy of special laws for children outlined in Section 1(4) of the Juvenile Justice Act of 2015.

    What does the new penal law prioritize?

    • A Shift in Focus: Departing from the Colonial Framework
      • Recognizing a departure from the colonial chapter scheme that favored the interests of the ruling class over body and property offenses.
      • Placing bodily interests in Chapter VI, just before offenses against the state, indicating a significant shift in priorities.
    • Measuring against the Constitution: Article 13(2)
      • Raising questions about whether the proposed reforms will align with the constitutional vision enshrined in Article 13(2), which prohibits laws that infringe upon fundamental rights.
    • Upholding Values: Autonomy, Equality, and Fraternity
      • Highlighting the vital role of the proposed reforms in upholding principles of autonomy, equality, and fraternity as guaranteed by the Preamble of the Constitution

    Conclusion

    • The government’s initiative to reform the Indian justice system is laudable, but it must be accompanied by extensive public participation, a thorough examination of undesirable behavior, and a balanced approach to legal complexity. Only through careful consideration and a commitment to justice can the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita Bill truly decolonize and rejuvenate the Indian justice system.

    Get an IAS/IPS ranker as your 1: 1 personal mentor

  • BRICS Summits

    The implications of the expansion of BRICS

    op-ed snap | International Relations | Mains Paper 2: Bilateral, Regional and Global Groupings and agreements involving India

    Note4Students

    From UPSC perspective, the following things are important:

    Prelims level: BRICS

    Mains level: BRICS Expansion and significance

    What’s the news?

    • The 15th BRICS summit held in Johannesburg recently made headlines with its announcement to expand its membership.

    Central idea

    • The 15th BRICS summit in Johannesburg made waves in international diplomacy when it announced the invitation of six new members: Iran, Saudi Arabia, the United Arab Emirates (UAE), Egypt, Ethiopia, and Argentina. This move signifies BRICS’ commitment to challenging the West-dominated world order and building a more representative international system.

    Expanding BRICS: A New Global Landscape

    • The expansion of BRICS to include Iran, Saudi Arabia, the United Arab Emirates (UAE), Egypt, Ethiopia, and Argentina
    • It was reported that 40 countries have shown interest in BRICS’ membership, with 22 having submitted formal applications.
    • BRICS has been a platform for emerging economies to voice their dissatisfaction with Western-dominated global institutions like the World Bank, IMF, and UN.
    • At the Johannesburg summit, the UN Secretary General labeled these institutions of yesterday’s world, reflecting the need for change.
    • With the inclusion of new members, BRICS now represents 46% of the world’s population and 37% of the global GDP in PPP terms, surpassing the G-7.
    • This expansion also greatly impacts the energy sector, with the BRICS now accounting for 42% of global oil production.

    Significance of BRICS Expansion

    • Economic Clout: The BRICS’ share of global GDP in PPP terms rises from 31.5% to 37%, surpassing the G-7. This expansion creates a formidable economic bloc with the potential to shape global economic policies and trade dynamics.
    • Demographic Powerhouse: The BRICS now represent 46% of the world’s population, giving them significant demographic weight. This diverse population can influence global consumer markets and labor forces.
    • Energy Dominance: The inclusion of new members from energy-rich regions, especially West Asia, boosts BRICS’ role in global energy markets. It solidifies BRICS as a major player in shaping global energy policies.
    • Geo-Strategic Influence: West Asian members already have strong ties with BRICS countries, contributing to the group’s geo-strategic significance. Egypt and Ethiopia hold key positions in the Horn of Africa and the Red Sea region, adding to BRICS’ strategic reach.
    • Shared Political Views: BRICS members have historically shared political views on global issues. The new members’ alignment with these views strengthens BRICS’ collective stance on the United Nations, Middle East conflicts, and global terrorism.
    • Multipolar Advocacy: BRICS challenges the Western-dominated international order. The expansion reaffirms BRICS’ commitment to advocating for a multipolar world order and reforming global institutions.
    • Cooperative Opportunities: The inclusion of new members opens avenues for increased cooperation in areas such as trade, investment, infrastructure, and technology transfer. This expansion promotes South-South collaboration.
    • Global Balance Shift: BRICS’ expansion further shifts the global balance of power away from Western-dominated institutions. It elevates the influence of emerging economies in shaping global policies.

    BRICS’ Substantial Achievements

    • Consistent Declarations: BRICS leaders have met for over 15 years, consistently overcoming internal divisions and competitions to issue consensual “Declarations” at each summit. These declarations have expanded in content, reflecting the group’s evolving priorities and interests.
    • Focus on Specific Deliverables: The declarations have increasingly focused on specific deliverables, indicating BRICS’ commitment to achieving tangible outcomes. This shift from broad rhetoric to concrete action is a substantial achievement.
    • Intra-BRICS Cooperation: The Johannesburg Declaration emphasizes the importance of intra-BRICS cooperation. Member countries are committed to encouraging the use of local currencies in internal trade and financial transactions, promoting economic integration within the group.
    • Outreach to Developing Nations: BRICS recognizes its role in supporting other developing nations. The group aims to extend its cooperation beyond its borders, reaching out to other countries that share similar development challenges.
    • Shared Political Views: BRICS members have a history of sharing common political views on various global issues. This shared perspective strengthens their collective voice on matters such as the centrality of the United Nations, conflicts in the Middle East, and global terrorism.
    • Promoting Multipolarity: BRICS challenges the Western-dominated international order by advocating for a multipolar world. This advocacy represents a substantial achievement in pushing for reforms and greater representation for emerging economies in global institutions.

    Criticisms directed at the BRICS

    • Talk-Shop with No Vision: Some Western commentators have criticized BRICS as being a talk-shop with no clear shared vision or meaningful achievements. This criticism suggests that BRICS meetings and declarations may lack substance and practical outcomes.
    • Lack of Shared Vision: Critics argue that BRICS members have not demonstrated a cohesive or unified vision for the group’s role in global affairs. This criticism implies that the members may have divergent interests that hinder effective cooperation.
    • Limited Achievements: Some critics have suggested that BRICS has not achieved significant or tangible results in its over 15 years of existence. This criticism questions the group’s ability to translate its discussions into meaningful actions or outcomes.
    • Emerging Global Binary Divide: While not explicitly mentioned in the article, there is an implied criticism that BRICS may contribute to an emerging global binary divide or a new cold war between Western and non-Western nations. This view suggests that BRICS could exacerbate global divisions rather than promote cooperation.

    Outlook for Regional Affairs

    • West Asia:
    • The new BRICS members from West Asia, such as Saudi Arabia and the UAE, have pursued independent foreign policy paths since 2020.
    • Saudi Arabia, for instance, has actively engaged in de-escalation efforts, including ending the Qatar blockade in January 2021, establishing relations with Turkey, and initiating interactions with Iran in April 2021.
    • These diplomatic engagements culminated in a significant China-brokered accord with Iran in March of the following year.
    • Maritime Expansion: The UAE has also normalized ties with Iran and is actively expanding its maritime presence across key strategic regions, including the Gulf, the Gulf of Aden, the Red Sea, and the Horn of Africa. This maritime expansion underscores the UAE’s growing influence in these areas.

