Explained | Enviro & Biodiversity | Mains Paper 3: Conservation, Environmental Pollution & Degradation, Eia

Introduction

Plastic pollution represents one of the gravest environmental crises of our times. Despite decades of regulation and bans, plastics remain ubiquitous, cheap, and nearly indestructible. Talks in Geneva involving 180 countries failed to secure an internationally binding legal agreement to limit plastic pollution, reflecting deep divisions over whether the treaty should target waste alone or include production.

Global Plastic Treaty Deadlock: Why It Matters

Global deadlock: 180 countries failed to agree on a binding treaty on plastic pollution in Geneva, despite a UNEP-backed resolution already in place.
First-time sharp focus on health: Unlike earlier discussions centred only on waste management, the health impact of plastics is now central.
Scale of problem: Plastics contain more than 16,000 chemicals, with little knowledge on 10,000+ of them. A Nature study showed 4,000 chemicals of concern are present across major plastic types.
Striking evidence: Microplastics detected in blood, breast milk, placenta, bone marrow, bringing urgency to the debate.

The Persistence and Ubiquity of Plastics

Symbol of consumption economy: Cheap and versatile, plastics reflect today’s global consumption.
Persistence and flexibility: Synthetic, fossil-fuel-derived polymers are non-biodegradable and endure for decades.
Waste mismanagement: Cheap production, ubiquity, and limited recycling capacity turn plastics into the prime source of litter.

Plastics and Human Health: Emerging Evidence

Chemicals of concern: Plastics use ethylene, propylene, styrene derivatives, along with bisphenols, phthalates, PCBs, PBDEs, and PFAS.
Products of exposure: Found in food containers, bottles, teething toys, polyester, IV bags, cosmetics, paints, electronics, adhesives.
Health links: Studies link plastic chemicals to thyroid dysfunction, hypertension, kidney/testicular cancer, gestational diabetes.
Evidence base: Around 1,100 studies, involving 1.1 million individuals, compiled by Boston College & Minderoo Foundation dashboard.
Nature of studies: Mostly associative; longitudinal studies (gold standard) are still underway.

The Microplastic Menace

Definition: Plastics smaller than 5 mm, found in additives or broken-down products.
Recent discoveries: Detected in human blood, breast milk, placenta, bone marrow.
Health uncertainty: Exact impacts still under study, but linked to multiple disorders.

Policy Responses: Global and Indian Perspectives

Global scene: Negotiations divided on waste vs production; developing countries demand funding support.
India’s stance:
- Ban on single-use plastics in ~20 States
- Administrative push for Extended Producer Responsibility (EPR)
- Views plastics as a waste management issue, not a health issue.
- Prefers health dimension to be dealt with at WHO, not in the plastics treaty.

Conclusion

The Geneva deadlock reflects not just a failure of diplomacy but the widening gap between scientific evidence and policy action. Plastics are no longer an invisible convenience; they are a pervasive health hazard. While India treats plastics as a waste issue, ignoring health risks leaves a blind spot in policy. A robust, binding treaty addressing both production and health impact is indispensable if the world is to prevent plastics from becoming the new tobacco of the 21st century.

PYQ Relavance

[UPSC 2023] What is oil pollution? What are its impacts on the marine ecosystem? In what way is oil pollution particularly harmful for a country like India?

Linkage: Since UPSC has already asked about oil pollution (2023), it shows the exam’s focus on pollution and ecosystem impacts. Plastic pollution, like oil, originates from fossil fuels and has severe effects on marine life and human health. Hence, a direct question on plastic pollution and its health–environment nexus is highly probable.

Practice Mains Question

Plastics are no longer merely a waste management problem but a serious health hazard. Critically examine the health risks associated with plastic use and evaluate India’s stance in global plastic treaty negotiations.

Mapping Microthemes

GS-1: Impact of industrialisation and consumerism on environment.
GS-2: International negotiations, India’s foreign policy stance in environmental treaties.
GS-3: Pollution, waste management, health-environment nexus.
GS-4: Ethics of sustainability, intergenerational justice, corporate responsibility.

Get an IAS/IPS ranker as your 1: 1 personal mentor for UPSC 2024

Attend Now

Tax Reforms

Is the new Income Tax law more accessible?

Explained | Economics | Mains Paper 3: Indian Economy

Introduction

In August 2025, Parliament passed the Income Tax Bill, 2025, a shorter and simplified legislation with 23 chapters (down from 47) and 536 sections (down from 819). The Bill aims to reduce discretion with clearer provisions, introduce taxpayer-friendly reforms like longer timelines for return updation, and curb harassment. However, it has also expanded the powers of tax officials, especially over digital information and personal data, raising concerns about privacy and misuse.

Need for Overhauling the 1961 Income Tax Framework

Obsolete framework: The Income Tax Act, 1961 had become outdated, riddled with amendments, and difficult for laypersons to interpret.
Harassment potential: Excessive discretion allowed officials to harass taxpayers.
Structural reform: New law cuts down chapters from 47 to 23 and sections from 819 to 536, simplifying compliance.
Greater clarity: More tables (57, up from 18) and formulae (46, up from 6), along with examples to aid understanding.

From Draft Bill to Final Law: The Legislative Journey

Initial draft (Feb 2025): Introduced in Parliament but referred to a Select Committee given the Bill’s significance.
Committee review: Headed by Baijayant Panda, with MPs across parties; submitted a detailed report in July 2025.
Withdrawal & replacement: Government withdrew the earlier version on August 8, 2025, to incorporate committee recommendations.
Final Bill (Aug 11, 2025): Introduced and passed the same day, avoiding confusion through multiple versions.

Key Reforms and Structural Simplifications:

No slab changes: Finance Minister clarified tax rates and slabs remain unchanged.
Technical refinements: Clearer provisions for Minimum Alternate Tax (MAT) and Alternate Minimum Tax (AMT), separated into sub-sections.
Taxpayer-friendly features: Returns can be updated up to 4 years from the end of the relevant assessment year without penalty; Assessment reopening period reduced to 5 years.

Simplification Gains and Emerging Concerns

Expanded search powers: Tax officers can now demand passwords of electronic devices, emails, and social media accounts.
Override access: Officials may bypass access codes to computer systems if passwords are not shared.
Privacy concerns: Unlike earlier provisions (limited to inspection and lock-breaking), the new law extends to personal digital data, raising red flags.

Government’s Rationale for Expanding Digital Powers

Rationale: Much of financial data today is exchanged via messaging apps, emails, or stored digitally.
Committee stance: Though some dissent was recorded, the Select Committee accepted the government’s view that these provisions are essential for effective investigation.

Conclusion

The Income Tax Bill, 2025 is a watershed reform, simplifying one of India’s most complex laws. While the codification of taxpayer-friendly provisions marks a progressive step, the enhanced surveillance powers granted to tax authorities highlight the thin line between efficiency and overreach. The challenge ahead lies in ensuring that simplification does not come at the cost of citizens’ trust and constitutional rights.

Value Addition for UPSC

Governance angle (GS-II): Balancing simplification of laws with citizen rights and privacy.
Economic reforms (GS-III): Tax rationalisation improves compliance and ease of doing business.
Ethics (GS-IV): Dilemma of state surveillance vs. individual liberty; Kantian duty-based ethics vs. utilitarian approach.
Comparative context: Similar debates exist globallye.g., U.S. IRS’s digital access powers vs. EU’s stricter GDPR protections.

PYQ Relevance

[UPSC 2020] Explain the rationale behind the Goods and Services Tax (Compensation to States) Act of 2017.How has COVID-19 impacted the GST compensation fund and created new federal tensions?

Linkage: The GST Compensation Act, 2017 aimed to build Centre–State trust during the GST transition but COVID-19 strained revenues, sparking federal tensions. Similarly, the Income Tax Bill, 2025 seeks to simplify direct taxes to build citizen trust but raises concerns over state overreach in digital surveillance. Both show that taxation is ultimately about trust and legitimacy in governance.

Practice Mains Question

The Income Tax Bill, 2025 seeks to simplify India’s tax regime but also introduces stronger surveillance powers for officials. Discuss the balance between efficiency, transparency, and taxpayer rights. (250 words)

Mapping Microthemes for GS Papers

GS-I: Evolution of economic policies post-Independence.
GS-II: Governance, legislative reforms, fundamental rights (privacy).
GS-III: Fiscal reforms, tax policy, ease of doing business.
GS-IV: Ethics of surveillance, transparency, accountability.

Get an IAS/IPS ranker as your 1: 1 personal mentor for UPSC 2024

Attend Now

Tax Reforms

Is the new Income Tax law more accessible?

Explained | Economics | Mains Paper 3: Mobilization Of Resources

Introduction

Need for Overhauling the 1961 Income Tax Framework

Obsolete framework: The Income Tax Act, 1961 had become outdated, riddled with amendments, and difficult for laypersons to interpret.
Harassment potential: Excessive discretion allowed officials to harass taxpayers.
Structural reform: New law cuts down chapters from 47 to 23 and sections from 819 to 536, simplifying compliance.
Greater clarity: More tables (57, up from 18) and formulae (46, up from 6), along with examples to aid understanding.

From Draft Bill to Final Law: The Legislative Journey

Initial draft (Feb 2025): Introduced in Parliament but referred to a Select Committee given the Bill’s significance.
Committee review: Headed by Baijayant Panda, with MPs across parties; submitted a detailed report in July 2025.
Withdrawal & replacement: Government withdrew the earlier version on August 8, 2025, to incorporate committee recommendations.
Final Bill (Aug 11, 2025): Introduced and passed the same day, avoiding confusion through multiple versions.

Key Reforms and Structural Simplifications:

No slab changes: Finance Minister clarified tax rates and slabs remain unchanged.
Technical refinements: Clearer provisions for Minimum Alternate Tax (MAT) and Alternate Minimum Tax (AMT), separated into sub-sections.
Taxpayer-friendly features: Returns can be updated up to 4 years from the end of the relevant assessment year without penalty; Assessment reopening period reduced to 5 years.

Simplification Gains and Emerging Concerns

Expanded search powers: Tax officers can now demand passwords of electronic devices, emails, and social media accounts.
Override access: Officials may bypass access codes to computer systems if passwords are not shared.
Privacy concerns: Unlike earlier provisions (limited to inspection and lock-breaking), the new law extends to personal digital data, raising red flags.

Government’s Rationale for Expanding Digital Powers

Rationale: Much of financial data today is exchanged via messaging apps, emails, or stored digitally.
Committee stance: Though some dissent was recorded, the Select Committee accepted the government’s view that these provisions are essential for effective investigation.

Conclusion

Value Addition for UPSC

Governance angle (GS-II): Balancing simplification of laws with citizen rights and privacy.
Economic reforms (GS-III): Tax rationalisation improves compliance and ease of doing business.
Ethics (GS-IV): Dilemma of state surveillance vs. individual liberty; Kantian duty-based ethics vs. utilitarian approach.
Comparative context: Similar debates exist globallye.g., U.S. IRS’s digital access powers vs. EU’s stricter GDPR protections.

PYQ Relevance

[UPSC 2020] Explain the rationale behind the Goods and Services Tax (Compensation to States) Act of 2017.How has COVID-19 impacted the GST compensation fund and created new federal tensions?

Practice Mains Question

Mapping Microthemes for GS Papers

GS-I: Evolution of economic policies post-Independence.
GS-II: Governance, legislative reforms, fundamental rights (privacy).
GS-III: Fiscal reforms, tax policy, ease of doing business.
GS-IV: Ethics of surveillance, transparency, accountability.

Get an IAS/IPS ranker as your 1: 1 personal mentor for UPSC 2024

Attend Now

Climate Change Negotiations – UNFCCC, COP, Other Conventions and Protocols

How does plastic pollution affect health?

Explained | Enviro & Biodiversity | Mains Paper 3: Conservation, Environmental Pollution & Degradation, Eia

Introduction

Global Plastic Treaty Deadlock: Why It Matters

Global deadlock: 180 countries failed to agree on a binding treaty on plastic pollution in Geneva, despite a UNEP-backed resolution already in place.
First-time sharp focus on health: Unlike earlier discussions centred only on waste management, the health impact of plastics is now central.
Scale of problem: Plastics contain more than 16,000 chemicals, with little knowledge on 10,000+ of them. A Nature study showed 4,000 chemicals of concern are present across major plastic types.
Striking evidence: Microplastics detected in blood, breast milk, placenta, bone marrow, bringing urgency to the debate.

