💥Join UPSC 2027,2028 Mentorship (July Batch) + XFactor Notes & Microthemes PDF
Talk to Mentor

Civilsdaily

Login

Archives: Mains

  • India and USA are two large democracies. Examine the basic tenets on which the two political systems are based.

    The United States as the first republic and India as the mother of democracies share a common philosophical foundation of liberty, equality, and constitutionalism, expressed through distinct institutional frameworks.

    Similar Basic Tenets

    Constitutional Supremacy: Constitution is the supreme law governing all institutions.

    Popular Sovereignty: Political authority derives from “We, the People” in both systems.

    Rule of Law: Enforced through Article 14 (India) and Fifth Amendment (USA), ensuring equality before law and due process.

    Representative Democracy: Based on universal adult franchise and periodic elections.

    Separation of Powers: Distinct organs maintain balance-Articles 50, 53-74 (India) and Articles I-III (US Constitution).

    Judicial Independence: Judiciary acts as guardian of the Constitution with review powers.

    Fundamental Rights: Part III (Arts. 12-35) in India parallels the Bill of Rights (1791) in the USA protecting civil liberties.

    Differences in Political Systems

    The shared democratic ideals of both nations affirm universal constitutional principles, while their institutional differences reflect unique historical and socio-cultural contexts.

  • How far do you agree with the view that tribunals curtail the jurisdiction of ordinary courts? In view of the above, discuss the constitutional validity and competency of the tribunals in India.

    Tribunals are quasi-judicial bodies established to deliver specialized, speedy, and cost-effective justice in specific matters like taxation, service disputes, environment etc.

    Objectives of Tribunals

    Specialized Adjudication

    Speedy Justice Delivery

    Reduce Burden on Courts

    Cost-Effective Dispute Resolution

    Simplified Procedures – Principles of Natural Justice

    Decentralized Justice Access

    Efficient Enforcement of Rights – Eg- NGT

    Tribunals Curtailing the Jurisdiction of Ordinary Courts

    Exclusion of High Court Jurisdiction – Articles 323A & 323B permit exclusion of High Courts’ writ powers in tribunal matters.

    Executive Control over Appointments of tribunal members

    Creates Parallel Judicial System

    However, in L. Chandra Kumar (1997) Case, SC struck down exclusion of High Court jurisdiction as unconstitutional, reaffirming judicial review as part of basic structure.

    Constitutional Validity of Tribunals

    Constitutional Basis – Established under Articles 323A & 323B (42nd Amendment, 1976) for specialized adjudication.

    Legislative Competence – Parliament empowered to create tribunals for administrative and quasi-judicial functions under Entry 11A, Concurrent List.

    Judicial Endorsement – L. Chandra Kumar v. Union of India (1997)- Upheld constitutional validity of tribunals.

    Tribunals Reforms Act, 2021 – Reorganized and rationalized tribunals.

    Functional Validity – Tribunals are supplementary judicial mechanisms, constitutionally valid as long as they do not replace or restrict High Court or Supreme Court powers.

    Competency of Tribunals in India

    Limited Jurisdiction – Competency confined to specific subject matters. Eg- NGT on environment.

    Quasi-Judicial Powers – Empowered to summon witnesses, take evidence, and deliver binding decisions similar to civil courts.

    No Inherent Jurisdiction – Unlike High Courts, tribunals cannot exercise writ or contempt powers unless conferred by statute.

    Subject to Judicial Review – Decisions are reviewable by High Courts. (L. Chandra Kumar, 1997).

    Appellate and Supervisory Role – Certain tribunals (e.g., NCLAT, DRAT) exercise appellate functions over subordinate tribunals or authorities.

    Administrative Control – Function under ministries (NCLT under Corporate Affairs).

    Guided by Principles of Natural Justice – Must ensure fair hearing, reasoned orders, and impartial adjudication in all proceedings.

    Tribunals, in line with Article 39A, must enhance access to justice while upholding judicial independence and judicial review as constitutional safeguards.