    Outlook for Global Affairs

    • Rejecting the Binary Divide:
    • In contrast to Western commentators who perceive an emerging global binary divide or a new cold war, India and other BRICS members reject this view.
    • They insist on asserting their strategic autonomy within a multipolar world order, rejecting the idea of being drawn into simplistic global power struggles.
    • Historical Significance:
    • A recent media report described the Johannesburg summit as a turning point in modern history.
    • This suggests that the expansion of BRICS, combined with its evolving role in global affairs, is seen as a pivotal and historic moment with profound implications for the contemporary international landscape.

    Conclusion

    • BRICS continues to assert its strategic autonomy and push for a multipolar world order, challenging Western-led international institutions. This expansion is a turning point in modern history, reflecting the evolving dynamics of global diplomacy.

    Get an IAS/IPS ranker as your 1: 1 personal mentor

  • Cashless Society – Digital Payments, Demonetization, etc.

    UPI QR Code-Central Bank Digital Currency interoperability: How does it work and how do customers benefit?

    op-ed snap | Economics | Mains Paper 3: Indian Economy,S&T – Applications In Everyday Life

    Note4Students

    From UPSC perspective, the following things are important:

    Prelims level: UPI, QR Code-CBDC and applications

    Mains level: UPI QR Code-CBDC interoperability, significance and benefits

    interoperability

    What’s the news?

    • The fusion of UPI and CBDC is an essential component of the Reserve Bank of India’s (RBI) ongoing pilot project aimed at propelling the retail digital rupee.

    Central idea

    • Banks are boosting digital rupee (e₹-R) adoption by integrating UPI QR codes with CBDC or e₹ apps. Users can now scan any UPI QR code for transactions, while merchants can accept digital rupee payments using their existing UPI QR codes.

    Definition- Interoperability

    • Interoperability, as defined by the RBI, is the technical compatibility that enables a payment system to operate harmoniously with other payment systems.
    • This fosters the seamless execution, clearance, and settlement of payment transactions across diverse systems.
    • The synergy between payment systems contributes to fostering adoption, coexistence, innovation, and efficiency for end-users.

    Understanding QR Codes

    • A Quick Response (QR) code is a pattern of black squares arranged in a grid on a white background, interpretable by imaging devices like cameras. It carries information about the attached item.
    • This versatile tool provides an alternative contactless payment channel, allowing merchants to directly receive payments into their bank accounts.

    What is a Central Bank Digital Currency (CBDC)?

    • CBDC is a legal tender issued by the central bank in digital form. Like rupee notes or coins, which are in physical form.
    • Simply put, it’s just like rupee (₹) notes but in digital form (e₹). You can also exchange e₹ for physical currency notes.
    • However, unlike fiat currency that’s usually stored in banks and hence their liability, CBDC is a liability on the RBI’s balance sheet. That’s why you don’t necessarily need to have a bank account to own a digital rupee.

    What is the Unified Payments Interface (UPI)?

    • UPI is India’s mobile-based fast payment system, which enables customers to make round-the-clock payments instantly using a virtual payment address (VPA) created by the customer.
    • It eliminates the risk of the remitter sharing bank account details with the remitter.
    • UPI supports both Person-to-Person (P2P) and Person-to-Merchant (P2M) payments, and it also enables a user to send or receive money.

    The interoperability between UPI and CBDC

    • The interoperability between UPI and CBDC introduces the concept of UPI QR code-CBDC interoperability. This entails the compatibility of all UPI QR codes with CBDC applications.
    • In the pilot phase of the retail digital rupee, e₹-R users had to scan a specific QR code for transactions. However, with UPI-CBDC interoperability, transactions can now be initiated using a single QR code.
    • The digital rupee, a tokenized digital variant of the rupee, is issued by the RBI as CBDC. The e₹ is stored within a digital wallet linked to a customer’s existing savings bank account, while the UPI directly connects to the customer’s account.

    Significance of Interoperability

    • Enhanced User Experience: Interoperability simplifies the payment process, allowing users to seamlessly make transactions using any UPI QR code. This eliminates the inconvenience of switching between multiple payment apps or systems, enhancing user satisfaction.
    • Accelerated Adoption of the Digital Rupee: Leveraging the popularity of UPI, interoperability promotes the adoption of the retail digital rupee. This aligns with the government’s objectives to drive digital currency usage and reduce reliance on physical cash.
    • Merchant-Friendly: Merchants benefit from this interoperability as it eliminates the need for them to manage a separate QR code for digital rupee payments. This lowers the entry barrier for merchants to accept digital currency, making it more accessible to a wider range of businesses.
    • Expanding Financial Inclusion: Interoperability has the potential to extend financial inclusion efforts, particularly in underserved regions. Users and merchants with limited exposure to digital payments can now participate more easily in the digital economy.
    • Efficiency and Cost Savings: For both users and merchants, interoperability reduces the operational costs associated with maintaining multiple payment platforms. It simplifies accounting and transaction management for businesses.

    How will it drive CBDC adoption?

    • Presently, UPI is a widely used payment method. The interoperability between UPI and CBDC is poised to accelerate the adoption of the digital rupee.
    • With over 70 mobile apps and 50 million merchants accepting UPI payments, the existing UPI ecosystem sets the stage for the retail digital rupee’s growth.
    • The RBI reported 1.3 million customers and 0.3 million merchants using e₹-R in July, with daily transactions ranging from 5,000 to 10,000.
    • Prominent banks, including State Bank of India, Bank of Baroda, Kotak Mahindra Bank, Yes Bank, Axis Bank, HDFC Bank, and IDFC First Bank, have introduced UPI interoperability on their digital rupee applications.

    interoperability

    Benefits for Users

    • Seamless Transactions: Users can effortlessly execute digital rupee transactions by scanning any UPI QR code, eliminating the need for multiple apps or QR codes for different transactions.
    • Wider Acceptance: Users are no longer restricted to specific QR codes; they can utilize their digital wallets linked to UPI for transactions at various merchants, increasing flexibility.
    • Financial Inclusion: Interoperability ensures that users, including those in remote areas, can easily access and use the digital rupee without specialized infrastructure or additional QR codes, promoting financial inclusion.
    • Reduced Transaction Costs: Users can avoid extra fees associated with using multiple payment platforms. Interoperability makes digital rupee transactions more cost-effective.
    • Streamlined Wallet Management: Users can consolidate their digital transactions within a single digital wallet, simplifying financial management.

    Benefits for Merchants

    • Ease of Adoption: Merchants can accept digital rupee payments without the complexity of creating and maintaining a separate QR code for CBDC, simplifying onboarding for businesses, including small retailers.
    • Expanded Customer Base: With interoperability, merchants can cater to a broader range of customers using digital rupees, regardless of whether customers possess a specific QR code.
    • Reduced Infrastructure Costs: Merchants save on expenses related to setting up and maintaining additional payment infrastructure, such as separate QR codes or payment terminals.
    • Efficient Settlement: The integration allows for efficient settlement of digital rupee payments, whether or not the merchant has a CBDC account. This ensures prompt and secure payment receipts for merchants.
    • Increased Sales: Simplified payment options often lead to smoother and quicker checkouts, potentially boosting customer satisfaction and increasing sales for merchants.