The Persistence and Ubiquity of Plastics

Symbol of consumption economy: Cheap and versatile, plastics reflect today’s global consumption.
Persistence and flexibility: Synthetic, fossil-fuel-derived polymers are non-biodegradable and endure for decades.
Waste mismanagement: Cheap production, ubiquity, and limited recycling capacity turn plastics into the prime source of litter.

Plastics and Human Health: Emerging Evidence

Chemicals of concern: Plastics use ethylene, propylene, styrene derivatives, along with bisphenols, phthalates, PCBs, PBDEs, and PFAS.
Products of exposure: Found in food containers, bottles, teething toys, polyester, IV bags, cosmetics, paints, electronics, adhesives.
Health links: Studies link plastic chemicals to thyroid dysfunction, hypertension, kidney/testicular cancer, gestational diabetes.
Evidence base: Around 1,100 studies, involving 1.1 million individuals, compiled by Boston College & Minderoo Foundation dashboard.
Nature of studies: Mostly associative; longitudinal studies (gold standard) are still underway.

The Microplastic Menace

Definition: Plastics smaller than 5 mm, found in additives or broken-down products.
Recent discoveries: Detected in human blood, breast milk, placenta, bone marrow.
Health uncertainty: Exact impacts still under study, but linked to multiple disorders.

Policy Responses: Global and Indian Perspectives

Global scene: Negotiations divided on waste vs production; developing countries demand funding support.
India’s stance:
- Ban on single-use plastics in ~20 States
- Administrative push for Extended Producer Responsibility (EPR)
- Views plastics as a waste management issue, not a health issue.
- Prefers health dimension to be dealt with at WHO, not in the plastics treaty.

Conclusion

PYQ Relavance

[UPSC 2023] What is oil pollution? What are its impacts on the marine ecosystem? In what way is oil pollution particularly harmful for a country like India?

Practice Mains Question

Mapping Microthemes

GS-1: Impact of industrialisation and consumerism on environment.
GS-2: International negotiations, India’s foreign policy stance in environmental treaties.
GS-3: Pollution, waste management, health-environment nexus.
GS-4: Ethics of sustainability, intergenerational justice, corporate responsibility.

Get an IAS/IPS ranker as your 1: 1 personal mentor for UPSC 2024

Attend Now

Electoral Reforms In India

How inclusive is EC’s special revision exercise?

Explained | Polity | Mains Paper 2: Representation Of People's Act

The Election Commission of India’s (ECI) Special Intensive Revision (SIR) of electoral rolls has become a focal point of debate, extending beyond a routine update. The ECI’s insistence on specific identity and citizenship proofs, most notably the birth certificate, has sparked a critical discussion. The core issue is the potential for widespread voter exclusion, which stands in stark contrast to the foundational democratic principle of ensuring the broadest possible inclusion of all eligible citizens. A recent Lokniti-CSDS survey, conducted across five states and one Union Territory, provides compelling data that challenges the feasibility and inclusivity of the SIR exercise as it is currently designed.

The Paradox of Electoral Reforms: Inclusion vs. Exclusion

The Unintended Consequences of the Special Intensive Revision

Documentation Burden: Over half of all respondents lack a birth certificate. A similar proportion lacks a domicile or caste certificate, while at least two-thirds don’t have their parents’ birth certificates.
Widespread Lack of Awareness: Only 36% of respondents were aware of the SIR exercise or its document requirements, indicating a massive information gap.
Socio-Economic Disparities: The lack of necessary documents disproportionately affects vulnerable groups. Roughly 5% of respondents had none of the 11 documents required by the EC. This group of “No Document Citizens” had a higher percentage of women, and were predominantly from the lower economic half, with over one-fourth being SC and over 40% OBC.

Which groups are most vulnerable to exclusion?

No-document citizens: 5% of respondents had none of the 11 documents.
Marginalized impact: Majority of these were women, ¾ from lower economic strata, ¼ SC, and 40% OBC.
Parental records: Absence of parental birth certificates was as high as 87% in Madhya Pradesh and 72% mothers in Uttar Pradesh.

Impact of the SIR on Indian democracy

Core democratic risk: Exclusion of eligible voters undermines the principle of universal adult suffrage.
State capacity challenge: Weak record-keeping and low administrative accessibility deepen inequalities.
Policy dilemma: While cleansing electoral rolls is important, the current framework risks mass deletion of legitimate voters.

Administrative challenges contributing to this problem

Inconsistent Birth Certificate Possession: The possession of birth certificates varies sharply across states, revealing significant administrative and historical disparities. In Madhya Pradesh only 11% of respondents had a birth certificate and in West Bengal, with a 49% possession rate. Even in states with higher rates like West Bengal and Delhi, at least half the population still lacks this document.
Difficulty in Obtaining Documents: The process is perceived as “very difficult” by a substantial portion of the population in major states, including 46% in Delhi, 41% in Kerala, 40% in Madhya Pradesh, and 41% in West Bengal.
Parental Documents as a Major Hurdle: The requirement for parental documents for those born after 1987 (and for both parents for those born after 2003) is a near-impossible condition for many.
State Capacity Gaps: The survey highlights the varying capacity of different states to provide and maintain official records, which is a major factor in the documentation gaps.
Exclusion of Aadhaar: The EC’s decision to exclude Aadhaar creates an unnecessary barrier for voters, especially in states where other documents are rare.

The findings of the Lokniti-CSDS survey underscore that while cleansing electoral rolls is a valid goal, the current SIR framework is not inclusive. The reliance on documents that many citizens lack, coupled with significant state-wise and socio-economic disparities in document possession, creates a high risk of voter exclusion. The data show that the exercise, as it stands, is more likely to disenfranchise legitimate voters than to simply remove errors, highlighting the need for a more pragmatic and flexible approach that accounts for the ground realities of India’s diverse population.

Value Addition

The SIR’s Challenge to Inclusive Democracy

The Election Commission’s Special Intensive Revision (SIR) aims to update voter lists but risks excluding many citizens. This is a problem because it goes against the core democratic principle of including all eligible voters.

Cleansing vs. Exclusion: While cleaning up the voter list is a good goal, the SIR’s strict rules about documents could lead to the removal of many people who have a legal right to vote. The survey showed that 5% of people lack any of the required documents, with this problem hitting women and people from lower economic backgrounds the hardest.
State Variation: The SIR’s uniform rules are problematic because the ability to get official documents varies greatly across India. For example, possession of a birth certificate is very low in Madhya Pradesh (11%) compared to West Bengal (49%).
Democratic Principle: Democracy depends on everyone having the right to vote. By creating new barriers, the SIR exercise weakens the foundation of free and fair elections.

Mapping Micro Themes:

GS1: Social exclusion, regional disparities in documentation.
GS2: Electoral reforms, governance capacity, rights of citizens.
GS3: Use of technology (Aadhaar vs exclusions), administrative bottlenecks
GS4: Ethical governance, fairness, justice in democracy.

PYQ Relevance:

[UPSC 2017] To enhance the quality of democracy in India the Election Commission of India has proposed electoral reforms in 2016. What are the suggested reforms and how far are they significant to make democracy successful?

Linkage: The 2016 ECI reforms aimed at enhancing transparency and accountability (e.g., NOTA, state funding, criminal disqualification), while the SIR focuses on electoral roll accuracy. Both highlight the tension between integrity and inclusivity in democracy. The linkage shows that reforms must balance systemic credibility with citizens’ access, else democracy risks exclusion.

Get an IAS/IPS ranker as your 1: 1 personal mentor for UPSC 2024

Attend Now

Trade Sector Updates – Falling Exports, TIES, MEIS, Foreign Trade Policy, etc.

Balancing code and commerce in U.K. trade compact

Explained | Economics | Mains Paper 3: Effects Of Liberalization On The Economy, Changes In Industrial Policy and their effects on Industrial Growth

India–U.K. Comprehensive Economic and Trade Agreement (CETA), especially its Chapter 12 on Digital Trade, marks a shift from cautious digital policy to strategic global engagement. It brings major trade gains, but also sparks debate on data sovereignty and oversight. Chapter 12 of India–U.K. CETA exchanges some regulatory control for greater digital market access. Gains include mutual recognition of e-signatures, duty-free digital exports, and innovation-friendly provisions, while concerns focus on limited source-code checks and voluntary data sharing.

Digital Gains from the Agreement

Recognition of Electronic Signatures and Contracts: Both nations commit to mutual recognition, reducing paperwork for SaaS firms and lowering entry barriers for SMEs.
Paperless Trade & E-Invoicing: Eases cross-border documentation and payments, enhancing trade efficiency.
Zero Customs Duties on Electronic Transmissions: Preserves a Commerce Ministry–estimated $30 billion software export pipeline.
Regulatory Sandboxes for Data Innovation: Encourages pilot projects that allow payments and data-driven firms to test tools under supervision, boosting credibility abroad.
Duty-Free Access for Indian Merchandise: Nearly 99% of exports could enter the U.K. duty-free; textile tariffs dropping from 12% to zero will aid hubs like Tiruppur and Ludhiana.
Openings in British Public Procurement: Expands market opportunities for Indian IT suppliers.
Social Security Waivers: Reduces payroll costs for short-term assignments abroad by about 20%.

Digital Costs and Concerns

Source-Code Inspection Restrictions: Ban on routine checks; regulators can only demand access in investigations or court cases.
Voluntary Government Data Sharing: No binding obligation; India decides what data to release, and in what format.
No Automatic MFN for Data Flows: Only a forward review mechanism exists if stricter data rules appear in other agreements.
Review Timelines: First formal review in 5 years; critics suggest 3-year reviews to match rapid AI developments.
Domestic Readiness Gap: Digital Personal Data Protection Act, 2023 rules are pending notification; absence of clear internal processes could weaken negotiation leverage.

Balancing Sovereignty and Openness

Security Exceptions Preserved: National supervision over critical infrastructure like power grids and payment systems remains intact.
Good Governance Safeguards: Prevents disguised restrictions on trade under the guise of regulation.
Trusted Labs Proposal: Accrediting secure labs to review sensitive code could bridge the trust gap.
Audit Trails for Cross-Border Data Flows: Ensures accountability follows the data.
Institutionalised Consultations: Open, pre-negotiation dialogue to anticipate and address stakeholder concerns.

Steps for Future Digital Treaties

Integrate market openness with regulatory oversight
Set three-year review cycles to adapt to technological change
Develop domestic readiness before external commitments
Maintain a balance between security and trade facilitation

Conclusion

The India–U.K. digital trade compact is both a leap and a litmus test. It affirms India’s readiness to engage strategically in global digital commerce while underscoring the necessity of robust domestic regulation. The real challenge is not in signing such pacts but in ensuring that sovereignty, security, and innovation move forward together.

Value Addition

Reports / Data

Commerce Ministry (2024): India’s software exports via electronic transmissions valued at $30 billion annually.
UNCTAD Report on Digital Economy (2023): India among top 5 global economies in digital services exports.
NASSCOM 2023: Digital public infrastructure (UPI, Aadhaar, DigiLocker) key enablers of India’s digital leap.

Case Studies / Examples

UPI in G20 (2023): India pushing UPI internationalisation – similar to how digital trade pacts expand India’s reach.
Singapore & Australia FTAs: Precedent for including digital trade rules, but U.K. CETA is India’s first binding digital chapter.
Textile exports from Tiruppur/Ludhiana: Example of how tariff elimination + digital facilitation = trade gains.

Concepts & Theories

WTO-plus Agreements: Regional/bilateral pacts that go beyond WTO commitments (like CETA’s Chapter 12).
Data Sovereignty vs Digital Openness: Core tension between national control over data and global free flows.
Regulatory Sandboxes: Innovation-friendly regulatory spaces balancing innovation & oversight.

Quotes for Enrichment

Nandan Nilekani: “India has built digital public goods at population scale, something no other democracy has attempted.”
UNCTAD: “The digital economy is now the fastest growing trade frontier, but also the most contested.”

PYQ Relevance

Though there is no direct PYQ, the digital trade compact can be used in many questions like

[UPSC 2023] What is the status of digitalization in the Indian Economy? Examine the problems faced in this regard and suggest improvement.