  • A number of outside powers have entrenched themselves in Central Asia, which is a zone of interest to India. Discuss the implications, in this context, of India’s joining the Ashgabat Agreement, 2018.

    The region of Central Asia is located in the heart of Eurasia and denoted as Heartland by Helford Mackinder. It connects Europe, West Asia, South Asia, and Russia, and holds vast reserves of energy and minerals.

    Outside Powers Entrenched in Central Asia

    China- Through its Belt and Road Initiative (BRI) and China-Central Asia-West Asia Corridor

    Russia through Collective Security Treaty Organization (CSTO) and the Eurasian Economic Union (EAEU).

    United States- involvement in Afghanistan

    India – through Bilateral relations and SCO. Eg- PM visited all 5 CA Republics

    Central Asia as a Zone of Interest to India

    Geopolitical – Area of Great Game.

    Energy Security- Central Asia possesses abundant oil, gas, and uranium reserves vital for India’s growing energy needs (e.g., TAPI gas pipeline).

    Connectivity and Trade- Provides a gateway to Eurasia and Europe, helping India bypass Pakistan. Eg- INSTC

    Strategic Balancing- counter China’s strategic dominance

    Cultural-Historical Linkages- Shared Silk Road heritage, Buddhism, and Sufi culture

    The Ashgabat Agreement is a multilateral transport and transit pact aimed at creating an International Transport and Transit Corridor (ITTC) between Central Asia and the Persian Gulf.

    Positive Implications of India’s Joining

    Enhanced Connectivity via the Persian Gulf and Iran’s Chabahar Port, complementing the International North-South Transport Corridor (INSTC).

    Energy and Economic Integration- Opens efficient trade routes for energy imports, minerals, and agricultural goods.

    Reduces India’s dependence on traditional routes blocked by Pakistan; provides alternative trade corridors aligned with its “Connect Central Asia Policy.”

    Balancing China’s BRI and enhancing India’s geo-economic presence.

    Regional Cooperation- Deepens engagement with Iran, Oman, and Central Asian republics.

    Challenges

    Geopolitical Constraints- US sanctions on Iran threaten India’s ability to operationalize corridors through Chabahar and Iran-Turkmenistan routes.

    Security Instability- Afghanistan’s volatility disrupts regional connectivity and supply chains.

    China’s deep pocket diplomacy limits India’s economic space and bargaining power.

    India’s delivery Deficit – Eg- Delay in INSTC

    Compared to Russia and China, India’s economic and physical presence remains limited

    Agreement reinforces India’s “Connect Central Asia” and “Act West” policies.

  • Whether the Supreme Court Judgement (July 2018) can settle the political tussle between the Lt. Governor and elected government of Delhi? Examine.

    The governance of Delhi has remained contentious due to its special constitutional status under Article 239AA. The Supreme Court’s July 2018 Constitution Bench judgment in Government of NCT of Delhi v. Union of India sought to clarify the powers of the Lt. Governor (LG) vis-à-vis the elected government.

    Key Features of the 2018 Judgment

    Aid and Advice– LG is bound by the aid and advice of the Council of Ministers, except in matters of land, police, and public order.

    No Independent Power– LG cannot act independently; he is not an obstructionist authority.

    In case of conflict, LG should refer matter to President.

    SC concluded (following Balakrishnan Committee) that Delhi is not a state.

    Can the 2018 SC Judgment Settle the Tussle?

    Yes – Scope for Settlement

    Judicial clarity – LG bound by aid and advice except land, police, public order.

    Strengthens democracy – Elected govt. empowered.

    Curtails obstruction – LG cannot act independently or stall routine decisions.

    Constitutional morality – Promotes cooperative federalism, mutual trust.

    Checks arbitrariness – Limits misuse of “difference of opinion” clause.

    Encourages dialogue – Pushes for institutional maturity and coordination.

    No – Tussle Likely to Persist

    Ambiguity remains – Article 239AA(4) still allows LG to escalate disputes.

    Key exclusions – Land, police, public order under Centre control.

    Services issue – Left unresolved in 2018, led to fresh disputes till 2023.