    Conclusion

    • The convergence of UPI and CBDC through interoperability marks a transformative phase in the realm of digital payments. With the fusion of two powerful platforms, the retail digital rupee is poised to gain widespread adoption, revolutionizing the landscape of digital transactions in India.

    Also read:

    India’s Central bank digital currency (CBDC) in detail

     

    Get an IAS/IPS ranker as your 1: 1 personal mentor

  • Climate Change Impact on India and World – International Reports, Key Observations, etc.

    Emerging countries need women-led climate action

    op-ed snap | Enviro & Biodiversity | Mains Paper 1: Important Geophysical Phenomena

    Note4Students

    From UPSC perspective, the following things are important:

    Prelims level: Climate change

    Mains level: Climate Change and its Impact on Women, gender equality and environmental sustainability

    climate

    What’s the news?

    • In the current era, the fusion of gender equality and environmental sustainability presents a dynamic duo that holds the key to accelerating the achievement of the Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs).

    Central Idea

    • The Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD) aptly points out that gender equality and environmental goals are not isolated endeavors; they forge a symbiotic relationship that can amplify progress towards a sustainable future.

    Vulnerability in a Changing Climate

    • Climate change, a pressing global concern, has repercussions that reverberate across demographics, with women bearing a disproportionate brunt of its impact.
    • The International Labour Organization (ILO, 2019) forecasts that by 2030, scorching temperatures will result in a 2.2% loss of global working hours—equivalent to 80 million full-time jobs.
    • The United Nations (2009) highlighted that across genders, women are considered to be more vulnerable and disproportionately affected by climate change than men.
    • Estimates project that by 2050, climate change risks, coupled with natural disasters and food inflation, could push 130 million people into poverty, disproportionately affecting women’s inequality.

    Climate Change and its Impact on Women, Particularly in Low-Income Countries

    • Gendered Vulnerability in Low-Income Countries:
    • Women across the globe face heightened risks to their health, safety, and quality of life. Yet, the vulnerability is notably more pronounced in developing and less developed countries, especially those grappling with low-income realities.
    • This vulnerability is rooted in their reliance on natural resources and labor-intensive work, making them more susceptible to climate change impacts.
    • A crucial aspect of this vulnerability lies in the interconnectedness of poverty and climate change.
    • Climate Crisis Intensifying Basic Needs Struggles:
    • Rural women, in particular, are burdened with the responsibility of ensuring access to essentials like clean water, cooking fuel, and nutritious food for their families.
    • This often involves arduous journeys and exposes them to health and safety risks.
    • Underpaid and Overworked:
    • Despite their pivotal role in food production systems, women engaged in agriculture face persistent challenges.
    • Data from the International Labour Organization (ILO) highlights that over 60% of working women in southern Asia and sub-Saharan Africa are in agriculture. Unfortunately, they often receive inadequate pay and work under challenging conditions.
    • Owning Land: A Gender Disparity:
    • A significant gender disparity exists in land ownership, with women owning only a small fraction of cultivated land.
    • Despite being the backbone of the food production system, women own only about 10% of the land used for farming.
    • This discrepancy further diminishes their resilience against the impacts of climate change.
    • Projected Displacement and Urgent Action:
    • As a grim outlook, studies like McAllister’s 2023 research forecast a potentially staggering 1.2 billion climate refugees by 2050.
    • This underscores the urgency of addressing these intertwined challenges.

    Gender-specific issues

    • Displacement and Vulnerability: A UN study reveals a stark reality – a substantial 80% of those displaced by climate-related disasters are women and girls.
    • Challenges for Vulnerable Women: Women, especially from marginalized communities, grapple with distinct challenges in the aftermath of natural disasters. Their displacement increases their susceptibility to prejudice and exploitation, exacerbating the hardships they already face.
    • Exploitation Post-Disasters: The disruption caused by disasters creates an environment ripe for exploitation, with women as primary targets. Notably, the aftermath of the 2015 Nepal earthquake exposed women to trafficking and exploitation, further highlighting the risks they face.
    • Gender-Based Violence Intensifies: The upheaval following disasters leads to an alarming escalation of gender-based violence against women. Disrupted communities and increased vulnerability create an environment where women are at greater risk.
    • Limited Access to Essential Services: Essential services like employment, education, healthcare, and psychosocial support become scarcer post-disaster. For women, this translates into further limitations and challenges, exacerbating their already marginalized status.
    • Resource and Knowledge Disparities: Women in agriculture face barriers in accessing quality resources, education, and technical knowledge. As climate change compounds these challenges, their vulnerability is magnified.

    Way Forward: Empowering Women for Climate Resilience and Action

    • Women’s Role in Climate Adaptation: Acknowledging the potential women possess to contribute to climate adaptation is crucial. Women bring unique perspectives and knowledge to the table, making their engagement indispensable in finding effective solutions.
    • Empowerment Through Education and Training: Investing in women’s education and training is paramount for building resilience to the impact of climate change. Equipping women with the knowledge and skills needed for sustainable practices, such as agriculture, water management, and energy generation, fosters their capacity to adapt to changing conditions.
    • Supporting Women Farmers: Initiatives like the Self-Employed Women’s Association (SEWA) in India exemplify the importance of imparting knowledge to women farmers on how to navigate shifting climate patterns.
    • Women in Climate Policy Decision-Making: Acknowledging the disparities women face in climate change impacts, the need for their active involvement in decision-making becomes evident.
    • Programs to Amplify Women’s Voices: Initiatives like the Gender and Climate Change Development Programme in South Asia seek to elevate women’s influence in policymaking, granting them a stronger voice in shaping climate strategies that directly impact their lives.
    • Global Imperative for Women-Led Climate Action: The call for women-led climate action is not confined to specific regions; it’s a global imperative. Developing and emerging countries, where women often bear the brunt of climate impacts, necessitate collective efforts to empower women as agents of change.

    Conclusion

    • The convergence of gender equality and environmental sustainability is no longer an abstract concept; it is a tangible pathway towards a more equitable and resilient world. In a future marred by climate uncertainty, investments in women’s education, training, and participation stand as beacons of hope.

    Get an IAS/IPS ranker as your 1: 1 personal mentor

  • One Nation, One Election: Prospects and Challenges

    What is the debate around ‘one nation, one election’?

    op-ed snap | Polity | Mains Paper 2: Federalism,Indian Constitution – historical underpinnings, evolution, features, amendments, significant provisions and basic structure

    Note4Students

    From UPSC perspective, the following things are important:

    Prelims level: Election- Constitutional provisions

    Mains level: One nation, one election plan, advantages and concerns and challenges and federalism

    What’s the news?

    • The government forms a committee to explore the possibility of One Nation, One Election.