Linkage: The India–U.K. CETA’s digital trade provisions—like e-signatures, paperless trade, and zero customs duty—highlight India’s progress in integrating digitalization into global commerce. At the same time, issues like restricted source-code access, weak data protection readiness, and voluntary data sharing mirror the broader problems of digitalization in India. Thus, the pact underlines both India’s digital gains and the urgent need for domestic reforms and safeguards to fully leverage such agreements.

Mapping Micro Themes

GS-2: Trade diplomacy, sovereignty.
GS-3: Digital trade, AI regulation, cybersecurity.
GS-4: Transparency, public trust.

Get an IAS/IPS ranker as your 1: 1 personal mentor for UPSC 2024

Attend Now

J&K – The issues around the state

Aid and advice: On Jammu and Kashmir and the Lieutenant-Governor’s Assembly member nominations

Explained | Polity | Mains Paper 2: Federalism

The Union Ministry of Home Affairs (MHA) has told the J&K High Court that the Lieutenant-Governor (L-G) can nominate five Assembly members without the “aid and advice” of the elected government. This position has sparked a constitutional debate over democratic accountability in a politically sensitive Union Territory where such nominations could alter the balance of power. This is significant because these nominations could decide the majority in a 119-member House, potentially overturning the people’s electoral verdict. The High Court is examining whether this undermines the Constitution’s basic structure.

Core issues before the J&K High Court

Constitutional question: Whether the 2023 amendments to the J&K Reorganisation Act, allowing the L-G to nominate five members, violate the Constitution’s basic structure.
Potential impact: These five voting members could “convert a minority government into a majority government and vice versa,” influencing governance stability.
Judicial scope: Goes beyond statutory interpretation into democratic essence.

Provisions of the 2023 amendments

Sections 15A & 15B of the Jammu and Kashmir Reorganisation Act, 2019: Allows nomination of two Kashmiri migrants (including one woman) and one from Pakistan-occupied J&K, in addition to two women if inadequately represented.
Total seats: Creates five nominated members in the 119-member Assembly.
Voting rights: These nominees have full voting powers.

Centre’s justification of this power

MHA’s submission: Nominations fall outside the elected government’s remit, citing K. Lakshminarayanan vs Union of India (Puducherry).
Legal references: Invokes “sanctioned strength” concept, including elected + nominated members, and Section 12 of the 1963 Union Territories Act on voting procedures.
Approach: Focuses on legal technicalities rather than broader constitutional implications.

Concerns over democratic implications

Risk of mandate distortion: In a tight Assembly, nominees could decide government stability.
Precedent in Puducherry: In 2021, nominated members plus defectors contributed to the collapse of the Congress-led government.
UT context: J&K’s downgrade from State to UT in 2019 happened without consultation with elected representatives, making accountability critical.

Supreme Court jurisprudence on L-G’s powers

Delhi Services Cases (Government of NCT of Delhi vs. Union of India (2018), Government of NCT of Delhi vs. Union of India & Anr. (2023)): SC held that the L-G should act on the “aid and advice” of the elected government, with discretion as the exception.
Contradiction: MHA’s stance that nominations lie outside the elected government’s domain runs counter to this jurisprudence.

Conclusion

The J&K nominations issue highlights the tension between administrative authority and the democratic mandate. In politically sensitive regions, bypassing elected governments in decisions that can shift Assembly majorities risks undermining public trust and the constitutional promise of representative governance.

Value Addition

Basic Structure Doctrine: It evolved through landmark cases such as Kesavananda Bharati vs State of Kerala (1973), which holds that Parliament cannot amend the Constitution in a way that damages its essential features. Representative democracy and federalism are recognised as part of this basic structure.
Lakshminarayanan Case (2019): In K. Lakshminarayanan vs Union of India, the Supreme Court upheld the Centre’s power to nominate MLAs in Puducherry without consulting the elected government. While constitutionally valid, the aftermath showed that nominated members could be politically aligned with the Centre, leading to destabilisation of the elected government. This precedent is now central to the J&K dispute, as similar powers are being exercised by the L-G.
Delhi vs L-G Jurisprudence: Through Government of NCT of Delhi vs Union of India (2018) and Government of NCT of Delhi vs Union of India & Anr. (2023), the Supreme Court emphasised that the L-G should act on the “aid and advice” of the elected Council of Ministers, except in explicitly stated matters of discretion. This jurisprudence reinforces the principle that administrative authority should not override the electoral mandate, making the MHA’s argument in J&K appear contrary to evolving constitutional norms.
Union Territory Governance Model: Union Territories with legislatures (like Delhi, Puducherry, and now J&K) operate under a hybrid governance system where the Centre retains significant control while local governments have legislative powers. This model inherently contains tensions between central authority and local democratic accountability. In politically sensitive UTs like J&K, such tensions are magnified, especially when powers like nominations can shift legislative majorities.

Mapping Micro Themes for GS Paper II

Topic	Micro Theme	Example
Centre–State Relations	Constitutional role of L-G in UTs & states	J&K L-G nominations without elected govt’s aid and advice
Electoral Process Integrity	Impact of nominated members on Assembly majority	Puducherry 2021 govt collapse case
Basic Structure Doctrine	Threat to democratic accountability	HC challenge to J&K Reorganisation Act amendments
Comparative Jurisprudence	Lakshminarayanan vs Union of India precedent	Puducherry nominated MLAs case
Federalism in Special Regions	J&K statehood restoration debate	SC acknowledgement & public demand

PYQ RELEVANCE

[UPSC 2016] Discuss the essentials of the 69th Constitutional Amendment Act and the controversies regarding the powers of the Lieutenant Governor vis-à-vis the elected government in the NCT of Delhi.

Linkage: The 69th Constitutional Amendment Act created a legislative assembly for Delhi and defined the relationship between the L-G and the elected government, leading to recurring disputes over whether the L-G must act on the “aid and advice” of the Council of Ministers.

The J&K nominations case mirrors this constitutional tension—while Delhi’s dispute involved administrative control and services, J&K’s controversy centres on the L-G’s power to nominate voting members without elected government concurrence. Both situations raise a common constitutional question: Can the L-G exercise discretionary powers in a manner that can override or alter the democratic mandate? This makes Delhi’s precedent and Supreme Court rulings directly relevant to interpreting J&K’s case.

Practice Mains Question

Discuss the constitutional implications of granting the Lieutenant-Governor of Jammu & Kashmir the power to nominate Assembly members without the aid and advice of the elected government. In your answer, examine its impact on the democratic process in light of Supreme Court jurisprudence.

Get an IAS/IPS ranker as your 1: 1 personal mentor for UPSC 2024

Attend Now

Foreign Policy Watch: India-Africa

Africa is challenging China’s mining hegemony

Explained | International Relations | Mains Paper 2: Effect Of Policies & Politics Of World On India'S Interests

For two decades, China has led Africa’s mining sector, securing vast stakes in cobalt, lithium, copper, and iron ore. Now, African governments and civil society are challenging opaque contracts, environmental damage, and lack of value addition. The old “raw resources for infrastructure” model is giving way to demands for local processing, transparency, and economic sovereignty.

Significance

For the first time in decades, China’s unchallenged hold on African mining is weakening. Nations like the DRC, Namibia, and Zimbabwe are renegotiating deals, banning raw mineral exports, and holding Chinese firms accountable for environmental and labour violations. The scale is significant, in 2024 alone, DRC lost $132 million due to tax exemptions for Chinese companies. These actions could reshape global cobalt and lithium supply chains essential for the green economy.

China’s Long-standing Dominance in Africa’s Mining

Control over critical minerals: DRC produces 80% of the world’s cobalt; China controls ~80% of that output via deals like Sicomines.
Infrastructure-for-resources model: Chinese firms exchanged infrastructure for mining rights, but local benefits have been minimal.

Drivers of the Pushback Against Chinese Projects

Civil society pressure: Groups like Congo Is Not for Sale exposed $132 million revenue loss in 2024.
Market-linked risks: Contracts tied to commodity prices risk leaving nations with no investment in downturns.
Government renegotiations: DRC raising stake in joint venture with Sinohydro & China Railway Group from 32% to 70%.

African Nations Taking Assertive Measures

DRC: Cancelled Chemaf Resources’ sale to China’s Norin Mining after state miner Gecamines’ opposition.
Namibia: Alleged $50 million bribe by Xinfeng Investments; failure to build promised processing facilities.
Zimbabwe: $300 million Huayou Cobalt lithium plant; benefits may flow back to China without safeguards.

Environmental and Social Concerns from Chinese Mining

Pollution incidents: Acid spill in Zambia contaminated the Kafue River.
Biodiversity protection: Hwange National Park coal permit blocked for ecological reasons.
Community and heritage impacts: Cameroon’s Lobé-Kribi Iron Ore Project opposed by NGOs over health and cultural threats.

Policy Shifts for Economic Sovereignty

Export bans: Zimbabwe (2022) and Namibia (2023) banned unprocessed lithium exports to promote local beneficiation.
Retention of value: Policy aims to strengthen domestic processing, but risk of elite capture remains without broader reforms.

Conclusion

China remains Africa’s largest mining partner, but African nations are increasingly asserting control through renegotiations, environmental enforcement, and value addition. If sustained, these actions could reposition Africa from a raw material supplier to an active player in global green economy supply chains.

Value Addition

China’s Role in Mining in Africa (2000–2024)

Scale of Presence

Largest external mining partner: Operates in over 15 African countries.
Dominance in cobalt & lithium: Controls ~80% of DRC’s cobalt output; major stakes in lithium mines in Zimbabwe, Namibia.

Investment Model

Infrastructure-for-resources deals: e.g., Sicomines agreement in DRC (mining rights in exchange for roads, hospitals, railways).
High-value acquisitions: Purchase of mining stakes from global and local firms to secure long-term supply chains.

Strategic Objectives

Securing supply for EV & battery industries: Critical minerals channelled to Chinese manufacturing hubs.
Vertical integration: Ownership from extraction to processing facilities (mostly located in China).

Criticism & Concerns

Limited local benefits: Minimal skills transfer, inadequate job creation.
Environmental damage: Incidents like Zambia’s Kafue River acid spill.
Opaque contracts: Alleged bribery (Namibia) and lack of transparency in revenue flows.

Shifts & Resistance

Renegotiations and policy pushback: DRC increasing state stake in ventures; export bans in Zimbabwe and Namibia.
Civil society pressure: Activist coalitions exposing revenue losses and demanding fairer contracts.

Critical Minerals Geopolitics

Strategic importance: Minerals like cobalt, lithium, and copper are essential for EV batteries, renewable energy storage, and electronics manufacturing.
Global competition: Control over their supply chains influences technological dominance in the clean energy transition.
China’s leverage: By securing ~80% of DRC’s cobalt and significant lithium reserves, China holds a strategic advantage over rivals such as the US, EU, and Japan.
UPSC linkage – Relevant for GS II (International Relations) and GS III (Economy, Technology), particularly in questions on energy security and global trade politics.

Resource Nationalism

Definition: A policy stance where nations assert control over natural resources to maximise domestic benefit and reduce foreign dependency.
African examples: Zimbabwe and Namibia banning export of unprocessed lithium; DRC renegotiating mining contracts to increase state ownership.
Implications: Can boost domestic processing industries but may deter foreign investment if not paired with stable policy frameworks.

Mapping Micro Themes

GS Paper	Theme/Topic	Micro Theme	Example
GS Paper II	International Relations	South-South cooperation & friction	China-Africa mining ties
GS Paper II	Governance	Resource nationalism	DRC renegotiation of Sicomines
GS Paper III	Environment	Ecological threats from mining	Hwange NP permit denial, Kafue River spill

PYQ Relevance

[UPSC 2021] “The USA is facing an existential threat in the form of China, that is much more challenging than the erstwhile Soviet Union.” Explain

Linkage: While the question is US–China centric, Africa’s mining sector is a key arena of US–China competition. China’s dominance over Africa’s critical minerals gives it strategic leverage in global supply chains, posing long-term geopolitical and economic challenges to the US, a dimension comparable to Cold War-era resource and influence battles.

Practice Mains Question

Examine how Africa’s policy shift in mineral governance could alter global supply chains for critical minerals.

Get an IAS/IPS ranker as your 1: 1 personal mentor for UPSC 2024

Attend Now

Innovations in Sciences, IT, Computers, Robotics and Nanotechnology

How does satellite internet work?