    Party rivalry – Conflict driven by politics, not just legal text.

    Structural limits – Delhi lacks full statehood, unlike other states.

    Comparative experience – Capitals like Washington D.C. also face similar tussles.

    Way Forward

    Legislative clarity on Article 239AA to reduce ambiguity.

    Institutionalised cooperative mechanisms such as inter-governmental councils for Delhi.

    Judicial restraint and constitutional morality from all actors.

    Political maturity to balance Union concerns with the democratic mandate of Delhi’s citizens.

    “Federalism is not a monolith; it is a dialogue between self-rule and shared rule.” Both Union & States are creatures of the Constitution

  • E-Governance is not only about utilization of the power of new technology, but also much about critical importance of the ‘use value’ of information Explain.

    The World Bank defines e-governance as the use by government agencies of information technologies that can transform relations with citizens, businesses, and other arms of government.

    E-Governance as Utilization of the Power of New Technology

    Digital Platforms like e-Office, UMANG, DigiLocker, CPGRAMS, and GeM.

    Automation and Paperless Processes: Eg- e-Procurement, e-Courts.

    Connectivity and Infrastructure Expansion: Eg- Digital India, BharatNet, and 5G rollout.

    Data Integration and Interoperability: Eg- Unified databases such as Aadhaar and SECC.

    Smart Technologies and AI Use: Eg- IndiaAI Mission, Smart Cities.

    Citizen-Government Interface: Eg- Mobile governance and MyGov platform.

    Importance of the ‘Use Value’ of Information

    Use Value – The relevance, accessibility, and usability of information by citizens, administrators, and policymakers to make informed decisions and ensure accountability.

    Informed Decision-Making: Data-driven policies depend on real-time, accurate information. Eg- Aadhaar-linked welfare, PM-KISAN, JAM Trinity

    Platforms like RTI Portal, NJDG, and CPGRAMS ensure information availability, empowering citizens to hold government accountable.

    Targeted Service Delivery: Use of information helps identify beneficiaries and prevent inclusion exclusion errors. Eg- SECC data.

    Citizen Empowerment: Information accessibility through UMANG, DigiLocker, and MyGov enables citizens to interact directly with the state.

    Evidence-Based Governance- Dashboards like PRAGATI and Aspirational District Programme use information analytics for performance monitoring.

    Crisis Management and Responsiveness: During COVID-19, platforms like CoWIN and Aarogya Setu turned data into real-time governance tools for vaccine delivery and tracking.

    Reduction in Asymmetry and Corruption: Public disclosure reduces discretion and builds public trust. Eg- GeM portal, PFMS

    Technology enables e-governance; the use value of information sustains it.

  • India’s relations with Israel have, of late, acquired a depth and diversity, which cannot be rolled back.” Discuss.

    India and Israel relations, though formally established only in 1992, have evolved from a transactional defense relationship into a multidimensional strategic partnership.

    Depth and Diversity in India-Israel relations

    Geopolitical Convergence

    2017 Modi visit to Israel (first ever by an Indian PM) and reciprocal visits institutionalized the partnership through Joint Working Groups and 2+2 dialogues.

    Strategic autonomy- India has successfully balanced ties with Israel, Palestine, and Gulf states

    Indo-Abrahamic Bloc- India’s participation in I2U2 (India, Israel, UAE, US), reflect shared Indo-Pacific interests.

    Defense and Security Cooperation

    Defense Procurement- Israel is one of India’s top three defense suppliers. Eg- Heron and Searcher UAVs, Barak missiles, and Spyder air defense systems.

    Counterterrorism Cooperation- Intelligence-sharing and joint training have strengthened India’s counterterrorism capabilities post-26/11.

    Maritime Security- Joint initiatives in the Indian Ocean and Red Sea strengthen India’s position in West Asian maritime architecture.

    Technology, Agriculture, and Water Cooperation

    The India-Israel Agricultural Project (IIAP) has established over 30 Centers of Excellence across Indian states.

    Water Management- Collaboration in drip irrigation, desalination, and wastewater recycling.