    Central idea

    • On September 1st, the Central government established a committee chaired by former President Ram Nath Kovind to assess the viability of the ‘one nation, one election’ (ONOE) proposal. This concept revolves around synchronizing the timing of Lok Sabha and State Assembly elections across all states to reduce the frequency of electoral processes across the country.

    What is the ONOE plan?

    • Concept: The ONOE plan aims to synchronize the timing of the Lok Sabha and State Assembly elections across all states in India to reduce the frequency of election cycles nationwide.
    • Historical Context:
      • After the enforcement of the Constitution on January 26, 1950, the first-ever general elections for both the Lok Sabha and State Assemblies occurred simultaneously in 1951-1952.
      • This practice continued for the following three Lok Sabha elections until 1967, streamlining the election process.
    • Disruption:
      • In 1959, the cycle was disrupted as the Central government invoked Article 356 of the Constitution, leading to the dismissal of the Kerala government, due to a perceived failure of constitutional machinery.
      • Subsequent to 1960, defections and counter-defections among political parties led to the dissolution of several State Legislative Assemblies.
      • This fragmentation resulted in separate election cycles for the Lok Sabha and State Assemblies.
    • Current Scenario: Presently, only specific States such as Arunachal Pradesh, Sikkim, Andhra Pradesh, and Odisha conduct their assembly polls concurrently with the Lok Sabha elections.

    Reports and Perspectives on ONOE

    • Law Commission of India (LCI) Report – 2018:
    • The LCI, led by Justice B. S. Chauhan, issued a draft report in August 2018 that scrutinized simultaneous elections.
    • The report acknowledged the constitutional and legal complexities surrounding this proposal.
    • It emphasized that the current constitutional framework necessitates amendments for the plan to be realized.
    • The LCI also recommended seeking approval from at least 50% of the States for such an overhaul.
    • Despite feasibility challenges, the report recognized potential benefits, including cost savings, reduced administrative burden, timely policy execution, and focused governance.
    • Historical Context – LCI Report 1999:
    • Notably, the LCI, headed by Justice B. P. Jeevan Reddy, supported the concept of simultaneous elections as early as 1999.
    • This historical context underscores that the idea has been debated over time.
    • Balancing Perspectives:
    • The reports and perspectives reveal a dualistic landscape: ONOE offers advantages like efficient governance and reduced election strain, but it’s hampered by practical and constitutional complexities.
    • In assessing ONOE’s viability, the focus is on a well-rounded understanding that considers both the potential benefits and the intricate challenges.

    Concerns Regarding the One Nation, One Election Plan

    • Feasibility and Constitutional Implications:
      • The Constitution outlines fixed tenures (Article 83(2) and 172) for the Lok Sabha and State Assemblies, raising doubts about the feasibility of simultaneous elections.
      • The possibility of mid-term government collapse necessitates a clear mechanism for holding fresh elections or imposing the President’s rule.
    • Federalism and Conceptual Incompatibility:
      • ONOE seems to conflict with the federal structure, contradicting the idea of India as a Union of States (Article 1).
      • Altering this balance might affect the autonomy and authority of state governments.
    • Frequency, Accountability, and Blending of Issues:
      • Frequent elections allow citizens to address national and state issues separately, enhancing accountability.
      • ONOE’s merging of issues might dilute accountability mechanisms and lead to a less-focused governance approach.
    • Cost Misconceptions:
      • While the Central government highlights the substantial costs of frequent elections, critics argue that the actual expenses are not as massive.
      • The analysis questions whether the Election Commission’s expenditure of ₹8,000 crore over five years, amounting to ₹1,500 crore annually or ₹27 per voter per year, is a significant expense for maintaining India’s democratic pride.

    Way forward

    • Comprehensive Constitutional Review:
      • Engage legal experts to meticulously assess necessary constitutional amendments for ONOE.
      • Develop a contingency plan to handle midterm government collapses, ensuring stability and smooth transitions.
    • Balancing Federalism and Centralization:
      • Initiate dialogues with state governments to understand and address their concerns about centralization.
      • Craft a balanced framework that respects both federal principles and national electoral efficiency.
    • Hybrid Accountability Model:
      • Explore a hybrid approach that retains staggered elections for select states while implementing ONOE for others.
      • Maintain distinct accountability mechanisms for national and state issues, promoting effective governance.
    • Transparent Cost-Benefit Analysis:
      • Conduct an independent and transparent assessment of the costs and savings associated with ONOE.
      • Present factual data to address misconceptions and inform stakeholders about the financial implications.
    • Pilots and Gradual Implementation:
      • Begin ONOE implementation through pilot projects in a limited number of states.
      • Assess challenges, gather insights, and refine the approach before nationwide adoption.

    Conclusion

    • The proposal for one nation, one election envisions synchronizing Lok Sabha and State Assembly elections to curtail the frequency of polls. The Indian democracy’s complex dynamics and diverse contexts warrant a comprehensive assessment before implementing such a transformative change.

    Get an IAS/IPS ranker as your 1: 1 personal mentor

  • Hunger and Nutrition Issues – GHI, GNI, etc.

    The State Hunger Index (SHI)

    op-ed snap | Economics | Mains Paper 3: Inclusive Growth & Issues,Issues relating growth and development, employment

    Note4Students

    From UPSC perspective, the following things are important:

    Prelims level: Global Hunger Index,

    Mains level: GHI, Subnational Analysis, India's Calorie Undernourishment challenge, efforts and way forward

    What’s the news?

    • Despite boasting the world’s largest public distribution system and comprehensive food security schemes, India’s standing on the Global Hunger Index (GHI) remains alarming.

    Central idea

    • The 2022 GHI ranked India a staggering 107 out of 121 nations, trailing behind Nigeria (103) and Pakistan (99). The GHI, encompassing calorie undernourishment, child malnutrition, and under-five mortality dimensions, highlights India’s ongoing battle against these challenges.

    Extent of the Issue

    • The State of Food Security and Nutrition in the World report for 2022 reveals a staggering statistic – India is home to approximately 224.3 million undernourished individuals.
    • Alarming disparities surface among various states, prompting the utilization of subnational data to develop a more nuanced and localized hunger index.
    • By harnessing such data, India can assess the extent of undernourishment at the state and union territory level, a crucial step towards achieving the Sustainable Development Goals aimed at eradicating hunger and malnutrition.