Explained | Science Tech | Mains Paper 3: S&T - Applications In Everyday Life

Why in the News:

Elon Musk’s Starlink will soon launch in India, promising high-speed internet access in regions beyond the reach of ground-based networks. This is significant as it can bridge rural-urban gaps, improve disaster resilience, and strengthen defence capabilities. Globally, satellite internet has been a lifeline during Hurricane Harvey and a tactical tool in the Russia-Ukraine war. For India, it represents both a technological leap and a strategic necessity.

Introduction:

In today’s digitised and interconnected world, internet access is as vital as electricity or transport. Traditional cable and tower-based networks excel in cities but falter in remote terrains. Satellite internet, powered by mega-constellations like Starlink, offers a borderless, high-resilience alternative that operates irrespective of geography.

Why are ground-based internet networks economically unviable in certain regions?

Physical Infrastructure Limits: Cables and towers are uneconomical for sparsely populated or remote regions
Disaster Vulnerability: Infrastructure can be wiped out during floods, earthquakes, or storms
On-the-Go Connectivity Gap: Mobile and temporary operations (airplanes, ships, oil rigs) often remain underserved

How does satellite internet overcome these challenges?

Global Coverage: Operates regardless of terrain or terrestrial infrastructure
Rapid Deployment: Can be set up quickly to meet sudden demand surges
Mobility Advantage: Supports moving platforms and remote sites
Dual-Use Potential: Functions for both civil and military purposes (e.g., Ukrainian defence, Siachen Glacier operations)

What makes the new wave of satellite internet significant?

Mega-Constellations: Networks like Starlink have thousands of satellites in Low Earth Orbit (LEO)
Disaster Response Role: Viasat aided Hurricane Harvey operations when 70% of cell towers failed.
Defence Integration: Ukrainian drones fitted with Starlink to bypass Russian jamming; Indian Army use in high-altitude conflict zones
Security Concerns: Smuggled Starlink devices used by insurgent groups and drug cartels

Working of satellite internet:

Two Segments: Space segment (satellites) and ground segment (user terminals, gateways).
Service Life: Satellites operate for 5–20 years depending on design.
Orbits:
1. GEO (35,786 km): Wide coverage, high latency; unsuitable for real-time apps. Example: Viasat GX.
2. MEO (2,000–35,786 km): Medium latency, requires constellations. Example: O3b.
3. LEO (<2,000 km): Low latency, small coverage; requires mega-constellations. Example: Starlink’s 7,000+ satellites.

Key Differences between satellites in GEO, MEO AND LEO:

Feature	Geostationary Earth Orbit (GEO)	Medium Earth Orbit (MEO)	Low Earth Orbit (LEO)
Altitude	35,786 km above equator	2,000 – 35,786 km	Below 2,000 km
Relative Motion	Stationary relative to a point on Earth	Moves relative to Earth	Moves quickly relative to Earth
Coverage	~1/3 of Earth (no polar coverage)	Larger than LEO, smaller than GEO; needs constellation for global coverage	Small footprint; single satellite covers area like an Indian metro city
Satellite Size	Large	Large	Smaller, often table-sized
Cost & Deployment	Expensive, long deployment	Expensive, smaller constellations	Cheaper, quicker to deploy
Latency	High (unsuitable for time-sensitive apps)	Medium (lower than GEO but still limits real-time use)	Very low (good for real-time use)
Example	Viasat Global Xpress (GX)	O3b constellation (20 satellites)	Starlink (7,000+ satellites, aiming for 42,000)
Key Drawback	High delay due to distance	Still costly, latency not ideal for all uses	Needs thousands of satellites for global coverage

How do LEO mega-constellations maintain connectivity?

On-Board Processing: Improves efficiency and reduces terminal complexity
Optical Inter-Satellite Links: Satellites communicate directly in space for faster routing
Seamless Handoff: Steerable antennas track multiple satellites to maintain uninterrupted service

What are the key applications of satellite internet?

Civil Connectivity: Rural broadband, IoE (Internet of Everything)
Transportation: Navigation, self-driving cars, logistics optimisation
Public Administration: Smart cities, disaster warnings, rescue coordination
Healthcare: Telemedicine, remote diagnostics
Agriculture: Precision farming, crop health monitoring
Defence & Security: Real-time communication in conflict zones, strategic surveillance

Conclusion

Satellite internet represents not just a technological upgrade but a strategic asset in the digital era. For India, it offers a pathway to bridge the digital divide, enhance national resilience, and project influence in the global communications domain. However, its dual-use nature demands strong regulatory frameworks to balance innovation, accessibility, and security.

Value Addition

Key Terms & Phrases Explained

Satellite Internet: A communication service where internet connectivity is provided through satellites orbiting the Earth, rather than terrestrial cables/towers. It enables access in remote, disaster-hit, or mobile scenarios.
Mega-Constellation: A large network of hundreds or thousands of satellites, often in Low Earth Orbit (LEO), working in coordination to provide continuous coverage. Example: Starlink (planned 42,000 satellites).
Latency: Time taken for a signal to travel from sender to receiver; critical for real-time applications like video conferencing or online gaming.
Optical Inter-Satellite Links (OISL): Laser-based connections between satellites, enabling direct space-to-space data transfer without routing through ground stations, reducing delays and congestion.
Dual-Use Technology: A technology with both civilian and military applications. In satellite internet, the same network can support remote learning and healthcare or battlefield communication and drone operations.
Digital Divide: The socio-economic gap between those with access to modern digital technologies (internet, computing) and those without.
International Telecommunication Union (ITU): A UN agency responsible for coordinating global telecom networks, including orbital slot and spectrum allocation for satellites.
On-Board Processing: Satellite’s ability to process data directly in orbit, improving signal quality, speed, and reducing complexity of user terminals.
Seamless Handoff: Automatic switching of user connection from one satellite to another as satellites move, ensuring uninterrupted service.
Internet of Everything (IoE): An extension of IoT where not only devices, but also data, processes, and people are interconnected via the internet.

Mapping Micro Themes

Paper	Macro Theme	Micro Themes	Sub-Micro / Example
GS Paper III	Types of Orbits	GEO (Geostationary)	INSAT series, GSAT satellites
		MEO (Medium Earth Orbit)	O3b constellation for broadband
		LEO (Low Earth Orbit)	Starlink, OneWeb
GS Paper III	Application in Navigation	GNSS Variants	GPS (USA), GLONASS (Russia), Galileo (EU), IRNSS/NavIC (India)
GS Paper III	Application in Navigation	LEO & MEO in Navigation	Faster signals, better coverage
GS Paper II	Policy & Governance	India’s Space Policy 2023	PPP in satellite communication
GS Paper II	Policy & Governance	International Coordination	ITU spectrum allocation

Practice Mains Question:

Discuss the potential of satellite internet in bridging the digital divide in India. Examine the associated security and regulatory challenges.

PYQ Linkage:

[UPSC 2018] Why is the Indian Regional Navigational Satellite System [IRNSS] needed? How does it help in navigation?

Linkage: IRNSS (also called NavIC) is India’s indigenous satellite-based navigation system providing accurate position information over India and surrounding regions.

Just like IRNSS uses satellites for positioning, satellite internet uses similar orbital infrastructure for data connectivity. Understanding satellite orbits, latency, and ground segments from this topic directly aids in explaining IRNSS’s working, advantages, and strategic value in navigation.

Get an IAS/IPS ranker as your 1: 1 personal mentor for UPSC 2024

Attend Now

Labour, Jobs and Employment – Harmonization of labour laws, gender gap, unemployment, etc.

Debunking the myth of job creation

Explained | Economics | Mains Paper 3: Issues relating growth and development, employment

Why in the News?

The government has recently approved the Employment Linked Incentive (ELI) Scheme as one of the largest fiscal commitments towards employment generation in recent years. The scale of underemployment in India is striking, over 53% of graduates are working in semi-skilled jobs and 46% of low-skill workers earn less than ₹1 lakh a year raising questions about whether such a scheme can genuinely address unemployment or will deepen structural inequalities.

Significance of ELI Scheme:

Government Approval: Cleared on July 1, 2025, with ₹99,446 crore outlay.
Primary Aim: Provide fiscal incentives to employers for job creation, especially in manufacturing.
Significance: Represents one of the largest government-led employment incentive packages in India.

Issues with the ELI Scheme’s design:

Employer-Centric Approach: Focuses on incentivising employers rather than directly empowering workers.
Capital-Labour Asymmetry: Risks strengthening employer bargaining power while leaving workers vulnerable.
Exclusion of Informal Sector: 90% of India’s workforce, largely informal, is excluded as the scheme prioritises EPFO-registered firms.
Underprepared Workforce: Only 4.9% of youth have received formal vocational training, creating a mismatch between jobs and skills.

Skill Mismatch and Underemployment Trends in India:

Low Skill Utilisation: Only 8.25% of graduates work in jobs matching their qualifications.
High Underemployment: 53% of graduates and 36% of postgraduates in semi-skilled or elementary roles.
Wage Disparity: 46% of low-skilled workers earn < ₹1 lakh/year, while only 4.2% of specialised graduates earn ₹4–8 lakh/year.
Inefficient Education-to-Employment Pipeline: Shows systemic disconnect between education system and industry needs.

Sectoral Imbalance and Employment Implications:

Manufacturing Bias: Targets manufacturing despite its declining employment elasticity.
Employment Share: Manufacturing employs <13% of total workforce, while agriculture and services employ ~70%.
Potential Marginalisation: Rural youth, women, and informal workers, largely in low-skill services/agriculture, risk being left out.
Automation Pressure: Capital-intensive manufacturing growth reduces labour absorption.

Risks to Job Quality and Employment Sustainability:

Disguised Unemployment: May encourage enterprises to relabel old jobs as new to claim subsidies.
Structural Inequality: Channels fiscal benefits to already formalised enterprises.
Bypassing Informal Workforce: Misses the majority of new labour market entrants in the informal sector.
Stagnant Productivity: Without skill investment, job creation may remain low-quality.

Policy Alternatives for Equitable Employment Generation:

Investment in Skilling: Strengthen vocational training to prepare low-skilled workers
Education Reforms: Align curricula with industry demands
Social Security Inclusion: Extend benefits to informal workers for equity
Shift to Long-Term Strategy: Focus on productivity, job quality, and labour rights rather than short-term headcount increases.

Conclusion

The ELI Scheme reflects a high-investment, employer-focused strategy that risks deepening existing inequalities in India’s labour market. Without addressing the skill mismatch, informal sector exclusion, and sectoral imbalances, the scheme may generate headcount without creating sustainable livelihoods. A shift towards worker-centric, skill-driven, and socially inclusive employment policies is essential to ensure equitable economic growth.

Value Addition

Economic Survey 2024–25

Key Insight: Reveals that only 8.25% of graduates are in jobs matching their qualifications, with 53% of graduates underemployed in semi-skilled or elementary roles.
Relevance: Strengthens arguments on the education–employment disconnect and the urgent need for targeted skilling reforms.
Application: Can be quoted in answers on unemployment, skill development, or human capital formation.

Dual Labour Market Theory

Concept: The labour market is split into two segments, formal (primary) with stable jobs, better wages, and benefits; and informal (secondary) with insecure, low-paid work and no social protection.
Relevance to ELI Scheme: The scheme’s EPFO-based targeting inherently supports the formal sector while neglecting the 90% informal workforce, deepening this divide.
Application: Useful in analysing structural inequality in employment policies.

Employment Elasticity

Definition: The responsiveness of employment growth to GDP growth.
India’s Case: Manufacturing’s employment elasticity is declining due to automation and capital-intensive processes.
Relevance to ELI Scheme: Explains why heavy focus on manufacturing may not yield proportional employment gains.
Application: Adds depth when evaluating sectoral choices in employment policy.

ILO’s “Decent Work” Agenda

Framework: Promotes productive employment, rights at work, social protection, and social dialogue.
Relevance: The ELI Scheme lacks strong components on worker rights, social protection for informal workers, or job quality improvement — thereby falling short of ILO’s standards.
Application: Ideal for international comparison in labour policy answers.

Disguised Unemployment

Definition: A situation where more workers are employed than necessary, resulting in negligible or zero marginal productivity.
Indian Context: Common in agriculture and informal services.
Relevance to ELI Scheme: Risk of enterprises relabeling existing jobs as new to claim subsidies, creating apparent employment without productivity gains.
Application: Can be linked to inefficiencies in job creation schemes and low productivity traps.