    The India-Israel Industrial R&D and Technological Innovation Fund (I4F) supports joint projects in AI, quantum computing, water tech, etc.

    Economic and Trade Relations

    Bilateral Trade- Increased from $200 million in 1992 to over $10.7 billion in 2023, with focus shifting from diamonds to pharmaceuticals, defense electronics, and agri-tech.

    Negotiations for a Comprehensive Economic Partnership Agreement (CEPA) to deepen commercial linkages.

    India and Israel have signed a fresh bilateral investment treaty.( first OECD country to adopt India’s new investment treaty model.)

    People-to-People and Cultural Ties – Shared democratic values, historical goodwill, and academic and cultural exchanges

    Major Areas-of Friction

    India maintains a principled support for Palestine and the two-state solution. Eg- India abstained from a UNGA resolution on Gaza ceasefire in October 2023.

    India walk a tightrope between its strategic embrace of Israel and economic entrenchment in the Gulf. – Harsh V. Pant (ORF)

    Non-defense trade remains modest and over-reliant on diamonds and agriculture.

    The India-Israel Free Trade Agreement, under negotiation since 2010 (14 rounds held), remains inconclusive.

    Domestic Political Issues – left-leaning and minority groups, criticize deepening ties with Israel.

    Way Forward

    Partnership based on Enlightened Self interest

    Joint Collaboration for development projects in Africa and South Asia under platforms like I2U2.

    As Israeli PM Benjamin Netanyahu stated, “The sky is the limit for India-Israel cooperation” – symbolizing deep mutual trust and strategic alignment.

  • Appropriate local community-level healthcare intervention is a prerequisite to achieve ‘Health for All ‘ in India. Explain.

    The goal of ‘Health for All’, as envisioned in the Alma-Ata Declaration (1978) and reinforced through National Health Policy 2017, emphasizes universal, equitable, and accessible healthcare.

    Importance of Local Community-Level Healthcare Interventions

    Accessibility and Inclusivity – Brings primary healthcare closer to grassroot and reduces dependency on overburdened tertiary hospitals. Eg- Ayushman Bharat – Health and Wellness Centres (HWCs)

    Preventive and Promotive Health – Community health workers (e.g., ASHA, Anganwadi, ANM) enable early detection, immunization, maternal and child care.

    Local interventions are more trust-based, improving adoption of health services. Eg- ASHA workers act as a bridge between local communities and formal healthcare systems

    Cost-Effectiveness – Community-based preventive healthcare reduces out-of-pocket expenditure (OOPE). (Presently at 40%)

    Empowering Local Governance – Panchayati Raj Institutions (PRIs) and Village Health Sanitation and Nutrition Committees (VHSNCs) ensure decentralized planning and monitoring.

    Integration of Traditional and Modern Systems – Incorporates AYUSH practices alongside allopathy to widen reach and enhance preventive health.

    Empowering Women and Local Workforce – ASHAs and Anganwadi workers-over 10 lakh women-act as frontline caregivers.

    Community health networks enable rapid disease surveillance and emergency response. Eg- ASHAs and PRIs played a critical role in contact tracing during COVID-19

    Continuous community engagement increases awareness of disease prevention, hygiene, family planning, and nutrition.

    Key Challenges

    Shortage of trained manpower and high attrition among ASHA and ANM workers.

    Inadequate infrastructure at Sub-Centres and PHCs.

    Weak inter-sectoral convergence (between health, sanitation, and nutrition departments).

    Limited community participation due to lack of awareness and ownership.

    Way Forward

    Strengthen Primary Health Infrastructure: Upgrade all 1.5 lakh HWCs with telemedicine and diagnostics.

    Capacity Building: Continuous training and performance-based incentives for ASHA and ANM workers.

    Community Ownership: Empower Panchayats and SHGs in planning and monitoring local health outcomes.

    Technology Integration: Use eSanjeevani, digital health IDs, and mobile-based health tracking.

    Social Determinants Approach: Integrate health with nutrition, sanitation (Swachh Bharat), and clean energy (Ujjwala Yojana).