    The State Hunger Index (SHI)

    • Indicators: The SHI is derived from the Global Hunger Index (GHI) framework, utilizing four main indicators:
      • Prevalence of stunting, wasting, and under-five mortality among children below five years of age.
      • Body Mass Index (BMI) undernourishment among the working-age population.
    • Calorie Undernourishment Replacement: Calorie undernourishment, a GHI indicator, is replaced by BMI undernourishment due to data unavailability post-2012.
    • Data Sources: SHI calculations involve data from various sources, including:
      • National Family Health Survey (NFHS-5)
      • Longitudinal Ageing Study in India (LASI)
    • Calculation: Normalized values of the indicators are combined using techniques recommended by the GHI.
    • Score Range and Categories:
      • SHI scores range from 0 to 100.
      • Higher scores indicate higher hunger levels.
      • The categories of SHI scores are as follows:
        • Below 10: Low hunger
        • 10-20: Moderate hunger
        • 20-30: Serious hunger
        • 30-40: Alarming hunger
        • 50 or above: Extremely alarming hunger

    Findings of the State Hunger Index (SHI)

    • Alarming Hunger Levels: States like Bihar, Jharkhand, and Chhattisgarh have alarmingly high SHI scores of 35, indicating significant hunger levels.
    • Moderate Hunger Levels: States such as Gujarat, Uttar Pradesh, Assam, Odisha, Madhya Pradesh, Tripura, Maharashtra, and West Bengal score above the national average (29), indicating moderate hunger levels.
    • Lower Hunger Levels: Chandigarh stands out with a notably low SHI score of 12, suggesting relatively lower hunger levels.
    • Moderate Hunger Category: States like Sikkim, Puducherry, and Kerala have SHI scores below 16, placing them in the ‘moderate hunger’ category.
    • Serious Hunger Concerns: Several states score below the national average but above 20, pointing to serious hunger challenges in these regions.

    Calorie Undernourishment: A Critical Challenge

    • Deteriorating GHI Score: Over the past few years, India’s Global Hunger Index (GHI) score has worsened primarily due to the increasing prevalence of calorie undernourishment. This underscores the urgent need to address this challenge effectively.
    • Escalating Proportions: Data from the Food and Agriculture Organization reveals that the proportion of calorie undernourishment has been on the rise since 2017, reaching a concerning 16.3% in 2020. This trend mirrors statistics from over a decade ago, such as those from 2009.
    • Government Disputes and Data Concerns: Despite these alarming figures, the Indian government has raised doubts about the accuracy of the data and methodologies employed in calculating the GHI. However, the absence of empirical evidence to support these disputes leaves room for further clarity.
    • Data Limitations: Notably, a challenge in understanding the scale of calorie undernourishment stems from the lack of recent National Sample Survey (NSS) rounds on nutritional intake since 2011-12. This survey previously offered insights into the prevalence of undernourishment at both national and subnational levels.
    • Impact on Health and Development: Calorie undernourishment directly affects health and development, leading to weakened immune systems, stunted growth, impaired cognitive development, and increased susceptibility to diseases.
    • Economic and Social Implications: The persistence of calorie undernourishment has far-reaching socio-economic consequences, hindering productivity, reducing human capital potential, and perpetuating the cycle of poverty.

    Way forward

    • Urgent Focus on Calorie Undernourishment: Recognize the urgent need to address calorie undernourishment, which has contributed to India’s declining GHI score.
    • Reviving NSS Rounds: Prioritize conducting new National Sample Survey (NSS) rounds on nutritional intake to obtain updated and accurate data on undernourishment levels.
    • Evidence-Based Approach: Encourage the Indian government to substantiate their concerns about GHI data accuracy with empirical evidence.
    • Collaborative Efforts: Collaborate between government agencies, NGOs, researchers, and communities to formulate and implement targeted strategies.
    • Alignment with SDGs: Align efforts with Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs), particularly Goal 2 focused on eradicating hunger and malnutrition.

    Conclusion

    • While the GHI is not immune to criticism regarding its methodology and aggregation techniques, it remains a critical tool for gauging undernourishment and child nutrition. Despite strides in reducing extreme poverty, disparities persist in addressing food insecurity, hunger, and child malnutrition. India must prioritize targeted interventions to overcome these challenges and fulfill its commitment to sustainable development.

    Get an IAS/IPS ranker as your 1: 1 personal mentor

  • Economic Indicators and Various Reports On It- GDP, FD, EODB, WIR etc

    China’s economic slowdown, its ripple effect

    op-ed snap | Economics | Mains Paper 3: Effects Of Liberalization On The Economy, Changes In Industrial Policy and their effects on Industrial Growth

    Note4Students

    From UPSC perspective, the following things are important:

    Prelims level: NA

    Mains level: China’s economic slowdown, its ripple effect, Economic Growth Comparison with India

    Central Idea

    • The recent news of China’s economic slowdown has sparked a range of responses. China’s concerns about stagnation and the middle-income trap have shifted to fears of deflation, raising global implications. To comprehend the root causes and gravity of China’s current economic dilemmas, it is crucial.

    Background: Unstable Growth and Strategic Choices

    • Premier Wen Jiabao’s Concerns (2007): Premier Wen Jiabao raised alarms in 2007, highlighting instability, imbalances, a lack of coordination, and unsustainability as China’s economic challenges.
    • 2008 Global Financial Crisis Strategy: China responded to the 2008 crisis by investing heavily in infrastructure (railways, highways, energy, and construction) to maintain double-digit growth and stabilize the economy.
    • Deferred Structural Issues: While this strategy spurred growth, it deferred addressing issues like low consumption, regional disparities, and inadequate social security measures.
    • Leadership Imperative for Growth: The need to sustain prosperity for domestic legitimacy drove China’s focus on high growth rates, even if it meant overlooking structural concerns.

    Current Realities

    • Transition to the New Normal: President Xi Jinping’s 2017 shift focused on quality-of-life issues, acknowledging the limitations of export-driven, investment-heavy growth.
    • Acceptance of Slower Growth: China entered the new normal, accepting slower growth rates and requiring adjustments in economic expectations.
    • Challenges in Transition: Slower export growth due to rising labor costs from increased wages and social security investments led to unemployment challenges.
    • Balancing Priorities in the New Normal: Adapting to the “new normal” entails managing the delicate balance between sustainable growth, addressing structural issues, and maintaining social stability.

    Escalating Challenges and the Evergrande Crisis

    • Trade War and De-risking Impact: The escalation of challenges was fueled by the impact of the US-China trade war and the implementation of de-risking strategies. These factors introduced complexities to China’s economic landscape.
    • Evergrande Crisis Unveiled: The Evergrande crisis, spanning from 2020 to 2023, emerged as a significant event exposing vulnerabilities within China’s housing sector. The crisis highlighted potential issues of misregulation and systemic risk.
    • Path-Dependency Concerns: The Evergrande crisis exacerbated concerns about China’s economic dependence. The fear of a crash landing became more pronounced, underscoring the importance of addressing structural challenges.
    • Complexity of Structural Problems: The challenges faced by Evergrande shed light on broader structural issues present within China’s economy. The crisis revealed the intricate interplay of development challenges and regulatory oversights.
    • Policy Implications and Regulatory Oversight: The Evergrande crisis triggered discussions about the need for stronger regulatory oversight and effective policy responses. Stabilizing the housing market has emerged as a critical concern for the government.