Mapping Microthemes:

GS Paper	Theme	Micro Theme	Example from Article
GS Paper III	Economy	Employment generation policies	₹99,446 crore ELI Scheme
GS Paper III	Economy	Formal–informal sector divide	90% informal workforce excluded
GS Paper III	Economy	Skill mismatch & underemployment	8.25% graduates in matching jobs
GS Paper III	Economy	Sectoral imbalance	Manufacturing bias despite low share in jobs
GS Paper II	Governance	Policy design flaws	Employer-centric incentives

Practice Mains Question

Critically evaluate the Employment Linked Incentive (ELI) Scheme in the context of India’s structural labour market challenges. Suggest policy measures to ensure equitable and sustainable employment growth. (250 words)

PYQ Linkage:

[UPSC 2014] “While we flaunt India’s demographic dividend, we ignore the dropping rates of employability.” What are we missing while doing so? Where will the jobs that India desperately needs come from? Explain.

Linkage: Address the role of skilling in tackling unemployment, evaluate gaps in current initiatives, and connect with how ELI Scheme mirrors or misses these elements. The PMKVY question emphasises the necessity of industry-relevant skills for employment generation. The ELI Scheme, while aiming at job creation, lacks a robust skilling component, risking the same shortcomings seen in earlier programmes like PMKVY.

Get an IAS/IPS ranker as your 1: 1 personal mentor for UPSC 2024

Attend Now

Industrial Sector Updates – Industrial Policy, Ease of Doing Business, etc.

What will be the impact of Google antitrust case?

Explained | Economics | Mains Paper 3: Effects Of Liberalization On The Economy, Changes In Industrial Policy and their effects on Industrial Growth

The Google–Competition Commission of India (CCI), anti-trust case is a pivotal moment for India’s digital market regulation. It revolves around allegations that Google abused its dominant position in the Android ecosystem to indulge in anti-competitive practices, especially through mandatory Google Play Billing System (GPBS) usage and bundling of proprietary apps. The matter now rests with the Supreme Court, which will hear appeals from Google, the Competition Commission of India (CCI), and the Alliance Digital India Foundation (ADIF) in November 2025.

Background: The Core Dispute in Brief

CCI’s Key Findings (2022)

Abuse of Dominance under Section 4 of the Competition Act, 2002.
Mandatory use of Google Play Billing System (GPBS) for in-app purchases (15–30% commission).
Self-preferencing — exempting YouTube from GPBS, giving it a cost advantage.
Bundling of Google apps (Search, Chrome, YouTube) with Android licensing.
Imposed a ₹936.44 crore fine and behavioural remedies (decoupling payment system, transparency in billing data, no use of developer data for competitive advantage).

Google’s Defence

Open-Source Nature: Open-source Android with no obligation to install Google apps if the Play Store is not licensed.
Pre-installation improves user experience and security.
Security and User Experience: GPBS ensures fraud protection and global distribution reach.
Exemptions for in-house services reflect different business models.
Market Competition: Success of major Indian apps (like PhonePe and Paytm) on the Android platform as proof of competitive market

National Company Law Appellate Tribunal (NCLAT) Ruling (March 2025)

Upheld parts of CCI’s findings (bundling & GPBS abuse).
Reduced penalty to ₹216.69 crore (proportionality principle).
Struck down some remedies, reinstated two key transparency-related directions in review.

Broader Implications and Stakeholders

Consumers: More choice and possibly lower in-app prices via alternative payment gateways; risk of Android ecosystem fragmentation.
Indian Startups & Developers: Level playing field, competitive payment options, and stronger bargaining power against Big Tech.
Smartphone Manufacturers (OEMs): Greater flexibility to pre-install own services or use alternative Android versions without losing Play Store access.
Google & Global Tech: May need to re-evaluate global Android business model; could trigger similar regulations in other countries.
Regulatory Bodies: Will define CCI’s role in digital market regulation and set precedent for balancing innovation, competition, and consumer rights.

Conclusion

The Google antitrust case is not just about app payments — it is about defining the rules of engagement in India’s platform economy. The Supreme Court’s verdict will influence how innovation, competition, and consumer rights are balanced in the digital age. It could either mark a new era of platform accountability or reinforce the status quo, shaping the way over a billion Indians interact with their smartphones

Value Addition:

Antitrust:

It refers to a set of laws and regulations designed to prevent monopolies, stop abuse of market dominance, and ensure fair competition in the market.
Purpose: Protect consumers, encourage innovation, and maintain a level playing field for businesses.
Example in India: The Competition Act, 2002, enforced by the Competition Commission of India (CCI), is India’s primary antitrust law
Example globally: The Sherman Antitrust Act (1890) in the U.S.
In simple words: Antitrust laws stop big companies from becoming so powerful that no one else can compete with them fairly.

Mapping Micro Themes

Subject	Topic Name	Micro Theme	Example
GS Paper -II	Regulatory Institutions	Role, functions, and challenges of statutory bodies like CCI & quasi-judicial bodies like NCLAT	CCI’s penalty on Google for abuse of dominance; NCLAT’s partial reversal
	Government Policies	Policy needs for digital governance & fair digital ecosystem	Draft Digital Competition Bill; TRAI’s consultation on platform regulation
	Judicial Intervention	Role of judiciary in interpreting digital economy laws	Supreme Court hearing Google–CCI appeal
GS Paper-III	Competition Law	Abuse of dominance, anti-competitive practices, cartelisation in the digital economy	Google Play Billing System commission model
	Digital Economy	Impact of Big Tech on market structure, innovation, startups	App developers’ reduced bargaining power due to Google’s policies
	Innovation vs Regulation	Balancing tech growth and preventing monopolistic behaviour	CCI’s remedies vs Google’s claim of user experience efficiency
	Digital Public Goods	Need for open, fair ecosystems for inclusive growth	UPI as an open-access payment system in contrast to GPBS
	Platform Neutrality	Equal treatment for all apps/services on digital platforms	Ban on self-preferencing in EU’s Digital Markets Act

PYQ Linkage

[UPSC 2020] How is the Government of India protecting traditional knowledge of medicine from patenting by pharmaceutical companies?

Linkage: This question demands explaining legal, institutional, and international mechanisms (like TKDL, Patents Act provisions, WIPO engagement) that protect India’s traditional medicinal knowledge from unfair patenting. Similarly, in the Google–CCI case, India is using competition law and regulatory bodies to protect local digital market interests against global corporate dominance, ensuring fair competition and safeguarding the domestic innovation ecosystem.

Practice Mains Question:

“In the context of India’s Competition Act, 2002, discuss how the Google–CCI case reflects the challenges of regulating digital platform dominance. Suggest measures to balance innovation and market fairness.”

Get an IAS/IPS ranker as your 1: 1 personal mentor for UPSC 2024

Attend Now

Oil and Gas Sector – HELP, Open Acreage Policy, etc.

Assuaging concerns: On India and ethanol-blended fuel

Explained | Enviro & Biodiversity | Mains Paper 3: Conservation, Environmental Pollution & Degradation, Eia

Introduction:

Ethanol blending with petrol, mixing ethyl alcohol derived from biomass with conventional fuel, began globally in response to the oil shocks of the 1970s, with countries like the U.S. and Brazil leading the way. In India, the push is driven by three key factors:

Import substitution to save foreign exchange
Price advantage compared to petrol
Lower carbon footprint

The Government of India has set a target of 20% ethanol blending (E20) by 2025, aiming to save $10 billion annually in import costs. Yet, technical limitations, uneven economic benefits, and food security concerns demand a careful, transparent approach.

Rationale Behind Ethanol Blending in India

Import Substitution: Reducing dependency on crude oil imports.
Economic Benefit: Estimated savings of $10 billion annually.
Environmental Considerations: Ethanol is considered carbon-neutral as the CO₂ emitted during combustion is offset by plant absorption during growth.
Waste Utilisation: Use of C-heavy molasses, broken rice, and maize to avoid wastage and enhance rural income.

Economic and Agricultural Concerns

Uneven Benefits:
1. Farmers, traders, and distillers benefit differently: sugarcane-growing regions may profit disproportionately.
2. Maize, being less water-intensive, is promoted for ethanol feedstock, but scaling up acreage and productivity has its limits.
Food Security Risks: Initial use of non-edible or surplus produce avoids conflict, but once ethanol supply chains are entrenched, prioritising food over fuel during shortages may become politically difficult.
Hidden Imports: Fertilizers and other agricultural inputs required for ethanol crops may lead to forex outflow, negating some import savings.

Technical and Engineering Challenges

Efficiency Penalty:

1. Ethanol has lower energy density than petrol, leading to reduced fuel efficiency.
2. Material durability issues: corrosion of fuel systems and engine parts.

Vehicle Compatibility:

1. BS-II (since 2001) norms allow safe use up to E15.
2. Vehicles sold since 2023 can handle E20, but older vehicles may face damage.
3. Lack of consumer choice in fuel type is a concern.

International Experience:

1. U.S. and Brazil’s long history shows ethanol blending is feasible with proper engineering, norms, and market flexibility.

Policy Framework and Transparency Issues

India has two ethanol-specific fuel norms and is moving towards E27 (Brazil model).
Price benefits not visible at fuel stations despite earlier claims.
Absence of clear consumer disclosures on vehicle compatibility.
Need for automakers to publish past model ethanol limits and mitigation measures.
Insurance policies must cover ethanol-related damages.

Conclusion

Ethanol blending offers India a chance to reduce oil imports, utilise agricultural surplus, and move towards greener energy. However, policy success depends on technical readiness, transparency, equitable benefits, and food security safeguards. A balanced roadmap, combining engineering upgrades, farmer diversification, consumer choice, and global best practices, is essential for a sustainable ethanol economy.

Value Addition

Ethanol: Definition & Types

Ethanol: Ethyl alcohol (C₂H₅OH), a renewable biofuel produced by fermenting sugar/starch-based crops or cellulosic biomass.
Blended Fuel: Petrol mixed with ethanol in specific proportions (e.g., E10, E20, E27)

Key Facts for UPSC

National Policy on Biofuels 2018 (amended 2022): Advanced target for 20% blending (E20) by 2025–26 from 2030.
Sources in India: Sugarcane juice, C-heavy molasses, damaged food grains, maize, surplus rice.
Economic Impact: $10 billion/year projected forex savings with E20 blending (MoPNG & NITI Aayog’s joint report “Roadmap for Ethanol Blending in India 2020–25”)
Environmental Impact: Estimated reduction of 27 million tonnes CO₂/year at E20 (NITI Aayog’s 2021 roadmap document, calculated based on life-cycle emissions studies).

Global Comparisons

Country	Current Blending Standard	Notable Feature
Brazil	E27	Long-standing flex-fuel vehicle ecosystem
USA	E10–E15	Voluntary blending with incentives
India	Target E20 by 2025–26	Mandatory programme via OMCs

Vehicle Compatibility Norms

BS-II (since 2001): Safe up to E15.
Since 2023: Vehicles designed for E20 compatibility.
Flex-Fuel Vehicles (FFVs): Can run on any ethanol-petrol mix (0–100%).

Related Schemes & Initiatives

Ethanol Blended Petrol (EBP) Programme: Launched 2003, scaled up post-2014.
PM–JIVAN Yojana: Supports 2G ethanol projects using lignocellulosic biomass.
SATAT Scheme: Promotes compressed bio-gas (CBG) as transport fuel.

Micro Theme Mapping

Paper	Topic	Micro Theme	Example
GS Paper III	Sustainable Development/Pollution	Biofuel production from agricultural residues	Ethanol from C-heavy molasses, broken rice under EBP Programme
GS Paper III	Food–Fuel Debate	Balancing ethanol feedstock with food security	Maize promotion for ethanol with lower water footprint
GS Paper I	Urbanisation- Urban Challenges	Waste generation pressure in cities	Indore’s waste segregation success
GS Paper IV	Transparency	Public disclosure in environmental compliance	Automakers’ ethanol compatibility disclosures

PYQ Linkage

“[UPSC 2018] What are the impediments in disposing the huge quantities of discarded solid wastes which are continuously being generated? How do we remove safely the toxic wastes that have been accumulating in our habitable environment?

Linkage: India’s solid waste disposal is hampered by poor segregation, inadequate processing plants, and weak enforcement of rules. Toxic waste removal suffers from limited treatment capacity and high costs. Solutions include scientific landfills, incineration, bioremediation, and EPR. Waste-to-energy projects like ethanol from crop residues show sustainable disposal in action.