    Achieving Universal Health Coverage (UHC) by strengthening local healthcare will help realize the vision of “Swasth Bharat – Samriddh Bharat.”

  • Policy contradictions among various competing sectors and stakeholders have resulted in inadequate ‘protection and prevention of degradation’ to environment. ” Comment with relevant illustration.

    While environmental protection is constitutionally mandated (Article 48A, 51A(g)), it is marked by overlapping sectoral priorities and fragmented institutional mandates.

    Policy Contradictions Among Various Competing Sectors

    Energy vs. Environment – Expansion of coal-based thermal power leads to deforestation, displacement, and carbon emissions. Eg- Coal block allocations in Hasdeo Arand (Chhattisgarh)

    Agriculture – MSP policy promotes water-intensive crops like paddy and sugarcane, leading to water scarcity, salinity, and soil degradation. Eg- Over-extraction of groundwater in Punjab and Haryana.

    Industry vs. Environmental Regulation – Ease of Doing Business reforms relax environmental clearances (EIA 2020 draft allows post-facto approvals).

    Infrastructure vs. Ecosystem Stability – Eg- Projects like Bharatmala, Char Dham Highway, and river-linking projects lead to habitat fragmentation and increased disaster vulnerability.

    Tourism – Unregulated eco-tourism and pilgrimage infrastructure stress fragile ecosystems. Eg- Joshimath Crisis.

    Urban Development – Unplanned urbanisation encroaches upon natural drainage systems. Eg- Chennai floods (2015) due to wetland encroachment; Bengaluru lake pollution.

    Policy Contradictions Among Various Competing Stakeholders

    Central vs. State Governments – Conflict between industrial promotion by states and environmental clearance norms by Centre.

    Government vs. Local Communities – Top-down project approvals often ignore Gram Sabha consent under Forest Rights Act (2006). Eg- Niyamgiri Case

    Corporate Interests vs. Civil Society – Private sector prioritizes profit, while NGOs and activists demand sustainability. Eg- Industrial pollution in Sterlite Copper Plant (Thoothukudi).

    Judiciary vs. Executive – Eg- NGT banned illegal constructions in Aravalli Hills (Gurugram, 2018) and Delhi Ridge

    Inter-Ministerial Contradictions – Eg- MoEFCC seeks conservation, while the Ministry of Coal or Power pushes extraction projects.

    Way Forward

    Integrated Policy – Establish a National Council for Sustainable Development (NCSD) under NITI Aayog. Model it on the UK’s Department for Environment, Food & Rural Affairs.

    Whole-of-Government Approach – Institutionalize inter-ministerial task forces for projects with ecological sensitivity.

    Implement committee recommendations like Madhav gadgil Committee on Western Ghats

    Green Budgeting – Integrate ecosystem valuation and environmental costs into budgets.

    Create National Environmental Information Grid (NEIG) for real-time monitoring of forests, emissions, and water resources.

    Community Participation – Ensure FRA and PESA provisions are respected in all forest and mining projects through joint monitoring committees including tribal representatives.

    These measures can help align the developmental process with SDG-13 (Climate Action) and India’s Panchamrit targets.

  • The Comptroller and Auditor General (CAG) has a very vital role to play. Explain how this is reflected in the method and terms of his appointment as well as the range of powers he can exercise.

    CAG is established under Article 148 of the Constitution as the supreme audit authority of India. Ambedkar called it as most important officer under the Constitution of India

    Importance of the office of CAG

    Guardian of Public Purse – CAG ensures all government expenditure is sanctioned by law and used appropriately.

    Bulwark of Democracy along with ECI and SC

    Promotes Accountability – Eg: 2G Spectrum scam (2010)

    Strengthens Parliamentary Oversight – CAG reports form the basis for examination by Public Accounts Committee (PAC) and COPU.

    Ensures Financial Propriety – Audits whether expenditure follows financial rules, principles, and economy norms.

    Auditor of Federal Finances – Audits accounts of both Union and State Governments under Articles 149-151.

    Promotes Good Governance – Performance audits drive improvements in scheme design, implementation, and outcomes.