    China’s economic slowdown and its ripple effect

    • Global Trade Impact: China’s economic slowdown has implications for global trade. As one of the world’s largest economies and trading partners, China’s reduced economic activity affects international trade flows, impacting both suppliers and consumers worldwide.
    • Commodity Markets: The slowdown has led to decreased demand for commodities such as crude oil, cement, and steel. China’s status as a major consumer in these markets has caused a cooling of prices, impacting countries that rely on exporting these commodities.
    • Supply Chain Disruptions: China plays a critical role in global supply chains. Its economic slowdown and disruptions in production have affected supply chain dynamics, causing delays and disruptions for companies worldwide.
    • Investor Sentiments: China’s economic challenges have led to cautious investor sentiments. Uncertainties about the Chinese economy have influenced global financial markets and investment decisions.
    • Global Economic Growth: China’s slowdown contributes to lower global economic growth rates. The country’s reduced demand for goods and services affects other economies, particularly those that heavily depend on exports to China.
    • Regional Trade Partners: Neighboring countries that have strong economic ties with China, such as those in Asia, are directly impacted by China’s slowdown. Reduced demand for their exports to China affects their economies as well.
    • Currency Exchange Rates: China’s economic slowdown can impact currency exchange rates. Fluctuations in China’s economic performance can influence the value of its currency, affecting exchange rates globally.

    Future Outlook

    • State-Owned Enterprises (SoEs) Challenges: State-owned enterprises, due to preferential treatment and political networks, pose ongoing challenges. Their resistance to change and reliance on political influence can hinder necessary reforms for economic growth.
    • Evergrande Crisis and Systemic Issues: The Evergrande crisis exposed vulnerabilities within China’s housing sector and revealed potential systemic issues. Addressing these challenges is crucial to preventing further disruptions in the economy.
    • Middle-Income Trap and Value Chain Advancement: The looming middle-income trap poses a dilemma for China’s economic trajectory. To avoid stagnation, China must navigate this challenge and advance its position in the global value chain, which requires innovation and upgrading industries.
    • Economic Growth Comparison with India: Despite the challenges, China’s projected 5% growth rate still surpasses India’s anticipated 6.1% growth rate. China’s size and economic influence make this growth rate significant and impactful on global markets.

    Conclusion

    • China’s economic challenges underscore the need for strategic decisions in a shifting landscape. Achieving growth while addressing internal imbalances and global uncertainties remains a formidable task. As China’s economy evolves, its choices will resonate on the international stage, reshaping the perception of its rise and risk appetite.

     

    Get an IAS/IPS ranker as your 1: 1 personal mentor

  • Uniform Civil Code: Triple Talaq debate, Polygamy issue, etc.

    A progressive UCC must protect the child’s best interests

    op-ed snap | Indian Society | Mains Paper 2: Indian Constitution – historical underpinnings, evolution, features, amendments, significant provisions and basic structure

    Note4Students

    From UPSC perspective, the following things are important:

    Prelims level: UCC

    Mains level: UCC- Child-centric approach

    Central Idea

    • In the backdrop of a potential UCC being brought to the fore during a special parliamentary session from September 18 to 22, 2023, it’s crucial to transcend the traditional discourse surrounding polygamy and divorce. The forthcoming UCC must delve deeper into issues beyond these and prioritize the well-being of children in custody.

    What is the Uniform Civil Code (UCC)?

    • The UCC is a framework aimed at replacing personal laws based on religious customs and traditions with a unified set of civil laws applicable to all citizens of a country, regardless of their religion or background.
    • The goal of a UCC is to provide a common set of laws for matters like marriage, divorce, inheritance, and adoption, among others.
    • This unified code is intended to promote equality, justice, and uniformity in personal matters while respecting individual rights and cultural diversity.

    Reimagining child custody

    • The Guardians and Wards Act, 1890, fundamentally prioritizes the child’s welfare when determining custody.
    • Within the Hindu Minority and Guardianship Act, 1956, Section 6 asserts the father’s status as the natural guardian, followed by the mother. However, this distinction should not be interpreted as lifetime primacy but rather ‘in the absence of’ the father.
    • A more holistic UCC should move beyond this binary.

    Exploring Islamic Law

    • Intriguingly, custody under Islamic law centers on the child’s rights rather than the parents. The father’s custody right ranks sixth, following the mother, maternal grandmother, paternal grandmother, sister, maternal aunt, and paternal aunt.
    • Different schools of thought allocate custody at varying ages or events. Notably, the Hanafi school does not strip the mother of custody upon ceasing to be Muslim.
    • Such varied approaches provide a lens for crafting a comprehensive UCC.

    Nuanced Issues in Child Custody

    • Complexities Beyond Conventional Disputes:
      • Child custody disputes involve intricate challenges that go beyond the typical battles between fathers and mothers.
      • The complexities arise from scenarios involving biological parents’ rights after adoption and situations related to a biological father accused of rape.
    • Favoring biological parents over adoptive ones:
      • Courts are increasingly leaning towards granting custody to biological parents, often at the expense of adoptive parents.
      • The growing concern is that the child’s best interests might be overlooked in such cases.
    • Case of Custody to the Biological Father:
      • In a specific case where the Bombay High Court granted custody of an adopted child to the biological father.
      • This decision was made despite the biological father facing rape charges that led to the child’s birth.
    • Balancing Biological and Adoptive Rights:
      • The case underscores the importance of the Uniform Civil Code (UCC) addressing the rights of both biological and adoptive parents.
      • The primary focus should be on the child’s well-being and best interests.
    • Biological Mother’s Situation:
      • Another case involves a 17-year-old biological mother who allegedly eloped with an accused rapist, resulting in the birth of a child.
      • Despite the biological mother’s subsequent marriage and decision to surrender the child for adoption, the High Court awarded custody to the biological father.
    • A Holistic Approach to Custody Decisions:
      • These instances highlight the need for custody decisions to consider not only legal aspects but also the child’s welfare and the well-being of all parties involved.
      • Advocates for the UCC to address such nuanced scenarios and ensure that custody decisions are guided by the principle of prioritizing the best interests of the child.

    Significance of a Progressive UCC

    • A Holistic Approach to Custody:
      • A progressive UCC goes beyond superficial changes, addressing custody beyond the father’s role.
      • It ensures the “best interests of the child” principle in custody disputes, balancing parental rights.
    • Balancing Biological and Adoptive Parents:
      • The UCC’s recognition of both biological and adoptive parents prevents favoring one over the other.
      • It prioritizes child welfare over parental status.
    • Reflecting on a Changing Society:
      • A progressive UCC adapts to evolving family dynamics and structures.
      • It caters to diverse familial arrangements, avoiding outdated norms.
    • Protection Against Discrimination:
      • The UCC safeguards individual rights, preventing discrimination based on religion, gender, or background.
      • It ensures equal treatment in family matters.
    • Empowering Children’s Interests:
      • The UCC’s child-centric approach minimizes the adverse effects of custody disputes on children.
      • It promotes a healthier environment for their growth.
    • Encouraging Equitable Gender Roles:
      • A progressive UCC challenges traditional gender roles, empowering individuals to make choices.
      • It dismantles biases, promoting gender equality.
    • Legal Clarity and Unity:
      • Uniform laws reduce legal complexities, providing clarity for the individuals involved.
      • They foster a sense of unity by treating all citizens equally.
    • Recognition of Modern Family Models:
      • LGBTQ+ relationships, single parenthood, and non-traditional families gain legal recognition.
      • The UCC acknowledges diverse family structures.
    • Enhancing Adoption and Surrogacy Regulations:
      • A progressive UCC offers comprehensive guidelines for adoption and surrogacy.
      • It safeguards the rights and responsibilities of all parties involved.