Practice Mains Question

Critically analyse the potential of ethanol blending as a sustainable fuel solution for India. Discuss the associated challenges in terms of technology, agriculture, and policy transparency.

Get an IAS/IPS ranker as your 1: 1 personal mentor for UPSC 2024

Attend Now

Artificial Intelligence (AI) Breakthrough

How is AI reshaping India’s infotech sector?

Explained | Science Tech | Mains Paper 3: Awareness in various sc and tech fields

PYQ Relevance:

[UPSC 2023] Introduce the concept of Artificial Intelligence (AI). How does Al help clinical diagnosis? Do you perceive any threat to privacy of the individual in the use of Al in healthcare?

Linkage: Artificial Intelligence (AI) simulates human intelligence to perform tasks like analysis, prediction, and decision-making, and in healthcare, it aids clinical diagnosis through rapid image interpretation, predictive analytics, and early disease detection. Linking to India’s evolving IT sector, AI’s role in data management and compliance can ensure safe healthcare adoption, but risks such as data breaches, misuse of personal health records, and algorithmic bias highlight the need for strong privacy safeguards and ethical standards.

Introduction:

The Indian IT industry, valued at $280 billion and employing over 5.8 million people, has been the backbone of India’s digital economy for decades. However, the rise of AI is reshaping business models, altering talent requirements, and compelling firms to rethink their role in the global technology ecosystem. Far from being a simple “job killer,” AI is redefining the industry’s competitive advantage.

Why is the IT Industry in Restructuring Mode?

Beyond the “AI kills jobs” narrative:
1. The shake-up is not merely about replacing human workers with AI, but about re-engineering processes for efficiency and scale.
2. AI is driving transformation across the entire software lifecycle — from coding to testing and maintenance.
The TCS trigger:
1. TCS’s freeze on experienced hires and planned removal of 12,000 employees has been interpreted as a signal to markets, clients, and employees:
2. Markets: Cost optimisation and forward-looking adaptation.
3. Clients: AI-powered efficiency.
4. Employees: Need for continuous upskilling.

Why is AI Gaining Momentum Now?

Cost-optimisation as a driver:

1. AI-led productivity boosts (30%+) are critical in a cost-sensitive, investor-driven market.
2. Examples: AI-powered coding assistants, intelligent debuggers, automated testing.

Investment surge:

1. In 2025, $1 trillion+ expected global spending on AI infrastructure, training, and applications.

Impact on Jobs and Skills

Job contraction in some areas:
1. Automation, low-code platforms, and AI reduce the need for large teams in certain roles.
2. Example: U.S. firms openly using workforce attrition to streamline operations.
Skills that remain resilient:
1. Core coding in C++ (OS, gaming, security systems), robotics, embedded systems.
2. High-value areas: product management, UI/UX, tech architecture.
Traits that will rule: math skills, imagination, problem-solving.

Opportunity for India’s IT Sector

Addressing global AI adoption barriers:

1. Legacy systems, poor data quality, and compliance requirements are major bottlenecks abroad.
2. Indian firms can: Modernise systems, Organise and clean data and Build compliant AI solutions (aligning with laws like EU’s AI Act).

Moving from “back office” to “AI innovation partners”:

1. Future advantage lies with small, lean AI-native teams solving complex domain-specific problems (healthcare, defence, fintech, sustainability, education).

From Scale to Specialisation:

The traditional “IT park with thousands of coders” model is declining.
A 50-member AI-focused team can outperform a 5,000-member legacy services team.
Requires cultural shift in Indian IT firms from scale efficiency to innovation agility.

Conclusion:

AI is not the end of India’s IT story, but a call for reinvention. By leveraging its talent pool, improving innovation culture, and addressing global AI adoption barriers, India can position itself not just as a participant but as a shaper of the AI era. The challenge lies in embracing the shift from large-scale coding work to lean, high-value, AI-driven problem solving.

Value Addition:

Thinkers & Scholars on AI:

Andrej Karpathy

Background: Former Director of AI at Tesla, known for his work on deep learning and computer vision.
View: Describes the shift to Software 2.0 and 3.0, where AI models themselves become the primary source code, reducing the advantage of large coding teams.
Relevance: Highlights why India’s IT sector must shift from scale-based operations to innovation-focused, AI-native solutions.

V. Balakrishnan

Background: Chairman, Exfinity Ventures; former CFO at Infosys.
View: AI is becoming the fabric of enterprise operations, shaping everything from customer service to boardroom decision-making; Indian IT firms can become enablers of global AI adoption.
Relevance: Emphasises India’s opportunity in data cleaning, system modernisation, and AI compliance.

Extra Mile:

AI Capitalism – Concept: It refers to an economic and social order where artificial intelligence technologies become a core driver of capital accumulation, market power, and social influence. In this system, AI is not just a tool but a means of consolidating wealth and control in the hands of a few global tech giants, venture capital firms, and AI infrastructure providers.

Scholars and Thinkers

Shoshana Zuboff (The Age of Surveillance Capitalism) – Warns that AI capitalism commodifies human behaviour through constant data extraction.
Nick Srnicek (Platform Capitalism) – Argues AI platforms centralise power and reshape markets in ways that undermine competition.
Kate Crawford (Atlas of AI) – Highlights the environmental, political, and ethical costs of AI capitalism.

Mapping Micro-themes:

GS PAPER II

Governance in technology adoption, regulation, Tech policy & regulation, India as a global technology partner:

Regulatory dimension: Global AI governance (EU AI Act) influencing Indian compliance services.
Geopolitical angle: India’s role as a trusted AI partner amid U.S.-China tech tensions.

GS PAPER III

Economic growth, employment (AI & automation impact on employment ), AI innovation ecosystem (Innovation-driven economy), Start-up ecosystem in AI

Economic implications: Job losses in low-skilled IT roles vs. high-skilled job creation in AI.

GS PAPER IV

Ethical AI (fairness, transparency, bias mitigation)

Examples:

TCS workforce restructuring as a market signal
EU AI Act influencing compliance-driven service demand
AI-native teams in healthcare and defence as future growth hubs

Practice Mains Question

Discuss how Artificial Intelligence is reshaping India’s information technology sector. In your answer, highlight both the challenges and opportunities this transition presents. (250 words)

Get an IAS/IPS ranker as your 1: 1 personal mentor for UPSC 2024

Attend Now

Waste Management – SWM Rules, EWM Rules, etc

What are the new rules on chemically contaminated sites?

Explained | Enviro & Biodiversity | Mains Paper 3: Conservation, Environmental Pollution & Degradation, Eia

[UPSC 2023] Enumerate the National Water Policy of India. Taking river Ganges as an example, discuss the strategies which may be adopted for river water pollution control and management. What are the legal provisions of management and handling of hazardous wastes in India?

Linkage: The National Water Policy emphasises pollution prevention, water quality monitoring, and restoration of contaminated water bodies. Strategies for river pollution control, such as those for the Ganga, parallel the approach in the Environment Protection (Management of Contaminated Sites) Rules, 2025, which involve identification, assessment, remediation, and polluter accountability. Legal provisions for hazardous waste management include the Environment Protection Act, 1986 and the Hazardous and Other Wastes (Management and Transboundary Movement) Rules, 2016, under which contaminated site rules now operate.

Introduction

India has identified 103 contaminated sites across states, caused by historical dumping of hazardous wastes. These sites often lie abandoned, with polluters defunct or unable to pay for clean-up. The newly notified Environment Protection (Management of Contaminated Sites) Rules, 2025 under the Environment Protection Act provide the first legal, institutional, and procedural framework to identify, assess, and remediate such locations, addressing a long-standing regulatory gap.

What are Contaminated Sites?

Defined by the Central Pollution Control Board (CPCB) as areas where past dumping of hazardous wastes has likely contaminated soil, groundwater, and surface water, posing risks to human health and ecosystems.
Examples: Landfills, waste storage/treatment sites, spill-sites, and abandoned chemical handling facilities.
Out of 103 identified sites, only 7 have begun remediation.

Background – Why New Rules Were Needed:

2010 Capacity Building Program for Industrial Pollution Management Project initiated by the Environment Ministry aimed to:
1. Create an inventory of probable contaminated sites.
2. Develop guidance for assessment and remediation.
3. Establish a legal, institutional, and financial framework — the missing final step until 2025.
Previous absence of legal codification led to delays, inconsistent responses, and lack of accountability.

Key Provisions of the 2025 Rules

Identification & Assessment Process:

District Administration: Submits half-yearly reports on suspected sites.
State Board/Reference Organisation:
1. Preliminary assessment within 90 days.
2. Detailed survey within another 90 days to confirm contamination.
3. Establish levels of hazardous chemicals (189 listed under Hazardous and Other Wastes Rules, 2016).

Public Notification & Restrictions

Sites exceeding safe chemical levels are publicly listed.
Access restrictions imposed to safeguard health.

Remediation Planning

Expert body drafts remediation plan.
Polluters identified within 90 days; responsible parties bear clean-up costs.
If polluters cannot pay, State/Centre funds the remediation.

Legal Accountability

Criminal liability under Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023 if contamination leads to loss of life or damage.

Exemptions

Radioactive waste
mining waste
marine oil pollution
municipal solid waste dumps; governed by separate legislations.

Key Gaps & Challenges

No fixed remediation deadline post-identification.
Capacity limitations in expert bodies.
Financial constraints for large-scale clean-ups.
Coordination issues between Centre, States, and Local Bodies.

Conclusion

The 2025 Rules mark a significant policy milestone in India’s environmental governance. While they close a crucial legal gap, their success will depend on timely implementation, strong enforcement, and adequate funding. Integrating strict timelines, expanding technical expertise, and ensuring polluter accountability will be essential to safeguard public health and restore ecological balance.

Value Addition:

Environment Protection (Management of Contaminated Sites) Rules, 2025 are Applicable on:

‘Radioactive waste’ as defined under the Atomic Energy (Safe Disposal of Radioactive Wastes) Rules, 1987
‘Mining operations’ as defined under the Mines and Minerals (Development and Regulation) Act, 1957
Pollution of the sea by oil or oily substance as governed by Merchant Shipping Act of 1958 and the Merchant Shipping (Prevention of Pollution of the Sea by Oil) Rules, 1974
‘Solid waste dump’ as defined under Solid Waste Management Rules, 2016.
In case contamination of a site is due to a contaminant mixed with radioactive waste/ mining operations/ oil spill/ solid waste from dump site, and if the contamination of the site due to the contaminant exceeds the limit of response level specified in these rules, then remediation of the site would be covered under these rules.

Extra Mile:

Case Linkage: Bhopal Gas Tragedy (1984) – absence of strict site remediation frameworks
Environmental Principles:
1. Polluter Pays Principle
2. Precautionary Principle
3. Sustainable Development
Global Context: Comparable frameworks exist in the USA (Comprehensive Environmental Response, Compensation, and Liability Act – CERCLA), EU’s Environmental Liability Directive.
Policy Linkages: National Environmental Policy 2006, SDG-3 (Health), SDG-6 (Clean Water), SDG-15 (Life on Land).

Mapping Micro-themes

GS PAPER I	Environmental degradation and public health impacts
GS PAPER II	Centre-State coordination in environmental regulation; constitutional provisions (Art. 21, 48A, 243W)
GS PAPER III	Pollution management, hazardous waste rules, environmental governance, technology in remediation
GS PAPER IV	Corporate ethics, polluter responsibility, environmental stewardship, intergenerational equity

Practice Mains Question

Q: The Environment Protection (Management of Contaminated Sites) Rules, 2025, represent a long-awaited legal framework for chemical contamination in India. Discuss their significance, key features, and challenges in the context of sustainable environmental governance. (250 words)

Get an IAS/IPS ranker as your 1: 1 personal mentor for UPSC 2024

Attend Now

Minority Issues – SC, ST, Dalits, OBC, Reservations, etc.

Revision of creamy layer income limit ‘need of the hour’:

Explained | Polity | Mains Paper 2: Indian Constitution - historical underpinnings, evolution, features, amendments, significant provisions and basic structure

The Parliamentary Committee on Welfare of Other Backward Classes (OBCs) has reiterated the need to revise the “creamy layer” income ceiling for OBC reservation benefits. It called the revision the “need of the hour”, citing inflation and rising income levels, which have rendered the current ₹8 lakh per annum limit (fixed in 2017) inadequate. The Ministry of Social Justice and Empowerment (MoSJE), however, stated that there is currently no proposal under consideration for a revision.