    Reflection of importance in method and terms of appointment

    Appointed by the President of India under Article 148(1) by warrant under his hand and seal.

    Oath of Office under Third Schedule to uphold the Constitution. The oath symbolises the solemn responsibility and independence of the office.

    Fixed Tenure – CAG holds office for 6 years or until age 65, whichever is earlier (Section 3, CAG Act 1971). Fixed tenure shields from executive pressure and ensures continuity.

    Removal Same as Supreme Court Judge- This stringent removal procedure protects CAG from arbitrary action by executive.

    Salary Charged on Consolidated Fund, not voted by Parliament (Article 148(3)).

    Service conditions cannot be varied to CAG’s disadvantage during tenure (Article 148(4)).

    No Eligibility for Further Government Office

    Reflection of importance in powers vested

    Comprehensive audit authority across federal levels. – CAG audits all expenditure from Consolidated Fund of India, Consolidated Funds of States, and UTs with legislatures.

    Audit of Contingency Fund and Public Account – Ensures complete coverage of government finances.

    Audit of Public Sector Undertakings- Eg: Audits LIC, ONGC, FCI, BHEL, Indian Railways under Companies Act provisions.

    Audit of Autonomous Bodies substantially financed by governmentEg: ICAR, CSIR

    Performance Audit evaluating economy, efficiency, effectiveness of schemes. Eg: Performance audits on MGNREGA, NHM, PMAY, Swachh Bharat Mission.

    CAG Standardises government accounting practices by prescribing form in which accounts of Union and States shall be maintained (Article 150).

    Independent Investigation Powers – CAG can call for any document, information, books, accounts from any government office without restriction.

    Discretionary Powers – Section 23, CAG (DPC) Act 1971 allows CAG to issue directions on accounting and audit principles.

    “The CAG is the conscience-keeper of public finance, ensuring not only lawful but also wise spending.” – 2nd ARC

  • Why do you think the committees are considered to be useful for parliamentary work? Discuss, in this context, the role or the Estimates Committee.

    According to LS speaker Om Birla, Parliamentary Committees are the “backbone of parliamentary democracy.

    Parliamentary committees

    Standing Committees – PAC, Estimate committee, Committee on public undertaking

    Ad-Hoc Committees – Eg- JPC

    Importance of Parliamentary Committees

    Checks and Balances – Eg- PAC examined CAG’s 2G spectrum report for irregularities.

    In-Depth Policy Analysis – Enable clause-by-clause scrutiny of Bills, which is not possible in open House debates. Eg- JPC on Data Protection Bill (2019) proposed over 90 amendments

    Reducing Legislative Workload – Committees share Parliament’s burden, ensuring thorough scrutiny without delaying legislation.

    Expert Consultation – Committees invite experts, industry, and civil society to promote evidence-based policymaking.

    Budgetary Oversight – Departmentally Related Standing Committees (DRSCs) analyse ministry budgets to ensure fiscal prudence.

    Consensus Building – Committees promote bipartisan dialogue, e.g., IT Committee built consensus on the Personal Data Protection Bill (2019).

    Public Engagement – Committees seek public and expert inputs, e.g., Standing Committee on Environment reviewed the EIA Draft Notification (2020).

    Continuity in Oversight – Committees function year-round, ensuring continuous policy review beyond parliamentary sessions.

    Bridging Knowledge Gaps – Committees enhance MPs’ expertise through research support and technical briefings.

    Role of the Estimates Committee

    Established under Rule 310 of the Lok Sabha, it has 30 Lok Sabha members and is chaired by a ruling party MP.

    Examines budget estimates to ensure efficiency, economy, and effectiveness.

    Suggests alternative policies for better fiscal management and administrative reform.

    Monitors implementation of government schemes and performance of ministries.

    Eg- Under Murli Manohar Joshi (2018), it reviewed PSU disinvestment and defence procurement, highlighting fiscal prudence.

    In the words of Woodrow Wilson, “Congress in session is Congress on public exhibition, while Congress in its committee rooms is Congress at work.”