    Conclusion

    • As the horizon of legal reform broadens, a child-centric approach should be at the heart of the UCC. The UCC should not only evolve with changing societal dynamics but also serve as a testament to the nation’s commitment to nurturing the best interests of its children.

    Get an IAS/IPS ranker as your 1: 1 personal mentor

  • One Nation, One Election: Prospects and Challenges

    Govt forms committee on simultaneous elections: What is the idea, and the arguments around it?

    op-ed snap | Polity | Mains Paper 2: Parliament & State Legislatures

    Note4Students

    From UPSC perspective, the following things are important:

    Prelims level: NA

    Mains level: The concept of one nation, one election, pros and cons

    What’s the news?

    • The government forms a committee to explore the possibility of One Nation, One Election.

    Central idea

    • In a significant move, the Indian government has established a committee under the leadership of former President Ram Nath Kovind to delve into the viability of implementing the concept of one nation, one election. This proposal coincides with the announcement of a special parliamentary session scheduled between September 18 and 22, with its specific agenda undisclosed.

    Historical Context

    • Independent India’s initial elections featured simultaneous Lok Sabha and state assembly polls. However, the synchronized cycle was disrupted due to various political changes, including the rise of regional parties.
    • Over time, some states aligned their assembly elections with the Lok Sabha polls, while others maintained separate cycles.
    • Prime Minister Narendra Modi has consistently advocated for the synchronization of Lok Sabha and state assembly elections.
    • He announced the formation of a committee in June 2019 after his re-election, intending to explore this concept in consultation with political party leaders.

    Arguments in Favor of Simultaneous Elections

    • Cost Efficiency: Conducting multiple elections throughout the year consumes significant resources. Synchronizing elections could lead to substantial cost savings by consolidating administrative efforts, reducing expenses, and optimizing resource allocation.
    • Effective Governance: Frequent elections disrupt governance as the Model Code of Conduct restricts policy announcements. Simultaneous elections could ensure uninterrupted policy implementation and governance, benefiting citizens with a consistent and focused administration.
    • Resource Rationalization: Organizing elections requires considerable manpower, security personnel, and financial resources. Simultaneous elections would streamline resource allocation, reducing the strain on logistical arrangements and personnel deployment.
    • Enhanced Voter Participation: Coordinated elections could potentially boost voter turnout by creating a sense of importance and urgency among citizens to participate in a comprehensive electoral process.
    • Engagement of security forces: Deployment of security forces is normally throughout the elections and frequent elections take away a portion of such armed police force which could otherwise be better deployed for other internal security purposes.
    • Impact on social fabric: Frequent elections perpetuate caste, religion, and communal issues across the country as elections are polarising events that have accentuated casteism, communalism, and corruption.
    • Focus on populist measures: Frequent elections will impact the focus of governance and policymaking as it forces the political class to typically think in terms of immediate electoral gains rather than focus on long-term programs and policies.

    Arguments Against Simultaneous Elections

    • Logistical Challenges: Coordinating elections across states and levels of government presents significant logistical challenges, including the availability of polling stations, security arrangements, and managing a large-scale operation.
    • Regional Representation: Simultaneous elections may favor national parties over regional ones, leading to a reduction in the representation of regional issues and undermining the diversity of political voices.
    • Disruption on Government Collapse: If a government collapses before its term concludes, simultaneous elections could lead to a prolonged period of political uncertainty and governance instability at both state and national levels.
    • Constitutional Amendments: Implementing simultaneous elections necessitates extensive amendments to the Constitution, electoral laws, and parliamentary procedures, which may require complex negotiations and consensus-building.
    • Impact on Federal Structure: Simultaneous elections might blur the distinction between state and national issues, potentially weakening the federal structure and eroding the autonomy of state elections.
    • Electoral Commission Capacity: Coordinating simultaneous elections would place a significant burden on the Election Commission’s resources, possibly affecting the efficiency and credibility of the electoral process.
    • Complexity of the Anti-Defection Law: Simultaneous elections could complicate the implementation of the anti-defection law, potentially leading to legal challenges and political instability.
    • Suppression of Diverse Voices: A single overarching election campaign might overshadow regional concerns and reduce the space for a diverse range of opinions and local issues.

    Previous Considerations and Recommendations

    • Election Commission’s 1983 Suggestion: In 1983, the Election Commission proposed the idea of holding simultaneous elections to the Lok Sabha and state legislative assemblies.
    • The Law Commission’s 1999 Recommendation: The Law Commission, led by Justice B.P. Jeevan Reddy, presented its 170th report in May 1999. The report recommended exploring a system where elections for the Lok Sabha and all legislative assemblies are held simultaneously.
    • Atal Bihari Vajpayee’s Effort (2003): In 2003, then Prime Minister Atal Bihari Vajpayee discussed the concept with Congress President Sonia Gandhi. Though initial discussions were positive, the idea did not gain traction beyond that point.
    • L.K. Advani’s Proposal (2010): In 2010, BJP leader L.K. Advani proposed fixed-term legislatures and simultaneous Lok Sabha and Assembly elections. He emphasized the need to avoid frequent elections for the stability of governments.
    • Election Commission’s Support (2019): In 2019, Chief Election Commissioner Sunil Arora expressed support for the idea of simultaneous elections, calling it a desirable goal. He suggested aligning the terms of state assemblies with the life of the Parliament for successful implementation.
    • Parliamentary Standing Committee (2015): The Parliamentary Standing Committee on Personnel, Public Grievances, Law, and Justice, led by E.M. Sudarsana Natchiappan, compiled a report in 2015. The report highlighted benefits such as reduced expenditure, policy continuity, and a minimized impact on essential services during election times.
    • Law Commission’s Draft Report (2018): In August 2018, the Law Commission, under the leadership of Justice B.S. Chauhan, drafted a report stating that simultaneous elections couldn’t be held within the existing constitutional framework. The Commission recommended amendments to the Constitution, the Representation of the People Act 1951, and parliamentary procedures for its implementation. The report suggested that at least 50% of states ratify constitutional amendments.

    Contemporary Perspectives

    • BJP’s Manifesto (Recent Years): The BJP included the idea of “one nation, one election” in its election manifesto, viewing it as a means to streamline the electoral process and minimize disruptions caused by frequent elections.
    • Opposition’s Reservations (2023): In 2023, leaders from parties such as Jharkhand Mukti Morcha, Shiv Sena (UBT), and the Congress have expressed opposition to the idea of simultaneous elections. They argue that it could diminish the importance of state elections and regional parties, leading to their overshadowing by national leaders.

    Way forward?

    • The standing committee recommended a cycle of elections, according to which elections to some legislative assemblies whose term end within six months to one year before or after the election date could be held during the midterm of Lok Sabha . For the rest of the states, elections could be held along with the general elections to Lok Sabha.
    • Cost can be brought under control by ensuring that the legal cap on expenditure of candidates is followed by all parties.
    • Accomplishing one year one election will be easier as it doesn’t require as many legal amendments as simultaneous polls for which the Centre will have to make five amendments to the Constitution.