Understanding the “Creamy Layer” Concept

Introduced following the Indra Sawhney v. Union of India (1992) judgment of the Supreme Court, which upheld 27% OBC reservation but excluded the socially advanced among them.
The creamy layer criterion is an economic threshold: those above the prescribed annual family income are excluded from OBC reservation benefits.
Initially set at ₹1 lakh (1993), it has been revised periodically, ₹2.5 lakh in 2004, ₹4.5 lakh in 2008, ₹6 lakh in 2013, ₹6.5 lakh in 2014, ₹8 lakh in 2017 (last revision)
1. As per DoPT norms, revision should occur every 3 years.

OBC Reservations in India: Historical Background

Constitutional Foundation

Article 15(4): Allows the State to make special provisions for the advancement of socially and educationally backward classes (SEBCs), Scheduled Castes (SCs), and Scheduled Tribes (STs).
Article 16(4): Empowers the State to provide reservation in appointments or posts in favour of any backward class not adequately represented in State services.
Article 340: Empowers the President to appoint a commission to investigate conditions of backward classes and recommend measures.

Significance of Revising the Creamy Layer Limit

Social Justice: Ensures benefits reach those who truly need them, keeping pace with economic changes.
Reducing Inequality: Supports more OBC families in accessing education, jobs, and government schemes.
Compliance with Policy Guidelines: DoPT’s 1993 order mandates periodic revisions.

Challenges

Balancing Reservation Benefits: Avoiding over-expansion that may dilute benefits for the most marginalized.
Economic vs. Social Backwardness: Income is only one indicator; social deprivation is harder to quantify.
Political Consensus: Reservation policy changes are politically sensitive.

Committee’s Concerns on the Current ₹8 Lakh Threshold

Erosion by Inflation: Rising basic income levels have reduced the effectiveness of the threshold.

Exclusion of Needy Segments: Many OBC families in need of reservation benefits are above ₹8 lakh but still economically disadvantaged in terms of education and access to resources.

Socio-Economic Goals: Wider coverage will help raise the social and educational status of more OBC families.

Way Forward

Periodic & Transparent Revision: Institutionalize automatic inflation-indexed adjustments.
Comprehensive Backwardness Index: Incorporate education, occupation, and rural/urban disparities along with income.
Targeted Scholarships: Expand pre-matric support for lower classes to improve educational pipelines.
Better Data: Conduct regular socio-economic surveys for evidence-based policy.

The creamy layer provision is a critical filter to ensure reservation benefits reach the truly disadvantaged among OBCs. With inflation and rising income levels, the current ₹8 lakh ceiling may no longer serve its purpose effectively. The Parliamentary Committee’s push for revision aligns with constitutional principles of equality and social justice, but implementation will require careful balancing of inclusivity, efficiency, and fairness.

Value Addition

Key Developments:

First Backward Classes Commission (Kaka Kalelkar Commission, 1953) – recommended caste-based reservations, but not implemented due to lack of quantifiable data.
Second Backward Classes Commission (Mandal Commission, 1979) – recommended 27% reservation for OBCs in government jobs and educational institutions, implemented in 1990.
Indra Sawhney Case (1992) – capped total reservation at 50% and introduced the creamy layer exclusion for OBCs.

Recent Trends

The 102nd Constitutional Amendment (2018) gave constitutional status to the National Commission for Backward Classes (NCBC).
The 105th Constitutional Amendment (2021) restored the power of states to identify OBCs for their own purposes.

Mains Practice Questions:

“Reservation for backward classes should be based on social and educational backwardness rather than economic criteria alone.” Discuss.
The creamy layer in OBC reservation is a safeguard for ensuring equity within equity.’ Comment.

Get an IAS/IPS ranker as your 1: 1 personal mentor for UPSC 2024

Attend Now

Industrial Sector Updates – Industrial Policy, Ease of Doing Business, etc.

Industrial Accidents in India – The Human Cost of Indifference

Explained | Economics | Mains Paper 3: Effects Of Liberalization On The Economy, Changes In Industrial Policy and their effects on Industrial Growth

Industrial accidents in India are neither rare nor accidental; they are recurring human tragedies rooted in systemic negligence, regulatory apathy, and corporate cost-cutting. From chemical plant explosions in Telangana to firecracker unit disasters in Tamil Nadu, these incidents underscore a grim reality, industrial safety in India is still treated as a compliance hurdle rather than a fundamental right.

Magnitude of the Problem

6,500 workers have died in the last five years in factories, construction sites, and mines averaging three fatalities every day in peacetime.
Centre for Science and Environment (2022): Over 130 major chemical accidents in 30 months post-2020, causing 218 deaths and over 300 injuries.
Small and medium-sized enterprises (SMEs) are disproportionately involved, often escaping robust inspections.

Root Causes of Industrial Accidents in India

Regulatory Non-compliance:
1. Factories operating without Fire Department No-Objection Certificates (NOCs).
2. Missing or dysfunctional firefighting systems, alarms, and sensors.
Unsafe Work Practices:
1. Absence of permit-to-work systems for high-risk jobs.
2. Migrant and contract workers without language-appropriate training or signage.
Infrastructure Failures:
1. Locked or blocked emergency exits.
2. Poor maintenance of hazardous material storage.
Weak Enforcement and Accountability:
1. Safety audits treated as formalities.
2. Negligible penalties and rare convictions for violations.
Cultural Mindset:
1. Safety seen as an “overhead” instead of a core operational value.
2. Class bias — migrant and contract workers’ lives undervalued.

Comparative Global Perspective

Germany, Japan: Safety is embedded into industrial design and workplace culture.
South Korea, Singapore: Corporate manslaughter laws hold senior executives criminally liable for gross safety failures.

Policy and Governance Gaps in India

Industrial safety boards are under-resourced.
Weak whistle-blower protections discourage reporting of hazards.
Digital risk-reporting systems are minimal or absent.
Limited integration between labour inspection, pollution control boards, and disaster management authorities.

India-Specific Legal and Policy Framework

Factories Act, 1948: Provides provisions on workplace safety, health, and welfare of workers, mandates fencing of machinery, safety officers, and periodic medical examinations.
Occupational Safety, Health and Working Conditions Code, 2020: Consolidates 13 labour laws on safety and health, Introduces provisions for free annual health check-ups, safety committees, and hazard communication.
Environment (Protection) Act, 1986: Framework law for protecting and improving environmental safety, including hazardous process management, Manufacture, Storage and Import of Hazardous Chemical Rules, 1989, Requires industries to prepare onsite and offsite emergency plans.
Explosives Act, 1884 & Petroleum Act, 1934: Regulate storage, handling, and usage of explosive and flammable substances.
Bhopal Gas Leak (Processing of Claims) Act, 1985: First special legislation to address industrial disaster victims’ compensation
National Disaster Management Act, 2005: Guides chemical, biological, radiological, and nuclear safety protocols through the NDMA.

Way Forward

Strengthen Enforcement: Make industrial safety audits independent and transparent; link non-compliance to criminal liability.
Digitisation: Use real-time IoT monitoring for hazard detection and compliance tracking.
Worker Empowerment: Mandate safety training in local languages for all employees, especially contract labour.
Corporate Accountability: Introduce Corporate Manslaughter Legislation for gross negligence causing worker deaths.
Social Responsibility: Shift from post-accident compensation to pre-accident prevention culture.

Conclusion

Industrial accidents are not “acts of God” but acts of neglect. India possesses the legal framework to ensure safe workplaces, but without societal outrage, political will, and corporate responsibility, these frameworks remain on paper. For every worker who risks life and limb, industrial safety must be recognised and enforced as a right, not a privilege.

Practice Mains Question:

“Industrial accidents in India are not acts of fate but outcomes of systemic negligence.” Discuss the causes, implications, and reforms needed, with reference to recent incidents and existing legal frameworks.

(250 words, 15 marks)

Get an IAS/IPS ranker as your 1: 1 personal mentor for UPSC 2024

Attend Now

Port Infrastructure and Shipping Industry – Sagarmala Project, SDC, CEZ, etc.

The Coastal Shipping Bill, 2024: A Legislative Milestone for Maritime Growth

Explained | Economics | Mains Paper 3: Infrastructure: Energy, Ports, Roads, Airports, Railways Etc.

The Coastal Shipping Bill, 2024, which replaced Part XIV of the Merchant Shipping Act, 1958, marks a significant legislative reform aimed at modernizing and streamlining India’s coastal trade. It is a key component of the government’s vision for a “Viksit Bharat” and “Aatmanirbhar Bharat,” aiming to unlock the vast potential of India’s coastline. It provides a dedicated legal framework to boost coastal trade, reduce logistics costs, and promote sustainable transportation.

Need for the new Coastal Shipping Bill, 2024:

Repeals Part XIV of the Merchant Shipping Act, 1958, which was outdated and limited in scope.
Coastal cargo movement had been growing (119% increase from 2014–15 to 2023–24), yet regulatory hurdles, outdated provisions, and fragmented oversight hindered its full potential.
Aligns with key national missions such as PM Gati Shakti, National Logistics Policy, Sagarmala Programme and Maritime Amrit Kaal Vision 2047

Key Provisions of the Coastal Shipping Bill, 2024

The Act’s jurisdiction extends to vessels engaged in trade within India’s coastal waters, which include territorial waters (up to 12 nautical miles) and adjoining maritime zones (up to 200 nautical miles).

Expanded Definition of Coastal Trade:
- Earlier: Only carriage of goods and passengers.
- Now: Includes services such as exploration, research, and commercial activities, excluding fishing.
- Recognizes maritime zones up to 200 nautical miles from the Indian coast.
Simplified Licensing Framework: Supports Indian shipbuilding, maritime employment, and reduces regulatory burden.

Vessel Type	Licensing Requirement
Indian-owned vessels	Exempted for coastal trade
Foreign/chartered vessels	License required (issued by DG Shipping)
OCI-chartered vessels operating outside India	No license required

Mandated Strategic Planning: National Coastal and Inland Shipping Strategic Plan must be prepared within 2 years and reviewed biennially. It is to be designed by a committee with state representation, ensuring cooperative federalism.
National Database for Coastal Shipping: Aims for real-time tracking, transparency, and data-driven policymaking. It keeps investors informed and supports infrastructure planning.
Modernised Penalties and Decriminalisation

Strategic Vision and Long-term Impact

“This is a forward-looking, holistic framework aligned with global cabotage practices.”

— Union Minister of Ports, Shipping and Waterways

Economic Transformation:
1. Aims to increase India’s coastal cargo share to 230 million metric tonnes by 2030.
2. Reduces logistics cost (currently ~14% of GDP) by shifting cargo from roads/rails to coastal routes
3. Coastal shipping is 80% cheaper and more energy-efficient than road transport
Environmental Sustainability:
1. Supports Net Zero by 2070
2. Encourages green transport and lower-emission logistics
Job Creation and Industry Support:
1. Boosts shipbuilding, port services, and manning jobs
2. Encourages Make in India in the maritime sector.
Strengthened Maritime Security: Greater share of domestic cargo handled by Indian ships reduces reliance on foreign vessels.
Cooperative Federalism: Includes states and UTs in decision-making, enabling inclusive and participatory governance.

The Coastal Shipping Bill, 2024, represents a landmark step towards building a seamless, efficient, and globally competitive maritime ecosystem in India. By modernizing regulations, promoting domestic industry, and integrating coastal shipping with inland waterways, the Act lays the foundation for a future-ready logistics network that is central to the nation’s economic and strategic goals.

Mains Practice Question:

Discuss the significance of the Coastal Shipping Act, 2025 in India’s vision for a sustainable and cost-effective transport ecosystem.
Evaluate the role of strategic planning and digital infrastructure under the new Coastal Shipping Act in achieving India’s Maritime Amrit Kaal Vision 2047.

Get an IAS/IPS ranker as your 1: 1 personal mentor for UPSC 2024

Attend Now

Water Management – Institutional Reforms, Conservation Efforts, etc.

How groundwater contamination is fuelling chronic illnesses

Explained | Enviro & Biodiversity | Mains Paper 3: Conservation, Environmental Pollution & Degradation, Eia

India’s groundwater is increasingly getting contaminated with toxic substances. Over 85% of rural drinking water and 65% of irrigation needs are met through groundwater, yet unregulated extraction, industrial waste, agricultural runoff, and poor sanitation have turned this life source into a silent killer.

Scale of the Crisis

The 2024 Annual Groundwater Quality Report by the Central Ground Water Board (CGWB) reported the following:

Nitrates: Found in 20%+ samples (due to chemical fertilisers & septic tank leakage).
Fluoride: Detected in 9%+ samples, leading to skeletal & dental fluorosis.
Arsenic: Found in parts of Punjab, Bihar, Uttar Pradesh causing cancers & neurological damage.
Uranium: Detected in Punjab, Andhra Pradesh, Rajasthan linked to kidney damage.
Heavy metals: Iron, lead, cadmium, chromium, causing developmental & immune system issues.

Major Contaminants and Health Impacts

Fluoride Contamination:

1. Affects 230 districts across 20 states.
2. Health impact: Skeletal fluorosis, stunted growth, joint pain.
3. Rajasthan, MP, and UP report high prevalence.
4. Example: Jhabua (MP) – 40% of tribal children affected

Arsenic Exposure:

1. Concentrated in Gangetic belt.
2. Health impact: Skin lesions, respiratory illness, cancers (skin, liver, kidney, bladder).
3. Example: Ballia (UP) – Arsenic 200 g/L (20× WHO limit) linked to 10,000+ cancer cases.

Nitrate Pollution:

1. 56% districts exceed safe limits.
2. Health impact: Blue Baby Syndrome in infants, gastrointestinal distress.
3. Driven by fertilisers & poor waste management.

Uranium Contamination:

1. Increasing due to over-extraction & phosphate fertilisers.
2. Health impact: Nephrotoxicity, chronic organ damage.
3. Example: Malwa (Punjab) – 66% samples risky for children.

Heavy Metal Pollution:

1. Sources: Industrial discharge, mining.
2. Health impact: Neurological issues, anaemia, developmental delays.

Groundwater Death Zones: Case Studies

Budhpur, Baghpat (UP) – 13 deaths in 2 weeks from kidney failure linked to industrial waste.
Jalaun (UP) – Petroleum-like fluids from hand pumps due to underground fuel leaks.
Paikarapur (Bhubaneswar) – Sewage leakage caused illness in hundreds.

Why the Crisis Persists: Root Causes and Systemic Failures:

Institutional Fragmentation: Various agencies like the CGWB, the CPCB, the SPCBs, and the Ministry of Jal Shakti operate in silos, leading to a lack of a unified, coordinated approach.
Weak Legal Enforcement: The Water (Prevention and Control of Pollution) Act, 1974, has inadequate provisions for groundwater. This, combined with lax enforcement and regulatory loopholes, emboldens polluters.
Lack of Real-Time Data: Monitoring is infrequent and poorly disseminated. Without early warning systems, contamination is often discovered only after serious health consequences have emerged.
Excessive Groundwater Extraction: Over-pumping lowers water tables and concentrates pollutants, making aquifers more vulnerable to both geogenic toxins and industrial contaminants.
Deficient Waste Management: Inadequate industrial effluent treatment and poor sanitation infrastructure, especially in rural areas, allow pollutants to seep directly into aquifers

The Way Forward: A Multi-Dimensional Strategy

Addressing this crisis requires a bold, multi-dimensional strategy that integrates regulation, technology, health, and public participation.

National Framework: Enact a comprehensive National Groundwater Pollution Control Framework with clear legal authority to regulate groundwater use and discharge.
Modern Monitoring Infrastructure: Deploy real-time monitoring systems using sensors and public dashboards to create an early warning network.
Targeted Remediation: Implement targeted interventions for specific contaminants, such as defluoridation plants in high-fluoride zones and arsenic removal technologies in affected regions.
Waste Management Reforms: Enforce strict industrial effluent treatment norms and promote sustainable agricultural practices to reduce the use of chemical fertilizers.
Citizen-Centric Governance: Empower local communities through Jal Gram Sabhas to manage local water resources, conduct community water testing, and raise public awareness.

Value Addition: Key Concepts:

Geogenic Contamination: Naturally occurring pollutants like arsenic and fluoride mobilized by human activity.
Anthropogenic Contamination: Human-induced pollution from industries, agriculture, and urban waste.
Skeletal Fluorosis: A debilitating condition causing bone deformities.
Methemoglobinemia (“Blue Baby Syndrome”): A potentially fatal condition in infants caused by nitrate-laced water.

Practice UPSC MAINS question:

“Groundwater pollution in India is no longer about scarcity—it is about safety and survival.” Discuss this statement with recent examples and suggest a multi-pronged approach to tackle this issue.

Get an IAS/IPS ranker as your 1: 1 personal mentor for UPSC 2024

Attend Now

Waste Management – SWM Rules, EWM Rules, etc

What is the potential of Biochar?

Explained | Enviro & Biodiversity | Mains Paper 3: Conservation, Environmental Pollution & Degradation, Eia

As India gears up to launch its carbon market in 2026, biochar, a carbon-rich material made from agricultural and organic waste, is gaining attention as a sustainable solution for carbon capture and waste management. Despite its immense potential, biochar remains underutilised due to lack of policy support, market structures and awareness.

What is the potential of biochar?

What is Biochar and Why is it Important?

Biochar is a type of charcoal/black carbon produced by heating organic waste (like crop residue or solid municipal waste) in a low-oxygen environment.
It locks carbon into the soil for hundreds of years, reducing greenhouse gases and improving soil quality.
It is an effective long-term carbon sink.

Biochar Potential in India:

India generates over 600 million tonnes of agricultural waste and 60 million tonnes of municipal waste each year, much of which is burned or dumped, contributing to pollution.
By converting just 30–50% of this waste into biochar, India could:
- Produce 15–26 million tonnes of biochar
- Remove 0.1 gigatonnes of Carbon Dioxide (CO₂) equivalent emissions annually
Biochar production also provides with the following:
- Syngas (20–30 million tonnes) which can generate 8–13 TWh of electricity, replacing about 0.5–0.7 million tonnes of coal
- Bio-oil (24–40 million tonnes) which can offset 12–19 million tonnes of diesel/kerosene, reducing oil imports and fossil fuel emissions by more than 2%

Applications of Biochar in Key Sectors:

Agriculture: It improves soil health and water retention, especially in semi-arid and nutrient-poor regions. It can reduce nitrous oxide emissions by 30–50%, which is vital as this gas has 273x more warming potential than CO₂. Its application leads to higher crop yields (10–25%) and reduced fertilizer needs (by 10–20%). Biochar can also enhance soil organic carbon, helping restore degraded soils.
Construction: Adding just 2–5% biochar in concrete improves strength and heat resistance. It helps capture 115 kg of CO₂ per cubic metre of concrete, turning buildings into carbon sinks.
Wastewater Treatment: One kg of biochar can help treat 200–500 litres of wastewater. India’s untreated wastewater (~72%) could use 2.5–6.3 million tonnes of biochar annually.
Carbon Capture: Biochar can be modified to absorb CO₂ from industrial exhausts, though current efficiency is lower than traditional methods.
Circular Economy: Biochar aligns with the circular economy model, waste to wealth.

Why is Biochar Still Not Widely Adopted?

It remains underrepresented in carbon credit systems due to the absence of standardised feedstock markets and consistent carbon accounting methods, which undermine investor confidence.
Limited policy support, low public awareness, and no coordinated action across sectors.
No strong carbon credit mechanism to reward users and producers.

Steps that can be undertaken for Large-Scale Adoption of Biochar:

R&D Support: Develop region-specific feedstock guidelines and technologies.
Policy Integration: Link biochar with Crop residue management schemes, Bioenergy programs and State Action Plans on Climate Change
Carbon Market Recognition: Allow biochar to earn carbon credits, giving financial incentives to farmers and investors.
Village-Level Deployment: Establish small-scale biochar units that can create over 5 lakh rural jobs.
Linkage with National Missions: Can be linked with Mission LiFE and the Swachh Bharat Abhiyan.

Biochar offers a powerful tool for India’s climate smart and sustainable agriculture by enhancing soil health, improving water and nutrient retention, and bolstering climate resilience. Its integration can reduce dependency on synthetic inputs, aligning with organic farming principles. Crucially, biochar provides a significant mechanism for carbon sequestration and mitigating greenhouse gas emissions from agriculture, contributing to India’s climate goals. Leveraging this “black gold” through targeted policy support and research is essential for a greener, more resilient future.

Practice UPSC Mains Question

Biochar is emerging as a multipurpose tool for sustainable development in India. Discuss its potential across sectors and the challenges in its adoption.
What are the salient features of ‘Waste-to-Energy’ policy of India? Describe the role of waste to energy technologies in achieving energy security in India.

Get an IAS/IPS ranker as your 1: 1 personal mentor for UPSC 2024

Attend Now

Global Geological And Climatic Events

Sleeping disasters: Cloudbursts

Explained | Geography | Mains Paper 1: Important Geophysical Phenomena

Cloud Burst:

A cloudburst is an extremely intense, localized shower, defined by the India Meteorological Department (IMD) as at least 100 mm of rain within one hour over 10 sq km. These events occur due to deep, rapid atmospheric uplift over steep terrain, typical of high-altitude Himalayan regions. They can trigger sudden flash floods and landslides, devastating communities in mountainous regions. The term does not refer to a literal bursting cloud but to rapid precipitation from cumulonimbus clouds, sometimes accompanied by thunder or hail.

Why was the recent Uttarkashi Disaster not a Cloudburst?

Despite initial reports, Uttarkashi district did not record any cloudburst-level rainfall. Actual rainfall was only light to moderate, ranging from 8 mm to 43 mm on Aug 5, far below the 100 mm/hour threshold
The region lacked weather radar coverage at that altitude, so precise measurements were unavailable and the “cloudburst” classification was premature.
Uttarkashi’s steep, rugged topography, with narrow valleys and loose debris, turned the soil into unstable slopes.
A debris-laden flood, possibly triggered by a glacial lake burst, glacier collapse, or landslide, raced downstream as mud and silt-laden water to hit Dharali village violently.

Reasons for occurrence of cloudbursts:

Cloudbursts happen when warm, moist air quickly rises over mountains, cools down, and turns into heavy rain. This process, called orographic lift, causes the air to release a large amount of rain in a short time.
Sudden mixing of warm and cold air
Strong upward air movement (convection) and high moisture in the air at high altitudes

Why Do Cloudbursts Happen In The Hills?

Topography: Mountains force moist air to rise rapidly, causing sudden cooling and condensation.
Weather Conditions: Warm air with high moisture content meets cooler air at high altitudes. This results in intense convection and localised torrential rain.

Can cloudbursts be forecast?

The India Meteorological Department (IMD) forecasts rainfall events well in advance, but it does not predict the quantum of rainfall, in fact, no meteorological agency does.
IMD gives general rainfall forecasts (light, heavy, very heavy), but not exact amounts.
These forecasts are for large areas like districts or states, not specific locations.
Cloudbursts can’t be predicted exactly due to tech limitations and lack of dense instruments.
However, warnings for very heavy rain (which may lead to cloudburst-like events) are given 6–12 hours in advance.

Impacts of cloud burst:

Flash Floods: The most immediate and destructive impact is the rapid overflowing of rivers and streams, leading to widespread flooding of low-lying areas.
Landslides and Mudslides: The excessive water saturates the soil on slopes, leading to the rapid downward movement of earth, rocks, and debris, causing significant destruction and posing a threat to human lives and infrastructure.
Soil Erosion: The intense rainfall can wash away topsoil, degrading the land and negatively affecting agriculture.
Land Subsidence: The weakening of the ground due to excessive water absorption can cause the sudden sinking or settling of the Earth’s surface
Loss of Life: The suddenness and intensity of cloudbursts often leave little time for evacuation.
Damage to Infrastructure: Roads, bridges, homes, and public utilities can be severely damaged or completely destroyed.

While the term “cloudburst” often evokes images of catastrophic floods and landslides, it’s crucial to adopt a nuanced approach, avoiding knee-jerk reactions and recognizing that not all instances of heavy rainfall are cloudbursts. While the unpredictable ferocity of cloudbursts remains a formidable challenge, a proactive blend of scientific innovation, infrastructure resilience, and community-centric preparedness offers the compass to navigate their escalating threat, particularly in fragile ecosystems like the Himalayas.

Get an IAS/IPS ranker as your 1: 1 personal mentor for UPSC 2024

Attend Now