    Conclusion

    • The concept of one nation, one election remains a subject of ongoing deliberation in Indian politics. While proponents emphasize its potential advantages, critics raise valid concerns about its implementation and impact on regional dynamics. The future of this proposal will depend on how these considerations are navigated in the evolving political landscape of India.

    Get an IAS/IPS ranker as your 1: 1 personal mentor

  • Electoral Reforms In India

    Appointing Election Commissioners: The government must not control the watchdog

    op-ed snap | Polity | Mains Paper 2: Indian Constitution – historical underpinnings, evolution, features, amendments, significant provisions and basic structure

    Note4Students

    From UPSC perspective, the following things are important:

    Prelims level: CEC and Other ECs -Appointment, Conditions of Service, and Term of Office and constitutional provisions

    Mains level: The CEC and Other ECs (Appointment, Conditions of Service, and Term of Office) Bill, 2023 and concerns and way forward

    What’s the news?

    • The Chief Election Commissioner and Other Election Commissioners (Appointment, Conditions of Service, and Term of Office) Bill, 2023, introduced in the Rajya Sabha on August 10, seeks to alter the control dynamics of the Election Commission (EC) by increasing political executive influence.

    Central idea

    • The proposed legislation establishes a Selection Committee for appointing the Chief Election Commissioner (CEC) and Election Commissioners (ECs), with the Prime Minister, the Leader of the Opposition in the Lok Sabha, and a nominated Cabinet minister as its members. This change excludes the Chief Justice of India (CJI) from the committee and overturns a prior Supreme Court ruling.

    Background

    • To ensure the EC’s impartiality and independence in conducting free and fair elections, a five-judge bench of the Supreme Court, in the case of Anoop Baranwal vs Union of India on March 2, established interim guidelines.
    • This mandates a three-member committee composed of the Prime Minister, the Leader of the Opposition in the Lok Sabha, and the Chief Justice of India for appointments.
    • The Court specified that this composition would remain until a corresponding law is passed by Parliament.

    Historical Context

    • The Constituent Assembly aimed to ensure the EC’s independence. B. R. Ambedkar stressed that elections must be conducted by an independent body separate from the government.
    • While the Constitution left legislative room for future parliamentary intervention, it was expected to uphold fairness and reason.

    Constitutional Provisions and Autonomy

    • Article 324 Authority: The Constitution assigns the Election Commission (EC) the crucial responsibility of Superintendence, direction, and control of elections, granting it the power to oversee and manage various aspects of the electoral process.
    • Composition Defined: Article 324, clause 2, outlines the composition of the EC, comprising the Chief Election Commissioner (CEC) and a determined number of other Election Commissioners (ECs) as determined by the President.
    • Autonomy Safeguarded:
    • Article 324(5) serves as a crucial safeguard to ensure the autonomy and independence of the EC. It stipulates that the removal process for the CEC mirrors the procedure applicable to a judge in the Supreme Court.
    • By mirroring the removal process of a Supreme Court judge, the Constitution seeks to shield the EC from arbitrary or partisan influences.
    • EC Member Removal: While the same level of security of tenure is not extended to other Election Commissioners, their removal remains contingent on the recommendation of the Chief Election Commissioner. This provision reflects the intent to uphold an EC that operates independently and free from external political pressures.
    • Precedent and Autonomy: The case of T N Seshan vs Union of India (1995) further establishes the notion that any removal of EC members must be grounded in intelligible and cogent considerations.

    Concerning Provisions of the Bill

    • Shift in Selection Committee Composition: The proposed bill introduces a new Selection Committee responsible for appointing the CEC and ECs. However, the composition of this committee excludes the CJI, a departure from established practices. This shift raises concerns about reduced judicial participation in the appointment process.
    • Quorum Dynamics and LoP’s Role: The bill sets a quorum requirement for the Selection Committee, consisting of two members – the Prime Minister and a Cabinet Minister. This setup potentially diminishes the Leader of the Opposition’s (LoP) role to a mere formality, impacting the balanced representation and input from all relevant stakeholders.
    • Consideration Beyond Search Committee Recommendations: Section 8(2) of the bill allows the Selection Committee to consider candidates not recommended by the Search Committee. This provision conflicts with the transparency objective set out in Section 8(1) and raises concerns about the potential for arbitrary appointments and favoritism.
    • Procedure Regulation and Lack of Transparency: Section 8(1) empowers the Selection Committee to regulate its own procedure. This provision introduces the possibility of an unregulated decision-making process lacking transparency and potentially leading to an opaque and subjective appointment process.

    Potential adverse impact of the bill

    • EC Autonomy Erosion: The proposed bill threatens to undermine the autonomy of the EC. The changes in the appointment process and composition of the SC could expose the EC to increased political influence, potentially compromising its impartiality.
    • Reduced Judicial Oversight: Exclusion of the CJI from the SC reduces judicial oversight in appointments. This could lead to a lack of checks and balances, eroding the credibility of the appointment process.
    • Executive Dominance: The quorum dynamics favoring the PM and CM could result in executive dominance over appointments. This could weaken the EC’s ability to function independently and impartially.
    • Impaired Democracy: If the EC’s autonomy and credibility are compromised, the democratic process itself could be undermined, with elections losing their impartiality and fairness.
    • Precedent from the Ashok Lavasa Case: The case of Ashok Lavasa, whose independent stance led to cases against his family members, illustrates the potential repercussions of dissenting voices within the EC. In the context of such cases, the proposed bill could further discourage independent decision-making within the EC, impacting its ability to operate freely.

    Way Forward

    • Reconsider Composition: Reevaluate the composition of the Selection Committee for appointing the Chief Election Commissioner (CEC) and Election Commissioners (ECs). Consider reintroducing the Chief Justice of India (CJI) to ensure balanced participation and uphold checks and balances.
    • Balanced Quorum: Revise the quorum requirement of the Selection Committee to include the LoP as a full participant. This balanced representation will ensure a comprehensive decision-making process.
    • Transparency in Selection: Implement measures to maintain transparency in the appointment process. Avoid considering candidates not recommended by the Search Committee, preserving the fairness and credibility of appointments.
    • Clarity in Procedure: Establish clear and transparent procedures for the Selection Committee. Providing well-defined guidelines will ensure an objective and equitable appointment process.
    • Parliamentary Scrutiny: Subject any proposed changes to thorough scrutiny by the Parliament. A comprehensive debate involving various political parties will help ensure the legitimacy of the amendments.
    • Uphold Constitutional Values: Prioritize adherence to constitutional principles when considering changes to the appointment process. Upholding the autonomy and integrity of the EC is paramount.

    Conclusion

    • The CEC and Other ECs (Appointment, Conditions of Service, and Term of Office) Bill, 2023, threatens the fundamental autonomy of the Election Commission. Upholding the EC’s independence is vital for maintaining the integrity of India’s democratic process and ensuring the equal representation of all citizens and political parties in elections.

    Get an IAS/IPS ranker as your 1: 1 personal mentor